What this covers
This is a solo episode in which Sia works through Sony as a Margin Expansion Investing case rather than a bet on a large addressable market. She builds a Sum-of-the-Parts Valuation: PlayStation and Crunchyroll get a multiple above 20 times on roughly $10 to $11 billion of earnings in four to five years, and the other segments get consensus multiples. She says Sony's margins were historically low single digits, with brief peaks, and that the mid-teens level now is a new norm rather than another cycle. PlayStation, in her framing, is an app store, content library and storage locker, not cyclical hardware.
Most of the detail concerns Crunchyroll. She cites about 150 million users but only 15 million payers, and ARPU near $9 a month against roughly $140 for Netflix. She likens it to Netflix in 2011. Her argument for its durability is that most anime is licensed from Japanese manga IP, which Netflix's originals have not matched. The claim that it is the world's third-largest streaming platform is flagged as contested. Elsewhere she covers Japanese transmedia IP and Bandai Namco, concerts in Fortnite with Epic Games, console penetration in China and India, and game streaming as the main risk. She also covers Sony's Sonium Layer-2 blockchain for IP ownership.
The closing turn is about management. She says Japanese investing taught her that a thesis fails if management cannot communicate the vision, and that better segment disclosure, especially of Crunchyroll, would let the market value the parts.
Sia argues Sony is undervalued because its PlayStation and Crunchyroll software platforms will drive a margin doubling and earnings growth at the conglomerate, which should trigger a multiple re-rating that the market has not priced.
- PlayStation and Crunchyroll are high-margin software and distribution platforms that are early in monetization, so conglomerate margins should roughly double from about 10% over four to five years.
- Sony trades at a single-digit multiple despite having a leading position in entertainment categories, so earnings growth plus multiple expansion creates a roughly triple return.
- The conglomerate discount persists because the entertainment engine is buried among six divisions, so better disclosure would let investors value the parts.
Undervalued PlayStation and Crunchyroll software deserve higher multiples, driving Sony's re-rating.
- Sony is a roughly $120 billion enterprise value company with about $80 billion in revenue and $9 billion in earnings across six segments, and its Sony Entertainment division, which is three of the six divisions, represents about 60% of revenue and earnings, making it the key to the investment thesis.
“It's a company of 120 billion enterprise value. It generates about 80 billion of revenue, 9 billion earnings across six business segments.”
- Sony's underappreciated value lies in two generational consumer platforms, PlayStation and Crunchyroll, which capture secular growth in video games and anime, while the market still views Sony mainly through its hardware and legacy media reputation.
“it has two generational consumer platforms in PlayStation and Crunchyroll.”
- Crunchyroll is the largest anime streaming platform with about 150 million users, and Sony's software earnings from PlayStation and Crunchyroll of about $2 billion today could grow five times over the next five years.
“they already own the largest streaming platform in Crunchyroll, which you can think of as the Netflix of anime. This has reached over 150 million users”
- PlayStation should be valued as a critical distribution channel that functions as an app store, content library, and storage locker rather than as a cyclical hardware business, and its customer lifetime value is expected to grow about three times over the next five years.
“for us, we view this as really a critical distribution channel for games and it functions as the app store, the content library, and storage.”
- PlayStation generates about $30 billion in revenue and about $2 billion in operating profit today, with margins of 7 percent expected to rise to 19 percent, and operating profit should grow to $8 billion or more, supported by 116 million monthly active users with 70 percent buying games through the console.
“under PlayStation you have a business that's about 30 billion in revenue today, generates about 2 billion operating profit, and we think this grows to 8 billion plus and margins go from 7 to 19%.”
- Sony Pictures is about a $10 billion revenue business with only about $800 million in operating profit, so it is very low margin, but within it sits Crunchyroll, which is expected to grow revenue at 40 percent or more CAGR and eventually take over the segment.
“Pictures is about a 10 billion revenue business but its operating profit is about $800 million. So very low margin.”
- Because Crunchyroll is half the size of Netflix in user base and early in monetization, the thesis is that Sony's buried asset could repeat the Netflix growth trajectory, which Sia compares to Netflix in 2011.
“imagine buried in this conglomerate called Sony, you have a business that's almost half the size of Netflix in terms of user base. But monetization-wise, it's early days. This is Netflix in 2011.”
- Sony's earnings of about $11 billion could double to $20 billion or more, and combined with multiple expansion from single-digit multiples, the thesis implies a $400 billion company and roughly a triple from current levels.
“you think earnings are going to double from here and get to 20 billion plus. Well that's an easily double terms of return from here.”
- Crunchyroll has about 150 million users but only about 15 million paying subscribers, with the rest monetized through ads, and its average revenue per user is about $9 per month versus roughly $140 per month for Netflix, which makes the paid-conversion opportunity large.
