Spotter: Funding YouTube Creators
What this covers
Aaron DeBevoise explains Spotter's model to host Ali Hamed, who closes by summarizing its defensibility as a flywheel: data improves pricing, premium ad optimization lifts returns, re-up deals compound, and shared creator intelligence draws in more creators. The first half is platform history. YouTube borrowed Google's AdSense approach, runs an ad auction serving millions of small advertisers, and shares about 55% of ad revenue with creators. After click-based search invited misleading thumbnails, it moved to a recommendation engine built on watch time. That made viewer behavior predictable enough for creators to program channels, and for Spotter to underwrite them.
The second half covers the financing itself. Spotter grew out of the MCN model, which favored high-traffic creators. DeBevoise argues creators' income is too volatile for loans or equity, and that banks will never lend to individuals against it, which is a contested claim. Spotter instead buys catalog cash flows and pools thousands of channels under the Portfolio Approach to Creator Financing, using what it believes is the first borrowing base built for YouTube assets. Its main moat is roughly ten years of platform data. The talk also compares musicians who sell royalties as an exit, such as Sting, with creators who reinvest. It contrasts YouTube's monetization with Snapchat and TikTok, and argues the platform has held up across economic cycles. The most speculative turn extends "creator" to play-to-earn gamers on Axie Infinity.
Spotter funds YouTube creators by buying cash flows from their back catalogs rather than taking equity or making loans, and it earns a spread by treating those catalogs as a data-driven portfolio whose ad value it can optimize.
- Catalog cash-flow acquisition gives creators upfront capital while they keep 100% of future video revenue, avoiding equity control and loan repayment risk
- Deep YouTube performance data makes creator catalogs predictable enough to underwrite, and the data advantage grows with each deal
- Owning high-engagement catalogs lets Spotter sell premium ad inventory to advertisers, widening the spread between its borrowing cost and its returns
Buying back-catalog cash flows suits volatile creators better than equity or traditional loans.
- Creator income is volatile because a single video can perform unpredictably and weather or content choices can disrupt output, so individual creators cannot reliably service debt, and banks will never lend to individual creators against YouTube revenue.
“Never going to be a business where banks can individually loan out capital to creators based on their YouTube revenue streams.”
- Spotter does not take equity or make traditional loans to creators because creator income is volatile and creators lack the information to manage debt, so Spotter instead buys the cash flows from back catalogs while creators keep future revenue.
“Loans are really scary for creators because the whole issue with creators is that their business is actually fairly volatile.”
- Spotter uses equity to fund operations and experiments, while financing catalog purchases with a pool of debt borrowed against a borrowing base it built, and it earns the spread between borrowing cost and catalog returns.
“we used traditional lending practices to build a portfolio or a pool of capital that can be deployed to creators”
- Spotter raises ad value by owning high-engagement catalogs and guaranteeing advertisers land on them, because advertisers do not know which channels they reach in auctions, and engaged audiences need fewer ad impressions per completed view, so advertisers pay more per unit.
“in the auction, you probably have to serve two or three ads for every one ad you serve on the content that has high engagement”
- Buying a creator's back catalog works like post-release box-office financing for films, because the historical performance of existing videos is known and can be used to predict future revenue.
“It's almost like postbox office financing for movies. You already know what the box office is”
- Spotter's main moat is its roughly 10 years of historical YouTube data, and financing more content makes its predictions more accurate, which justifies higher prices in second and third deals on the same catalog.
“So actually financing more content has allowed us to get more accurate, pay higher prices.”
- Music royalty financing is the closest comparison to YouTube catalog financing, but the difference is that YouTube buyers optimize ad monetization on assets they own, whereas music royalty deals were typically discounts on fairly determined cash flows.
“the music royalty financing business is very similar to this. But there's some really specific differences.”
Upfront creator capital funds growth and reinvestment rather than creators cashing out like musicians selling royalties.
- Creators who received Spotter capital grew much faster, with example Unspeakable doing in one year what would have taken four, and Spotter's second deal with him was as large as the first and came eight months later.
“he did what would normally take him four years, he did in one year.”
