Life as a Writer with David Coggins
What this covers
This is a conversation between the host, David, and the writer David Coggins about how a writing life gets built. Coggins traces his sensibility to adults who lived with art, books, and readings, including Glen O'Brien and Duncan Hannah, and to a father who recommended art school before law school. The talk then becomes practical: he starts commissions right away to avoid deadline dread, has traded early perfectionism for steady output, and says drafting is the easy part compared with hundreds of revisions.
Editing and publishing take up much of the middle. Coggins says a good editor makes a writer sound like their best self, the idea behind Editor as Voice Preserver, and that after a hundred readings a writer must imagine a first-time reader and cut whatever slows the narrative momentum, even vivid details such as the streets of Buenos Aires. His most contested claim is that publishing no longer nurtures young writers, so an unedited Substack newsletter is risky for beginners. He also recalls the Esquire archive, where Ernest Hemingway and John Cheever ran at 8,000 words, and he argues that each format asks readers for a different frame of mind.
Other turns are shorter. Before a book, he says, a writer should decide whether they want reach, specificity, money, or beauty. He measures a book's success by whether he is glad to see it in the world, and he prefers to wait months before writing about recent events. He argues that bold work, like Paul Thomas Anderson's, often needs time before audiences catch up. He also explains why he returns to the same cities each year.
Coggins argues that creative work depends on an environment of mentors, literary exposure, and disciplined habit, and that the editor-writer relationship and repeated writing do more to shape a writer than inspiration from a place or the immediate reception of a work.
- Early exposure to creative adults and mentors such as Glen O'Brien shaped his sensibility, and the same transfer can happen as a teacher or editor.
- Good editing makes writers sound like their best selves, while the act of drafting matters less than the long revision process.
- Writing deals with the writing and the process, not with the environment, and works often need years before they are fully understood.
Good writing comes from self-questioning, drafting, waiting for perspective, and heavy revision.
- Many people who are not professional writers can write well for a magazine or publication, but they are held back by the mistaken belief that writing must sound important and formal, as if they were writing a school paper.
“I think many people will sound great if they sound like themselves, but there's a barrier because they think they're trying to do something really important and significant”
- Good writing, even short essays, should arrive somewhere the writer did not expect, and reaching that place requires writing through the process and being willing to ask questions about oneself, which can be uncomfortable.
“even if it's a shorter essay, you should arrive at some place you didn't expect”
- Coggins carries a small notebook on trips to record unusual phrasing, guides' remarks, and profound statements by non-native speakers, then expands them in ink each night because these phrases are impossible to remember later.
“those are really just to get certain phrases that are impossible to remember because they're so unusual”
- For Coggins, the act of drafting is not the hard part; the real work is understanding how the piece will sit with readers, which requires heavy editing across hundreds of revisions, like seasoning a dish.
“Part of writing is -- the actual act is not the difficult part for me. It's understanding how it's going to sit. Editing is a huge part.”
- Writing about events shortly after they happen is hard, and Coggins prefers to wait a few months, because perspective lets him understand what actually happened and what he learned.
“even 2 months, you get a better perspective on what's happening”
- Asking for personal feedback is a trap for writers, since the honest answer is often harsh, and reading negative reviews gives the most painful knife in the back.
“do you honestly want people to know? If I want to find out, I can just read one-star reviews of my book”
- A straight writing book with no photographs or design elements leaves the writer exposed, so the author must project confidence in the importance of what they say even when they do not feel it.
“You're just turning in a word document and then there's nowhere to hide”
A good editor is a generous collaborator who preserves the writer's voice.
- Editing is a generous act that Coggins believes is diminishing, and Glen O'Brien's legacy as a terrific and supportive editor is as important as his public-facing achievements.
“the art of editing is, Robert Gottlieb just passed, not a lost art, but diminishing art”
- Editing someone who has already decided what they want to say is like telling them what to wear after they've chosen their outfit, which requires going around the edges and asking questions rather than prescribing.
“it's sort of like telling someone what they should wear after they've already decided what they want to wear”
- A good editor helps the writer sound like the best version of themselves rather than imposing the editor's own voice, and when editors impose their voice, the collaboration becomes a disaster.
“they want the writer to sound like the best version of themselves. They're not trying to make the write or sound like the editor, that doesn't work”
- When placing The Optimist, Coggins and his agent chose Scribner partly because editor Colin Harrison was there and Coggins wanted to work directly with him.
“we, my agent and I, chose Scribner, which was part of Simon & Schuster because Colin Harrison is the editor there”
- In narrative nonfiction, interesting local details such as the streets of Buenos Aires can distract readers from the story's forward movement if they are not right for the moment, so editors often cut them.
“just because the detail is exciting to you, distracts people from how the thing is moving”
Writing happens best alone in routine rather than in travel or inspiring locations.
- Coggins expects a reassessment of why people travel after COVID, because the pandemic-era return to travel was excessive and was amplified by social media and TV-driven fame.
“And I think there's going to be a reassessment of what people want and why they want to go to certain places”
- As Coggins gets older, he feels less urgency to see everything on a trip and prefers to sit in a good cafe or bar, arguing that being in the right place is enough.
