What this covers

This Business Breakdowns episode has Chadd walking through Archaea Energy, which cleans landfill gas until the methane is pure enough to sell into pipelines as RNG. He opens with the scale of the problem, since municipal solid waste accounts for 14.5% of U.S. human-related greenhouse emissions. He then tells the origin story: founders Nick Stork and Richard Walton, both former investors, bought a landfill, found RNG bids too slow and costly, and built their own plant at about half the price. The treatment process gets a step-by-step explanation, with the final removal of carbon dioxide, nitrogen, oxygen, and VOCs singled out as the hard part.

The policy section covers the Renewable Fuel Standard, D3 RIN pricing driven by EPA volume obligations, state mandates, and voluntary buyers such as data centers and the University of California system. Chadd addresses the bear case directly. If a government drops its mandates, fixed-price contracts with no regulatory out still bind counterparties.

On the business side, roughly half of volume is under 10-to-20-year contracts, against about 20% at a competitor. A Republic Services joint venture spans 39 projects, and about 500 of 2,600 U.S. landfills are good candidates. Chadd forecasts that EBITDA could pass $1 billion through carbon sequestration, hydrogen, and well-field expansion. He also infers a tie to GFL from a joint venture named Saturn Renewables. And he credits Jim Koch's habit of listing every objection to his own business as the basis for his Objection Mitigation Heuristic.

Sharpest takeaway

Chadd Garcia argues Archaea Energy is a low-risk, long-duration renewable natural gas business whose value rests on locked-in landfill gas supply, long-term contracts, and government-mandated and voluntary demand for environmental attributes, with its modular build process as the key competitive barrier.

  • Archaea contracts about 50% of volume in 10-20 year contracts with creditworthy buyers, rising toward 70%, making revenue highly forecastable
  • RNG uses existing gas-cleaning technology, so the risk is execution and competition, not new technology
  • Mandated demand (federal RFS, state mandates) and voluntary ESG demand both exceed current RNG supply, and the supply is concentrated among a few producers

The argument · threads9 threads · 56 claims
0.71

Long-term fixed-price contracts give haulers predictable, inflation-protected revenue and remove price risk.

10 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Some rural West Coast communities granted government-mandated monopoly franchises decades ago to attract haulers of scale, and these arrangements remain enforced today, creating protected waste businesses.

    “they had to establish franchises or government-mandated, monopolistic contracts. And for whatever reason, those contracts and franchises are still enforced today.”

  • Waste haulers that own their landfill gain a low-cost economic moat, while haulers that depend on municipality-owned landfills deploy less capital and earn high returns on collection and disposal alone, paying tipping fees for disposal.

    “If you own the landfill, that gives you a bit of an economic moat. You have the low-cost business in the area given that you own the landfill.”

  • Municipalities sign waste hauling contracts of about 3 to 5 years with fixed-price components plus CPI escalators, while residential and commercial customers often pay on shorter month-to-month pickup-based arrangements, giving haulers inflation protection.

    “These contracts can be 3 to 5 years. They'll have a fixed price component with some variability for CPI.”

  • The uncontracted portion of Archaea's RNG is sold on a highest-and-best-use basis into the spot market, currently mostly transportation fuel, and that mix could shift with changes to D3 RIN or LCFS credit economics.

    “The rest of the volume, they sell on a highest and best use basis on the spot market.”

  • Archaea contracts about 50% of its volume under 10-to-20-year agreements with creditworthy blue-chip counterparties, far above a competitor's roughly 20%, making its revenue highly forecastable for a decade or more while the rest is sold spot.

    “Archaea currently contracts around 50% of their volume in long-term contracts, think 10 to 20 years, with creditworthy blue-chip parties.”

  • Even if one state drops renewable electricity mandates, other states will still value renewable gas, so regulatory risk is diversified across jurisdictions rather than a single point of failure.

    “But if one state decides that they don't care about that anymore, that doesn't mean that every other state is not going to care.”

  • A commercialization strategy built on long-term contracts can materially affect other parts of the business, making revenue and free cash flow more durable, which makes equity and debt investment safer and allows higher leverage at lower cost.

