What this covers

This March 2020 conversation has Patrick questioning Chad Cascarilla on how the pandemic shock compares with 2008. Cascarilla treats 2008 as a rolling credit crisis of falling house prices. This one he likens to a war or the 1918 pandemic, because businesses stopped working and the damage hit Main Street restaurants and commercial real estate before Wall Street. He judges policy through a Hole-Filling Framework of size, duration, and speed, and points out that in 2008 stimulus checks took about 60 days and the ECB's corporate bond program about 90.

The middle of the conversation catalogs vulnerabilities. Pre-tax corporate profits had not grown in seven years while the S&P 500 nearly doubled. Leverage stood near 3.3 times, and leveraged loans were underwritten cov-lite. Banks hold roughly 2 trillion dollars of capital against a hole he sizes at 4 to 6 trillion. He also argues the Fed's facilities are built for large institutions, leaving small businesses and non-bank mortgage servicers, which need about 50 billion dollars a month, exposed. Triple-A catastrophe bonds jumping to about 10 percent yield serve as a liquidity-stress signal.

The most contentious stretch covers tail outcomes: a bank holiday, nationalization of undercapitalized banks, and redenomination, which he puts at around 5 percent or less. He also warns that mailing checks directly could turn inflationary if recovery comes faster than expected. On assets, he explains the falls in gold and Bitcoin as forced liquidation rather than risk-off. He contrasts gold tokens with ETFs, which have 15 to 20 intermediaries, and recommends T-bills in segregated accounts over bank deposits above the FDIC limit.

Sharpest takeaway

Cascarilla argues that the COVID-19 shock hit a economy already at record leverage and priced for perfection, so outcomes could range from inflationary to deflationary depending on the size, duration, and speed of policy response. He concludes investors should hold a diversified portfolio with stocks, gold, Bitcoin, and government-backed cash rather than bet on one scenario.

  • Record global leverage and priced-for-perfection asset valuations meant little resilience to a shock
  • The policy 'hole' is large, and the response must be big, long enough, and fast enough, or it fails
  • Non-bank Main Street and mortgage-servicer liquidity gaps are underappreciated risks that the Fed's bank-focused tools may miss

The argument · threads2 threads · 51 claims
0.85

Overpriced, leveraged markets lack resilience, so unprecedented fiscal and monetary action is required.

2 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Being priced for perfection while carrying high leverage means the system has little resiliency to absorb a 100-year storm, which is why the response has to be unprecedented fiscal and monetary action.

    “you're priced for perfection with high amounts of leverage, which means you just didn't have a lot of resiliency to deal with a 100-year storm”

  • Key indicators to track are daily case counts and fatality rates to judge whether the outbreak is burning out, along with whether fiscal and monetary programs are filling the hole enough, measured through liquidity and solvency signals.

    “You're really looking at case counts on a daily basis. What are the fatality rates? Is it burning itself out?”

0.71

Non-traditional assets like gold tokens and Bitcoin hedge inflation, default, and redenomination tail risks.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Assets outside traditional stocks and bonds, including gold tokens and Bitcoin, can protect against inflation or default when held alongside stocks and cash, and the advantage is that such positions can be unwound.

    “the advantage is they can always be unwound. There's not like a permanent position that anyone needs to have”

  • A redenomination of the dollar, where account balances and government debt are reset to a new currency and debt is cleared, is a deflationary tail with historical precedents in Argentina, Brazil and Germany, but Cascarilla puts its probability at around 5 percent or less.

    “I think that's say a 5% risk or something or less”