What this covers

Ryan O'Connor tells Nintendo's story in two halves. The first is history. He attributes the 1983 crash to a flood of copycat third-party games for the Atari VCS, plus declining quality in Atari's own titles such as the rushed E.T. adaptation. He also covers Activision's founding by disgruntled Atari developers in 1979. The NES, in his account, revived the market through unusual hardware, a thumb-operated D-Pad, and the first real quality control. A lockout chip kept unlicensed games from running. Third-party developers were capped at five games a year and kept off rival consoles for about two years. A 30% fee leads him to call the licensing system the world's first app store, a contested framing.

The second half turns to the present. Consoles once rebuilt their user base every five to six years, and the roughly 13.5 million Wii U sales are his trigger for change. He leans on diminishing returns in hardware: a PS5 game looks better than a PS4 game, but nothing like the leap from 2D Mario to the N64. He contrasts Nintendo, which profits on hardware, with Sony and Microsoft, which sell at a loss. He argues that roughly $300 million AAA budgets push those two toward multiplatform releases, and that they have ceded young children to Nintendo.

Several tangents follow. Nintendo shunned licensing after the early-1990s Super Mario Bros. film, then moved into movies, theme parks, and merchandise around 2015. It also reportedly canceled a roughly half-billion-dollar Zelda anime deal with Netflix after a leak. Digital distribution, Japan's push against cross-shareholdings, and Metacritic scores as evidence of quality round out the territory. He frames investing as spotting value-unlocking change already underway.

Sharpest takeaway

Ryan O'Connor argues Nintendo has shifted from a hits-driven console maker into a recurring-revenue platform business modeled on Apple's iterative hardware and app-store economics, so its installed base never resets and its margins and valuation should keep expanding.

  • Nintendo's installed base now accumulates across hardware generations instead of resetting to zero, as it did every five to six years before
  • Digital software, online subscriptions, DLC, and the third-party ecosystem raise margins and revenue durability
  • IP monetization through movies, theme parks, and licensing creates a flywheel that drives hardware and software sales

The argument · threads13 threads · 78 claims
0.82

A single persistent, upgraded platform keeps Nintendo's installed base from resetting each generation and eliminates hardware-cycle losses.

9 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Historically each console generation forced platform makers to rebuild their user base from zero every five to six years, making console earnings highly cyclical and unpredictable.

    “never needed to reset to zero as it had every five to six years in the past”

  • By adopting a Apple-like iterative hardware model, in which one platform keeps receiving upgrades and software, Nintendo ensures its installed base keeps growing and never resets to zero with each new system, which was the Achilles heel of the console business.

    “transitioned to a very Apple-like iterative hardware model where the net effect of all this is its installed base will continually grow and never reset to zero with each new system as it had in the past”

  • Unlike Sony and Microsoft, which have historically sold consoles at a loss and recouped through software and app store fees, Nintendo makes a profit on its hardware, much like Apple does.

    “Unlike Sony and Microsoft, Nintendo does make a profit on its hardware, much like Apple does”

  • Improvements in gaming and phone hardware have become incremental, so older devices remain viable for newer software, which allows platforms to keep their installed base across generations.

    “there's a much bigger difference between, say, a 2006 Nokia flip phone and the original 2007 iPhone than there is between a 2007 iPhone and today's iPhone 16”

  • Under the old model, profit grew for three or four years of each console cycle and then fell for a year or two during hardware transitions; the Apple-like iterative model should eliminate those losses and profitability drops.

    “you should never have losses or a massive drop in the profitability of the business as you approach new generations of hardware”

  • Because technology improvements are incremental and operating systems persist across hardware, Apple, Nintendo, Sony, and Microsoft no longer need to rebuild their user base from scratch, which massively reduced revenue volatility across hardware and related products.

    “Those two things together basically massively reduced their company's revenue volatility”

  • Apple's third-party app store generates tens of billions of dollars in profits a year by taking a tax on every third-party game sold, and Nintendo has been building the ingredients for a similar ecosystem.

