What this covers

Patrick hosts a conversation with two people who sit on opposite sides of company building. Rich Barton founded Expedia, Glassdoor, and Zillow. Brad Gerstner is an investor who sponsored a SPAC. Barton's half is operating history. Zillow first meant to auction every home, and when that failed, testing produced the Zestimate, which started out inaccurate but provocative and improved over time. He also recounts Bill Gurley challenging the team to launch as if it had no advertising budget. The Zillow Offers move into physical operations gets candid treatment: a roughly $10 billion ad-supported business grew complacent, prompting a "second founding moment." Barton says high-margin digital businesses can hide operational sloppiness, so he brought in outside talent such as Arik Prawer, whose team had managed 30,000 rental homes.

Gerstner's half moves to markets and capital formation. He attributes the Q4 2018 Nasdaq drawdown to multiple contraction after the Dot Plot signaled rate increases, and he reads 2020's rally as the reversal. He names a Fed admission that it underestimated inflation as the biggest risk to software valuations, a claim he presents with conviction and others may dispute. He also argues that a growth investor should not be alarmed by 100 times forward sales for a company growing well past 100 percent.

The sharpest disagreement concerns going public. Gerstner describes bank-led IPOs as slow, expensive at 6 to 7 percent fees, and prone to underpricing. Barton adds that they leave a churning, randomized cap table. They contrast this with a sponsor-led SPAC and forecast that the sponsor market will sort into a few reputable names. The conversation also touches on whether AI will concentrate gains and fuel backlash against capitalism.

Sharpest takeaway

Rich Barton and Brad Gerstner argue that durable company building comes from putting power in the hands of the customer, staffing with balanced courage-brains-heart leaders, and leading with product, and that SPACs sponsored by experienced investors can give founders a cheaper, faster, less dilutive route to public markets than traditional IPOs.

  • Power to the people: consumers armed with connected computers can break information monopolies held by intermediaries, as in Expedia, Zillow, and Glassdoor
  • Traditional IPOs are costly, slow, and randomize the cap table, while a sponsor-led SPAC can set price, use forward-looking forecasts, and charge no fee to the company
  • Great companies depend on balanced leadership (courage, brains, heart), product-led growth, and high talent density maintained by removing underperformers early

The argument · threads8 threads · 80 claims
0.85

Companies now have three IPO paths, and sponsor-backed SPACs align incentives better than banks.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Almost every company thinking about IPO readiness now includes slides evaluating all three IPO doors (bank, sponsor, direct listing), a shift that Gerstner calls a surprising appetite among boards and CEOs.

    “I don't think there's any company thinking about IPO readiness who won't have slides in their deck that are now actively considering all three of those.”

  • Altimeter Growth Corp charges the issuing company no fee; instead the costs are borne by SPAC shareholders who gave shares to the sponsor as a finder's fee, and the sponsor acts like an owner rather than an agent, aligned with long-term ownership.

    “we don't charge your company a fee. None. Zero.”

  • There are now three legitimate paths to an IPO: partnering with a bank such as Goldman, partnering with an investor sponsor such as Altimeter, or doing a direct listing.

    “there are clearly now three legitimate paths to an IPO”

  • The SPAC sponsor market will evolve like the bank market: tier one companies will choose a handful of reputable sponsors and avoid unknown ones, while unknown or niche sponsors will serve companies with fewer options.

    “My own sense is that the sponsor market will evolve in much the same way the bank market evolved.”

  • Nearly every company thinking about IPO readiness now has slides in its board deck that actively consider the three doors, but there is still a broad lack of understanding of how SPACs work, how they differ, and what it means for shareholder votes to be withheld.

    “I don't think there's any company thinking about IPO readiness who won't have slides in their deck that are now actively considering all three of those.”

0.71

Demand for cloud and AI data infrastructure is surging, with Snowflake as the clearest example.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Machine learning and AI tools will soon outperform the most sophisticated human merchandisers with decades of experience, requiring infrastructure that structures and moves both structured and unstructured data in the cloud and analyzes it in real time.

