What this covers

This is a conversation between host Patrick and Franklin Foer, author of World Without Mind, about how the largest technology companies came to stand between people and reality. Foer starts with the Counterculture-to-Tech Lineage. The region that produced LSD and the Grateful Dead also produced personal computing, and Stewart Brand and the Whole Earth Catalog framed the computer as a tool of personal liberation. In his account the industry's defining ideas are communal, not the Ayn Rand libertarianism it is usually associated with.

The middle of the conversation is about power. Foer argues that search engines look neutral because they seem to run on math, yet whatever ranks first gets read or bought. He points to Google hardwiring its own reviews into restaurant searches as an example of Platform Neutrality vs. Self-Preferencing. He says 30 to 50 percent of readers for major media arrive via Facebook, whose Feedback Loop Filter Bubble he blames for amplifying polarization. Amazon's ebook pricing and its pressure on Hachette serve as the case study in monopsony. Patrick presses on why a company people love for cheapness and convenience fits poorly with the Standard Oil picture of monopoly. Foer ties this to Thomas Jefferson and the founders' worry about concentrated private power, and he argues the digital economy that looked open in the 1990s has settled.

The conversation also covers the failed predictions that the Kindle would end paper books, the claim that a world without gatekeepers is an illusion, and the chilling effect if searches were public. Foer compares the regulation of digital platforms to the stop signs and seat belts that made cars safe. He closes on a more contested note: that notifications and attention-harvesting are a spiritual crisis, and that myths of solitary genius and of collaboration are both false but useful to keep believing.

Sharpest takeaway

Foer argues that Silicon Valley's collectivist, counter-culture-derived ideals have become a centralizing force that captures attention and concentrates market and political power, so people and regulators must deliberately cultivate contemplation and rules that harness these platforms.

  • Platforms pick winners and losers by ranking what users see, which gives them control over information and commerce
  • Monopoly power in the digital economy has re-concentrated after a brief period of apparent dynamism
  • Individual agency and deliberate contemplation must be cultivated, since technology will not regulate itself

The argument · threads11 threads · 65 claims
0.71

Digital tools erode attention and contemplation, so individuals must deliberately reclaim their attention and privacy.

13 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Humans are becoming cyborgs, as people outsource navigation and memory to phones and wearables, and brain-computer interfaces such as Facebook's and Neuralink's may soon be implanted.

    “we are, as a species, becoming cyborg... the day in which Google or something like that is implanted in your brain is not that far away.”

  • Unlike earlier tools that automated physical labor, current technologies automate mental functions, creating a form of intellectual automation that stands between people and their understanding of the world.

    “a lot of what is being automated are actually mental functions. There's a form of intellectual automation that's happening right now.”

  • If jobs disappear and people spend their days in virtual reality, that lifestyle could become a religion, since it would have to supply the meaning people no longer find in work.

    “It almost has to become a religion at some point to supply people's lives with the meaning that they no longer have in work”

  • Paper books are disconnected: no one watches over the reader, no corporate store is attached, and no notifications interrupt, so they enable a deep commitment to text that digital reading does not.

    “There's nobody watching over your shoulder as you read. You're no umbilically connected to a corporate store.”

  • When parents see children hunched over phones, they see their own addiction reflected back, and rather than improving themselves, they panic and feel dread about their children's technology use.

    “When you see your kid with an iPad or a phone hunched over texting or swiping... it reflects yourself back to you.”

  • Constant notification and attention reverse-engineering are the biggest spiritual crisis, since they eliminate the space for contemplation and independent thought, and religion would be wise to exploit this opening.

    “I think it's actually the biggest spiritual crisis. If you're always being notified, if you kind of lose the possibility for independence of thought”

  • Technologies are addictive like food and drink, and society teaches moderation for those, so people should enjoy digital tools without letting them exercise mind control.

    “those things are addictive too, but we are taught moderation... We should be able to enjoy the fruits of them without them exercising mind control.”

  • Franklin reclaimed attention by keeping his phone out of his bedroom, disabling notifications so only humans can interrupt him, and removing Facebook from his phone so he must deliberately use it on a laptop.

    “I used to sleep with my cell phone but I don't do that any more... I've turned off notifications on my phone so that only a human being has the ability to grab my attention.”

  • The kindest act Franklin experienced was a friend who spent a week selflessly helping him through a fabrication crisis at work during the Iraq War, when advertisers pulled back after the magazine published articles later alleged to be fabricated.

    “He spent a week just kind of helping me, on his own, going full time, crazy long days”

  • Tristan Harris, who was Google's ethicist-in-chief after Google acquired his startup Apture, left because he believed technologies were more addictive and manipulative than people understood, and he founded Time Well Spent to help people create space from technology.

    “He ended up leaving because he felt like these technologies were even more addictive and manipulative than people understood.”