    “the third-party app store ecosystem that Apple has gone on to generate tens of billions in profits a year from by taking a tax”

  • When the Switch launched in 2017, its games looked much the same as those on its immediate predecessor, yet Nintendo was already hinting at the Apple-style model of a platform that persists across hardware.

    “But when the Switch launched in 2017, its games looked pretty much the same as those of its immediate predecessor.”

  • With the original Switch, Nintendo restructured its business around a single console that works as both a home and portable device, which had permanent effects on the company's profitability.

    “Nintendo restructured its business around a single console that was essentially a home and portable console in one.”

0.71

Recurring software, subscription, DLC, and in-game revenue make Nintendo a stable, secular growth company.

10 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Over roughly the last five to seven years Nintendo transformed from a cyclical, hits-driven console business into a secular growth company with increasingly stable recurring revenue, expanding margins, and declining capital intensity, because its earnings no longer depend on the success or failure of each new console.

    “transformed from a cyclical kind of hits-driven business to what is now fast approaching a secular growth juggernaut defined by increasingly stable recurring revenue, expanding margins, and declining capital intensity”

  • Nintendo plans a Nintendo Cinematic Universe with a movie cadence approaching one per year, modeled on Disney's Marvel Cinematic Universe, using films as infinite return marketing for console and game sales.

    “they were building up to a movie cadence of approximately one NCU”

  • Nintendo Switch Online membership has compounded at about 25 percent a year, and digital software, now about 50 percent of software sales, is expected to approach 85 percent at maturity.

    “Membership at Nintendo Switch Online is compounded at 25% a year.”

  • The Super Mario Bros. movie was seen by over 170 million people, and Mario title sales rose roughly 50 percent in the aftermath, showing that film exposure drives game and hardware demand.

    “you saw that I think Mario titles increased roughly 50% in total sales in the aftermath of the Super Mario Brothers movie”

  • After the poorly received live-action Super Mario Bros. movie in the early 1990s, Nintendo was extremely averse to licensing its IP until around 2015, when it began monetizing IP through films, theme parks, and merchandise.

    “That event, the fallout from just how bad that movie was, created a very deep level of PTSD within the culture of Nintendo”

  • Software has grown from roughly half of Nintendo's revenue mix alongside hardware to about 60 percent today, and Ryan expects the mix to reach roughly 80 percent software, 20 percent hardware in the long run.

    “Think of it broadly speaking as 60-40 today versus 50-50 in the past”

  • Nintendo Switch Online's value comes from a back catalog of retro games such as NES, Super Nintendo, Game Boy Advance, Sega Genesis, and N64 titles, and this library is expected to expand to GameCube and Wii games with Switch 2.

    “you get basically all of the retro consoles and vintage, call it evergreen game classics that Nintendo had put in the past”

  • Downloadable content and in-game purchases convert Nintendo's major franchises from one-off purchases into recurring revenue, extending the life of titles like Mario and Zelda by a year or two after launch and generating long-duration profit.

    “instead of it being just a simple one-off purchase, it creates recurring revenue and more consistent durable revenue and profits over time”

  • Nintendo's subscription is cheap to deliver because it monetizes software Nintendo built and expensed decades earlier, so the marginal cost of offering retro classics to subscribers is low.

    “Nintendo had built this software and expensed it through their income statement in some cases decades ago”

  • Nintendo's core first-party games are sold as one-time purchases rather than through subscriptions, while recurring revenue comes from online services, DLC, and in-game monetization layered on top.

    “You have your classic evergreen franchises, the latest Mario and Zelda, you're going to pay for those. It's going to be, for the most part, a one-off purchase.”

0.68

Reversing past neglect, Switch and Switch 2 make third-party AAA development attractive and essential for publishers.

9 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Nintendo's Switch-era investments in online infrastructure, a developer portal, Unity and Unreal middleware support, and cheap development kits make it more attractive for third-party developers to build games, echoing the NES licensing strategy.

    “they have gone out of their way to make their development kits”

  • Average big AAA tentpole games cost around 300 million dollars, and installed bases of Sony and Microsoft are no longer large enough to justify those budgets, which is why they are going multiplatform with first-party titles.

