What this covers

Mario Cibelli of Marathon uses a run of past and current positions to show how the firm builds conviction: Blockbuster against Netflix, Stitch Fix, Xoom, WWE, and the tequila producer Becle. The common method is firsthand operating evidence. Eric Hidy noticed that repeating number sequences on Blockbuster's mailing envelopes encoded shipment volumes. Combined with reported subscriber counts, they implied churn three to five times Netflix's, a pattern Cibelli calls triangulation of operating data.

The operational cases form the middle of the conversation. Netflix's distribution center embodied years of bottleneck-solving, which a store-based rival could not easily copy. This is the logic of process power through mistakes and the good luck test. Stitch Fix is framed as a service business, with labor-heavy pre-processing and unusually smooth, forecastable volume, in contrast to e-commerce swings of 3x to 8x. Xoom's remittance platform is valued for the regulatory and fraud-control head start it would keep if growth slowed. Cibelli also sketches what makes a good activist target and argues that deep research still pays, even as information has become widely accessible.

The last stretch turns to mispricing. Blue Weber agave takes five to nine years to mature, so supply lags price. A spike from about five pesos per kilo to the high twenties crushed Becle's margins and, in Marathon's view, its shares. WWE offers a more contested case: the market disliked the Network launch and dividend cut, media rights rose roughly fourfold after Fox's bid, and Cibelli forecasts that streaming bundles will lift the value of WWE's audience.

Sharpest takeaway

Cibelli argues that deep, operational diligence (tracking competitors' service data, visiting distribution centers, and studying a company's unit economics) reveals durable competitive advantages and mispricings that headline financials and management messaging miss.

  • Operational data gathered firsthand (Blockbuster envelope serial numbers, DC visits) exposed churn and process advantages the market had not priced
  • Process advantages built through years of bottleneck-solving are hard to replicate, so 'good luck' to would-be competitors signals a durable moat
  • Market pricing of cyclical or event-driven risk (agave prices, WWE media rights renewal) can diverge from what a reasonable assumption implies

The argument · threads10 threads · 64 claims
0.85

Firsthand, detailed research reveals what filings and public information fail to show investors.

14 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Marathon Partners subscribed to Netflix, Blockbuster Total Access, and Walmart's DVD-by-mail services and benchmarked them on how often the top queue pick was received and turnaround days, finding Netflix clearly outperformed.

    “We subscribed to every service, and we said, Let's start putting them through their paces.”

  • By combining envelope-derived shipment data with the subscriber counts Blockbuster reported on quarterly calls, Marathon estimated Blockbuster's churn was roughly 3x to 5x that of Netflix, which they judged unsustainable.

    “Essentially we could see that their churn was astronomically high, absurdly high, maybe 3x to 5x the churn that Netflix had.”

  • Repeating number sequences printed on Blockbuster DVD mailing envelopes encoded how many customers and DVDs Blockbuster was shipping, which Marathon's Eric Hidy spotted and used to track subscriber counts.

    “on the Blockbuster envelope there were certain sets of numbers that would repeat and other sets that wouldn't.”

  • Marathon presented its Blockbuster subscriber findings to Netflix, which initially doubted the method, and Netflix adopted the insight, helping the company during a period when its success was uncertain.

    “We had a couple of calls with them. I think they initially didn't even believe this, that we were able to do this, and then we showed it to them. They took it over.”

  • Visiting a company's facilities gives investors an edge over analysts who rely only on filings and management presentations, because management teams market to investors and will tell them what they want to hear, while physical operations reveal what is actually happening.

    “Management teams are marketing to you. Of course they're going to tell you what you want to hear.”

  • Investment insights reach Marathon in two ways: some arrive as an instant reaction to an idea that is later bought at an attractive price, and others emerge only after persistent questioning and detailed work reveals nuggets.

    “I'd say they happen in a variety of ways.”

  • An idea can produce an immediate positive reaction years before it is investable, and Marathon waited until the price fell to an attractive level during the pandemic to buy it.