  • Facebook's aim to read brain waves and Elon Musk's Neuralink reflect a human-machine interface that Foer finds crazy but which the speaker notes has already moved from far-fetched to reality with entire television libraries in a palm.

    “Mark Zuckerberg talks about this human-machine interface where Facebook wants to be able to read your brain waves, which is something that Elon Musk also invests in.”

  • Two competing spiritual visions may emerge: a virtual-reality religion that gives meaning to people who no longer have work, and a contemplative defense against distraction that treats attention capture as a spiritual crisis.

    “It almost has to become a religion at some point to supply people's lives with the meaning that they no longer have in work”

  • Privacy is essential to human selfhood, and Foer is militantly hostile to the view that its disappearance will make people better.

    “I'm fairly devoted to privacy as a concept. I think it's essential to human selfhood.”

0.69

Concentrated private tech power and eroding shared facts threaten democratic functioning.

6 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The US Constitution was designed to balance power, and the founders, including Thomas Jefferson, worried not only about executive power but also about excessive concentrations of private power that would harm democracy.

    “they were also worried about excessive concentrations of private power and they could see the ways in which once you had excessive concentrations of private power it would be bad for the democracy.”

  • The biggest political concern is that common factual ground is eroding, so that even simple facts like the sky being blue become partisan, which threatens democratic functioning.

    “there's diminishing basis for common fact. So that if I say, The sky is blue, that becomes a partisan issue.”

  • Hearing only what one wants to hear is intellectually incapacitating, leaving people weak against fake news, propaganda, demagoguery, and bad actors who exploit distrust and anger.

    “If you're just hearing the things that you want to hear all the time it is intellectually incapacitating.”

  • The American founders feared executive power and kingship, but they also worried about excessive concentrations of private power harming democracy, a concern that dominated American political economy through the 1960s and 1970s before fading.

    “they were also worried about excessive concentrations of private power and they could see the ways in which once you had excessive concentrations of private power it would be bad for the democracy.”

  • The centrist group No Labels named taking on the titans of tech one of its five big ideas for the year, and its Wall Street and centrist audience cared because of democracy and the incentive to start companies.

    “One of their five big ideas for this year was taking on the titans of tech.”

  • Donald Trump's disruption of the political system has forced people to reconsider truisms and may shift politics toward a renewed analysis of concentrated power that worries both left and right.

    “That Donald Trump is a giant disruption to the system and that it's forced people to reconsider a lot of truisms”

0.53

Platform and search power controls what people see and who succeeds.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Media outlets are pivoting to video because it keeps users engaged longest, and Facebook is paying producers and will inevitably favor its own content, making Facebook a television set that controls both eyeballs and what they see.

    “That means that Facebook is becoming your television set... Facebook is inevitably going to start to favor Facebook's own content.”

  • Search engines appear neutral because they seem to use math, but whatever ranks at the top gets read or bought, so Google gains enormous control over information and business outcomes, and those who game the system rise.

    “A search engine looks and behaves as if it's a neutral thing... that gives Google huge control over outcomes in information and in business too.”

  • Facebook is a feedback loop that uses everything users reveal about their pleasures, anxieties, and turn-offs to sort newsfeed content, which amplifies political polarization and filter bubbles far beyond what existed before the internet.

    “Facebook is a feedback loop. Facebook takes everything that you tell it and then uses that data as a basis for sorting information.”

  • There is a split between how elites perceive large tech companies as dangerous and how consumers perceive them as beloved, and elite media hostility to Facebook is partly driven by media's own dependence on it.

    “there's a split right now between the way that elites perceive these corporations and the way that consumers perceive these corporations.”

  • The internet's architecture is a choice between centralization and decentralization, and it is possible to build it as a set of smaller interconnected networks rather than one giant network.

    “Is it possible to imagine an internet that exists in a way, shape, or form that's different from the internet that we now know?”

0.44

Amazon's dominance over ebooks and retail gives it monopsony power over suppliers.

7 pointscentrality 3/5
  • When a firm is the dominant seller, suppliers become dependent and can be squeezed, which is the monopsony problem exemplified by Amazon's treatment of Hachette in ebook contract talks.

    “Amazon exerts enormous control over the people who supply it with the stuff it sells, which in economics it's the problem of monopsony.”

  • Amazon controls somewhere between 70 and 90 percent of the ebook market, so Kindle is effectively synonymous with ebooks.

    “It's somewhere between 70% and 90%. Nobody can say exactly how much that they control”

  • Amazon started as the everything store but has morphed into a movie studio, owner of The Washington Post and Whole Foods, and power behind the cloud, raising the question of where its expansion will stop.

    “It started off as the everything store... it owns The Washington Post, it owns Whole Foods, it powers the cloud.”