- Creators who receive upfront capital mostly reinvest in their own businesses rather than spending it on personal purchases, which is why Spotter sees exponential growth in deal size across repeat financings.
“most of the time, they're investing in themselves because the growth opportunity is there.”
- Creators spend financed capital first on hiring an editor, which is their main time sink and a $5,000 to $10,000 per month cost, then on production facilities, travel shoots, and property, and later on new product lines and second channels, with some creators running 50 to 100 staff.
“that is the main time-suck for creators”
- Spotter has deployed more than $600 million into YouTube creator catalogs over the past two years and targets $1 billion deployed by the end of Q1 2023, with no competitor coming close to that scale.
“So we've deployed over $600 million in the last two years.”
- Musicians typically sell royalties as an exit, such as Sting selling his catalog for $300 million, while YouTube creators take capital and reinvest in growth, which drives exponential scaling of deal sizes.
“the motivation behind why people sell royalties to music versus what someone can do on YouTube”
- Music royalty multiples expanded over time because streaming platforms increased the value of optimizing music assets, plus competition, whereas 20 years ago royalty deals priced fairly determined radio cash flows at discounts.
“then the multiple started to expand because the opportunity to optimize those assets, the music royalties, distributing on Spotify”
- Unlike musicians who sell catalogs as an exit, creators who receive Spotter capital mostly reinvest in growth, such as hiring staff, expanding studios and launching product lines, rather than cashing out.
“most of the time, they're investing in themselves because the growth opportunity is there.”
- Some Spotter-funded creators now run organizations of 50 to 100 employees, making them functionally media companies.
“some of our creators have upwards of 50 to 100 people working for them now at their major organizations.”
- Funded creators expand beyond YouTube by launching Shopify product lines, multi-language productions, and second and third channels, diversifying revenue beyond ad income.
“they're launching product lines that they can launch on Shopify.”
- When Machinima began in 2006, its main goal was to give creators a steady income stream that would let them quit their jobs, and YouTube has now largely solved that problem, so the focus has moved to accelerating growth.
“our main goal as a business was to help creators -- work with creators by giving them the steady income stream that would allow them to quit their jobs.”
- Some creators used funding for non-core assets such as a house converted into a studio and a man-made island with jet skis as a fun park, showing that capital can go into lifestyle and production in ways that create brand value.
“they bought a mansion that was on a man-made island”
YouTube's ad economics and reach give creators steadier revenue and income across economic cycles.
- YouTube creator payouts grew from about $7 billion two years before the interview to about $11 billion and then $15 billion, with about 2 million professional creators earning money on the platform.
“I think it was around $7 billion two years ago, then I think it went to 11, now it's 15.”
- YouTube's ad auction serves millions of small and medium advertisers rather than a few hundred large brands, and YouTube shares 55% of ad revenue from a creator's videos with the creator, a split no other platform had offered.
“we will split 55% with you. No one else has done that.”
- YouTube's creator monetization program came before professional content production, launching early as invite-only in 2006 and later opening to any creator above a viewership threshold, which allowed creators to fund better work.
“When you think about what came first, it was really the monetization that they provided creators.”
- YouTube has held up across economic cycles because free content is the cheapest entertainment option when consumers cut paid subscriptions, and because YouTube is the cheapest and most measurable ad channel, so budget cuts shift money toward it.
“YouTube is the cheapest form of advertising and the most measurable comparative to television and other places.”
- Google's business evolved from impression-based pricing to cost-per-click pricing, which made ads more targeted and raised the value of each ad unit over time.
“Google initially started as an impression-based business”
- During the pandemic, YouTube viewership grew roughly 30% to 40% at one point before settling, and while ad markets took a temporary hit, creator revenue stayed flat to up because viewership offset falling ad rates.
“I think it grew probably 30% to 40% viewership at one point and then settled back down.”
- YouTube monetizes creators better than Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, or TikTok mainly because it inherited Google's advertising methodology and advertiser base, with many Google ad leaders later becoming YouTube executives.
“I do think it has almost 100% due to their heritage.”
