What this covers
This is a conversation with Brad Gerstner of Altimeter about how he has invested across public and private markets, and it reads partly as a career narrative. He describes seeing around 2002-2003 that internet search and discovery were consolidating on Google, so vertical businesses could be built in its shadow. He then describes the 2012 turn, when purchase intent began moving to iPhone app homepages and desktop hotel search turned negative on Google. He also says Google's ownership of Priceline showed him how much public and private activity inform each other. His private relationships, such as Bill Gurley and Rich Barton, give him better research than sell-side calls.
The range is wide. On markets, he explains how a 150-basis-point drop in the discount rate lifts a growth software multiple by two to three turns, and he attributes the late-2018 tech sell-off to fears about Fed rate hikes rather than earnings. Elsewhere he covers airline consolidation from 12 carriers to four, software reshaping traditional industries, and the meeting of life sciences and software after the COVID vaccine sprint. He also forecasts that shopping feeds on Facebook and Instagram will challenge Amazon and Google. He pairs ByteDance's roughly $200 billion private valuation with a claim that the first $10 to $15 billion of winners' value now accrues to private investors. Contested points include whether illiquidity actually protects investors from themselves, and whether LP demands for specialization have hurt long-run returns. He also argues that healthcare should attach to people rather than employers as gig work grows.
The closing thread is personal discipline. He cites Warren Buffett's six punches, asks of every commitment whether it is an easy yes, and keeps Altimeter free of group meetings and daily reviews.
Gerstner argues that value creation has shifted to private markets and that durable returns come from concentrated, long-held bets on platforms that capture user attention, with essentialism as the discipline that makes this work.
- Companies now create most of their equity value before going public, so late-stage private investing captures returns that once went to public investors
- Consumer discovery and intent moved from Google search to mobile platforms and super apps, and value follows the platforms that own that attention
- Concentrated positions held through a company's full lifecycle, and resistance to short-term trading, generate outsized returns
Long-horizon, commingled capital and three-to-five-year judgment beat short-term trading and returns.
- Altimeter does not do early-stage venture because better practitioners exist and it has no competitive advantage there, focusing instead on Series B through Series D rounds from $100 million to $1 billion and then the quasi-public market.
“we don't do early-stage venture at all. There are better practitioners than us”
- When Altimeter started, LPs did not want public and private investments commingled in one fund, but today LPs accept it, and Gerstner's approach relies on LPs who stand with the firm in volatile periods.
“nobody wanted them commingled, it was a hard sell”
- In late March and early April 2020, Altimeter put hundreds of millions of dollars into private software because it was not thinking about the next six weeks, and it had built relationships with partners who shared that long horizon.
“we put hundreds of millions of dollars to work in the private software market at the end of March and early April”
- Far more money has been lost in the venture and hedge fund businesses betting on the end of times, trading out of good ideas, and hedging out of COVID than by making great bets on great companies and letting them compound.
“far more money has been lost in this business”
- LPs pushed investment firms into specialization such as venture, mid-stage, late-stage and macro, which created formulas that prevent generating long-run alpha, while early Buffett-style funds gave LPs a pro-rata share of all ideas, public and private.
“it was LPs who pushed the investment firms into specialization”
- The biggest mistake most investors make is over-indexing on 12- and 24-month returns, because any great growth company will look expensive over short horizons, so price targets should be set for three to five years out.
“the biggest mistake most investors make is they over-index to their 12-month return”
- Altimeter came within about $100 to $200 million of a meaningful pre-IPO investment in Zoom at roughly $5 billion valuation, and two years later the company was valued far higher, illustrating that anchoring on price causes investors to miss winners.
“We were within probably 100 or $200 million of doing a meaningful pre-IPO around in Zoom”
- Facebook was trading at roughly 9 to 10 times Gerstner's 2022 EBITDA estimates, which he says is not taxing on a multi-year view even though it may look expensive on current-year numbers.