    “the commercialization strategy can have a material impact on other parts of the business.”

  • If a government drops renewable mandates, D3 RIN demand could collapse, but one state's exit does not remove others' mandates, and Archaea's fixed-price contracts have no regulatory out, so counterparties must keep buying for 5 to 20 years.

    “Additionally, their fixed-price contracts have no regulatory out.”

  • RIN and LCFS price volatility is the main price risk, but about 50% of volume under long-term fixed-price contracts, rising to 70%, removes most of that exposure, and even those contracts include inflation escalators.

    “50% of their volume is contracted through long-term fixed-price contracts with creditworthy counterparties. That's going to go up to 70%. That risk is off the table.”

  • CFO Brian McCarthy, who came from the multifamily office Saltonstall with decades of energy investing experience, created the commercialization strategy of contracting most volume to creditworthy counterparties over long periods.

    “Shortly after joining, Brian created the commercialization strategy in which they would contract a majority of their volume to creditworthy counterparties over a long period of time.”

0.70

Landfill gas RNG generates strong revenue, cash flow, and high financeable returns for operators.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Archaea generated $195 million of GAAP revenue and $76 million of EBITDA last year, and was expected to reach about $370 million of revenue and about $143 million of EBITDA in 2022, with maintenance capex only about 5% of EBITDA so EBITDA approximates unlevered free cash flow.

    “Last year, they generated, on a GAAP basis, $195 million of revenue. And with that revenue, they generated $76 million of EBITDA.”

  • About 87% of Archaea's revenue comes from RNG or gas-to-electricity production, with 2022 volumes of 10-11 million MMBTU versus about 75 million MMBTU of total RNG supply at end of 2021, and announced voluntary demand projects roughly 2.4 times 2021 production.

    “about 87% of their revenue is generated within RNG or gas-to-electricity production”

  • Archaea's third revenue stream comes from joint ventures with landfill owners where both contribute capital, Archaea earns a margin on equipment sold to the JV, earns management fees, and the landfill partner receives JV equity earnings plus an overriding royalty on all gas produced.

    “A lot of the way that they deal with a landfill operator would be to form a joint venture.”

  • The Republic Services JV covers 39 landfill gas projects requiring about $1.1 billion of capital, with $800 million from Archaea and $300 million from Republic, and landfill operators earn 40%-plus IRRs according to GFL's CEO.

    “There are 39 landfill gas currently in this JV... $800 million of it is coming from Archaea, and $300 million is coming from Republic.”

  • RNG project capex is typically about 4 times projected EBITDA, which inverts to roughly a 25% unlevered IRR, and with long-term contracts lenders would finance about 70% debt, pushing equity IRR up dramatically.

    “The CapEx that's required for an RNG project is 4x the projected EBITDA. So if you invert that, that gives you around a 25% unlevered IRR.”

0.65

Locked-up landfill gas supply against excess RNG demand drives Archaea's path to $1 billion EBITDA.

8 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Beyond the 88 projects' $600 million EBITDA, Archaea could exceed $1 billion through carbon sequestration earning a 45Q credit worth about $1.50 per MMBTU, clean hydrogen on lower-volume sites, and well-field expansion, with those initiatives about 2 years from affecting financials.

    “There are several ways for them within the current 88-project base to get that over $1 billion.”

  • Archaea trades at roughly a $2.5 billion enterprise value, and if it reaches $600 million to $1 billion of EBITDA without another project win, the valuation looks compelling.

    “If they can get to $600 million to $1 billion of EBITDA a year without winning another project, that's compelling. The company is trading at a $2.5 billion enterprise value right now.”

  • Because demand will exceed supply and few producers can deliver volume, the strategic priority is to lock up landfill gas supply through agreements with landfill operators, since the demand will be there.

    “The key is to lock up the supply with the landfill operators. The demand is going to be there.”

  • Archaea has 88 announced projects, expects to commission about 20 in 2023, and these projects are expected to contribute about $600 million of annual EBITDA, requiring roughly $1.9 billion of Archaea capital, which management treats as the downside case.

