What this covers
Michael, who invests in consumer brands at Bullish, talks with host Patrick about what a brand is and how to spot one early. The anchor example is Coca-Cola: roughly $45 billion in revenue against a $170 to 180 billion market cap, with the gap attributed to the label rather than the recipe or the assets. Patrick adds that people can't tell products apart in blind tastings, so brand strength should appear as persistently high ROIC. Michael rejects the idea that the best product wins, since competitors in a category are often near-identical and emotional meaning decides.
The middle of the conversation ranges across marketing. Michael contrasts polls with search behavior, arguing that people lie in surveys and reveal themselves in stated versus revealed preference. He uses the 1982 Tylenol poisonings to show trust being rebuilt, and he claims legacy CPG leadership has eroded sharply since the 1980s. He also argues that digital attribution removes advertising's excuse of being unmeasurable, that agencies are paid for time rather than outcomes, and that CPG spend should move from Google to Amazon, a claim he states as fact but which is contestable.
The last stretch is about practice. Bullish's survey sorts consumers into 16 cohorts and hunts for categories with low NPS. Warby Parker and hearing aids illustrate slow, overpriced buying journeys that invite entrants. Michael says to test women's products in places like Boise and Syracuse, not on the coasts. He closes on rising valuations, as SoftBank and large PE funds move earlier, and he warns this could echo 2000.
Michael Duda argues that brands are the net result of what a brand does and how people feel, and that early-stage investors can identify brand strength through customer-experience gaps, founder ethos, and low NPS categories rather than purely quantitative models.
- Brand value shows up as a gap between a company's sales and its market value, and as high returns on capital that persist because consumers cannot easily substitute.
- Low Net Promoter Score categories and customer-journey inefficiencies mark where new brands can take share.
- Founder ethos and the ability to humanize a brand matter more than the product alone, because the product can be copied.
Brand strength is measured by sustained high returns on invested capital over time.
- Because people cannot distinguish products like Coke or wine in blind taste tests, the value of the label is real and should show up as high returns on invested capital, which is the only measurable trace of brand strength.
“If you can't actually tell the difference without seeing the label, that means that's valuable, and that is reflected as high returns on invested capital”
- An enduring brand is one that lets a company keep earning high returns on invested capital over time, and that persistence is the signature of brand strength.
“a brand that allows a company to continually earn high returns on its capital through time”
Information abundance weakens brands in non-luxury goods, opening room for new entrants in frustrating categories.
- Brands used to reduce search and trust costs for consumers, but the current information deluge makes that function less relevant, so brand matters less in non-luxury consumer goods.
“it used to be a trust and search cost thing”
- When people say a category is just the way it is, that phrase is a marker of opportunity, because unchanged categories with frustrating experiences are where new brands can win.
“If you find yourself saying that phrase about it, maybe that's a marker of opportunity.”