“Now it's got of that 150, about 15 million are monthly paying subscribers. The rest are being monetized via ads.”
- Sony trades at single-digit multiples despite its leadership in its categories, and the multiple should be much higher because the market has not recognized the software engine inside the conglomerate.
“Why is this trading at called single-digit multiples? Shouldn't this trade on a much higher multiple?”
- Sia values Sony with a sum-of-the-parts approach, assigning PlayStation and Crunchyroll a multiple above 20 times on roughly $10 to $11 billion of combined earnings in four to five years, while valuing the other segments at consensus multiples to keep the analysis simple.
“we try to do a sum of the parts and we say, okay, you've got these six different business units. But the one that we really care about is the entertainment business.”
- Crunchyroll's revenue of about $1.1 billion could compound at 40 percent for five years to nearly $9 billion, and Sia's model assumes Netflix-like margins for it.
“revenues today around 1.1 billion. And I think top line is going to grow at a 40% CAGR for five years. You're looking at a business that's close to 9 billion in revenue.”
- Crunchyroll, consolidated by Sony around 2021, is the third-largest streaming platform in the world with about 150 million users, and it owns the market for live-streamed anime.
“they basically own the market in live streaming of anime content.”
Anime and gaming IP is under-monetized, and its lock-in keeps consoles central despite streaming.
- Most anime watched on Crunchyroll is licensed content tied to Japanese manga and IP, which is hard for competitors to obtain exclusively, so Netflix's original anime efforts have not matched the success of major anime franchises such as Naruto or Dragon Ball Z.
“most of the content being watched is licensed content. It comes from the manga, it's come from Japan itself. You can't just go and so many of these relationships and exclusive licensed content on their side.”
- The overlap between anime fans and video game players is very high, yet games have not monetized anime as much as they could, and Bandai Namco is the company that has a stronghold on top anime IP and games.
“if you look at the overlap of people who love anime and people who play video games, it's actually very high. And so you wonder yourself why isn't there more monetization happening on the games front?”
- Gaming IP was once viewed as a toy for kids before COVID, but now every media giant considers gaming IP among the best assets, with The Last of Us showing that game-derived stories can succeed as mainstream series, which opens M&A potential.
“every media giant looks at gaming IP and says, wow, these are probably the best assets. Because not only are you monetizing in this software virtual world, but you've had things that come over to the world of media.”
- Japanese gaming companies have been building transmedia IP that spans games, books, movies, and merchandise, which is a model that is not commonly seen elsewhere and positions Sony to monetize anime across games.
“they've all been building transmedia IP. What I mean by that is it's across building IP across multiple channels. So whether it's games, books, movies, merch”
- A streaming platform sees what people watch, which lets it tailor future content and gives Sony an advantage in deciding what anime and games to invest in.
“part of that power of having a stream platform is you see what people watch. You can then tailor your future content to that.”
- The anime industry is roughly a $30 billion market, mostly from merchandise, and it has reached a tipping point where growth now comes from outside Japan for the first time, with an estimated 600 to 700 million fans heading toward a billion or more.
“the tipping point of industry has grown outside of Japan for the first time in domestic Japan. And it's about a 30 billion industry. Most of it's in merchandise.”
- During the Evolving Sony period Sony made a series of game studio acquisitions, most notably Bungie, the studio behind Destiny, and it plans to divest financial services next year to focus on creative entertainment and IP.
“They bought a few game studios. Probably the most notable one, you know, was Bungie, which has made a game called Destiny.”
- The main risk to a console thesis is game streaming directly to TVs, but this is mitigated because IP is the key lock-in to ecosystems and the console is where users store their games, so without strong IP streaming does not matter much.
“if you don't have the IPs, it doesn't really matter because the IP is the key part to the lock into these ecosystems.”
- Netflix is the one player that could change the gaming market because it is installed on everyone's TV and competes for sleep and gaming time, even though its game efforts are not yet successful and it is constantly evaluating that strategy.
“The one player that I think could really change the game literally is potentially Netflix. Because Netflix is installed on everyone's TV.”
- Since Kenichi Yoshida became Sony's president and CEO in 2018, Sony's messaging has increasingly focused on content and IP, yet the market still associates Sony with hardware, which management has worked to change.
“since Mr. Yoshida took over as President CEO in 2018, this is when you really started to see this focus and shift of Sony towards here.”
- Sony's blockchain approach will be consumer-led, a public chain where users own assets, rather than repeating earlier NFT iterations that failed to engage consumers.
“Sony, their move here will be very much consumer-led. This is not going to be the iterations of what you've seen before of how you think of NFTs”
PlayStation margins should expand to 20 percent as a new norm.
