What this covers

This is a conversation with Geoffrey Batt, who runs a fund focused on Iraq, and it starts with fund structure before it reaches the country. Batt argues that most funds are pro-cyclical: money leaves when performance sags, which creates a Forced Seller Dynamic much like a margin call. He describes his own fund as a Pre-FDIC Bank Stability Model, where the stability of the investor base decides survival. He also discusses Adjacency Risk, the danger that one large seed investor's exit steamrolls everyone else. He courts family-office principals so that investors add during sell-offs instead of redeeming.

The middle of the conversation covers the investment case. Batt cites long re-ratings, including Japan's roughly 40-year bull market with a decade of stagnation, and Sberbank moving from about 1 times earnings in 1999 to 20 to 24 times by 2007. He explains why managerial skill dominates in banks levered around 20 to one. For Iraq, he sets 2007 data on inflation, civilian deaths and oil output against coverage of a failed state. He puts Iraqi stocks near four times earnings, with some banks yielding 10 to 15 percent at one fifth of tangible book value, and he attributes the pricing to voting-machine trading on rights offerings and stock dividends.

The more contested turns concern information and incentives. Batt says only one or two of every 20 or 30 experts are useful, that media cannot convey complexity, and that no democratic transition has come without massive violence. He explains how career risk asymmetry keeps investment committees away from contrarian ideas. Smaller asides include dollar-priced shops as a currency signal and a framework for young investors.

Sharpest takeaway

Batt argues that transformational returns in frontier markets require patient, countercyclical capital and a willingness to bet against negative perception, and that Iraq's depressed valuations and stable data made it such an opportunity.

  • Historic re-ratings take 10-15 years and demand investors who can tolerate long stretches of nothing happening, which most fund structures and institutional LPs cannot accommodate.
  • Mainstream perception of Iraq diverged sharply from hard data on inflation, violence, and oil output, and that gap is where mispricing lies.
  • Iraqi equities remain priced as voting-machine sentiment rather than fundamentals, so cheap, cash-generating companies persist at low multiples.

The argument · threads8 threads · 62 claims
0.82

Negative perception keeps Iraqi companies mispriced despite strong growth and cash generation.

11 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Iraq trades cheaper than Nigeria, which Batt considers equally or more risky, because Iraq's enduring negative perception keeps investors away while Nigeria's huge-market story draws excitement.

    “It's really becoming the leper of the frontier and emerging market investment universe.”

  • In frontier markets, short-term prices are driven by popularity and sentiment rather than fundamentals, which Graham's voting machine idea describes, and Iraq's local investors trade on rights offerings and stock dividends rather than fundamentals.

    “We've just been stuck in the voting machine phase, where we have just local investors”

  • A tweet about Iraq's recovery went viral with over 3 million views, but was politicized by both sides, and Batt concluded that trying to change perceptions in a politicized country is pointless, so time must do it.

    “it's so politicized in this country. There's almost no point to trying.”

  • Iraq's market capitalization was smaller than the Palestinian exchange's despite Iraq's 150 billion barrels of oil, which Batt argued shows the market was not rationally pricing assets.

    “Which is sort of fascinating, because here you have this country with 150 billion barrels of oil.”

  • In 2007, nearly every asset class had risen through a global synchronized growth cycle, so Iraq was the only market Batt could find that had not, which is what led him there.

    “So Iraq was the only thing I could find that didn't.”

  • Negative perception of the Middle East, from the Arab Spring, Iran tensions, Syria, and Yemen, may create opportunities, and Batt suggests that Algeria protests could be an under-the-radar 'Arab Spring part two'.

    “maybe there are even more opportunities than they were when I was looking at it in 2007”

  • The most interesting investment situations exist where there is a huge gap between a country's negative perception and what the data shows, and the investor should test claims against data.

    “these situations where there's this huge gap between perception and reality”

  • Baghdad Soft Drinks' revenues roughly tripled in ten years and operating cash flow per share compounded near 20 percent for a decade, yet the stock only doubled, whereas in Pakistan it would trade at 25 to 30 times earnings.

    “cashflow from operations per share has compounded at about 20% for the last decade. But the stock has maybe doubled.”

  • Pepsi holds 70 to 80 percent market share in Baghdad and is the dominant soft drink in Iraq, the opposite of most countries where Coke leads with 60 to 70 percent.

    “Pepsi is 70 to 80% market share in Baghdad”

  • Batt's fund has not seen price catch up to fundamentals yet, but mispricing has been strictly undervaluation, and he expects that the manic phase, when Mr. Market assigns high multiples, will eventually arrive.