    “the average big AAA tentpole game for those systems costs around $300 million”

  • Nintendo has the largest active player base in the industry, compounding at about 30 percent a year since 2017, and third-party titles on the Switch have compounded at about 40 percent a year to roughly 11,000 titles.

    “That has compounded, I believe, at 30% a year since 2017”

  • With Switch 2 hardware approximately on par with current PlayStation and Xbox systems, Nintendo can run full-fidelity AAA third-party games, a step change from the dumbed-down ports the original Switch received, which should expand AAA availability on its platform.

    “That is approximately on par with the latest and greatest from the more graphically intense hardware of Sony and Microsoft”

  • Technological improvements between console generations have become incremental, so a PS5 game looks better than a PS4 game but the difference matters little, unlike the night-and-day jump from early 2D Mario to 3D Mario on the N64.

    “If you play a PlayStation 4 game versus a PlayStation 5 game, does the PlayStation 5 game look better? Yes. Does it really matter at this point? Not really.”

  • Because the original Switch used roughly 2013-era mobile technology, AAA third-party games like Call of Duty and Madden were too demanding, so the few that did release were dumbed-down versions.

    “The original Switch was a console that it's basically 2013-era mobile technology.”

  • Nintendo's previous approach kept its hardware built for its own games, and it largely ignored third-party developers after 1990, while the Switch era reverses that by investing in dedicated servers, developer portals, and engine support.

    “in the past Nintendo has created its own games for its own hardware and really didn't spend much attention at all post-1990”

  • Third-party AAA developers now cannot afford to skip the Switch because of Nintendo's large active player base and profit pool, which is a sharp change from the original Switch launch.

    “certainly they really can't afford not to make games for the Switch, given the way the industry has evolved.”

  • A Nintendo game might cost 50 to 100 million dollars to make, which is many times less than the cost of a peer's AAA game, because Nintendo's titles are built on gameplay loops rather than graphical horsepower.

    “It might cost Nintendo 50 to $100 million to make a game where it'll cost its peers many times that.”

0.65

Best-in-class franchises, monetized through films and licensing, are Nintendo's core source of value.

8 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Nintendo is focused on preserving the permanence and quality of its franchises, and unlike Disney, which Ryan says has damaged Star Wars, it avoids cash grabs and injecting contemporary politics into its entertainment.

    “you're not going to see the cash grabs or injecting contemporary politics into escapism”

  • Nintendo had a tentative deal to sell rights to an anime Zelda series to Netflix for roughly half a billion dollars, but canceled it after a Netflix employee leaked the project, showing it values trust over short-term payouts.

    “Nintendo had a tentative deal for three seasons to sell the rights to an anime Zelda franchise to Netflix for something like a half a billion dollars”

  • Roughly ten separate Nintendo franchises could become billion-dollar global blockbusters if given the same film care that Mario received.

    “There's probably 10 separate franchises that I think could be billion-dollar-plus global blockbusters”

  • Nintendo's IP monetization through films, theme parks, and licensing is treated as a flywheel that improves brand recognition and mind share while driving revenue and profit growth alongside margin and digital shifts.

    “better monetization of digital software and other forms of IP, think movies and theme parks and IP merchandise licensing that come together to create a flywheel effect”

  • The biggest risk to Nintendo is that it unwinds its post-2015 transformation by returning to insular IP protection, abandoning films and theme parks, and hoarding excess cash instead of returning it.

    “The risk is very simply that they start to unwind all of the progress that they have made since 2015”

  • Nintendo's film and entertainment segment could be worth between a third and a half of Nintendo's current market value on its own, a valuation Ryan offers as a rough estimate.

    “I think it's probably worth somewhere between a third to half what you're paying for Nintendo in its entirety today”

  • Nintendo has the best intellectual property in the video game business by several orders of magnitude.

    “Nintendo has the best IP in the video game business by, I would say, several orders of magnitude”

  • Nintendo was incorporated in September 1889 and originally sold playing cards, including to Yakuza, before moving through various businesses into toys and video games.

