What this covers
Matt and Dom debrief the launch of Art of Investing, a show from Rick and Paul recorded in a live classroom of students. They treat the existing classroom format as a lower-risk starting point than an interview show, since the format and guest type were already known and no episodes were scrapped. They want the recording to feel like a private conversation among three or four people rather than a live event, which is the Intimate Listener Framing idea. They say it outperformed the earlier Making Media launch because investors, the company's core audience, sit at the center of its reach. They also note that the hosts' years of meeting top capital allocators meant preparation began long before the roughly four-month timeline.
The range is practical. Matt lists the tracked workflow: CRM capture of alumni, TA leads researching guests, a custom website and newsletter, on-site audio testing, and feed, artwork, transcript and sponsorship setup. Dom explains why the first guest should be instantly recognizable yet rarely on podcasts. He also says aiming at early-career listeners fits a Cradle-to-Grave Customer Lifecycle logic. They contrast this with Web3 Breakdowns, which had a big splash and then struggled to fill guest slots a few weeks later. Spotify's growing share of listening, a claim that charts reward rate of change, and the claim that Twitter's link to episode engagement broke down in 2023 are the more contested points. The launch reached roughly 150,000 Spotify impressions.
Matt is candid that many variables can't be isolated, so the results are not a repeatable formula.
A podcast launch succeeds mainly through pre-launch setup: a stocked episode inventory, a trailer released a week early to fill the feed, and a rare high-profile first guest. Together these create algorithmic momentum before the first episode drops, which owned channels like newsletters and existing shows sustain better than social media.
- A trailer released a week early and promoted on Invest Like the Best builds feed subscribers before the first episode, avoiding a cold start.
- Launching with two or more episodes and a line of sight through the first month keeps the show from running dry after the splash.
- Owned channels such as newsletters and existing podcasts drive engagement more reliably than Twitter, whose link to episode engagement has weakened.
Successful podcast launches require months of advance preparation and table-stakes basics completed beforehand.
- Rick and Paul's Art of Investing launch was easier because they had spent years in the investing world meeting top capital allocators, so the podcast's preparation effectively began years before the launch timeline of roughly four months.
“they've been practicing for this podcast for a good number of years, and you could argue decades, given what profession they've been in and meeting these people.”
- Podcasting is very difficult to grow, so starting from a strong position with table-stakes preparation done in advance gives a show the best possible chance of success.
“I think the more you can populate a feed before the first episode actually drops, the better. And somewhat counterintuitive”
- The previous Making Media episode was not a glowing self-assessment; the team had a rough week in early February, with the trailer causing around 400 takes, showing that the company's results are not always rosy.
“I had caused 400 takes of our trailer and various other things going on, so yes, it's not always rosy.”
- The company had roughly three subpar launches in the prior three years, so it was time to get everything right, and the team lined up its basics to produce positive results.
“we have had probably three subpar launches our last three years. And so like it was time that we nailed everything.”
- The launch work ran from late May or early June until the October launch, roughly four months, and Dom argues at least a few months of advance thinking is necessary for a successful podcast launch.
“I think it's definitely necessary to have at least a few months thinking about it.”
Multiple episodes and guest inventory must be ready at launch to sustain momentum after the initial splash.
- A podcast should launch with at least two episodes already in the feed, so listeners can choose between them and the number of downloads grows, and the team should aim to have at least three episodes ready before launch.
“You got to want to at least three plus. You basically want to get yourself through the first month. And like let's say you want to start on launch day with at least two episodes in your feed”
- Before launch, a show should have line of sight to recording enough guests to get through the first month, because bookings often dry up after launch and an empty pipeline is a poor position to be in.
“you might find it easy to bring guests in, you'll get to a point where it fell a bit overwhelming... you see that there's very few people there that you've got to record with.”
- A new feed starts at zero listens, and platform charts and algorithms measure the rate of change rather than absolute totals, so going from zero to 4,000 listens is a monumental percentage increase that naturally pushes the show up the charts.
“the charts and the algorithms will measure the rate of change. So if you go from 0 to 4,000, for example, listens in your feed, like that percentage increase is monumental”
- The Web3 Breakdowns launch had a strong initial splash, but a few weeks later the team struggled to fill guest inventory, showing that a big launch without follow-up content loses momentum.
“we launched and then we had a great launch. And then a few weeks later, we were struggling to fill inventory in terms of bringing guests on the show”
- In weeks three or four after launch, people stop talking about the new podcast and it becomes just another show competing with thousands of others, so the team has to shift to executing consistently, which is why inventory is needed.