“Facebook I think is trading at 9 or 10 times our 2022 EBITDA estimates”
- Most investors over-index to 12-month or 24-month returns, and a manager cannot credibly promise returns over six months, but has an edge over three-to-ten-year horizons.
“the biggest mistake most investors make is they over-index to their 12-month return, their 24-month return.”
- A firm culture that rejects 'idea of the day' trading and requires several years of study before a pitch makes it easier to resist short-term pressure, and the firm's slower-twitch approach outperforms by avoiding trading out of good ideas.
“if you have an idea of the day, you're not a fit. If you have an idea a week, you're probably not a fit”
Concentrated, long-held positions in a few great bets drive Altimeter's alpha.
- Altimeter often invests in companies at Series B or C, becomes the largest buyer in the IPO, and holds for years afterward, so alpha comes from stock selection plus letting winners compound over the full business lifecycle, with enough concentration to move the fund.
“we're the largest buyer in the IPO”
- For Gerstner, essentialism, the disciplined pursuit of less, is both a business and life philosophy, and at Altimeter it is the cultural North Star that drives trade-offs and operating choices.
“essentialism is our cultural North Star”
- At any moment Altimeter may have 75% of its public portfolio in its top four or five ideas, and its private funds hold concentrated positions, such as about 10 investments in a $400 million fund, which reduces FOMO and makes returns depend on stock-picking skill.
“we're the largest buyer in the IPO”
- Buffett's idea that an investor only gets six punches on the card implies that most of an investor's career profits come from a few great bets, so over-trading and owning too many ideas divides attention and leaves no capital when the fat pitch arrives.
“you only need six punches on your card over the course of your career”
- Venture investments cannot be sold, and this illiquidity protects investors from the common mistake of selling great companies to trade them, which causes behavioral lock and missed compounding.
“There's one other advantage to venture that I remind people which is you can't sell.”
Value capture is moving to private markets and intelligent software, so investors must own across stages.
- Internet companies now create enormous equity value before going public (ByteDance at roughly $200 billion), whereas a billion-dollar exit once put a venture firm in the Hall of Fame, so a large share of value capture has moved to private markets.
“a big exit was a couple hundred million dollars or a billion-dollar exit”
- By Altimeter's account, enterprise cloud adoption is still roughly a decade from 50% penetration, with about 20% penetration to date driven mostly by cloud-native businesses, and a trillion dollars of enterprise spend is shifting to the cloud.
“we're still a decade away from having 50% penetration to the Cloud”
- Gerstner believes applying intelligent software to traditional industries, such as route planning and engine maintenance for airlines, could produce productivity gains bigger than the internet itself, with the value captured by software companies that provide these services.
“the productivity gains that will unleash may be bigger than the internet itself”
- ByteDance, most recently valued at $150 billion, still has five to 10 times upside because consumers are increasingly turning to its platforms, including TikTok outside China and Toutiao inside China, and monetization dollars will follow attention.
“we think that company still has five to 10x ahead of it”
- Gerstner founded Altimeter in 2008 as a throwback fund to compound his own capital alongside long-term investors, and its hybrid venture-and-hedge-fund design was unattractive to LPs coming out of the 2008 crisis.
“we always viewed this as more of a throwback fund”
- If an investor such as T. Rowe Price wants to participate in the value creation of top technology companies, it cannot avoid private markets, because the most valuable growth happens before IPO.
“If your fidelity, if you're T. Rowe, if you're one of these companies that wants to participate in all of that value creation, you can't not be in the private markets.”
- Given intangible value in the internet and software winners, a fund may be better served by concentrated bets across both public and private companies rather than specialized vehicles, because the lifecycle from private to public captures the compounding.
“I can't not be in the private markets”
Internet discovery is migrating from Google search to apps, streams, and predictive assistants.
- Baidu is worth about 50% less than six years ago even as Chinese internet platforms such as WeChat, ByteDance, Pinduoduo and Alibaba are worth multiples of their values five years earlier, because users now reach information and shopping without going through Baidu.
