Entrepreneurship Through Acquisition
What this covers
Patrick talks with Rick Ruback and Royce Yudkoff about buying small, established, profitable companies instead of starting one. The arithmetic comes first. A business with $1 to 1.5 million of EBITDA bought at four times yields about 25 percent on assets before any growth. With 80 percent debt, much of it SBA-backed, equity returns become Leverage Amplifies Cash Yield in practice. Investors take common equity aimed at roughly 35 percent, and searchers keep 60 to 70 percent. The screens follow from that leverage: recurring revenue, no customer concentration, no cyclicality, and capital-light operations. Growth is deliberately left off the list.
The range is wide. They compare funded search, which increasingly resembles a venture portfolio, with self-funded search, which looks more like private equity and dwarfs the MBA-based version. They also cover the red flags that never show up in the numbers: an owner-CEO whose relationships make the company a job, add-backs near 50 percent of EBITDA, and multiple owners who may not sign. Rick argues that committed sellers are at least as scarce as good companies, and that bids should leave room for diligence surprises.
The later sections turn to what happens after the purchase. Buyers typically land about 5 percent below their base case, with the payoff arriving in year three. Many exit around year five or six because they hold most of their net worth in one company. Royce repeats Will Thorndike's contested point that owners sell too early. The conversation closes on why so few graduates try search.
Rick Ruback and Royce Yudkoff argue that entrepreneurship through acquisition is a durable, low-multiple path to business ownership because the return comes from buying good companies at attractive prices, so the real bottlenecks are finding deals and committed sellers, not growth.
- Buying recurring-revenue, low-concentration, non-cyclical businesses at low multiples and using SBA or conventional leverage generates high equity returns without requiring growth.
- Funded and unfunded searchers face different risks, and failure to find a deal is the main risk for funded searchers, while bad-business risk is rarer because investors and lenders screen deals.
- The market stays underpriced at the low end because deal sourcing is fragmented and illiquid, and talent for running small firms has to be matched to businesses the buyer can learn to manage.
Seller claims are unverified, so buyers must bid with room for diligence surprises
- Empirically, buyers project 5 to 10 percent growth in year one but usually see results about 5 percent worse than their base case, because sellers sell at good times and the business degrades during the sale process; the big payoff tends to come in year three as ideas from the first year take effect.
“What looks is that people buy their businesses and then they all project 5 or 10% growth”
- Multiple owners are the biggest red flag for deal completion, because an older owner who has driven the sale may find a younger co-owner in their 50s will not sign once they understand the transaction, causing months of effort to collapse; committed sellers are at least as scarce as good companies.
“the biggest red flag is multiple owners”
- Broker sale documents, called SIMs, record what the owner says and present it in polished form, so buyers bid on unverified claims about contracts, licenses, tax payments, insurance, and recurring revenue that often prove wrong in diligence.
“The broker writes down what the owner says, puts it in fancy language with some pictures, and produces a SIM.”
- Searchers should bid a price that leaves room to absorb due diligence surprises, because brokers' marketing documents often overstate revenue quality, insurance, and employee costs, and sellers who have already spent the proceeds react irrationally when the price drops, so deals bust.
“you want to pay a price that allows you some margin of safety for due diligence surprises”
Searchers should buy businesses they can learn to run, avoiding capital-heavy or fashionable sectors
- Searchers should buy businesses they can manage or learn to manage, because they need not be experts in the industry but must be the kind of person who can learn it; 'if you're allergic to fur, don't buy a pet shop.'
“if you're allergic to fur, don't buy a pet shop”
- Auto repair roll-ups can unlock value by separating the skilled mechanic from management: as a shop grows, the founder shifts to back-office work, so a roll-up can keep great mechanics doing repairs while centralizing management, the same principle as specialization in veterinary and concierge medicine.
“let the fabulous mechanics be mechanics. And we're just going to take the management piece and do that centrally.”
- Searchers who buy software tend to buy niche vertical software for steady markets such as podiatrists or municipalities, and avoid fashionable consumer apps or social media, because niche established software has a sustainable investment thesis.
“They're software for podiatrists, they're software for small municipalities.”
- The businesses recommended are capital-light, with EBITDA close to free cash flow and episodic capital allocation, and Rick is skeptical of large IT spending, arguing that a new CRM costing hundreds of thousands of dollars consumes free cash flow and that an old owner's sticky notes can serve until the buyer knows what is needed.
“a couple hundred thousand dollars is a lot of your free cash flow. You gotta be thoughtful about that.”
Illiquid, fragmented markets and seller timing keep low-end acquisition multiples from rising
- The small-firm acquisition market has split: funded searchers have moved upmarket into deals around $20 million total enterprise value, while unfunded searchers have shifted toward buying sub-$1 million EBITDA businesses at 3x to 4x, and others buy much bigger companies at 6x to 8x.
“the small firm acquisition space is really bifurcated with the funded searchers really moving upmarket into much larger deals”
- Low-end multiples have not been driven up: a recurring-revenue business with $750,000 of EBITDA and little customer concentration can still be bought for around 4x, though a $2 million EBITDA business can no longer be bought at 4x as it might have been a decade ago.
“If you want to buy a firm with $750,000 of EBITDA... You can still do that for 4x.”