    “how many years later we had the opportunity to buy it all this summer and during the coronavirus pandemic at prices that we thought were pretty attractive.”

  • Marathon, which calls itself a generalist, is consistently drawn to inefficient sectors where information is poorly processed, because mispricing is most likely there.

    “I consider us generalists, but going back to my old days of selling research to hedge funds, we're always turned on by inefficient sectors in the marketplace.”

  • Deep, detailed research remains as valuable today as when Marathon started in 1997, even though information access has democratized and competition for differentiated information has intensified.

    “I think it's just as valuable now.”

  • In the 1990s, roughly 80% of spin-offs could be shorted in the when-issued market and then covered after they traded down, and even reasonable spin-offs could be bought afterward, reflecting slower information flow.

    “you could short spin-offs in the when-issued market. And then everyone would get their shares and then they would trade down.”

  • In the 1990s a high short-interest ratio was a red flag that a sophisticated short seller had found aggressive accounting, so it served as a signal to investigate, whereas short interest is now common and less informative.

    “I remember if there was a high short-interest ratio in a company, it was a red flag in of itself. Companies weren't highly shorted.”

  • In the 1990s, investors had to call companies to request quarterly and annual reports and rely on microfiche or next-day paper delivery services, so gathering information was slow and painful, which made deep research a larger differentiator.

    “It was labor intensive to get information, you had to call up the companies and ask them to send the quarterly reports, and annual reports”

  • Marathon runs concentrated portfolios and does deep work on details, because such portfolios make detailed research especially valuable.

    “We do a lot of thinking, a lot of deep work, details. The concentrated portfolios like we run are very, very important.”

  • Information has become more democratized and moves faster than in the 1990s, making it tougher and more competitive today to obtain differentiated information about companies, even though the core challenge of the investing job has not fundamentally changed.

    “I'd say it's probably tougher and more competitive to get differentiated information today. Access to information has been democratized.”

0.56

Marathon backs hard-to-read operational businesses where others see unresolved risk.

7 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Stitch Fix's Dallas DC visit was the most interesting facility Cibelli had seen since his early Netflix days, because it displayed operational dynamics that he believes few companies in the world attempt at scale.

    “That was the most interesting DC that I've seen since my early days on Netflix.”

  • Reed Hastings had an ability to see where the business was going before others and to reduce a very big problem to simple language, which allowed him to pull employees and investors along toward a direction he believed in early.

    “His ability to just see things as they're going to be was just absolutely incredible, and he can boil down a very big problem into super simple language.”

  • Cibelli is not sure Stitch Fix will succeed, yet he believes it will, and says the operational difficulty it faces is precisely what could let it escape the gravity of its competitors and become a large business.

    “I'm actually saying it's really, really hard. That's the whole point.”

  • Marathon visited three Netflix distribution centers (Long Island, San Jose and Atlanta), and the Long Island visit was the most epic because the company sent no representatives, leaving only the investors and the office manager.

    “They sent us there without any representatives from the company, so it was just us and the manager of the office.”

  • Becle, the largest tequila producer, offered a cheap backdoor way into the spirits business because its US-generated profits were held in a company that listed only a small minority stake on the Mexican exchange and carried very little debt.

    “I guess I think what we've really done is we've figured out a backdoor, cheap way to buy into the spirits business.”

  • Cibelli describes Becle as the second-best risk-reward trade he has ever seen, arguing that the downside seemed limited because the financials looked so strong that he could not see how Marathon could lose money.

    “I actually called this one the second-best risk-reward trade I've ever seen in my career. Ever. I don't think I can lose money here.”

  • The kindest thing anyone did for Cibelli was when Stan and Myra Jaffe, parents of his friend Rich Jaffe, let him live in their Pleasantville basement after graduation when he had a job but no money for rent.

    “So Stan and Myra Jaffe open their house to me, with their son not even there. I moved in and lived in the basement with the parents of my friend.”