    “the tools around machine learning and artificial intelligence were very quickly going to be more intelligent at merchandising what should go on the homepage of Amazon”

  • Capital One named a chief data officer in 2002, reportedly among the first Fortune 1000 companies to do so, and by 2020 57 percent of companies had chief data officers, showing data has become a strategic initiative for the largest companies.

    “In 2020, 57% of companies have chief data officers.”

  • Snowflake's cloud architecture for storing, moving, scaling, and sharing data was fundamentally different from existing systems, and if the founders were right the size of the prize was the biggest in all of software.

    “the size of the prize was the biggest prize in all the software”

  • A software CEO's company signed a $250,000 consumption contract on Snowflake expected to last 12 months but used it in two months, and shifted workloads from other systems, illustrating demand that exceeds expectations.

    “We signed up for a $250,000 consumption contract that we thought would last us for 12 months. We burnt through it in two months.”

  • Altimeter quadrupled its insertion order in Snowflake, and customers are shifting workloads out of other places and simplifying data infrastructure to use Snowflake.

    “we just quadrupled our insertion order, our contract, we're shifting workloads out of other places.”

0.59

Traditional bank-led IPOs are slow, costly, and chronically underpriced.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The traditional bank-led IPO process takes around a year, leaves the company without a known price or shareholder base until the end, forces it to bear market risk throughout, and charges bank fees of 6 to 7 percent, making it costly for the company.

    “the bank's fees of 6 to 7%, this becomes very costly to the company”

  • Bill Gurley and others have argued that bank involvement in pricing and allocating IPO shares leads to chronic underpricing, which Gerstner cites as a cost of the traditional process even if the mispricing is not considered as large a problem by everyone.

    “which Bill Gurley and others have argued leads to chronic underpricing”

  • Over the last 25 years the traditional IPO has gotten harder and less efficient even as the rest of the world moved forward, so Altimeter Growth Corp was built to combine the mechanics of a SPAC with Altimeter's full capital-markets capabilities to give the best founders a less dilutive and faster path to public markets.

    “We wanted to give the world's best founders and companies a better, a less dilutive, and a faster path to the public markets.”

0.57

Fed signals and multiple shifts, not elections or comps, drive public software valuations.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Altimeter's growth software index moved from about 11 times to about 14.5 times two-year forward earnings this year, and its internet index moved from about 23 times to about 33 times, showing substantial multiple expansion in 2020.

    “We started the year in our growth software index at 11 times. Now we're at about 14 and a half times, two year forward.”

  • The largest risk to public software valuations is not the election or tough comps but a future Fed press conference acknowledging it underestimated inflation, which would make the dot plot explode and multiples contract, replaying the 2018 pattern.

    “all of that will be dwarfed by the impact of when we have a press conference out of the fed”

  • The Q4 2018 Nasdaq drawdown of roughly 25 percent was driven by multiple contraction caused by the dot plot signaling three rate increases in 2019, not by COVID or company misses, and 2020's multiple expansion mirrors that reversal.

    “that's because we were surprised by the fact that the dot plot was suggesting we were going to have three rate increases in 2019”

  • Markets tend to move in the direction of maximum pain, so in May, when many companies had bounced 50 percent off their bottoms, the market was pricing in low cost of capital for a long time rather than an impending recession.

    “markets tend to move into the direction of maximum pain.”

  • Markets have priced in the Fed holding rates for two to three years, but have been slow to price in how dramatically different the trajectory will be for many digital businesses, which is an underappreciated driver of valuations.

    “the market has well-priced in the fact that the fed said we're going to be on hold for two to three years. What it has been slow in pricing is how dramatically different the arc will be for many of these digital businesses.”

0.52

Growth investors should focus on opportunity size, specific use cases, and standout product pull.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • For a company growing well over 100 percent, a trading multiple of 100 times next year's sales is not an alarming signal, because twelve-month-forward multiples are somewhat irrelevant to a growth investor focused on how big the opportunity can become.

    “12 months forward, multiple sales is somewhat irrelevant to me.”

  • Zoom's decision not to require login and its simple design ensured nobody was left out of a conversation, and while analysts may call it a marginal difference from competitors, the product experience delighted users in a way that made it stand out.