    “I think it's September 23rd, 1889, was when Nintendo was originally incorporated”

0.48

Apple-style iterative hardware makes the risk of Switch 2 failing very low.

7 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Nintendo hardware has historically sold because of gameplay loops rather than graphical power, and most Switch-generation titles score above 85 on Metacritic, which Ryan treats as evidence of consistent quality.

    “the Metascore for almost all of them is above 85, which is kind of unheard of”

  • Apple grew its installed base from a standing start in 2007 to about 1.5 billion devices in roughly ten years, laying the groundwork for the App Store, which Ryan considers one of the greatest businesses of the last twenty years.

    “this is what allowed Apple to go from basically a standing start in 2007 to, I don't know what it is today, 1.5 billion”

  • Starting around 2014, Sony and Microsoft also moved toward backward compatibility and cross-generation software ecosystems, so all major console makers became structurally more profitable and reduced cyclicality.

    “both Sony and Microsoft starting around 2014 shifted to a similar transition”

  • The risk of Switch 2 failing is very low because no Nintendo hardware generation has sold less than about 90 million units, and the installed base does not reset to zero.

    “no Nintendo generation of hardware has ever sold less than 90 million”

  • Switch 2 uses Nvidia's DLSS AI, so games bought on the original Switch will receive graphical and frame-rate upgrades on day one, making them play almost like remasters.

    “they are actually going to be dramatically upgraded”

  • Nintendo leaders Iwata and Miyamoto explicitly referenced Apple's iterative hardware model in their statements, indicating a deliberate strategic study of Apple as the template for a long-lived console platform.

    “I was going back and reviewing a lot of the statements that Iwata and Miyamoto had made, but they were reflecting on Apple”

  • The Wii U sold about 13.5 million units over its life, a disappointing follow-up to the Wii caused by unclear positioning and marketing failures, which Ryan cites as the trigger for the shift to the iterative model.

    “They basically, I think they sold 13 and a half million over the life of the console”

0.43

Shifting to digital sales and subscriptions is expanding Nintendo's profit margins.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Nintendo Switch Online works like a Netflix of games, offering online multiplayer plus a rotating library of retro classics for a monthly fee, while the new first-party games are sold as one-time purchases, unlike Microsoft's pricier Game Pass.

    “simplistically, the way you could look at that is as a Netflix of video games”

  • Nintendo's operating margin rose from mid-single digits around the Switch launch in 2017 to the mid-30s today, and Ryan thinks margins could exceed 50 percent within two to three years.

    “This is a business that has gone from low single digits in terms of its operating profitability to the mid-30s”

  • Industry-wide digital sales are about 65 percent of game sales, and Nintendo, which started its shift about five years later than peers, is expected to converge toward the same mix, around 85 percent.

    “industry-wide it's right around 65%”

  • Physical game sales yield roughly 45 to 50 percent gross margin after retailer cuts, while digital sales can yield 80 to 90 percent including DLC, so the shift to digital structurally expands profit per unit.

    “that resulted in, call it a gross margin net of everything, I've call it in the 45 to 50% range”

  • Digital distribution is a clear win for all parties, because developers keep more revenue, Nintendo earns more per sale, and consumers avoid retail lines by pre-downloading games before midnight release.

    “it really is better for everybody, each side of the network”

0.40

Nostalgia and a broad audience of young kids and adults aged 30 to 50 let Nintendo reach players peers cannot.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The highest-spending console cohort is people aged roughly 30 to 50 who grew up with these games, and the average gamer is about 34 to 35, so peers have focused on this group despite long-run risk.

    “By far the highest spending players are those with income that are say 30 to 50 years old”

  • Sony and Microsoft have effectively conceded the young kids market to Nintendo because of the nature of their games, while Nintendo deliberately invests in titles like Yoshi, Princess Peach, and Super Mario Wonder for younger players.