    “Those 88 projects are expected to contribute $600 million a year in annual EBITDA.”

  • Ten publicly announced RNG sourcing mandates over the next 5 to 10 years imply demand about 2.5 times the current 74 million MMBTU of supply, and since only a handful of producers can supply volume, competition concerns are limited.

    “If you look at the 10 publicly announced mandates to source RNG over the next 5 to 10 years, the demand for it is expected to be 2.5x the current supply.”

  • Even if competitors could copy the modular design, the advanced treatment step is hard to execute, and Archaea has a large locked-up supply base with enough projects to reach $600 million to $1 billion of EBITDA, which provides enough margin of safety that competition is not a major worry.

    “I think that provides enough margin of safety to me to not really have to worry about the competition too much.”

  • Of 2,600 U.S. municipal solid waste landfills, about 20% already have gas-to-energy projects, and of the remaining 2,100, roughly 500 are good RNG candidates that have sufficient gas volume and sit within about 3 miles of a natural gas pipeline.

    “Around 500 of those sites are likely good candidates for RNG projects.”

  • Archaea has a $1.1 billion debt facility with $500 million drawn, has $600 million more to pull down to fund the roughly $1.9 billion needed over about 5 years, expects free cash flow to cover the rest, and would likely use project-level financing if new capital is needed rather than new equity.

    “They've got a $1.1 billion debt facility, of which $500 million of that is in use.”

0.62

Mandated and voluntary buyers create durable demand for renewable natural gas and credits.

7 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Data center operators pursuing carbon-neutral status by 2030 will have to buy renewable natural gas or its environmental attributes, because that is how they can reach neutrality given their electricity use.

    “Marc Ganzi, whom I believe you had on the podcast, from DigitalBridge, talked about being carbon neutral in the data center business by 2030.”

  • A D3 RIN trading at $2.50 converts to about $29.32 per million BTU of natural gas, which is substantial compared with a spot natural gas price of about $6 per MMBTU, so the credit can be worth more than the gas itself.

    “Presently, a D3 RIN is trading for $2.50. When you convert that to 1 million BTUs... that value of a RIN is $29.32 per million BTU”

  • Organizations such as large companies, data centers, and quasi-governmental bodies like the University of California system buy renewable gas or its environmental attributes to meet self-imposed Scope 1 emissions and ESG goals, and this voluntary demand is effectively quasi-regulatory once companies publicly report targets.

    “While these programs are voluntary, they're kind of not if the company comes out and says, Here are our ESG goals that we're going to hold ourselves to, and they report them.”

  • Chadd expects the SEC to crack down on companies that set ESG standards and fail to meet them, which would make voluntary ESG pledges more binding.

    “I think the SEC is going to crack down on setting ESG standards and not living up to them.”

  • The federal Renewable Fuel Standard, created under the Energy Policy Act of 2005, requires transportation fuel to contain renewable fuels, tracked by RINs, and landfill gas qualifies for the highest-tier D3 RINs, creating mandated demand for landfill gas.

    “The EPA mandated that a certain amount of transportation fuel needs to be generated with renewable fuels.”

  • Several U.S. states and Canadian provinces mandate that a percentage of electricity be generated from renewable fuels, extending mandated demand for renewable natural gas into the electricity generation market.

    “several states or Canadian provinces may have state mandates that mandate a certain percentage of electricity consumption within their state or province to be generated with renewable fuels”

  • The EPA's annual renewable volume obligation drives RIN demand, each renewable gallon generates a RIN, and new fuel types increase RIN supply, so RIN prices are volatile and set by policy and supply additions.

    “the amount of fuel that the government sets that must be made with renewable fuel every year is going to drive the demand part of D3 RINs as well.”

0.43

Archaea's prebuilt facilities and internal team deliver RNG faster and cheaper than competitors.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • CFO Brian McCarthy, who came from the Boston multifamily office Saltonstall, created the long-term contracting strategy, and in April 2021 Archaea combined with Ares-owned Aria Energy and went public via a Rice family SPAC with no SPAC carry for insiders.

