What this covers
Bryan Curtis, who covers sports media for The Ringer, talks with Matt and Dom about his career and the business he writes about. He looks back on his years at ESPN around 2012, when the cable bundle peaked, and calls them a golden age, a characterization the conversation treats as contested. He credits Bill Simmons with the biggest gift of his career: Simmons asked writers to be the best version of themselves rather than imitate the New Yorker. Curtis also praises Wright Thompson's Michael Jordan piece, which felt edited though it was written quickly, and says every story has a secret history that only its writer knows.
The business discussion centers on ESPN's trouble moving from linear television time slots to streaming. It has live-sports rights but no clear non-game draw. Curtis expects bigger companies, which must now justify themselves daily, to buy popular independent operators and put them behind paywalls or on TV. He also sees Substack-style free agency growing at the same time, and he admits he does not know which side to bet on. On talent, he predicts former athletes and nonathlete analysts will merge into one profession, and that near-elite ex-players do well in media because they have something to prove.
The last stretch is about craft. Curtis argues podcasts win on timeliness and host chemistry, while writing sets agendas and lasts longer. He says good podcasting is rehearsed spontaneity. Matt flags words like "therefore" as signs of over-scripting, and Dom explains why a host's listening face matters on video.
Bryan Curtis argues that media is splitting into two simultaneous trends, big companies buying safe harbor and independent creators going free agent, while podcasting's edge lies in timeliness, host chemistry, and disciplined preparation that feels spontaneous, not in escaping the discipline of writing.
- Podcasts win on timeliness and host relationships, while writing gives a durable, edited artifact that can redirect audience attention
- Big media companies are buying independent talent for safe harbor while Substack-style free agents bypass them
- Spontaneity on podcasts is produced by heavy research and rehearsal beforehand
Finished writing gives journalists lasting ownership and a directing role podcasts lack.
- Podcasts are largely reactive to daily news, while writing lets a journalist point audiences toward important or fascinating subjects that were not at the top of their social feeds, giving writing a longer shelf life and a directing role.
“with podcasting, so much of the time we're reacting to things that happen”
- Finishing a piece of writing and publishing it creates a sense of ownership and trust in the work because it reflects deliberate thought, unlike podcasting which often captures what comes to mind in the moment.
“there's something just incredibly satisfying about having finished a piece and putting it up and saying, this is mine. It's not just what came out at the top of my head”
- The trend of podcast series with many fixed episodes, such as 7 or 12 parts, has become daunting for listeners who now wonder whether they have time for the whole thing rather than one good part, a reflection of how much content exists.
“Am I up for 7 parts or 12 parts of this or am I up for whole one really good part of this?”
- Strong long-form magazine pieces still draw people to stop and read them, and this shared reading creates a watercooler-like effect that gets people to read the same thing.
“It is to the Watercooler point in our own little way. It has a way of getting people to all do the same thing.”
Legacy media faces consolidation and streaming shifts, must justify itself daily, and may need a patron.
- Bigger media companies, which must now justify their existence daily, will increasingly acquire popular independent operators and place them behind paywalls or on linear television, hoping the audience follows and accepts them as mainstream rather than a pirate ship.
“we're going to go get the super popular independent operator and put it behind our paywall or an ESPN's case, right, put him on linear television”
- ESPN's advantage in streaming is its large sports rights portfolio, since fans will follow live games wherever they are, but it has not answered what non-game programming will draw people to its streaming service, unlike Amazon and Max with scripted hits.
“But the problem they have is what about everything else? What else gets you there?”
- Linear TV programming was built around time slots that carried viewers from one hour to the next, but in streaming viewers do not choose by schedule, so ESPN's entire daily programming is at risk unless each show is a destination people seek out.
“what happens to our entire day worth of programming? ... what if you go into a streaming universe and be like, I don't care about that anymore”
- Two trends are happening at once: legacy media companies seek safe harbor by selling to wealthy owners or big corporations, while Substack-style creators work independently as free agents, and Bryan does not know which side to bet on.
“it's the age of Substack and people that don't need anything to succeed. ... So I guess the answer to that question is that both things are happening at the same time.”
- ESPN's period when Bryan worked there, around 2012 when the cable bundle reached its highest mark, was in retrospect a golden age when the company made large amounts of money and launched many initiatives, a moment that has since ended.
“I believe, the year that the cable bundle hit its highest mark. So they were just making so much money”
- Inside a large company like ESPN, talent competes intensely for place through silos and internal fights, and the most successful people were often those who fought hardest to be seen, without necessarily undermining colleagues.
“the people who were the most successful in a lot of cases were the people that fought the hardest”
- Pat McAfee said he wanted the power of the cable bundle, a fire hose of linear television, after finding audiences on YouTube, which shows that independent talent may move to linear TV for reach.
“I want the power of the cable bundle”
- Legacy newspapers may be unable to determine their future without a large company or rich patron behind them, so the consolidation path retains real upside for institutions that cannot survive alone.
“you don't understand what the future is going to be unless there is a big company or a rich patron waiting for.”
- Joining Spotify has felt easy for Curtis because his podcast and writing continued as before, with the comforts of a large company and no change to his output.