“Baidu is worth 50% less today than it was six years ago”
- In 2012 discovery and purchase intent began shifting from Google search to the iPhone and iOS app homepages, and desktop search for hotel queries turned negative on Google that year, which had profound implications for the internet thesis Gerstner had invested behind for a decade.
“hotel queries actually went negative on Google in 2012”
- Companies like TripAdvisor and Yelp, once the biggest beneficiaries of Google, later testified to the Senate about the rate of Google's tax collection, and Gerstner expected this tax to arrive as Google's own query volumes diminished.
“the tax collector would eventually come”
- Around 2002-2003 Gerstner saw that all search and discovery on the internet was migrating to Google, so businesses that optimized inside Google's ecosystem could build very large vertical businesses in its shadow.
“all intent on the internet was going to be funneled through this super aggregator”
- Google kept growing earnings at over 20% by diversifying its business even as desktop search shrank, and its AI investments may bridge to a future where it remains dominant.
“continuing to grow earnings at over 20%”
- Gerstner tells his team that being too early is as dangerous as being too late, because he worried about the future of vertical search starting in 2010 yet Google kept compounding earnings by diversifying.
“it's just as dangerous to be too early as it is to be too late”
- Search arguably democratized the internet, despite monopoly accusations against Google, because it let businesses like booking.com be discovered, and it is very difficult to build a large application if you cannot be discovered.
“the era of search democratized the internet”
- Commerce is evolving from search, which requires effort, to stream-based browsing and predictive assistants that understand context and surface needs before users ask, reducing friction and increasing purchases.
“getting me the things I need before I even ask for them”
Consolidation, scale, and aggregator platforms concentrate pricing power and capture most internet and software profits.
- The top six or seven global internet companies represented about 5% of the NASDAQ in 2006 and represent about 35% today, so the largest platforms have grown faster over time.
“the top six or seven global internet companies represented about 5% of the NASDAQ”
- Priceline became the single largest global advertiser on Google and built a roughly $100 billion vertical search business by giving better access to hotel inventory, a business that would not have existed without Google.
“Priceline became the single largest global advertiser on Google”
- The airline industry moved from 60% of capacity controlled by 12 airlines in 2004-2005 to 90% controlled by four, which gave the industry pricing power and seven years of record profitability before COVID.
“we went from 60% of the industry being managed by 12 Airlines in 2004, 2005 to 90% of the industry being managed by four airlines”
- Facebook became Altimeter's largest position in 2012 on the thesis that aggregators would capture most profits as commercial intent moved off search, and it remains the largest position in the fund.
“Facebook became our largest position in 2012”
- Aggregator platforms will capture the lion's share of profits because the largest platforms keep expanding into payments, chat and micro-apps, and because smaller companies cannot grow large without being discovered on them.
“the big have gotten bigger at an accelerating rate”
- ByteDance was built from day one to algorithmically serve content that causes users to act, and on Instagram and Facebook, content feeds are becoming commerce because logged-in users are known and can be marketed to, especially for non-discretionary purchases.
“now that content is actually ecommerce”
Feed-based commerce and Chinese innovation shift value toward successive generations of internet winners.
- Successive generations of internet companies scale faster and more capital-efficiently, so the first $10 to $15 billion of value creation for winners accrues to private investors, as with ByteDance's expected path compared with Facebook's.
“the first 10 or $15 billion of value creation is likely to accrue to private market participants”
- Instagram and Facebook feeds now show users products they want, and as users browse rather than type queries, non-discretionary items will increasingly be purchased through feeds, a challenge for Amazon and Google and a strength for Facebook.
“particularly as it relates to non-discretionary items, I think increasingly they'll be purchased that way”
- When ByteDance took its early investment four years earlier, it said it would be the first global internet company, long before it had conceived of the product that became TikTok via Musical.ly.
“We'll be the first global internet company”
- Early Chinese internet firms like Baidu and Ctrip copied US models such as Google and Expedia, but a Chinese professor predicted that a generation or two later innovation would come out of China, which Gerstner sees in ByteDance.