0.54

Becle trades cheaply versus spirits peers because of its limited float and cyclical depression.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Becle, a long-established US-based tequila and spirits business, listed equity on the Mexican exchange and sold roughly 15% of the company to the public, a limited float that left the stock under-owned and mispriced relative to its US earnings base.

    “decided to list equity on the Mexican stock exchange and sold a relatively small sliver to the public, 15%.”

  • Marathon estimated that Becle trades at 12 to 13 times 2022 EBITDA, versus high-teens multiples for peers such as Brown-Forman and Diageo, implying room for rerating even without an agave price collapse.

    “We believe Becle is trading at 12 to 13 times EBITDA on 2022 numbers versus peers today, like Brown-Forman and Diageo that are trading in the high teens”

  • Becle traded at a cyclically low multiple versus spirits peers while having cyclically depressed margins and faster growth from higher tequila exposure, a combination Marathon viewed as a near-riskless setup.

    “So here they were trading at a cyclically lower-than-peer multiple with cyclically depressed margins, growing faster than peers because their tequila exposure is way higher than peers, with very little debt.”

  • The agave input cost spike compressed Becle's margins, pushing its shares down to levels Marathon viewed as absurdly low relative to the company's debt-free balance sheet and its brands.

    “That caused the Becle shares to trade down to levels that we thought were absolutely absurd.”

  • Owning Becle gives investors a cheap backdoor way into the spirits sector, which the market has not yet recognized as belonging with its premium peer group.

    “I guess I think what we've really done is we've figured out a backdoor, cheap way to buy into the spirits business.”

  • Spirits companies are hard for value investors to justify on fundamentals because they persist through inflation, deflation, fees, famine, and war, so they are always well-bid, and in a zero-rate world their earnings growth is especially valuable.

    “Spirits businesses are hard to justify for value type investors because they're always well-bid for.”

0.38

Wall Street misreads WWE's engaged, multigenerational fanbase as fading attractiveness.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • When WWE launched its Network and cut its dividend to shift from a profitable pay-per-view model to a loss-making direct-to-fan business, Wall Street hated the uncertainty, and that dislike created an attractive entry window near six to seven dollars per share for investors who believed in the vision.

    “they went from a money-making business to a money-losing business, cut the dividend to make that transition, and Wall Street absolutely hated that.”

  • The COVID loss of live audiences hurt WWE more than it would hurt sports leagues because performers feed off crowds, but Cibelli expects live events to resume before 2024, re-engaging fans and restoring the storyline.

    “The performers feed off the audience. So the loss of the audience here has been way more difficult than any other event.”

  • WWE has engagement that ratings alone understate, shown by households with three generations of fans and a fan base that has not disengaged over time, so the company's attractiveness is misunderstood by Wall Street.

    “having three generations of people in the household were fans at one point.”

  • Marathon has bought WWE shares at three major points since 1999 when Wall Street worried about engagement, and it views those dips as the times to buy.

    “This, I think the third major opportunity since 1999 to buy the shares that have prices that we consider to be very attractive.”

  • WWE repeatedly finds the next star when performers retire or leave, such as when The Rock departed, so its engaged fanbase and years of storyline IP persist beyond any individual personality.

    “they've time and time again, been able to find the next one. That's the brilliance of the company and Vince McMahon.”

0.36

Hard-to-copy operational know-how makes businesses defensible against well-capitalized rivals and entrants.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Netflix's distribution center reflected years of bottleneck-solving, such as keeping DVDs on desks rather than storing them, using DVDs-in-hand routing to nearby homes, and deploying customized sorting machines, making the operation very difficult for a store-based rival like Blockbuster to copy.

    “They actually didn't store them anywhere, they always remained on the desks.”

  • A growing market attracts well-capitalized competitors, so the key question for investors is whether the business is defensible, and the answer depends on whether its operational know-how can be copied, which often takes competitors years of costly mistakes.