    “two of the three big players in console hardware have essentially conceded the kids market to Nintendo”

  • Nintendo's limited play test, which leaked, appears to be a live-service MMO aimed at younger players that could compete directly with Roblox and Minecraft.

    “it looks to be a Roblox-Minecraft killer MMO-type live-service game”

  • Nintendo's strategy of intergenerational nostalgia, where parents share childhood games with children and grandchildren, lets it acquire customers aged 4 to 12 in a way peers cannot replicate, which Ryan thinks will matter over ten years.

    “Nintendo will continue to acquire customers in the age groups of say 4 to 12 in a way that its peers can't possibly replicate”

0.40

Value-unlocking change and resumed capital returns should lift Nintendo's stock.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Intelligent investing means identifying value-unlocking change already underway, where the past and present diverge and markets fail to appreciate the shift, rather than attempting to predict the future.

    “this is not about predicting or forecasting the future at all. Rather it's about recognizing change that is already underway that the markets don't understand”

  • Nintendo bought back about 11 percent of its equity over the last decade but paused during the Switch 2 transition, and Ryan expects buybacks and dividends to resume and accelerate given its large cash pile.

    “they've bought back roughly 11% of their equity in various bits and pieces”

  • Looking at the stock price from one year before a new console launch to two years after, Nintendo's average net annual gain over that three-year window was roughly 200 percent, which Ryan says reflects the cycle of growth followed by reinvestment losses.

    “I think the average net annual gain over that three-year period is roughly 200%-ish or thereabouts”

  • The Japanese government is pushing corporations, through regulation and courts, to unwind cross-shareholdings that insulate management and to improve buybacks and return on equity, a structural change that reduces the old Japan Inc. governance problem.

    “the Japanese government basically forced corporates to unwind a lot of the insular habits of the past, like cross-holdings”

0.32

Nintendo's NES licensing, lockout chip, and quality control restored order after the 1983 crash.

6 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The NES was the first home console to feature a cross-shaped D-pad, which let players move on screen with a thumb and freed the other hand to press action buttons, a design that has persisted across nearly all consoles and portables since.

    “The NES was basically the first home console to feature the cross pad or as we would call it now, the D-Pad”

  • Nintendo's lockout chip meant only Nintendo could make working cartridges for the NES, so unlicensed games simply would not run on its hardware, which made the flood of low-quality games that had sunk the US market effectively impossible.

    “they created what are called lockout chips”

  • Nintendo limited third-party developers to five NES games per year and required them to avoid rival consoles for about two years, which kept low-quality flooding in check and locked developers into its platform.

    “they limited the number of games they could release on the NES to five games per year”

  • Nintendo charged third-party developers a 30% fee for access to its hardware and licensing, making the NES's seal-of-quality licensing system effectively the world's first app store, a model Apple later scaled.

    “Nintendo charged these third-party developers a 30% fee for access to its hardware, obviously a model that Apple would go on to leverage”

  • By the early 1990s Nintendo had roughly 90 percent market share in home consoles, comparable to Microsoft's dominance of Excel and Word.

    “they had essentially 90% market share dominance”

  • Nintendo's NES single-handedly revived the video game industry after the 1983 crash through three differentiators: unusual hardware such as the light gun and robot, ergonomic thumb-operated D-pad design, and the first real quality control over third-party games.

    “there were three points that I think are critical to what pushed video games in general, and Nintendo in particular, back into center stage”

0.29

The NES succeeded through gimmicky hardware, low cost, and strict quality control on Nintendo's own titles.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Mario was first named Jumpman as a generic plumber in arcade games alongside Donkey Kong, and arcades took off across the US, which is where Shigeru Miyamoto first entered the software space.

    “That's where you see, I believe Mario was first named Jumpman as just a generic plumber along with Donkey Kong.”

  • The NES's gimmicky hardware, including the Gyromite robot and the light gun, offered differentiated gameplay that attracted the first wave of consumers even though neither gimmick had long-lasting success.

    “they did offer differentiated gameplay experiences that basically were a big part of attracting that first wave of consumers to the system.”