- PlayStation ecosystem margins are compressed at about 11 to 12 percent because of PS5 hardware sales underperforming over the last four years, and they should reach 20 percent or more once a console-selling title arrives and live service games lean more people into subscriptions.
“PlayStation ecosystem margins have been compressed. They're around 11%, 12%. Because of the last four years this ecosystem has been weighed down by the hardware sales of PS5s”
- Sony's assets are at different stages of monetization, with the PS5 cycle lagging for four years due to low margins and weaker titles, while the next four years should bring a console-selling game, live service focus, and quarter-on-quarter paying-subscriber growth at Crunchyroll, which was consolidated only about three to four years ago.
“each of these assets have been at slightly different stages of monetization.”
- Sony's capital expenditure was rising during the last investment phase, but it is now expected to come down as the needed investments have been made, which should move Sony into a return-on-capital phase with possibly more selective buybacks.
“management teams communicate that capex will start coming down with the revenues accelerating because a lot of the investments that they want to make have been made.”
- Sia is more concerned about Sony's cost structure than its revenue, because a workforce of over 100,000 people has seen only modest layoffs compared with big tech, leaving room for more cost discipline that is hard to model without better disclosure.
“I'm more concerned probably around the cost side, not the revenue side.”
- Sony's margins have historically been low single digits, with periods of 4 to 5 percent and 10 percent before falling back, and Sia argues the current move to the mid-teens and toward 20 percent is a new norm rather than another cycle.
“realistically, margins have always been low single digits. And we are now entering this next phase of let's say the mid-teens.”
- Sony's image sensor business is a risk to the thesis because its roughly $10 billion of revenue is concentrated among a few customers and its capital intensity is hard to forecast, so if the hardware segments' capital intensity surprises, the conglomerate-level thesis could be wrong.
“if the capital intensity of the other hardware segments, if that surprises us, then that's a risk. And you gotta remember the chip sector, the image sensors business, but they're dominant in it's concentrated within a few customers”
- Sony's margins expanded after COVID, but every gaming company saw a similar boost, so the post-pandemic expansion was an industry tailwind rather than evidence of Sony-specific improvement.
“The one part when they margins expanded was obviously post-COVID where it really expanded. But I think every company that was in gaming saw that big boost.”
- PlayStation's margins should reach 20 percent or more, which is needed for the consolidated margin doubling to work.
“So PlayStation actually margins get to 20 plus percent. That's how we're looking at it to make it work.”
Sony's music catalog, image sensor leadership, and reach give durable competitive advantages.
- Sony's image sensor business is about a $10 billion business with high single-digit margins and holds roughly 53 percent of the world camera sensor market, which makes it a dominant leader in that category.
“They're dominant leader in this category in terms of camera sensors, about 53% market share of the world.”
- Sony Music is the number one publisher with over 5 million songs, a roughly $10 billion business with steady operating margins above 20 percent, and the analyst conservatively assumes an 8 percent CAGR built on streaming and royalties.
“this is an iconic asset because it captures over 5 million plus songs and it's in a solid business where margins have been steady at 20 plus percent on that front”
- PlayStation and Crunchyroll reach about 300 million or more fans, and including Sony Music the company touches over a billion people, with half of the top artists on its publishing side representing a valuable reach advantage.
“They reach about 300 million plus fans. And then if you said look, let's incorporate Sony Music into this dynamic too. Sony touches over a billion people.”
- Sony's music business has access advantages because artists want to perform in video games, and Sony was a pioneer in staging concerts in Fortnite, which gives it a unique moat that other music publishers may not replicate.
“They were the pioneer in terms of doing concerts in Fortnite. And I look at that and say, what music publisher can be that kind of access?”
- Sony's management is focused on entertainment and creative entertainment technologies, and it is leveraging its image sensor leadership, its investment in Epic Games, and its distribution through PlayStation and anime to capture the physical world through cameras and connect it to content creation and distribution.
“they've got this huge unique position of capturing the physical world right through cameras. And at the same time in tooling, at the same time creating content and then looking at their distribution channels.”
Sony's management is shedding non-core units to focus on creative entertainment and talent.
- Sony's strategic shift began in 2021 when it reorganized as a global consumer entertainment company and launched its fourth midterm plan, Evolving Sony, which ended last year and was followed by the fifth midterm plan, Beyond the Boundaries, focused on creative entertainment connecting physical and virtual realities.
“It's when it reorganized itself as a global consumer entertainment company. And it's also when it started its quote fourth midterm plan.”
- Sony has avoided the path of Disney and Paramount, which chased their own streaming apps to compete with Netflix, by licensing content instead, while Crunchyroll is the exception that shows some thoughtfulness about owning a platform.