“I don't have quite the insane urgency I used to have to see everything”
- Coggins does not draw inspiration from the place where he writes; he writes best alone in a quiet room, and the writing process depends on the process itself rather than on mood or setting.
“I don't need inspiration from the place. For me, it's just coming from a different”
- Coggins writes in Microsoft Word with distraction-free mode to hide notifications and listens to instrumental ambient music on repeat to keep a low-key background tone.
“all I do is put that sucker on no distraction mode”
- Finishing a book creates intense pressure, and Coggins has been uninvited from trips after trying to write in a European hotel room, concluding that the romantic idea of writing abroad is awful in practice.
“It's not romantic. It's awful. I was very stressed. Don't do that.”
Style loosens and improves through volume, fast deadlines, and accepting imperfect output.
- Writing art criticism for magazines like Art in America and Modern Painters under demanding female editors made Coggins sharper, though initially his writing was too dry for later clothing and travel writing.
“they made me extremely much sharper in my approach”
- Glen O'Brien told Coggins to 'let the air in' to his writing, and loosening a rigid critical style helped him write more fluidly across genres.
“Let the air in to it a little bit.”
- The more a person writes, the more they keep writing, so Coggins starts commissioned stories right away while in a good mood rather than waiting until the deadline, to avoid dread.
“The more you write, the more you end up writing, and just habits”
- Young writers should write a great deal, because the obsession with finding a recognizable style fades only with experience, and style emerges through doing more work rather than through deliberate searching.
“the most important thing, if you're a young writer, is to write a lot, really write a lot”
- Coggins defines a successful book as one that makes him happy to see in the world, recognizing that the book reflects an earlier version of himself and he should be charitable toward that younger self.
“You want to be happy when you see it in the world”
- Coggins' early desire for perfection kept him from producing work, so he now aims for a steady output of working-writer projects, accepting that some will be weaker and that the writer's name makes them their own responsibility.
“When I was younger, I did want things to be perfect and it kept me from doing things”
- Writing many quick pieces for Men's Vogue, such as auction and memorabilia reports, taught David to write fast and loosened him up, which he found valuable.
“it was really good for me to write a lot and fast. The nature of it made me feel a little more relaxed about things.”
Modern culture is losing the broad reading and patience that high art rewards.
- Reading widely, including books by authors one has nothing in common with, and learning to write clearly gives a sense of human nature that Coggins believes modern culture is losing.
“there is a reason to study literature and to even just be able to write with some sort of clarity that gives you a sense of human nature that I think we're moving away from”
- Coggins believes the trend toward choosing college majors for job-market fit, such as learning to code, undervalues the liberal arts and makes less sense for creative people like himself.
“we're moving away from what might be considered less learn how to code. Study something in college”
- High art feels uncomfortable to many people because it is no longer a natural part of daily life, and Coggins argues it should be experienced casually and without reverence, as with opera, which he finds visceral.
“high art has gotten to a place where because it's not part of our lives in such a natural way that then there's an uncomfortable marriage in a way”
- Shows like The Wire and Deadwood are ahead of their time because their dialogue rhythms take several episodes to understand, and viewers who persist are rewarded.
“they were ahead of the game there”
- Rewatching a show like The Sopranos reveals humor and detail that viewers miss the first time, because the urgency to learn what happens next consumes attention.
“you're so caught up in what's happening with a plot. When you're separated from what the plot, then you see all sorts of other things”
- Works that look unsatisfying at first, such as those by Paul Thomas Anderson or a musician who abandons his hits, often become clear later, and audiences need time to catch up with bold artistic choices.
“And then much later, you're like, Oh no, this is great. It took me a while to catch up to how great this was.”
Early family and mentors normalized creative life and taught rigor and confidence.
- Coggins' father gave friends and his children the opposite of conventional career advice, suggesting art school before law school, which gave the children confidence to pursue creative paths.
“he would give them advice about maybe you try the art school first before the law school and give the opposite advice that most people will get”
- Growing up with an artist father and an interior-designer mother who both did theater set design made creative work feel normal to Coggins, and he only realized otherwise when he visited friends' homes.
“So it seemed normal to me to have creative parents. My dad's an artist and my mom is an interior designer”
- Mentors like Glen O'Brien and Duncan Hannah shaped Coggins less through explicit instruction than through their sensibility, which showed how to live with art, books, and readings as a daily part of life.
“their sensibility wear off on me in a big way, how to live, how to have art as part of your life”
- Coggins' father edited his schoolboy writing aggressively with a blue pencil, and that early rigor was credited with making his high school and college writing clean.
“it was get out the blue pencil, and I could stay up past my bedtime”
Editorial feedback is hard to receive because writers feel exposed and seek validation.
- Writers find it harder to reveal their emotions than to structure a narrative, and editors often push for more of the writer's feelings, which makes the writer feel exposed.
“you're vulnerable in that moment”
- After reading a manuscript 100 times, a writer loses the ability to judge whether jokes or details land, so they must imagine a first-time reader and cut anything that distracts from the narrative momentum.