  • The product that opened the door for Nintendo's path to video games was the Duck Hunt light gun, and an early bowling-alley arcade business with a partner like Mattel or Magnavox started the relationship that led there.

    “the actual product that Nintendo made that really opened the door and made the rest of the runway possible is, believe it or not, the Duck Hunt light gun.”

  • When it launched, the NES was about five years ahead of competitors in graphics and gameplay while being far cheaper than the console systems then available, such as Atari's.

    “it was not only five years ahead of the competition in terms of graphics and gameplay ... but it was actually far cheaper than the current console systems”

  • Quality control was the most important innovation of the NES: Nintendo strictly controlled third-party developers, requiring submission and licensing to earn the Nintendo Seal of Quality, which made Nintendo's own in-house titles the benchmark.

    “for the first time ever, its games were subject to quality control”

0.26

Copycat flooding and rushed licensed games caused the 1983 video game crash.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Atari buried thousands of unsold E.T. game cartridges in a New Mexico landfill after the game sold poorly, a symbol of the industry's collapse.

    “it ended up selling so poorly that Atari, because it didn't know what to do with all of these excess copies, buried thousands of the unsold games in a New Mexico landfill”

  • The NES was a remodeled version of Nintendo's Famicom, which debuted in Japan around 1983 and launched in the United States in 1985 into a market that had been dead for nearly two years after the crash.

    “a remodeled version of Nintendo's Famicom, which stands for family computer, that debuted in Japan I think in '83”

  • In 1979 disgruntled former Atari developers founded Activision, which became the first third-party developer of games for home consoles and inspired a wave of copycat publishers.

    “some of the disgruntled software developers from Atari basically left and started Activision, which was essentially the world's first third-party developer of video games for home consoles”

  • The 1983 video game crash was caused by a flood of poor-quality copycat third-party games for the Atari VCS, combined with declining quality even in Atari's own titles such as the rushed E.T. adaptation, which made consumers close their wallets and the copycat firms exit.

    “The market had become smothered by a glut of copycat game developers for the Atari VCS”

0.26

Nintendo's broad family audience, Illumination partnership, and disciplined capital management support its strategy.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Nintendo's management will not follow Henry Singleton's aggressive model of tendering for a third of the shares and levering up, even though the company's stable profitability would allow it to do so safely.

    “This is not the second coming of Henry Singleton”

  • The Super Mario Bros. movie, which reportedly reached over 170 million viewers, and the merchandise and cross-media ecosystem have built a broad kids engagement that Ryan sees in local behavior like Halloween costumes and school screenings.

    “I think something like over 170 million people saw the 'Super Mario Brothers' movie.”

  • Nintendo's management philosophy changes are part of a larger shift in Japanese corporate governance, and the trend makes the 'Japanese Inc.' problem of cash hoarding less likely.

    “anyone that's being paying attention to the structural changes that are ongoing in Japan writ large right now should be pretty clear”

  • Illumination is the most capital-efficient, high-return movie studio in history, and its animated features are consistently profitable, making the partnership a home run for Nintendo.

    “Illumination, which is easily the most capital-efficient high-return movie studio in the history of man”

0.23

Rival platforms are struggling, with Sony's bloated AAA budgets and Xbox hardware in terminal decline.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Nintendo's strategy is built on intergenerational nostalgia, offering games that let parents and grandparents share experiences with children, while Sony and Microsoft's focus on adult, Call of Duty-style gaming makes them look withdrawn from the world.

    “one of the big differences ... is laser focused on what I would call intergenerational nostalgia”

  • Sony has struggled to create software for PS5 because budgets have grown to mind-bogglingly high levels, and each AAA game is like a motion-capture movie combined with a video game.

    “Sony itself has been struggling to create software for PS5. I mean, the budgets have gone into just mind-bogglingly insane levels of expensiveness.”

  • Ryan believes Xbox hardware is in terminal decline and that Microsoft is likely to abandon the hardware completely within about two years.

    “the writing's on the wall that Xbox hardware is in terminal decline. And I think they're likely to abandon it completely at some point over the next two years.”