“fast-forward a generation or two and you're going to see the innovation come out of China”
- Chinese eCommerce relies much less on search than US eCommerce, and Pinduoduo's purchases come entirely through a feed rather than search, so commercial intent is captured by content and algorithms.
“Chinese eCommerce is way less about search than US eCommerce is”
Technology reducing friction will keep creating large value across internet and software.
- By almost every measure the world is radically better than a decade ago, with improvements in childbirth mortality, malaria deaths, clean water, education and developing-nation GDP, which Gerstner attributes to enterprising people applying technology to basic problems.
“by almost every measure, the world is radically better today than it was a decade ago”
- The intersection of life sciences and software is the area Gerstner would most like to invest in, because two decades of genome and virus research enabled COVID vaccine development in about six days after sequencing, compared with two years for the original SARS virus.
“It took us something like six days for COVID-19”
- COVID accelerated digitization and cloud adoption as CEOs' phones ring more often, but the underlying shift was already underway and the cloud market had been underestimated in past cycles, just as mobile was underestimated in 2005-2006.
“let's say that COVID just accelerated the rates of digitization.”
- Over the next two decades there will be more value creation and destruction than in the last two decades, because technologies that reduce friction will drive deep traction in internet and software even though specific outcomes cannot be forecast.
“there'll be more value creation and destruction over the next two decades than we've seen over the last two decades.”
- Marketplace flexibility lets drivers earn a good yield on their time, which increases supply and reduces rider wait times, making both sides of the transaction happier and moving labor and capital toward optimal use.
“because we're offering them a good yield on their time. And so the rider is happier, the driver is happier”
Big markets with big prizes matter more than known solutions or small markets.
- Buffett said his highest-returning investments came from simple qualitative insights applied to a big business opportunity, such as GEICO having 1% market share in a massive market with a superior product, where growth to 10% would compound for decades.
“simple qualitative insights applied to a big business opportunity”
- A key lesson from founders is to assume everything you hope to be true occurs and to focus on opportunities with a big prize if things go right, because building a business is equally hard in a small market and a small competitive market is often harder.
“assume everything that you hope to be true occurs. How big is the prize?”
- Zillow's original plan was to disintermediate realtors like Expedia did for travel, but it developed the zestimate, which became a viral tool and a large advertising asset, and the company later returned to its founding principles.
“they famously developed the zestimate, that turned very quickly into a viral form of real estate porn”
- Rich Barton identified real estate as a very large market with a very poor consumer experience and applied the principles from online travel to it, and the lesson is that a big market matters even when the solution is unknown.
“he identified a very large TAM in the case of real estate”
Ride-share and delivery economics will consolidate around sound business models, not single winners.
- Ride-share and food delivery markets will trend toward two-player structures, where fragmented supply supports 15-20% take rates and 25-30% EBITDA margins, like other mature marketplaces, so conviction should rest on the business model rather than picking the single winner.
“these were ultimately going to trend toward two-player markets”
- When a business is good, with a good TAM and management, investors can bet on multiple players in a vast market, as an early China e-commerce investor did by backing the thematic bet but the wrong horse.
“you can bet on multiple players”
- Uber's ride-share segment EBITDA margins were over 30% in January and February, compared with negative 20% six quarters earlier, which Gerstner cites as evidence the model works.
“their segment EBITDA margins in January and February for ride-share were over 30%”
- Excess capital, epitomized by SoftBank's overinvestment, led to excess competition and discounting in ride-share and food delivery, which obscured whether the business model was actually profitable.
“excess capital led to excess competition, excess discounting, companies were burning extreme amounts of cash”
Deep individual study, not group consensus, produces better investment research.
- Altimeter avoids group meetings and daily portfolio reviews, instead giving analysts focused areas to study deeply, so they bring ideas only after years of study; people with an idea of the day or of the week are not a fit.