“Sony was the poster child for not going down the path that Disney and Paramount and so many others went down where they chased the streaming app themselves to compete with Netflix idea.”
- Management teams rarely provide loose guidance on something like Crunchyroll's timeline, so Sia's view of its trajectory is directional, based on accelerating growth and a busy anime event calendar next year rather than explicit company targets.
“Never known any management teams to give very loose guidance like that.”
- Sony's financial services unit is slated to be spun off next year, which signals management's commitment to becoming a leaner, focused consumer entertainment company.
“this is something that they will spin off next year and it shows a commitment from management team to really become a more leaner focused consumer play.”
- Sony lets indie studios remain indie while leveraging its reach, which helps it attract creative talent, and Japanese gaming companies generally respect creatives but are less aggressive at monetization than Korean and Chinese peers, though that is changing.
“Sony comes out and lets these indie studios be indie, but then says leverage our reach so that you can come out and make a big noise in that front.”
Conglomerates are undervalued because complexity hides parts that need disclosure.
- Conglomerates like Sony are undervalued because they are hard to analyze, and improving corporate disclosure, especially breaking out Crunchyroll, would let public investors value the parts separately and surface hidden gems.
“improving corporate disclosure and putting more of a light on this gem of the business and then allowing public investors like ourselves to break apart the pieces”
- Investing in Japan has taught Sia that if management cannot see and communicate the vision the investor sees, the investment does not work well, and Sony's management has been good about communicating its focus, which is why it is a positive case.
“we invested in Japan. If you can't get management team to see the vision that you see and communicate that, that doesn't work really well.”
- Conglomerates have become less popular because they are too complicated to analyze, and that complexity can hide valuable businesses inside the overall company.
“that might be the answer for why conglomerates are less and less popular. It's just too complicated to sort through sometimes.”
- Margin expansion stories are the favored investment approach because they require digging to the bottom line and proving sustainable expansion over time, which is more work than simply buying a big total addressable market with revenue growth that many growth investors rely on.
“our favorite has always been margin expansion stories because it takes a little bit more work and effort than just, hey, here's this big TAM, here's revenue growth”
- Crunchyroll's economics are hard for investors to see because Sony does not break it out separately, forcing back-of-the-envelope estimates, and the market will only recognize it once it is large enough to disclose.
“Until today I think because it's not broken out separately in its nice clean way. You have to do a bit of back of envelope math to figure it out.”
- Outsized investment returns come from thinking directionally about accelerating growth rather than linear extrapolation.
“if you ever think about these big outsized returns, they never come from thinking in a linear way. You have to think directionally”
- The key lesson from Sony is that management must communicate a vision clearly and disclose segments better, because without it investors cannot break the conglomerate into parts and value them.
“The other one, which is the one that we've learned the hard way, has been we invested in Japan. If you can't get management team to see the vision that you see and communicate that, that doesn't work really well.”
Console growth depends on rising spending power in emerging and developed markets.
- Console growth in developed markets depends on rising spending power among gamers, especially millennials entering their 40s, and gaming is the most value-for-money entertainment per hour of time spent, which supports merch and show spending around IP like The Last of Us.
“within the developed markets, within us, I think console grows because spending power of gamers increases materially.”
- Only about 20 million of China's 600 million gamers play on consoles, and in India PlayStation is dominant but the market is only about a $200 million business and under one million console users, though it grew 50 percent year over year, making these emerging markets an underappreciated long-term growth story as the middle class rises.
“there's only 20 million console gamers in China out of 600 million. We can grow a lot there.”
- Console adoption in emerging markets is constrained by cost, since players need a TV and must spend a couple hundred dollars on a device, which is why the console market has stayed concentrated in North America and Europe and could change as emerging-market incomes rise.
“It's cost. Every emerging market, remember you have to have a TV and you're going to spend a couple hundred dollars to buy a device to play a game.”
Consumer-owned blockchain assets could expand gaming's market, with Sony best positioned to lead.
- Consumer-led public blockchain ownership of digital assets could be a game-changer that expands the video game industry's total addressable market well beyond what can be seen today, with in-game items like a World of Warcraft sword eventually worth large sums as part of people's asset portfolios.
“it's something that I really think is one of the game-changer aspects of enabling the video game industry to expand its total addressable market in a way that we cannot fathom today.”
- Sony announced in August a Layer-2 blockchain called Sonium, building on patents filed about two years earlier around using NFTs to move digital assets across ecosystems, and Sia believes Sony is the best-positioned company in the world to execute on blockchain ownership of IP.
“one of the most interesting moves Sony made this past August they announced launching a Layer-2 blockchain called Sonium.”