What this covers

Patrick O'Shaughnessy talks with Meb Faber, starting in factor investing. Faber calls dividend yield a poor expression of value because it tends to pick heavily indebted companies, and says a composite of several value measures beats it. He adds the tax angle: in a taxable account, steering away from the top yielders while staying in value could add an estimated 40 to 400 basis points a year, a figure flagged as contested. From there the talk moves to behavior. Copying Warren Buffett's 13F filing holdings has beaten the market since 2000, yet it lagged in eight of the last ten years. That gap leads into the principal-agent problem and performance chasing in institutional management.

The middle of the conversation applies that behavioral lens to product design. Faber argues that illiquidity helps investors and that daily ETF liquidity invites self-sabotage. He sketches a "Forever Fund" with a ten-year lockup and a declining redemption fee paid to the remaining investors. He also cites the finding that most average fund managers hold under $100,000 in their own funds, and he calls $1-a-month savings apps predatory at small balances. He forecasts that Vanguard and Schwab will dominate robo-advisors.

The last stretch turns to angel investing. Faber covers the QSBS exclusion on gains up to $10 million, the 100x-to-10,000x upside of tiny starting valuations, and his habit of following top investors' syndicate deals, treating early losses as tuition and spreading commitments across vintages. He also notes record median price-to-sales. Smaller asides cover broken podcast discovery, evolutionary psychology, and why he answers every email.

Sharpest takeaway

Faber argues dividend yield is a crude, tax-inefficient value proxy that investors should avoid in taxable accounts, and that illiquidity and lock-ups can improve investor behavior and returns, while most fund and fintech incentives work against investors.

  • Dividend yield is a weak value factor that tends to select highly levered companies, and value composites outperform it
  • Dividend taxes in taxable accounts create a drag that avoiding high-yield stocks can recover
  • Liquidity and daily trading produce behavioral damage, so lock-ups and declining redemption fees can help investors

The argument · threads4 threads · 86 claims
0.85

Factor choices should be deliberate, avoiding redundant bets across value, size, momentum, and yield exposures.

7 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The hosts' challenge uses 50 equal-weighted stocks rebalanced quarterly, a schedule Patrick says plays to momentum's advantage.

    “Quarterly re-bal. That plays to your advantage. That's momentum.”

  • Accruals is a classic quality factor that can screen out risky stocks, though Faber admits he could not explain it well on a CFA Level 1 exam.

    “I'll go with kind of the classic accruals factor.”

  • Patrick chose to stay fully invested rather than use a timing factor because the dispersion in starting earnings across stocks is too wide to be reliable.

    “I'm going to stay fully invested over 10 years because the dispersion on that starting earning stuff is too wide for me.”

  • Shareholder yield includes buyback yield, so once one player picks buyback yield the other cannot pick shareholder yield, and dividend yield remains the only available yield factor.

    “shareholder yield, because it encompasses buyback yield? Correct. So you can only do dividends or something with that.”

  • A factor draft with low-correlation factors like value, momentum, size, quality, and trend is a sensible way to diversify, but Patrick's choice of price to sales was deliberately a value doubling-down rather than a momentum diversifier.

    “even though I know that obviously, I should take a momentum factor because it's got negative correlation with all this other stuff, this is just for fun.”

  • Quarterly rebalancing benefits a momentum strategy because frequent rebalancing captures trend shifts, and Faber notes it would help him, as long as returns are measured gross of taxes.

    “Quarterly re-bal? ... That plays to your advantage. That's momentum.”

  • Patrick argues that a size tilt and value factors naturally cluster small and mid-cap stocks, so choosing small size alongside value is a redundant bet on the same exposure.

    “my pushback there is a lot of this stuff will cluster you small and mid-cap naturally.”

0.58

Short-window manager evaluation drives performance chasing, which lockup-linked fee discounts could help align.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Lower liquidity can improve returns because fewer chances to tinker with a portfolio prevent investors from undermining their own process, so illiquidity should not be treated as something requiring extra compensation.

    “by being less liquid, or having fewer opportunities to go and dig up the roots of your tree, you'll actually do better.”

  • Institutional asset management suffers from a principal-agent problem in which managers are hired after strong three-year runs and fired after weak ones, driving performance chasing rather than sound decisions.

    “this kind of standard principle-agent problem, hiring, firing mistakes, that it's all performance chasing good or bad. So you get hired after a good three year old, and you get fired after a bad three year run.”

  • Paying lockup penalties to remaining investors rather than the fund manager gives the manager long-term locked capital and lets them charge reasonable fees, which aligns incentives.

    “the key point which, it was a great idea by you, is to pay the other people, not the fund manager.”

  • Evaluating managers on three-year windows creates performance chasing, which is why Patrick says fee discounts tied to lockups could help.

    “So you get hired after a good three year old, and you get fired after a bad three year run.”

0.27

Exploring unfamiliar areas beyond data-driven research counters investors' blind spots.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Patrick says his ideal alternative career would combine his love of research and data with the outdoors, perhaps as a guide-book business focused on travel and experiences.

    “I think maybe my second really big passion is just the outdoors, generally speaking.”

  • Data-driven research cements investors into the ideas that have worked, which is useful, but it causes them to lose track of esoteric ideas and blind spots, so exploring unfamiliar areas like venture capital is valuable.

    “you get cemented into those ideas, and that's great because they should work in the future. But you definitely lose track of a lot of the esoterica.”

  • Patrick notes he knows robo-advisors better than non-robo fintech, and that high customer acquisition costs have constrained many fintech subscription businesses.

    “just how hard it is to get customers. And those recurring revenue models are great if you can get subscribers. But it seems like that's been the variable that maybe has held some of these places back, just really high acquisition costs.”

0.13

Podcast discovery is poor today but should improve within a year as Apple changes host data.

3 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Podcast discovery tools are terrible because the top 20 shows get the same placement repeatedly, and there is no episode-by-episode curation, although Apple's changes to host data reporting may improve discovery within a year.

    “the tools available for discovery, they're terrible. I mean, it's basically the top 20 shows get all sorts of placement”

  • Podcast discovery tools will improve within a year, partly because enough attention is on the space and Apple is changing the data it reports to podcast hosts.

    “the tools available for discovery, they're terrible. I mean, it's basically the top 20 shows get all sorts of placement”

  • Podcast discovery is poor because the top 20 shows get all the placement and there are no episode-by-episode recommendations, even though podcasts are the most interesting way to consume information now.

    “the tools available for discovery, they're terrible. I mean, it's basically the top 20 shows get all sorts of placement”