    “The market gets validated, competitors are coming, some of them are going to be bigger and more well capitalized. Is that business defensible?”

  • Store-based apparel operators such as J.Crew and Urban Outfitters that attempt a subscription styling service will face major difficulty because the operating model is so different.

    “I think a store operator like J.Crew or Urban Outfitters, I think, is attempting a service like this, that operates stores, good luck. It's going to be tough.”

  • Marathon judged that Xoom's remittance platform was very valuable even though near-term profits were thin, because the regulatory and fraud-control demands of remittances were so hard to meet that a multi-year head start would persist if growth slowed.

    “We came to the conclusion that if this company's growth rate falls off a cliff, the platform is extremely valuable. We were right. PayPal recognized that.”

0.36

Agave supply constraints and expected price swings give Becle upside with downside protection.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Becle is growing its in-house agave supply, which costs about five to seven pesos per kilo, so it will be less exposed to agave market prices, a scale advantage competitors cannot easily match.

    “because they're insourcing more and more of their production with their costs, probably five to seven pesos per kilo, it almost doesn't matter agave prices don't correct.”

  • Blue Weber agave farmers have planted multiples of the harvest over the past three years, so Marathon expects a future agave price collapse that would create a margin windfall for Becle.

    “Blue Weber agave farmers in Mexico had been planting multiples of the harvest for the past three years, and we think there's a windfall of that margin event in the future of Becle.”

  • Marathon's Becle position can earn a positive return even if agave prices do not fall, which acts as downside protection, while an agave price collapse would produce a much larger return.

    “Agave pricing does not have to collapse for us to make a positive return on Becle. But if it does, we're really going to have a charged return.”

  • Blue Weber agave takes five to nine years to mature, unlike annual crops, so its supply cannot respond quickly to price, which has produced three major price spikes, most recently a move from about five pesos per kilo to the high twenties.

    “Blue Weber agave takes anywhere from five to nine years to mature, different than a lot of other spirit companies. The input is not an annual crop.”

0.36

The market underprices WWE's media rights and its value within a streaming bundle.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • WWE's US and international media rights, approaching a billion dollars in revenue, dominate its P&L, so merchandise and event-based sales matter far less to the investment case.

    “The media rights, which I think are fast approaching a billion dollars in revenue now dominate the P&L.”

  • WWE's announced review of alternatives for its Network effectively means treating its direct-to-fan pipe as another licensable asset, and large streaming or tech platforms could pay for the audience and the bundle.

    “the company announced that it's looking at alternatives, alternatives for the network. And what that really means is that they are now looking at their direct path pipe to their fans. It's just another licensing opportunity.”

  • Cibelli believes the market is pricing in a down round for WWE's 2024 media rights renewal, which he thinks is wrong because WWE reliably delivers a highly engaged audience on Monday and Friday nights, and comparable Major League Baseball rights renewed at roughly a 60% premium.

    “My belief is that with reasonable assumptions, that the market is pricing in a down round on their media rights. And I think that's wrong.”

  • The streaming wars are reassembling content into bundles in OTT and digital environments, as the traditional pay-TV bundle did, so a large player can extract more value from WWE's network within a broader portfolio than WWE could alone.

    “My opinion is that the bundle was in the process of being reassembled in OTT environment and digital environment, and that's likely to happen again.”

0.27

Stitch Fix's service model makes returns, labor, and predictable volume central to its economics.

6 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Because Stitch Fix's model expects a high volume of returns, which traditional e-commerce rarely plans for, returns are a significant margin drag, making return handling and keep rates central to the business's economics.

    “Returns are margin-killers for that model.”

  • Stitch Fix runs a service business rather than a conventional e-commerce operation: it must manage high expected returns, pre-process items for try-on, and maintain a predictable production schedule, so its operations are fundamentally different from traditional online retail.

    “This is not an e-commerce business that we just saw. This is a whole different kind of service.”