    “Zoom's decision not to require you to log in, their decision to make it super simple, that nobody was ever left out of a conversation.”

  • Life-cycle investors should focus on the most iconic founders building iconic companies and build a mental model and cultural north star that resists the temptation to trade against oneself, since investors trade against themselves almost all the time.

    “You trade against yourself almost all the time. It's hard to find those companies.”

  • In evaluating product-market fit, investors should get into the weeds on specific use cases, asking why people come to a product, what problem they solve, and why there is pull in the market, rather than investing against a general area and only later asking why one company won.

    “Why are people coming to Zillow? What is it with this Zestimate? What's the psychographic thing about people that causes them to want to understand what their neighbor's home is worth?”

0.52

Success breeds complacency, so companies must reinvent themselves, as Zillow did.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Zillow built a roughly $10 billion business on an ad-supported model with tens of millions of visitors, but its success bred complacency, and the original dream of transforming real estate was unfulfilled, which prompted a 'second founding moment' that required rebuilding the business to reinvent the industry.

    “It's a second founding moment in the history of Zillow.”

  • Brad Gerstner and Rich Barton bonded early because both were enamored with human empowerment through access to information, a shared conviction that made them clicking quickly on investing in Zillow.

    “I was already like Rich, enamored with the idea of human empowerment through access to this information.”

  • When Google turned the browser address bar into a search box so typed input became a commercial Google search, Zillow tactically exploited it while developing brand muscle, and Zillow's brand is now among the best in commercials.

    “Google co-opted the address bar and turned it into a search box.”

  • Because the Zestimate brought tens of millions of people to Zillow's front door, the company drifted into an ad-supported lead-generation model, which was easy to add by selling ads against that traffic, though it later took a decade to get back to transforming the real estate transaction itself.

    “All of a sudden you had a business with tens of millions of people clamoring to get into your front door.”

0.38

Organizations should avoid change for its own sake yet keep reassessing whether teams fit their tasks.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Frank Slootman's military-like, blue-collar leadership style and rejection of perks like massages and lattes stems from having lived through hard market cycles, and he insists on disciplined work during good times so the company can push advantage when cycles turn.

    “he has lived through market cycles where things get really tough”

  • Organizations should avoid change for its own sake but constantly evaluate whether the team is the best fit for the task, since the best five people for a role one year may not be the best the next year, and firms that fear change lose strategic advantage.

    “the ability to navigate change successfully is a strategic advantage”

  • The post-World War II model of one or two jobs is over; people will spend two to four years at a firm, so firms should aim for those years to be the best of people's careers rather than trying to retain them.

    “we're no longer in a W2 post-World War II world, where you're going to have one or two jobs.”

  • Publishing work publicly on platforms like Twitter for peer review forces people to refine their thinking, builds their network and personal brand, and that is better than restricting employees for fear of firm brand dilution.

    “it's the best place to force them to kind of really refine their own thinking, to get feedback, to build the network, to build their own brand.”

0.38

Capitalism's backlash reflects technology concentrating benefits, requiring a new social contract.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Gerstner argues that a new social contract should treat universal healthcare and universal education as basic human rights while preserving competition and innovation, since abandoning capitalism would reduce the goods and services that improve everyone's life.

    “I'm interested in how we start thinking about things like universal healthcare and universal education as basic human rights in a new world order.”

  • Backlash against capitalism reflects a technology revolution in which machines do increasingly more human work, so benefits concentrate among few, and AI and ML will boost productivity to a degree like the internet while concentrating its distribution.

    “I would argue that's not really a feature of capitalism so much as it's a feature of a technology revolution.”

  • The Board Challenge is a two-sided marketplace asking every board to add a Black or Latino director within 12 months while building a directory of younger diverse talent, and within eight weeks more than 60 companies had taken the pledge, with a goal of 500 within a year.

    “we've had over 60 companies now take the pledge.”

  • Gerstner's generation has pulled the lucky ticket on capitalism because it was born during the greatest time in modern capitalism, with fluid capital and generations of platforms to build companies on, and anyone with materials can get peer review and build a brand.

    “we've all pulled the lucky ticket on capitalism. I mean, we're born during the greatest time in modern capitalism.”