“get ready for the week three or four, when it's like business as usual. No longer are people talking about your new podcast”
- A podcast launch is not a one-and-done event, so the team must prepare for a second phase in which the show must compete on its own merits and attract listeners in other ways.
“So just be prepared for Phase 2 because this is not like a one-and-done thing.”
- Inventory matters to platforms because having multiple episodes in the feed supports download volume and rankings, which is why the team prioritized having several ready at launch.
“It's also going to help with just downloads generally, and that will help with the rankings that we just talked about.”
Owned channels and a staged pre-launch sequence through early evangelists drive initial launch momentum.
- A podcast company should focus on channels it owns and knows are effective, such as its podcast and newsletter, rather than heavy investment in social media, because those two channels move engagement the most for the company.
“the two things that move the dial the most for us is our podcast, the Invest Like the Best in particular, and our newsletter.”
- The launch produced roughly 150,000 impressions on Spotify alone, which Dom attributes to sustaining momentum early in the launch phase.
“this had 150,000 impressions or something just on Spotify alone. And like that's through keeping that momentum up early in the initial phase.”
- A three-step pre-launch sequence works best: first, promote the trailer to the audience, second, get the hosts onto an established show like Invest Like the Best to send listeners to the trailer and feed, and third, the first episode itself, which creates a self-sustaining loop of momentum.
“So one, here's the trailer. Listen to our new show. Two, get them on Invest Like the Best. Go listen to the trailer, subscribe. And then three, like your first episode”
- Identify the community most likely to become early evangelists for a new show and actively energize them, because early advocates amplify the launch.
“Find the community that you know are going to be early evangelists of this thing and then pump them up.”
Recording reliability, not content quality, is the main risk to resolve before launch.
- The quality of the conversations is high enough that the concern should be having enough recordings in the pipeline, not perfecting each one, because if the recordings are not all perfect, the team is in trouble.
“I'm not worried about, oh, we need to make sure that we've got three recordings coming up, but if they're not all perfect, then we are in trouble.”
- The Art of Investing is a class at the University of Notre Dame, run by Rick and Paul, both former endowment investors who now invest through their own capital vehicle Sator Grove, teaching about 40 final-year students.
“The Art of Investing is actually a class at a university in America to which I really struggle pronouncing, called Notre Dame”
- The Art of Investing's core format brings in a steady cast of world-class investors and operators for a couple of hours each, who discuss their careers with students, so the content draws on the hosts' long network of capital allocators.
“they bring in this literally all-star cast of investors and business operators, execs and other people interested in business and finance and investing”
- Booking quality is high enough that Dom is not worried about the content of conversations, but he is concerned that if recordings are not all perfect the show is in trouble, so potential issues need to be resolved before launch.
“if they're not all perfect, then we are in trouble. Like get out ahead of those potential issues before you launch something”
Audience fit, live classroom format, and guest choice shape listener connection from the start.
- A podcast should be started for a reason the host can draw on for years, because a show is a long-term commitment and passion is the only durable source of motivation to keep producing it.
“if you're going to start a podcast, we talked about this endless times on here, like do it for a reason that you will be able to draw from that source for years to come.”
- The company's audience is primarily investors rather than general business enthusiasts, and this show sits squarely in the center of that audience, which is why it outperformed the earlier Making Media launch.
“the core epicenter of our audience are investors and this kind of fits squarely in that field.”
- Targeting early-career listeners locks in customers for decades, because businesses want customers from cradle to grave, and a show aimed at students can attract late-career guests who want to advise young people, which in turn draws in the listeners.
“Not only do you end up with epic guests because people late in their career love talking to people early in their career about what advice they might share, so you get the guest, but then you also hopefully get the people listening”
- A podcast recorded in a live classroom should feel to the listener like a private, intimate conversation with three or four people, even though the setting is a room of students, because listeners want to feel personally connected with the host and guest rather than hearing a live event.
“people don't want to listen to a live conversation as a podcast. They wanted to feel like intimately connected with the host and the guest on the show.”
- The first episode should feature a guest who is both instantly recognizable to the audience and who rarely appears on podcasts, because that combination generates strong interest and locks in listeners from the start.
“making sure that your first guest is both recognizable to people easily, but also that they don't hear from them very often. And Todd Combs kind of fits the bill perfectly.”