  • Amazon is drifting toward roughly 50 percent of all retail over the next couple of years, and even critics must admit it is one of the greatest businesses ever built, though its profits do not yet reflect that.

    “Amazon kind of drifts in the next couple of years to being 50% of all retail.”

  • Predictions that the Kindle in 2008 would end paper books failed, as Nicholas Negroponte's 2015 forecast that paper books would cease publication was wrong, with paper sales ticking up 1 to 2 percent a year while ebooks plateaued.

    “Nicholas Negroponte, who headed MIT media labs, said by the 2015 paper books will cease to be published... Paper book sales tick up every year, maybe 1% or 2%”

  • After Franklin's article Amazon Must Be Stopped appeared, Amazon pulled its advertising from The New Republic, which Franklin took as proof of the monopoly thesis of his book.

    “Dear New Republic, because of your recent cover story about Amazon we're no longer running our ad campaign with you.”

  • Amazon set the ebook price at $9.99 without consulting publishers, reset the industry's pricing, and then extracted ever-harsher terms from Hachette by stripping buy buttons and delaying shipments once Hachette refused.

    “Amazon initially set the price for ebooks at $9.99... They stripped the buy button off of Hachette books.”

0.41

Platforms stand between people and reality, so they must be governed by neutrality rules.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • A world without gatekeepers is an illusion, comparable to anarchist or Marxist dreams of the withering away of the state, because some group always returns to exert dominance.

    “the idea that we could live in a world without gatekeepers is just an illusion... But the power of the state always returns.”

  • Platforms like Google, Facebook, and Amazon stand between people and reality, and by ranking results at the top they pick winners and losers, because whatever appears first is what users are most likely to read or buy.

    “They have a lot of power to set the terms for reality. What happens is that they pick winners and losers.”

  • Like the automobile, which became safe and clean only after rules such as stop signs, seat belts, and emission standards were imposed, digital platforms must be harnessed to human purposes through deliberate rules and systems.

    “we need to start thinking about how we can create systems and rules that can harness these technologies for human purposes.”

  • Google moved from being a neutral platform to an actor privileging its own services by hardwiring Google Reviews, a Yelp-like result, into restaurant searches, which is the main danger that has alarmed the European Union.

    “Google was no longer a neutral platform. Google was privileging its own service.”

  • Somewhere between 30 and 50 percent of readers for major media come via Facebook, and at some outlets such as BuzzFeed the share reaches 70 to 80 percent, which makes media dependent on the platform for revenue.

    “It's somewhere between 30% and 50%. In some places it's much higher. Like at Buzzfeed, I think I've seen it's like 70% or 80%”

  • From a regulatory perspective, ensuring the neutrality of platforms is absolutely essential, because platforms that privilege their own services gain unchecked power.

    “from the perspective of regulation ensuring the neutrality of these platforms is actually absolutely essential.”

0.37

Solitary, actively cultivated thinking sustains creativity and democratic life.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Both the romantic myth of the solitary genius and Silicon Valley's myth of collaboration are myths, yet creating paradigm-shattering ideas requires society to keep believing in individual genius and the quest for glory.

    “I think both of these myths, the romantic myth of individual genius, Silicon Valley's myth of the collective collaboration workplace, they're both myths.”

  • Hannah Arendt's lectures on the life of the mind distinguish thinking from the pursuit of knowledge and from science, and ask whether thinking is inherent to being human and necessary for functioning democracy.

    “how is thinking different than our pursuit of knowledge and how is thinking different than science”

  • Culture derives from the Latin culare and the agricultural idea of cultivation, so the mind must be tended actively rather than left to chance, because agency over one's own growth is the basis for affecting technology and climate.

    “the mind needs to be tended to in the same sort of way that we tend to our fields... you can't be passive in the course of that.”

  • The shift from individual offices to open floor plans and group school projects reflects a collaboration myth that reduces the solitary thinking time needed for creative work.

    “now you're supposed to work in these open floor plan things where you're kind of part of this amoeba”

0.34

Corporate ownership of consumer data without protection makes privacy erosion require data rules.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • If all Google searches were public, people would search less for embarrassing health conditions and controversial ideas, because they would fear shame or future employer penalties, which flattens human exploration.

    “if all of your Google searches were made public I think it would make you less likely to search for certain things on Google.”

  • Zuckerberg's argument that the disappearance of privacy makes people behave more virtuously is partly right, as radical transparency has exposed harmful behind-closed-doors power dynamics like sexual harassment, though Franklin is militantly opposed overall.

    “you can see the way in which a form of radical transparency is eliminating a very unhealthy power dynamic”

  • Consumer data collected by tech companies is not protected the way health and financial data are, yet the companies act as if they own it and can trade it, creating a strong incentive to expand surveillance; therefore data rules are needed.