    “Shortly after joining, Brian created the commercialization strategy in which they would contract a majority of their volume to creditworthy counterparties over a long period of time.”

  • Archaea's legacy gas-to-electricity assets are like oil reserves held by production: they keep a small operation running to secure the asset while building toward a fuller use, and over time the sites will be converted to RNG while electricity generation continues.

    “And it's called held by production. Archaea bought a business that was focused on gas to electricity.”

  • Archaea can buy pipeline natural gas to run its legacy electricity assets, which hedges electricity, one of its largest expenses, while RNG revenue is captured separately.

    “keep the electrical assets running on standard brown gas and use those assets and hedge one of their largest expenses, which is electricity”

  • Archaea's founders Nick Stork and Richard Walton, both former investors, bought a landfill, found RNG bids too expensive and slow, and built their own facility with an internal team at about half the bid cost in less time, which became the basis for the business.

    “They went out for bids with contractors to build an RNG facility on their landfill. They found the bids to be quite expensive and the development time to be quite long.”

  • Archaea prebuilds RNG facilities from interchangeable subcomponents delivered by flatbed truck and assembled on site, which yields lower cost, faster deployment, higher uptime, and greater methane recovery than bespoke competitor builds.

    “Archaea prebuilds their RNG facilities using a modular design. Most of the RNG projects are prebuilt, and they use interchangeable subcomponents.”

0.36

Existing gas-cleaning technology carries no new technology risk, given minor tweaks and better execution.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Archaea faces no new technology risk because it uses existing gas-cleaning technology with minor tweaks and better execution, so Chadd's initial worry about new technology risk was mistaken.

    “There's not any new technology risk because the company is not using a new technology to clean out the landfill gas”

  • Applying an existing technology to new uses can widen adoption of that technology without incurring new technology risk, which is a key lesson from the analysis of Archaea.

    “new applications of a technology can produce new uses or a wider spread of adoption of that technology without incurring new technology risk.”

  • Archaea addresses supply chain risk with an upfront bulk ordering program started in December 2021, and Chadd believes it could benefit from inflation because its long-term fixed-price contracts include inflation escalators.

    “The company is dealing with this by having an upfront bulk ordering program that started in December of '21.”

0.35

GFL's landfill gas business holds hidden value that BP's deal and partnerships reveal.

7 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Montauk Renewables is similar in size but sells mostly on spot, OPAL is a competitor, Kinder Morgan's RNG business is only about 2% of EBITDA, and Waste Management will build internally, leaving Waste Connections, Republic, and GFL as the realistic partners for landfill-gas JVs.

    “Waste Management, which is the largest landfill operator, is going to do it internally. Their landfills are kind of off the table at this point.”

  • Archaea's 10-K references a JV called Saturn Renewables, and by mapping its location to the local landfill operator, GFL, Chadd infers an established Archaea-GFL relationship that could yield future announcements.

    “the JV is called Saturn Renewables. And if you look at the location of that JV and go to Google, the landfill operator in that town is GFL.”

  • The $4.1 billion BP transaction value implies roughly 15 times the free cash flow expected in late 2023 or early 2024, and applying that multiple to GFL's $200 million internal estimate implies about US$5 per share, or CAD 8, of hidden value in GFL's stock.

    “that's about 15x free cash flow is what BP is paying.”

  • BP's $4.1 billion enterprise value purchase of Archaea looks like a good deal for BP, slightly under what Kinder Morgan paid for lower-quality landfill gas assets, and Chadd suspects it may spark a competitive bidding process by Kinder Morgan, Brookfield, or others.

    “I definitely think that BP is getting a good deal.”

  • GFL guided to $125 million to $150 million of annual unlevered free cash flow from its landfill gas projects within a couple of years, but its internal goal is $175 million to $200 million, which Chadd says investors should weight more heavily than the public estimate.

    “they also noted that their internal goals for these projects are to generate $175 million to $200 million a year in free cash flow.”