  • Stitch Fix's warehouse labor is spent removing collar stays and plastic, folding, quality-checking, and wrapping each item so the customer can try everything on within six or seven minutes, an expensive labor step for a small customer-experience gain that most e-commerce companies do not perform.

    “When the box is opened, you could try everything on inside of six or seven minutes because it's all ready to be tried on.”

  • Stitch Fix's production volume grows in a smooth, predictable way with no real seasonality, so it can forecast shipments weeks ahead, unlike traditional e-commerce whose peak-to-trough volume swings can reach 3x to 8x.

    “There's no seasonality in the business, really.”

  • Stitch Fix's website shows a first-available shipping date that ranges from about seven to fourteen days out, and this lead-time signal shows demand is booked ahead, giving operators visibility into shipments two weeks in advance.

    “they show here's the first available date. That first available date could be seven days in the future, 14 days in the future when they're busy.”

  • After Fox bid for the SmackDown rights alongside Comcast, the value of WWE's US media rights rose by roughly a factor of four in the last renewal, shifting the company from a touring business to one dominated by media revenue.

    “the value of the US media rights went up by a factor of, I think, almost four times on the last go around.”

0.27

Activism should target poorly governed companies, not well-run management teams.

6 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Good activist targets are companies with compensation too generous for underperformance, or a persistent gap between intrinsic or strategic value and market value that management refuses to address through buybacks, while well-run management teams have little to fear from thoughtful activists.

    “A lot of times it's the management teams that have a situation that's too attractive. The compensation's been too good, the board's overpaid for under-performance”

  • Some activists practice hit-and-run tactics that are not beneficial, while thoughtful, long-term-oriented activists who want to help the company should be welcomed by boards, though often they are not.

    “Some of them do kind of hit and run activism, that's not us. People that are thoughtful, take a long-term point of view”

  • Marathon's early fight with Ron Perlman at MNF Worldwide showed how boards can justify unjustifiable transactions, and the firm reversed a decision that transferred wealth to an insider at shareholders' expense.

    “We helped reverse a decision, a blatant kind of play to create wealth for Ron Perlman at the expense of shareholders.”

  • Marathon prefers finding companies like Stitch Fix where it can help management and then hold for a decade without heavy involvement, because the firm loves working with management teams and treats activism as a labor-intensive tool.

    “It's labor intensive, it's not necessarily fun, it's a tool in our toolbox.”

  • Cibelli entered investing expecting fair treatment from management and, when it was not forthcoming, decided to act, learning through early fights at MNF Worldwide and John Nuveen how to challenge boards and dynamics and how to justify or expose unjustifiable transactions.

    “I came to the business pretty naively. I'm like, well I expect to be treated fairly. If someone didn't treat me fairly, I got pretty upset.”

  • Netflix reportedly avoided a hostile run by Carl Icahn when Reed Hastings invited him in to explain the business, illustrating that a well-run management team with a strong business has little to fear from activists.

    “I think I read some stories, that Reed invited him in and said, Let me tell you about our business.”

0.20

Tequila's growth in the US and abroad will expand the category and drive Becle's share gains.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Tequila is gaining share in the US and Canada because many consumers who had negative college shot experiences change their view when given a high-quality bottle, and Latin heritage and cross-border travel help the category spread.

    “they had a negative experience for. I said, Try it anyway, try it anyway. And I brought a nice expensive bottle. They ended up loving it.”

  • Tequila's adoption in the US is growing exponentially, with the speaker's illustrative count going from one drinker at a party five years ago to four three years ago and an expected eight next year, so the category gains share domestically.

    “the party five years ago, there was one tequila drinker. Party three years ago, there were four, next year we're going to get past the coronavirus there'll be eight.”

  • Tequila holds about 9 to 10% of the US spirits market but only about 3 to 4% internationally, so if it catches on abroad Becle could become the fastest organically growing spirits company outside China over the next decade.

    “The market share for tequila is something in the nine-10% range in the US, but internationally it's much lower than that, maybe on the order of three or 4%.”