- The small-business acquisition market is very illiquid and fragmented, with heavy information costs, so finding and transferring good recurring-revenue companies is harder than people expect, and that friction is the real bottleneck that keeps low-end multiples down.
“This market is so illiquid. It's really hard to find good companies to buy with recurring revenues”
- Many owners delayed selling through COVID-era volatility, and because cash flows are still distorted and waiting does not end the disruption, a surge of pent-up selling is expected over the next three to four years before the market returns to steady state.
“I do believe that there'll be some surge over the next three or four years of pent up selling”
- Owners who bear concentrated, undiversified risk face a high personal cost of capital because they bear total risk rather than only diversifiable risk, so they may sell at the right time from their perspective even if investors would prefer they hold on.
“they're living with this really high cost of capital because they're bearing all this total risk, not just the diversifiable risk”
Unfunded search is safer and rarely fails, unlike funded search's venture-style risk profile
- Buying a genuinely bad business is rare because it is hard to pass due diligence and get financing from banks and equity holders, so investors act as a gatekeeper; when deals do go wrong it is usually because the world changed, such as an oil service business bought just before oil prices collapsed.
“I think investors provide a pretty good gatekeeper for getting stuck in a bad business”
- For unfunded searchers the failure-to-find rate is much smaller, under 25 percent, because they target boring businesses with steady recurring cash flows and enduring profitability rather than high-growth companies.
“The failure to find risk seems to be much, much smaller. So it seems to be less than 25% now.”
- Unfunded search looks like private equity and may be safer, with rare investor capital loss, while funded search increasingly resembles a venture capital portfolio in which one or two winners carry the fund and some capital loss is expected.
“Unfunded search is very much like private equity, maybe even on the safer side than private equity. Funded search really starting to feel like VC investing to me.”
- Funded search is increasingly done through small private equity funds that specialize in search rather than institutions, so investors without a diversified portfolio of these funds are taking a potentially scary single-deal risk.
“much of the funded search is occurring through institutional investors, but rather small private equity funds that specialize in search”
Deals and operations depend on in-person, hands-on presence and weekly accountability
- Owning a small business entirely remotely does not work, because belly-to-belly management, such as walking the shop floor and talking at the water cooler, is essential, especially for inexperienced owners learning the business.
“The idea that you can buy a business in Mississippi and run it from your ski lodge in Colorado just seems incredible to me.”
- Margin expansion and growth most often come when new owners talk to customers during the transition, discover services they eagerly want, and deliver reliable service and responsiveness, which Rick called capitalism done well.
“they go talk to their customers and they discover that there are services and extensions that their customers are so eager to get”
- Holding a weekly Wednesday meeting with deal participants helps close transactions because it gives people Monday and Tuesday to complete promised tasks and provides an accountable checkpoint on bankers, lawyers, and sellers.
“Well, weekly communication helps a lot. You need to have a meeting. I like to have them on Wednesdays.”
- Searching is a highly personal activity best done by choosing a small geography, moving there, attending Chamber of Commerce events, and meeting owners; the weekly goal is to have one owner conversation rather than theorize about industries for six months.
“your goal for this week is to have an owner's meeting. Just have a telephone conversation with an owner.”
Case-based education builds pattern recognition that theory and AI tools cannot replace
- Case-based education builds pattern recognition that cannot be Googled, because after two years of seeing hundreds of situations, graduates recognize recurring business problems, such as the Butler Lumber case of profits without cash because of working capital needs, and no AI tool substitutes for doing the work.
“I think it's really hard to Google your way to pattern recognition.”
- The course is extremely practical with little theory, according to Royce, who attributes its success to practical lessons and protagonist visits; Rick disagrees, saying the course teaches substantial theory but delivers it through concrete cases rather than equations.
“We teach a lot of theory, but we teach it in the context of practice.”
- In a teaching case, a business that cuts price 10% with unchanged costs removes its entire profit margin, and at 70 percent debt the equity holders lose nearly all their value from that single pricing decision.
“all that money is just coming out of profits. And my profit margin was whatever it is. And so, boy, I've just taken out my entire profit margin.”
- Harvard's strict faculty-student relationship rules mean faculty cannot signal interest in investing in students, so students who want faculty backing must wait until May after graduation; the investment market is open rather than a closed network.
“we can't even implicitly acknowledge that we're interested in investing in a student”
- Harvard Business School teaches through situations rather than only theory, and its research must have a business focus valued enough that someone would pay for the results; if nobody would pay, the work belongs in economics or the Kennedy School.
“if nobody cares enough to pay for your research, then maybe you should be doing it in the economics department”
The search career is becoming accepted but remains rarely pursued by graduates
- Ten years ago the search career path was viewed as quirky, with parents calling the school asking what was wrong with their child; it is now a well-traveled and accepted path with dozens of success stories among graduates across backgrounds.
“Now it's become a much more traveled path and our students can look back”
- Many blue-collar businesses are bought by former army and Marine Corps captains and lieutenants, who are used to managing blue-collar workforces and describe running a company as like running a platoon.
“It's usually the people who are captains and lieutenants in the army and the Marine Corps.”
- Of roughly 920 Harvard MBA graduates each year, only about 20 to 25 pursue search, far below the roughly 100 that Rick thinks ought to, even though the path offers a better life and independence than working for others.
“We have 920 students graduate every year. Ought to be 100 people searching. We get like somewhere around 20, 25 a year.”