The Evolution of FreightWaves
What this covers
This is a conversation with Craig Fuller, founder of FreightWaves and now FLYING, with Dom and Matt asking the questions. It traces how a trucking-data idea became a media company and then a template for buying niche publications. Matt challenges the most obvious lesson. He argues that FreightWaves raised money as a software business with media attached, so its funding history doesn't show that media can attract capital. Craig partly agrees: late-stage investors give the media arm little credit, though early venture backers valued it because it generated nearly all data-product sales up to about $10 million ARR without paid advertising.
The origin story is one of the more unusual stretches. FreightWaves began as an attempt to create a tradable futures instrument for U.S. trucking, which required near-real-time data plus news to give it context. Craig describes buying anonymized datasets that vendors had been deleting. He also argues that renting versus owning an audience is an arbitrage most SaaS companies miss until they are very large.
The FLYING half is more operational. Craig describes tripling the magazine's price and accepting the loss of roughly two-thirds of its audience, then buying small brands at 2x to 5x EBITDA. He strips out programmatic advertising and newsstand deals, and he expects about a 3.5-year payback. A surprise is that Plane & Pilot overlapped with FLYING's audience by under 20 percent, not the 70 to 80 percent he expected. He also argues that business models should be chosen by audience and not copied, and he defends an aspirational brand identity against early critics.
Fuller argues that owning a niche audience is a durable, underpriced asset that a company can monetize through adjacent products, and that the playbook must be tailored to each audience rather than copied across businesses.
- Owned audiences avoid the rented-traffic costs of paid acquisition, so content can drive top-of-funnel demand more cheaply than ads.
- Institutional capital undervalues media businesses, so acquiring small niche publications at low multiples creates arbitrage.
- Business models, pricing, and audience segmentation must match the audience type, as FreightWaves (B2B) and FLYING (consumer/prosumer) show.
Media businesses must earn their own audience and subscriber revenue, not rely on fundraising or advertising.
- Matt argues that surf magazines have dedicated readers but are poor consumers, so the FLYING model would not fit surfing, and Craig responds that owners must assess audience size and buying criteria before choosing a model.
“But I love the idea of it, but they're just not very good consumers. So I don't think that would fit in this particular model.”
- Matt argues that FreightWaves' fundraising success does not show that media businesses can raise capital, because the company raised money as a software business with media attached, and the media arm is now a much smaller piece of the business.
“I don't know if that proves that point though, because I think that he raised money for a software business and media just happened to be attached to it.”
- Matt values Craig's rule that a magazine should stand on its own from subscriber revenue, with advertising as upside, because it lets the publisher choose advertisers selectively.
“subscribers should basically be able to pay for the costs to produce a magazine and then that makes advertising gravy”
Founders with a major success pursue new ventures with more freedom and less anxiety.
- Matt suggests that founders with a major success, such as Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk, tend to pursue new ventures with more freedom and less anxiety about the first business, which he sees in Craig's approach.
“having people that have a lot of success under one thing and then have a little bit more freedom to do the next thing”