Mineral Resources: Unearthing Value
What this covers
This is a conversation between Fraser Christie and Matt about Mineral Resources, the Australian company split between InfraCo, which builds and runs processing and haulage infrastructure, and Mining Co, which holds lithium, iron ore and energy assets. Much of the discussion is about how the business works: the in-house design and construction, the habit of buying distressed mines cheaply, and a founder-led approach to capital allocation under Chris Ellison.
The operating claims are specific. Fraser says MinRes delivers projects in half the time and at a third of the capital intensity of peers that outsource construction, and that approvals came in under a year against a typical four to seven. The Onslow iron ore project is the main example, with roughly $800 million of capex against about $1 billion of annual EBITDA. The capital recycling flywheel is illustrated by a partial asset sale that implies returns above 80%. Fraser also notes that MinRes does not hedge and sells at spot, lithium included.
The contentious parts come later. Fraser argues that through-the-cycle return on invested capital matters more than forecasting commodity prices, a lesson he credits to investing in software-style businesses. He claims founder-led commodity companies can beat software on returns. The balance sheet, with about $4 billion of debt at peak leverage, is defended on the strength of InfraCo's earnings. The conversation also weighs whether to separate the two divisions and concludes the coupling between them matters too much to break. Comparisons to BHP, Rio Tinto and Fortescue anchor the valuation discussion.
Fraser argues Mineral Resources is a founder-run compounder whose fixed-fee InfraCo infrastructure business is undervalued because the market applies low mining multiples to it, so investors can effectively get the commodity business for free.
- InfraCo earns fixed dollars per volume processed with no commodity exposure and deserves 10x to 15x EBITDA versus 4x to 6x for mining
- Founder Chris Ellison's capital allocation and in-house construction capability generate returns on capital far above peers
- Mining Co sits low on the cost curve, so commodity downturns rarely impair the business
Scaled, infrastructure-backed iron ore expansion delivers high-return, low-cost earnings with little competition.
- The InfraCo investment for Onslow is about $1.7 billion of capex yielding about $560 million of EBITDA, a 30%-plus return on invested capital that is still attractive for infrastructure.
“it's about $1.7 billion of CapEx to result in about $560 million of EBITDA, which is about a 30% plus ROIC”
- MinRes's iron ore business, historically a small high-cost producer with about 2% of Australian output, is being transformed into a very large low-cost mine.
“this has historically been a very small high-cost mining business that represents, call it, 2% of Australia's iron ore output”
- InfraCo will deliver about $1 billion of annual EBITDA within the next few years from ports, airports, roads, and crushing and handling infrastructure needed to move ore from mine to export.
“the InfraCo business will deliver about a $1 billion of annual EBITDA within the next few years”
- MinRes faces essentially no competition in the crushing service it offers third parties, which is its key outsourced service.
“MinRes doesn't really have any competition, particularly in the crushing side of their infrastructure, which is the key service they offer to third parties.”
- Large iron ore deposits in these regions have scale economies: most miners would need tens of billions of dollars of capex in rail, port and mining infrastructure, which creates very long-life earnings streams for the few who can build it.
“Most miners would have to spend tens of billions of dollars in CapEx in rail and port and all the mining infrastructure, and that then gives you these very long life earnings streams.”
Founder-led management focused on ROIC and reinvestment discipline drives superior shareholder returns.
- Ellison built an airline and childcare, gym and medical services, and he treats employees well because he does it for the right reasons, with financial benefits following as a consequence.
“you do it for those right reasons, and inevitably, there are financial benefits.”
- Management's discipline means it would sell a project from a 30% ROIC to an 80% ROIC every day, and reinvests proceeds into other high-return projects, although the company may not need such derisking sales in future given its scale.
“if they can take a project from a 30% ROIC to an 80% ROIC, they're going to do it every single day”
- The key lesson is that founder-led businesses which care about shareholder value and ROIC can outperform software businesses on returns, even though commodity businesses are typically viewed as lower quality.
“Chris has taken what is a business that most people would not think particularly highly of in terms of quality in comparison to, say, a software business, but has delivered returns better than I suspect almost every software business”
Valuing long-term EBITDA works without heroic commodity price assumptions.
- Mining Co earnings are lumpy, since lithium operating costs have risen during expansion work, but long-term costs should stay reasonably stable year to year, so EBITDA is best modeled over the long term.
“Now it is lumpy. So as an example, the lithium business has had high operating costs more recently because there's a bunch of stuff happening to change and expand the volumes at the mines”
- MinRes does not require heroic commodity price assumptions, and investors have historically been comfortable owning the stock while assuming prices well below forecast consensus.
“We've always been able to assume prices well below forecast consensus and still get comfortable with owning the stock.”