“you have to imagine someone reading it the first time. Your joke, if you try to put a joke in there, is you're so tired of it at that point”
- A good agent pushes back on book ideas by asking whether they fit the market and how they will be executed, and this friction improves the work even though it is uncomfortable.
“Our first instinct, and I was alluding to this earlier, is not always perfect”
- People who ask how they did usually do not want honest answers, and writers in particular find harsh reviews such as Amazon one-star reviews cutting, so honest feedback often feels unwelcome.
“do you honestly want people to know? If I want to find out, I can just read one-star reviews of my book”
- Because a book is written privately over a long period, the first editorial feedback is a vulnerable moment, and writers often want validation even when they believe they are ready for criticism.
“you're getting feedback and you think you're ready for it, but you're not, or the moment you are you want the validation”
Each writing format demands different reader attention, so format and tone must be deliberate.
- The only way to learn what kind of publication a writer wants to be in is to experience it, because even a magazine that seems wrong can offer a chance to write something strong.
“the only way to do that is to do it and experience it and be like, Okay, I don't like being in Maxim magazine”
- Each writing format (book, magazine article, newsletter) demands a different reader frame of mind and speed, so a writer must decide the format and tone based on where the piece will appear and how readers will engage with it.
“Somebody who sits down to read a book is in a very specific frame of mind”
- Before writing a book, a writer should answer hard questions about whether they want reach, specificity, money, beauty, or a particular publisher, because books rarely generate much money and the trade-offs shape the work.
“What are you trying to achieve? Are you trying to have this reach a large audience?”
- Reading a book requires a specific frame of mind that is hard to reach when phones and other media compete for attention, so the format a writer chooses determines how much attention and time readers will give.
“Somebody who sits down to read a book is in a very specific frame of mind. It's harder to get into that frame of mind.”
A newsletter is a serious professional practice offering community feedback books cannot.
- A newsletter gives Coggins regular interaction and community feedback that a book, which takes years and gets feedback in a delayed way, does not provide.
“And then at the newsletter is very different because you're writing regularly and you're interacting with people regularly”
- Coggins treats his newsletter as a serious professional practice and the main way he makes a living, not a secret side project, and he believes it has changed his life.
“the newsletter changed my life. At Substack, it's not everything for everybody, but it is a lot for me”
- Publishing no longer has the infrastructure to nurture young writers, so an unedited newsletter is dangerous for beginners, who need a period of working with a good editor before writing without one.
“Publishing does not have the infrastructure to really nurture a writer”
- Coggins' Substack newsletter began with formal essays that were too long for phone reading, and he shortened and loosened them into conversational pieces written in the morning and lightly edited.
“they were too long. I made them a little shorter, more conversational”
Literary models from past publishing and famous writers shape what good writing looks like.
- James Salter rewrote entire passages by hand or retyped them to preserve his language, which Coggins finds extreme, and Coggins himself cannot imagine writing without cut-and-paste editing on a computer.
“James Salter, he rewrote it out again or typed it out again.”
- John Cheever's diaries are a recommended read for writers because they combine family love, nature writing, and unsparing self-examination of personal demons, and they can be read in short sessions.
“the range of those things and just writing that, is beautiful as ever been written in this country”
- Steven Soderbergh is an admirable example because he keeps projects moving, learns from each film, and reacts against his previous work in technique, editing, and release strategy.
“he learns from what he does and then can react against that”
- Reading the Esquire archive showed Coggins that past magazines published major writers such as Hemingway, Fitzgerald, Cheever, and Mailer in long, 8,000-word pieces, a depth of publishing largely absent today.
“It's heady, heady 8,000-word stories”
Learning and teaching depend on personal engagement and patience rather than avoidance.
- Growing up around actors and theater company members who gathered at the house weekly taught Coggins to interact with adults, which he believes fostered comfort in social settings, though not necessarily maturity.
“I think the expectation as a child to talk to adults, interact, and I don't know if it makes you more mature, but I think it makes you used to interacting with people”
- Coggins avoided fishing with older Wisconsin fishermen because he was intimidated by them, and he believes he would have become a better angler had he engaged with them sooner.
“I put off fishing with them because I was intimidated by them”
- Coggins has found he is more patient teaching people to fish than in other parts of his life, because he wants to transfer something he cares about to people he cares about.
“I'm more patient when it comes to that than I am in other parts of my life”
Returning to familiar places beats chasing hyped destinations for meaningful travel.
- Coggins prefers to wait for new restaurants to settle and goes at off-peak times, such as 2:30 for lunch, to avoid hype-driven crowds.
“let them be open for a while, typically”
- Returning to the same cities each year, such as Paris for New Year's, adds family and personal history to a place, making each visit more meaningful than discovering new destinations.
“You go back to these places and you have a history there, a family history and a personal history”
- Choosing a destination because it appeared in a TV show almost always disappoints, because by the time the show has aired, the crowds and hype have overwhelmed the place.
“Doing something after it's been on TV is almost guaranteed to not quite work out the way you want it to be.”
- Young travelers judge foreign places by comparing them to what they know at home, focusing on what is missing, while as adults they appreciate the gap between expectations and reality.
“you're comparing something to what you're familiar with. And so you're incredibly aware of what it doesn't have”