Building Europe’s Next Software Champion
What this covers
Jan-Hendrik Mohr talks with Paul and Jan about how Chapters is built and why. He starts by correcting the consumer-app picture of software: much of global spend goes to workhorse databases that run the economy. The discussion covers vertical market software, where gross retention is the favored metric and Chapters averages about 97 percent or more at acquisition. It also covers how Europe's differences in tax law, process and language keep businesses from being standardized end to end. The comparison case is Tyler Technologies, whose payments-led cross-selling Mohr says travels poorly to Europe.
The middle of the conversation turns to AI and data. Mohr treats AI as a layer on top of each system of record, and argues that it means more software for the world rather than displacement, a framing marked as contested. He says the real value lies in securely joining databases, and notes that few enterprises feed data into pricing or staffing decisions. The EU Data Act and cybersecurity against state-sponsored actors come up as concrete openings. Intrusion detection is described as a cheap upsell that benefits clients more than Chapters.
The rest is about organization and capital. Mohr contrasts deal-making with deal-doing and makes the case for permanent capital over a three-to-five-year private equity sale. He draws on Henry Singleton and The Outsiders to argue that no single capital tool suits every era. The incentive design is covered in detail: the original 20/80 platform split, shareholder loans at 10 percent, and a put-call structure tied to Chapters' own trading multiple. He also describes successive co-founder teams, hiring for the ability to grow into a business ten times larger, and the empty chair meeting ritual.
Mohr argues Chapters can become a leading European software company by acquiring mission-critical niche software businesses and running them with a decentralized, co-founder-driven operating system, using AI mainly to raise services efficiency and unlock data feedback loops rather than to displace existing systems, while permanent capital and a 10% cost-of-capital incentive model let winners compound.
- Mission-critical, hard-to-replace software creates lock-in and high gross retention that AI can enhance rather than destroy
- Europe's fragmentation, heterogeneity and public-sector software needs make aggregation a durable advantage, and deal-making rather than auction competition drives returns
- Permanent capital, long horizons and a 10% hurdle incentive model let the company hold and double down on winners
Sticky vertical software core systems and customer trust, not AI hype, sustain durable value.
- After a June Manuscript Days meeting, Mitch Rales urged Chapters executives that the company is still small enough to turn and that every team member needs to become an AI preacher, teacher, and implementer.
“AI is this important that I think he said every Chapters team member needs to become an AI preacher, teacher, and implementer.”
- Improving professional services, using data to add value, and simply interacting with customers gives an excuse to build trust, which locks in gross retention and makes AI a helper rather than a threat to vertical software.
“What's coming to mind for me is that you're locking in that gross retention even more the way that you interact with them.”
- Gross retention, the share of customers who stay the next year all else equal, is the favorite metric for vertical market software investors, and the category tends to have among the highest gross retention of any industry, with Chapters averaging about 97 percent or more at acquisition.
“What Chapters has done, I think it's something like an average of 97% plus when you buy these companies.”
- Paul argues that the AI hype cycle around AI-native startups distracts from the vital, boring core systems that businesses rely on, and that old-school core needs can remain the main driver of company value while new technology disrupts.
“he sells the box, which is this extremely boring product. But that is vital for so many companies”
Permanent capital and long-term shareholders give Chapters a private-company, unlimited time horizon.
- Permanent capital public companies can hold and double down on winners in a way funds cannot, provided the culture, systems, brand and talent are set up to do so, because fund life limits the time horizon.
“It's very unique that an entity, a fund definitely can't do this. A permanent capital public company like you're running can if the culture is right”
- The episode was recorded in Mallorca near Rafael Nadal's hometown of Manacor, which is an incidental detail of the recording location.
“We're only a few miles from Rafael Nadal's hometown of Manacor, Spain.”
- Paul argues that permanent capital structure combined with long-term strategic shareholders like Mitch Rales, Daniel Ek, and Will Thorndike cultivates a private-company mentality with an unlimited time horizon despite being public.
“It almost feels like it operates with a private company mentality with an unlimited time horizon even though it's a public company.”
Inorganic roll-ups using AI and data extend growth without capital-intensive ownership.
- Under the EU Data Act a software company can act as the core system of record and helper alongside AI for a business it does not own, such as a Hamburg bus depot, so it can capture the AI data opportunity without the capital intensity of ownership.
“you don't have to own the Hamburg bus depot or the company that runs it, you can just be that core system of record”
- Chapters functions as an inorganic growth engine alongside organic growth, using creative debt and many financial tools, and Will Thorndike's point that the addressable market for smaller companies is far larger than trying to build one company organically supports this.
“Chapters has been an inorganic growth engine alongside organic growth. You've issued debt in really creative ways.”
- Justin Yoshimura's CSE Generation rolls up low-margin, overbuilt US retailers bought in distress and layers an in-house AI system on top to speed decisions, which is the same play Chapters makes with data.
“He's rolling up across the United States, North America, a number of retailers in particular. Very low margin or they've been overbuilt.”