What this covers

Adam Hansmann talks with Matt and Dom about how The Athletic was put together, beginning with where the instincts came from. He credits Strava, where endurance athletes paid for something better than free, with teaching him and his co-founder that subscription-funded, user-first building beats advertiser-driven models. In 2015 they concluded a paywall was the only model that aligned the company with both readers and journalists, though paywalls were out of fashion. They launched in Chicago in 2016, aiming for a few thousand subscribers, because single-city unit economics could work at that scale.

The middle of the conversation covers product decisions. The bundle came out of data: in the second market, hockey fans following the Maple Leafs and Blackhawks were as numerous as the traditional local bucket. That led the team to drop the idea of per-city SKUs in favor of one tier. Readers also proved loyal to national writers like Ken Rosenthal. Hansmann says habit formation did more to reduce churn than pricing, and he uses the 2019 Houston Astros sign-stealing story to show that a scoop brings sign-ups without making readers regulars.

The talk turns contentious on the costs. Showing reporters their metrics caused stress and risked turning journalism into sales work. Matt raises the Substack-style alternative and a possible swing back toward team-based models, and he argues the company scaled because its thesis worked, not because funding rewarded growth. He also adds a short aside on why a DCF's exit value is real cash. Hansmann closes with advice for new publishers: start with a narrow niche and partner with great talent, because a broad consumer brand cannot compete with Netflix, YouTube, and Fortnite.

Sharpest takeaway

Hansmann argues The Athletic succeeded by treating talent as the product and users as the customer: it hired top local reporters, shared audience data with them, built a subscription-first bundle, and habituated readers daily rather than relying on viral scoops.

  • Top reporters carried name recognition and journalistic capital that drove paid sign-ups behind a paywall
  • Sharing audience data with editorial staff aligned journalism with subscriber needs
  • Bundling multiple teams and leagues into one tier kept users through habit formation rather than single-story spikes

The argument · threads4 threads · 73 claims
0.71

Concise, dense products earn subscriptions because their value clearly exceeds what readers pay.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Readers who try to circumvent the paywall by searching for free copies spend an hour of their time that is worth more than the $5 monthly subscription, so the paywall's cost-benefit is clear for users.

    “an hour of your time worth more than $5 for the month”

  • A DCF's terminal multiple is often a rough placeholder, but it represents whether a buyer will pay for the business, a cash flow that must be counted, and many people forget that exit value is real cash.

    “What that terminal multiple mean, it's, oh, I don't know, I can't forecast that far out. So I'm going to slap a multiple on it.”

  • Value Line's one-page reports show that condensing information forces concision, and constraints like one-page or 400-page formats help cut fluff.

    “you can really force us help to cut the fluff by taking the exercise of what value line does with their one pagers”

  • The Athletic's NFL draft guide, The Beast, runs about 400 pages, is dense with obscure information on prospects, and is worth a subscription on its own according to Matt.

    “it's worth a subscription alone, to be honest, 100%.”

  • Matt says many media products are not concise enough, and constraints like the Value Line one-pagers or The Beast draft guide can force cutting the fluff, which he finds valuable.

    “The problem that we often have is that things are just not concise enough. It's like cut the fluff.”

0.40

Organizational infrastructure is essential but underappreciated, with its right level still unsettled.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Substack-style platforms that offer infrastructure to solo writers exchange convenience for control and fall short on certain needs, so the right degree of organizational support for talent is still unsettled, with a persistent tension between short-term and long-term alignment.

    “There is that tension of short-term alignment versus long-term alignment between talent and media organizations.”

  • Organizational infrastructure such as accounting, expenses, and team support is like defense in sports: it is essential but underappreciated until it is missing, and the pendulum may swing back toward team-based models.

    “offense wins championships, they're popular. They get paid the most defense while it's incredibly important to any team”

0.40

The Athletic's scale-up followed proven insight rather than market funding conditions.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The Athletic scaled after proving its thesis in a few markets, so the strategy change was driven by the insight that worked rather than by the funding climate, as Matt argued against a view that market rewards caused the growth push.

    “no, we proved out what we thought was the thesis. And then once we realized it worked in a few markets, we wanted to grow it fast.”

  • Matt argues the company's early approach was almost bootstrapped and piecemeal, implying the switch to scale was driven by when the market began rewarding subscriptions rather than by a deliberate ambition from the start.

    “They were very much doing it almost bootstrap fashion. So that led me to believe, okay, it was just a matter of when the market started rewarding it is when they change the strategy”

0.26

Media should build its own viral moments rather than recreate famous past scoops.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Making Media is not very viral or memorable, and the right approach is to find its own version of viral moments rather than recreating what others did, such as the Astros scoop or celebrity podcast moments.

    “maybe just find our own version of it.”

  • Matt says the Houston Astros sign-stealing story was a major baseball scandal that led to suspensions and firings, and that breaking it gave the company a national-level inflection point that is hard to recreate on purpose.

    “Sign stealing story. It was this big issue in baseball where the Houston Astros were stealing signs.”