The Evolution of M&A and Corporate Strategy
What this covers
Patrick talks with Stephanie Cohen of Goldman Sachs, who moves between M&A practice and the strategy questions behind it. She begins with how dealmaking has changed. Sellers once needed a strategic buyer, but private equity's capital now means almost any sale has a financial bidder. Her advice for acquirers is to step out of deal mode first: define the strategy, the organic alternative, and a few backups. Then settle a walk-away price as a matrix of growth and margin assumptions rather than a single valuation. She treats the charm offensive as tactical, since relationships yield information and non-price advantages, and she wants integration planners sitting beside deal teams.
Two claims are marked contested. One is that M&A is not zero-sum, because capital structure and the story told to investors and rating agencies can create value for both sides. The other is that repeated dealings among the same people keep conduct better than critics assume.
The conversation then turns inward to Goldman. Cohen describes the cafeteria test for strategy, the balance of recurring fee revenue and deposit funding (with Caterpillar's push into services as an outside example), and the split between exploiting existing businesses through front-to-back reviews and exploring new ones. She covers innovation sprints, the risk of funding ideas just because they have sponsors, and the tension between a culture of full accuracy and stretch OKRs. She also argues that incumbents and FinTechs should build together.
The closing stretch covers venture funding going overwhelmingly to all-male teams, the disputed figure that a warm introduction makes a founder 13 times likelier to clear an investment committee, and her case for open networks and a personal board of directors.
Cohen argues that M&A is a tool for executing strategy rather than a goal, that value is created through relationships, preparation, and the ability to say no, and that a large incumbent like Goldman must balance exploitation of existing businesses with deliberate exploration and partnership to innovate.
- M&A should follow from a clearly defined strategy and a pre-set view of what a company is worth, not from pressure to show growth or from inbound banker calls
- Relationships and a charm offensive generate information and non-price advantages that change deal outcomes
- Large institutions need structured internal innovation, time for exploration, and partnerships with FinTech and big tech because building everything in-house is too slow
Relationships are an underappreciated edge in investing and deal-making, called relational alpha.
- Patrick's friend describes relational alpha, the value of relationships, as an underappreciated edge in investing and deal-making, which Patrick links to Stephanie's charm offensive concept.
“Friend of mine talks about this as a, he calls it relational alpha”