- Snapchat and TikTok do not give creators a predictable income stream: Snapchat is a gated system with unclear earnings, and TikTok shares revenue only on certain videos, so creators cannot quit their jobs on those platforms.
“they're only sharing on certain videos. So it's going to be really hard for creators to have a career”
- Premium high-engagement YouTube inventory could command 50% to 200% higher prices per ad unit, since advertisers effectively pay for fewer, more completed views rather than many skipped impressions.
“that could be somewhere between anywhere from 50% higher to maybe even 200% higher”
- Creator ad revenue grows with views and watch time because longer videos can carry multiple ad slots, so a 10-minute video earns more than a two-minute video.
“having multiple ads throughout your video because it's a 10-minute video instead of a two-minute video and people are watching it for longer.”
- Platforms need scale, and the fastest route to scale is paying creators, because gated systems like Snapchat and partial revenue sharing like TikTok's make it hard for creators to build full-time careers.
“they are the quickest who have realized that paying creators will drive the best content to give scale.”
- YouTube splits ad revenue roughly 55-45 with creators, and the company believes rewarding creators who produce content that brings audiences back is the core of its success.
“So that's a 55-45 split between YouTube and creator, which I think is the -- when you ask me how it all gets started and why they're so successful is the core to a lot of their success, which is this idea that they need to reward the creators on the platform that provide the content that makes the audiences come back so often.”
- YouTube has over 2 billion monthly users, and its platform has shifted from desktop-only to mobile, where 80% of traffic came from, and now about 40% of watch time is on TV screens.
“YouTube right now has 2 billion-plus monthly viewers or users”
Pooling thousands of channels into a portfolio is safer than financing any single creator.
- The spread between Spotter's borrowing rate and its returns on catalogs can expand over time because Spotter learns to optimize the assets, with winners and losers among catalogs creating an optimization opportunity.
“The vig between our borrowing rate and how much money we make can actually expand over time.”
- Financing thousands of channels as a portfolio is safer than single-title financing because one channel's downturn is offset by others' upturns, and the broader the pool the more aggressively Spotter can price each deal.
“It is a portfolio play. So the more you deploy on YouTube, the safer you are”
- Spotter's expected deal sizes will range from a few million dollars for smaller creators to $10 to $20 million for major producers.
“do you need $10 million, $20 million”
- Spotter's early lesson for investors is that owning a portfolio of YouTube assets is predictable and safe, and that deal-by-deal performance will vary, so early returns should not be judged on the first few deals.
“You cannot expect that the first seven, 10 or two assets that we invest in will perform exactly how we say it will perform.”
- Spotter built what it believes is the first borrowing base designed specifically for YouTube and digital assets, using traditional lending practices to pool capital and deploy it to creators.
“And we built, I think, the first borrowing base that was ever built for specifically YouTube or I think digital assets”
- Creators resist loans and equity because their income is volatile and unpredictable, and any single channel can drop while others rise, so a pooled portfolio view is more appropriate than individual repayment obligations.
“Loans are really scary for creators because the whole issue with creators is that their business is actually fairly volatile.”
YouTube's data volume and recommendation engine make creator catalogs predictable enough for specialized underwriting.
- Aaron's JPMorgan film-finance group held about a 96% share of the independent film finance market because its deep deal data let it value unusual asset classes better than other bankers.
“we had a 96% market share in the independent film finance business”
- YouTube's recommendation engine makes creator performance predictable enough to finance, unlike platforms such as Snapchat that lack a recommendation engine.
“It's the recommendation engine on YouTube that enables this business to be predictable”
- Spotter's focus on YouTube alone, rather than financing creators across platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, and Snapchat, makes it better at underwriting than generalist competitors.
“So you're just never as good as the person that just focuses.”
- Aaron has spent more than 16 years at YouTube-related businesses, from Machinima to Spotter, and his firsthand experience gives him credibility on how the platform evolved.
“There have been so many in spending over 16 years at YouTube, you shift all the time with them.”
- Spotter's team treats YouTube creator data as a set of predictable patterns that can be modeled mechanically, in the way mechanistic macro thinkers treat economies.