“my podcast is what my podcast was, my writing is what my writing was.”
- Curtis found that stacking print newspapers piled up unread, so he switched to Sunday print and relies on media newsletters with links and short write-ups, which organize his work more efficiently than any other source.
“the biggest things that help me, I think, the things that organize my life, the most are newsletters.”
- Big media companies can no longer assume an audience because they are the newspaper or radio station; they must justify their existence every day and ask why people read or listen to them.
“why are people reading us? What is necessary about us?”
Long-form magazine writing has distinct value through its length, edited polish, and human oversight.
- Asking a podcast audience to read a 200 to 300-page book is a big ask, while a magazine piece is short enough that listeners will read it, so authors are more available to discuss magazine work.
“Magazine piece, if you're interested, you're going to get it done.”
- Long-form journalism was overpraised in a period when many magazine pieces did not need 3,000 words, so justifying length is healthy for the subgenre even though online competition makes such pieces harder to justify.
“There were a lot of pieces that were just fine. They were just magazine pieces and really didn't have to be 3,000 words.”
- Pieces that feel edited, like those in magazines, have a manicured quality that web writing often lacks, and Wright Thompson's Jordan story felt edited even though he wrote it quickly and it ran largely unchanged.
“you wrote it really fast and then it largely ran. I'm sure there were some important edits on it”
- Writers and readers have moved away from the long-form anniversary phase of American culture, so people are not as eager to revisit old long-form stories as they once were, although they still usually agree to discuss them.
“For a while, I feel we were in the long-form anniversary phase of American culture and some of that stuff has faded away a little bit.”
- Writing that feels edited, as in New York Magazine, signals careful human oversight, whereas much internet writing feels unedited, long, and insufficiently reviewed by human eyes before publication.
“One of the things about writing for both good and new on the Internet is that sometimes it doesn't feel edited.”
Podcasts succeed by timeliness and presence for major news, which shapes audience expectations.
- Podcasting has spoiled listeners by cutting commercials, repetitive ticker updates, and filler, getting straight to the interesting conversation in the best instances.
“You don't have commercials quite as often. You don't have, at least in sports radio tickers in 20 minutes”
- Radio's fixed daily time slots create a clock-punching routine that podcasting, which is released on demand, does not replicate, so radio builds listening habits that podcasts struggle to match.
“people do it from a certain time to a certain time every single day. There is a clock punching aspect to that”
- Bryan and his co-host, who have been physically across the country for a while, coordinate through texts, a shared Google Doc, and emails with a producer, and fast-moving news often forces last-minute changes to planned episodes.
“We have been physically across the country for a while now, which makes everything incredibly challenging. So there's lot of texts. There's a Google Doc”
- Podcasters constantly search for the watercooler moment everyone is discussing and sometimes reach for things and try to turn them into events that are not truly national events.
“sometimes I think that makes us reach for things and try to turn them into an event”
- After a big game, fans want immediate, emotional reactions from people who share their feelings rather than network post-game shows, which is why timely audio is valuable.
“I need 30 minutes of bloodletting right now. I need somebody who's as upset as I am”
- Podcast growth depends less on distribution than on being timely and present on big news, because audiences want trusted hosts to respond when major events happen and that creates the watercooler moment.
“people want you to talk about certain things. They want to hear you. They want you to take them in interesting directions, but they want you to be there when big things happen.”
- Because on-demand viewing has weakened shared moments, media professionals constantly search for the next Watercooler event and sometimes try to manufacture one, asking whether it is truly a national event.
“sometimes I think that makes us reach for things and try to turn them into an event.”
- The Ringer recorded a podcast within about 15 minutes of Rupert Murdoch's retirement news, accepting a rougher outline in exchange for speed, since audiences want immediate reactions from hosts they like.
“So when Rupert Murdoch retired the other day, it's like we got to go, man, 15 minutes”
Great podcasts depend on prepared spontaneity and host chemistry rather than monologues.
- Unscripted candor on podcasts, such as a cohost saying something strange that turns the conversation, usually works because both people know the subject thoroughly, which lets one partner safely take the conversation off track.
“a lot of times, that comes with the fact that both people know everything they're supposed to be talking about. So you allow your cohost to do that.”
- The best podcasting is heavily researched and thought through beforehand, which allows hosts to appear spontaneous and be funny in the moment, while people who give huge written-out speeches are easy to spot.
“I always think the best podcasting is heavily researched and thought about beforehand, which then allows you to be spontaneous in the moment”
- Writers who transition to podcasting feel like they are back to being 22-year-old beginners, because podcasting requires new skills beyond being funny and smart, such as handling the medium and being willing to learn it.
“you're back to your 22-year-old days in your writing career”
- Podcasting's informal, shaggy style is an improvement over the polished radio and TV voices of earlier eras, and the best voice combines vocal quality with informality.
“I like people who sound like they're actually talking and not talking in the way they think radio people should sound”
- The relationship between podcast hosts is the single most important factor in a double-act podcast, and it can matter more than the daily topic, because listeners come back to the relationship.
“I think it's the single most important thing about a podcast, especially a double act where you have 2 hosts.”