  • GFL's CEO described landfill gas RNG projects as 40% plus IRR projects and the best use of capital in its business, which corroborates the attractiveness of the economics for landfill operators.

    “the CEO said that for him, these were 40% plus IRR projects and the best use of capital in this business.”

  • GFL has said it is evaluating partners and wants to deploy capital in this space, while Republic's existing contracts with other operators will expire, possibly opening its JV to new landfills.

    “Republic already has some contracts with other operators, but those contracts at some point will expire.”

0.32

Capturing and purifying landfill methane is difficult but eliminates a major warming source.

6 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Newer companies filter landfill gas to isolate methane at a purity high enough to sell into natural gas pipelines, converting a waste byproduct with no value into a commodity that also eliminates odor and reduces greenhouse impact.

    “Companies that are coming along now are taking the landfill gas and filtering it to isolate the methane in such a degree of purity that the methane can be sold into natural gas pipelines.”

  • Landfill gas from decomposing municipal organic waste is roughly 50% methane, 35% carbon dioxide, and 15% oxygen plus other volatile compounds, and methane is about 25 times more potent than carbon dioxide at trapping heat, so raw release is a major warming problem.

    “The composition of landfill gas is roughly 50% methane, 35% carbon dioxide, 15% oxygen and then a handful of other volatile organic compounds.”

  • Historically, landfills captured methane and flared it, which removes the odor and converts the methane to less potent carbon dioxide, but they received no economic value for it; others burned it in on-site generators to make electricity used locally or sold to the grid.

    “for which they receive no economic value, but when they flare it, it turns the methane into carbon dioxide and water”

  • Municipal solid waste accounts for 14.5% of human-related greenhouse gas emissions in the U.S., and landfill methane equals the annual emissions of about 20 million passenger vehicles or the CO2 from powering 12 million homes.

    “Municipal solid waste in the U.S. accounts for 14.5% of human-related greenhouse gas emissions.”

  • Landfills are built in lined cells with PVC-type liners to block groundwater leakage, leachate from rain is collected and treated, and landfill gas is pulled through vertical and horizontal wells, with little gas produced in the first year before anaerobic bacteria generate methane.

    “The landfill gas is collected by wells that are drilled both vertically and horizontally into landfills”

  • Converting landfill gas to RNG requires primary moisture removal, secondary impurity removal, and an advanced treatment that strips out carbon dioxide, nitrogen, oxygen, and VOCs to isolate methane, which is the difficult step to execute.

    “The third treatment removes the carbon dioxide, the nitrogen, the oxygen and other volatile organic compounds from the gas.”

0.29

Regulatory complexity and sponsor pedigree support the investment case.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Jim Koch of Boston Beer Company wrote down every reason people gave for why his beer business would fail, and left BCG only after finding a way to mitigate each one, a method Chadd applied to Archaea's risk analysis.

    “he just wrote down all the reasons why people told him that he would fail.”

  • Government regulation creates complexity, and that complexity creates opportunity, particularly where several layers of regulation overlap, as with RIN, state mandate, and ESG demand for landfill gas.

    “government regulations can create complexity, and that complexity creates opportunities, particularly when you have several layers of government regulations.”

  • Nick Stork and Richard Walton entered investing before buying a landfill and learning operations firsthand, and their compliance challenges running it led them to see the RNG opportunity.

    “The business was founded by Nick Stork, who's the CEO; and Richard Walton, who is currently the President.”

  • Blackstone told David Rubenstein in a 2021 interview with Jonathan Gray that every new asset would target a 15% carbon footprint reduction, and while efficiency upgrades help, most ESG compliance will come from buying environmental attributes.

    “he said that every asset they have going forward, they're going to try to reduce their carbon footprint by 15%.”

  • In April 2021 Archaea merged with Aria Energy, an RNG company owned by Ares Management, and went public through a Rice family SPAC; unlike most SPACs, there is no SPAC sponsor carry, so insiders gain only from outright stock ownership.

    “And there's no SPAC carry in this one, which is on the rarer side.”