“it's the recommendation engine on YouTube that enables this business to be predictable or enables us to find predictable patterns”
- Spotter's thesis is that YouTube's data volume, roughly a million times that of film, makes creator catalogs a new financeable asset class that banks cannot underwrite individually.
“It was very similar to television and film and music except for the amount of data was million times bigger.”
Creators keeping channel control makes catalog sales preferable to equity partners or networks.
- Creators who sell catalogs keep control of their channels and future upside, which makes Spotter more attractive than equity partners who take a say in the business.
“There's no feeling of obligation outside of continuing to do what they do.”
- Editing is the main time-consuming task for creators, and handing it to a hired editor is a hard decision because creators feel they lose creative control.
“that is the main time-suck for creators. And it's really hard for that creator to give up what they think is creative control”
- Traditional multichannel networks, or MCNs, struggled because they had to give disproportionate time to the creators who drove the most traffic, leaving smaller creators underserved and motivating a model that supports creators equally at every stage.
“it's hard to service every single creator the same way. You end up servicing creators that drive the most traffic”
YouTube's shift to watch time and long-form content made creator professionalism possible.
- Applying Google's click-based search algorithms to YouTube created fraud incentives, since creators optimized misleading thumbnails for clicks, which forced YouTube to shift to watch time and recommendations to differentiate.
“That, on YouTube, ended up creating a lot of fraud.”
- On YouTube, professional quality came to mean hyper-focused niche content that gives audiences a repeatable experience, such as a 100-recipe cupcake channel, rather than high-budget production values.
“That became the definition of quality. It was, like, hyper-focused giving the audience a specific experience that they can consume many times over.”
- YouTube shifted from a search-based content store to a recommendation engine driven by watch time, which made viewer behavior predictable enough that creators could program channels and become professional creators.
“that recommendation engine is what made it predictable enough so that creators can start to program their channels rather than having to put up random things that might be discovered by search”
- YouTube's first decade focused on extracting value from creators to build its platform, and its next decade is about delivering more value to creators so they can grow, according to people inside YouTube.
“the first 10 years of YouTube was about extracting value from creators to build their platform. The next 10 years is all going to be about delivering more value to creators”
- The growth of TV viewing changed Aaron's view: he had expected two-minute average videos in 2010, but now over 90% of Spotter's content is 10 minutes or longer, which increases monetization and creator spending on quality.
“I would never have guessed that in 2010. It would have been like average two minutes.”
- YouTube is rewarding long-form content, with over 90% of Spotter's content being 10 minutes or longer, and is building merchandise and shoppable video tools so creators can earn across more business models, with TV now around 40% of watch time.
“they're rewarding creators for creating both long-form content by giving them more monetization tools around long-form content”
Spotter's knowledge sharing and experiments deepen creator relationships beyond traditional video.
- Spotter uses its equity to test products such as international-language channels and production financing, and successful experiments deepen creator relationships in ways that are hard for competitors to replicate.
“we used equity capital to then say, hey, I think there's a business here”
- Spotter grew out of the multichannel network model, which could not serve every creator equally because networks focused on high-traffic creators, so Spotter aimed to fund creators at every stage with both capital and shared knowledge.
“You end up servicing creators that drive the most traffic, more -- you give them more of your time.”
- Spotter builds a knowledge engine that shares tactics such as editing, thumbnails, and posting timing across its creators, and it charges creators nothing for this knowledge, which builds loyalty and access to future financing.
“Our motivations are we're not going to charge you for knowledge. We're going to help you get better so we can finance you more often”
- The definition of a creator is expanding beyond video makers to include play-to-earn gamers such as those on Axie Infinity, who manage multiple characters like a production team, which makes this a financeable opportunity for Spotter.
“look what's happening on, like, play-to-earn games where Axie Infinity has individual gamers acting like creators”
- Machinima was founded on the thesis that YouTube would enable many niche networks like cable did, and it focused on gaming because video games were the MTV-like culture of the generation, and it was among the first on iPhone and Android.
“what network would make a lot of sense would be one that would focus on gamers”