- A common podcasting failure is an exchange of monologues, where each speaker talks for minutes without responding to the other, and conversation should instead sound like normal people talking.
“One person will have like a 4-minute monologue. And then the other person has a 3-minute monologue that doesn't really respond”
- Podcasting should learn from daily sports radio, particularly how hosts open a segment, make obvious topics less obvious, and handle audio conversation, because radio hosts have skills podcasters often lack.
“Listen to how they take a seemingly obvious thing into a less than obvious direction”
Interviewing writers reveals the unseen process behind stories, as the Wright Thompson Jordan piece shows.
- Every published story has a secret history known only to its writer, including the edits that saved it, reporting that never got done, and the calls the writer was too lazy to make, which is why interviewing writers reveals things readers never see.
“You know the things that should have been in the story but weren't either because you couldn't get them or you were too lazy to make one more call.”
- The One Perfect Story podcast started from envy of great writing, combined with a reporter's curiosity about how the piece was pulled off, and it treats good stories like great movies or episodes to be dissected.
“Those interviews come out of envy.”
- Interview guests such as Wright Thompson are highly receptive to podcast requests about their own revisited work, and retrospective anniversary pieces are an easy yes for long-form writers.
“Most people like to talk about their work, especially work like that, that they revisit.”
- Asking a question you already suspect the answer to, and then receiving confirmation, often yields especially good answers because the guest is willing to confirm a truth the host has already sensed.
“That's me casting a fishing line into the water, because I suspected that was the answer.”
- Curtis's One Perfect Story conversation with Wright Thompson began from envy of Thompson's 2013 Michael Jordan story, which Curtis considers Thompson's best work, and from curiosity about how it came together.
“I start with envy and then I start with the reporter's curiosity”
- Bryan chose the Wright Thompson Jordan story partly because Michael Jordan is a popular subject that draws casual listeners who are not journalism enthusiasts, making the podcast accessible.
“that's why I chose Wright, partly because not only it was a great story, but it's about Michael Jordan”
- Wright Thompson's 2013 Michael Jordan story was left out of the next year's Best American Sports Writing anthology, and Thompson was annoyed about it despite the story's acclaim.
“this story was not in the Best American Sports Writing the next year”
- Many writers want to be great writers, but explicitly wanting to be the best is different, and Wright Thompson's obvious desire to be the best is unusual among writers who rarely articulate it.
“I want to be a great writer, which I think a lot of people have that thought, including myself, but I want to be the best which is different”
Bryan measures success by his own standard of work, not by popularity.
- The Editor-at-Large title is an old magazine-era designation that gives Bryan freedom to pursue stories he finds interesting; the editor part is purely ceremonial with no management of other teams.
“It's actually an old-time life, glory days of magazines title, where they would pick a few people and say, You're the Editor-at-Large”
- Bryan's One Perfect Story interviews start from envy of a great story and the reporter's curiosity about how it was reported, including access, time, and what the writer did to move the subject beyond the usual anecdotes.
“I start with envy and then I start with the reporter's curiosity to think about how did that come together?”
- Bill Simmons' management style at Grantland and The Ringer did not require writers to emulate the New Yorker or New York Times Magazine, but to become the best version of themselves, which produced distinct talents.
“It was, can you write the best Bryan Curtis story you can write.”
- Bryan judges his podcast and writing by whether he is happy with the work and whether it met his own standard, not by popularity, because popularity can come from weak work and he no longer equates it with success.
“I'm much more worried about. When I got done with that, whether it was a piece of writing or it was the podcast, am I happy with that?”
Former athletes and nonathlete analysts are merging into one sports media profession shaped by Simmons's Ringer talent.
- Former professional athletes who were close to the top, but not elite, often move into media with something to prove, and that drive to be better in a second career is what makes them strong broadcasters.
“they got so close and then still came in their own way to the media business with something to prove with a second act”
- The distinction between former athletes and nonathlete analysts is collapsing because sports media now requires advanced expertise, such as breaking down tape and advanced stats, so the two groups increasingly operate as one profession.
“In a way, it's become one profession and the notes of expertise are still valued”
- Talent developed under Bill Simmons at Grantland and The Ringer, including Zach Lowe, Kevin Clark, Brian Phillips, and Wesley Morris, has gone on to distinct success across ESPN and other outlets.
“Wesley Morris has worked for ESPN. He was our colleague that is mind-blowing in retrospect.”
- Bill Simmons encouraged Curtis to be the best version of Bryan Curtis rather than writing to match legacy benchmarks like the New York Times Magazine or The New Yorker, and that personal expectation was the biggest gift of Curtis's career.
“It was, can you write the best Bryan Curtis story you can write.”
Curtis's on-air rapport and radio-friendly presence come from a long friendship and his voice.
- Curtis's on-air chemistry with David Shoemaker reflects a very long off-air friendship dating to high school rather than work done on the air.
“David Shoemaker, my partner, and I've known each other since we're a 14-year-old freshman in high school.”
- Curtis says he has a face made for radio and a voice made for print, which places him between the two modes, and he is relieved podcasts are audio-only because he does not have to manage his appearance.
“I've often said I have a face made for radio and a voice made for print.”