“if you have an idea of the day, you're not a fit”
- Google's ownership of Priceline and other internet companies revealed massive information synergies between public and private activities, and Gerstner's private venture relationships, such as Bill Gurley and Rich Barton, produce better research than sell-side analyst calls.
“there were massive information synergies between these two sets of activities”
- Paul Reeder taught Gerstner that groupthink is a real danger, so Altimeter hires passionate people, gives each an area of focus, and lets them study deeply rather than vote on companies in group meetings.
“if you have an idea of the day, you're not a fit”
Gig work requires a safety net that attaches healthcare to people, not employers.
- The shift to gig work exposes a dislocation because US healthcare is tied to corporate employers, so the social safety net must evolve to attach healthcare to people rather than employers, even though most drivers and delivery workers value flexibility.
“we certainly need to make sure that we evolve the social safety net that we attach healthcare to people instead of to employers”
- After talking with hundreds of drivers and delivery workers, Gerstner finds that most love the flexibility to work part-time and for multiple companies, which lets people like single mothers or students earn income on their own schedules.
“overwhelmingly, they love the flexibility”
- Racial inequities have not been solved by venture capital or technology, and winner-take-most dynamics in capitalism may widen wealth gaps, so society will have real problems to solve alongside technological progress.
“Certainly, racial inequities have not been solved by venture capital and technology”
Fewer, deeper commitments, judged by whether they are an easy yes, keep life focused.
- In a discussion of essentialism with about 100 busy people, it became clear there was no positive correlation between activity and happiness, so the test for commitments should be whether they are an easy yes.
“there wasn't a positive correlation between activity and happiness”
- Before taking on a dinner, meeting, board seat, or investment, ask whether it is an easy yes; if not, it is an easy no, which keeps life organized around fewer, deeper commitments even though it may not maximize financial return.
“Is what I'm thinking about doing an easy yes?”
- Rich Barton told Gerstner he was a terrible entrepreneur for being too conservative with money after investors had funded him, which exposed how his fear of loss, rooted in his father's bankruptcy, shaped his approach.
“You're a terrible entrepreneur”
Low interest rates and discount rates, not earnings, drive growth stock valuations.
- Gerstner's main macro worry is less about economic cycles or viruses and more about the competing cost of capital, given that investors have benefited from massive liquidity and very low interest rates over the last 15 years.
“if there was a macro item that I worried about, it's less about cycles, it's less about viruses, and it's more about what the competing cost of capital is”
- The technology sector sell-off in the fourth quarter of 2018 was driven by fears that the Fed would raise rates three times in 2019, as shown by the dot plot, rather than by earnings misses.
“It was because the market was worried that the Fed was going to raise rates three times in 2019”
- Lowering the discount rate on a growth software company by 150 basis points over ten years raises its multiple by two to three turns, so the decline in interest rates over the last year justified an index multiple moving from about 12.5 to 14.5 times.
“if I reduce my discount rate on any growth software company by 150 bits over the next 10 years, the multiple will go up by two to three terms”
Gerstner's personal path and mentors shaped how he built Altimeter.
- Gerstner would start Altimeter again over the other four companies he ran or started, because it lets him run an operating business while staying in the trenches as an analyst.
“I would say Altimeter.”
- Paul Reeder, who started Par Capital with about $2.5 million and grew it past $1 billion, gave Gerstner a roadmap, and Baupost showed that a small fund can grow into a great business, so Gerstner started Altimeter with under $5 million.
“Paul Reeder who had started Park Capital with two and a half million bucks”
- The kindest thing Gerstner received was his mother's sacrifice as a single mother working multiple jobs, which enabled a scholarship that led to law school and business school.
“helping me get a scholarship to college which then sent me to law school, sent me to business school”
- Coming out of 2008, no LPs wanted to invest in a hedge fund that also held illiquid private investments, so Gerstner had to start Altimeter with under $5 million using Paul Reeder's Par Capital playbook.
“how many LPs wanted to invest in a hedge fund that was also going to have illiquid private investments? Precisely zero.”