    “Your health data might be protected. Some of your financial data might be protected. But the data that these guys are collecting is not at all protected”

0.25

Silicon Valley's commune-derived collectivist ideals shaped a centralized internet and monopoly business.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Silicon Valley's defining ideas are collective: social media, crowdsourcing, and networks reflect a recreated commune ethos, which is both its core value and its core danger, more than the Ayn Rand libertarianism it is usually associated with.

    “so much of what Silicon Valley is about is about the collective. It's about recreating the commune.”

  • The 1960s dream of a global village, in which connecting everyone would improve human behavior, pushed the internet toward a centralized architecture, and that oneness ideal became the basis for monopoly business opportunity.

    “It seems to me that we were always pointed in this direction of centralization simply because the dream was always having everybody wrapped up into one.”

  • The 1960s and 1970s commune movement failed, but its utopian spirit survived in Northern California and was redirected into technology, becoming the foundation of Silicon Valley culture.

    “The communes completely fail. They're big flops... But the spirit of the communes doesn't die and it really lives in this part of northern California.”

  • Whether the internet is centralized or decentralized is a foundational design question that shapes how it develops economically and as a communications system, and it was not predetermined.

    “Is it centralized or decentralized? Is there ways to accentuate the decentralization or accentuate the centralization?”

  • Stewart Brand, through the Whole Earth Catalog, presented personal computing as a tool of personal liberation and as another route to consciousness, which fused counter-culture ideals with the emerging technology industry.

    “He gave a name to it. He was the first person to come up with the idea of the personal computer... he gave it a name and helped explain it as a tool of personal liberation”

0.21

Concentration of tech power recurs cyclically across politics and ideologies, threatening existing coalitions.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Within American liberalism, antitrust sentiment cycles over generations: periods of celebrating corporate concentration as efficiency alternate with periods of antitrust pressure as power waxes and wanes.

    “anti-trust kind of comes and it goes in cycles, in generations, as power waxes and wanes.”

  • Concern about tech monopoly has appeal across ideologies, including Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren on the left, a centrist No Labels audience, and Steve Bannon on the right, which could fracture existing political coalitions.

    “this topic of monopoly has appeal across ideologies and it could actually cause divisions within coalitions.”

  • The digital economy that seemed wide open in the 1990s, when Microsoft's dominance tumbled and new firms rose quickly, has now settled, with large economic chunks depending on platforms that hold dominance over markets.

    “maybe things have actually settled now, and the idea of the platform... was such that huge chunks of the economy were going to just become dependent on the platforms”

0.21

Technologists must become humanists who understand the consequences of what they build.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • At Stanford almost half of students are now in computer science, a shift Franklin cites as evidence that computer science has become too important to leave to those currently attracted to it.

    “if you go to a place like Stanford where it's like almost half the kids are computer science now”

  • Engineering as a mindset designs systems for efficiency on their own terms, so engineers and computer scientists must become humanists who understand the ethical and political consequences of what they build, since human beings are part of the system.

    “We need engineers and computer scientists who are also humanist, who are able to understand the ethical and political consequences of the systems that they build”

  • Universities need to take a leadership role in remaking curricula, since nearly half of Stanford students now study computer science and elites will need to rethink education and values to remain recognizably human.

    “I think universities need to take a leadership role in remaking curriculum.”

0.12

Stewart Brand's counterculture framing made personal computing culturally powerful and marketable.

5 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Stewart Brand conceived the Whole Earth Catalog after a LSD-fueled rooftop revelation that no one had photographed the whole Earth from space, and he then campaigned on college campuses for a movement to get such a picture.

    “Why haven't I ever seen a picture from outer space of the whole Earth?”

  • Stewart Brand did not invent the personal computer but gave it a name and framed it as a tool of personal liberation, which made it culturally powerful and marketable.

    “He gave a name to it. He was the first person to come up with the idea of the personal computer... he gave it a name and helped explain it as a tool of personal liberation”

  • Silicon Valley was simultaneously the epicenter of LSD and the Grateful Dead counterculture and the birthplace of personal computing and the internet, and Foer argues that these innovations could not have occurred without the counterculture spirit.

    “that innovation was actually born out of the spirit of the counter-culture.”

  • Stewart Brand compared programmers playing Pong to LSD, calling video games another way of achieving consciousness, which Foer treats as the punchline of the story about the shift from counterculture to computing.

    “Oh my god, this is just like LSD. It's another way of achieving consciousness.”

  • Stewart Brand created the Whole Earth Catalog to sell tools and books to people living in communes in the late 1960s and early 1970s, and the book, which celebrated technology as consistent with counterculture ideals, sold millions of copies and became a bible for that generation.

    “That book, which celebrated technology as being consistent with the spirit of the counter-culture, became kind of a bible to a lot of people in that generation.”