    “You want to stick around long enough to get to the point where mr. market gets manic”

  • AsiaCell, a Qatari-majority-owned Iraqi mobile operator, has an enterprise value near 1 billion dollars against roughly 700 million dollars EBITDA, a 14.5 percent dividend yield, and a free cash flow yield of around 33 percent.

    “That trades as a 14 and a half percent dividend yield.”

0.71

Media and consensus perception are unreliable, so firsthand visits and data must test it.

12 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Of 20 or 30 experts, perhaps one or two are useful, because think tanks and commentators bear no cost for being wrong, and dissent from the group's line can damage careers.

    “out of like 20 or 30 experts, maybe one or two that are useful”

  • Because experts and media are unreliable, an investor must rely on their own research and must visit the country to resolve the gap between perception and reality.

    “you really can't rely on anyone other than yourself and your own research”

  • In 2007, Iraqi CPI inflation had fallen from 75 percent year over year to 5 to 10 percent, the currency was appreciating, oil output was rising, and civilian deaths had dropped from about 3,000 to 200 per month, contradicting coverage of a failed state.

    “the CPI inflation, which was 75% year over year, a year ago is now five or 10%”

  • A large gap between a country's negative perception and what the data shows is the signal to investigate, because it means the worst may be behind the country and the price reflects the perception.

    “these situations where there's this huge gap between perception and reality”

  • The news media is not structured to convey complexity because audiences change the channel when complexity appears, so outlets reinforce audience views with sound bites and reader loyalty.

    “The moment you try and explain complexity to your audience, you're going to lose them.”

  • A useful framework for young investors is to take the prevailing wisdom, construct an alternative model of reality, and test whether it yields interesting results and opportunities.

    “try and come up with an alternative model to view reality through”

  • Batt's first Baghdad trip showed everyday normalcy, such as recreational tennis, shopping, and taxi rides, which contradicted the hell-on-earth image in the news, even though dysfunction existed.

    “two guys playing recreational tennis in the middle of the afternoon.”

  • Asking an Iraqi banker why taxi loans lacked vehicle collateral and hearing he was a cowboy revealed managerial risk, and the bank later blew up, which Batt took as a disqualifier.

    “And then he said to me, "But between you and me, I'm a bit of a cowboy."”

  • Visiting the country for the first time can produce overconfidence, but the trip is critical for testing whether the reality on the ground matches media or data, and Batt found it matched the data.

    “The danger is that you go to a place one time and you think you've got it all figured out”

  • Being the first American a company's CEO has met creates informational asymmetry, because others rely on television perception and ignore the local opportunity.

    “If I'm the first person from America this person has ever met, then things become extremely interesting.”

  • Opaque high-growth companies whose CEOs refuse to meet are not investable, because their reality cannot be verified.

    “How do you know if it's real or not?”

  • Early on, many Iraqi CEOs asked for CDs rather than discussing business, showing that some companies are hollow and must be filtered out.

    “instead of wanting to talk about their business, they'd ask you if you could send them CDs”

0.59

Owning honest, talented capital allocators drives transformational returns better than buying cheap assets.

7 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Owning a capital allocator who compounds at high returns, with a stock trading at 3 to 5 times earnings or free cash flow and growing 20 percent a year per share, is superior to classic Graham-style buying below liquidation value.

    “you can forget about this sort of old Ben Graham security analysis investment, where you're buying something at a discount to its liquidation value.”

  • Because banks are levered around 20 to one, a 5 percent asset mistake wipes out equity, so managerial skill matters most and a great bank is worth paying a slightly unreasonable price for, as Berkshire's Wells Fargo letter argued.

    “managerial skill is paramount because they make a 5% mistake with their assets, it wipes away your equity.”

  • Kobe Bryant once went out of his way to encourage Batt after a bad high school game, showing that unrequired kindness carries outsized value.

    “when you really don't have to do something to help someone else, but you do it anyway”

  • Transformational returns combine fundamental growth, which can be ten to twenty times in a decade for the best companies, with multiple expansion; even a move from four to ten times earnings plus profit growth yields a fantastic return.

    “Something goes from four-times earnings to 10-times earnings. And profits grow significantly along the way.”

  • After 11 years of relationships with management, Batt concentrates larger stakes in companies run by talented, honest entrepreneurs with bright futures, following the early Buffett pattern of 25 to 30 percent in one stock.

    “in the early days of his partnerships, he would have 25, 30% of his assets in one stock.”

  • Over five to ten years, the companies Batt owns could grow orders of magnitude in balance sheet, sales, and cash flow, making the multiple, which is unpredictable, the main open question.

    “the companies we own could be orders of magnitude larger than they are today”

  • Markets producing 3,000 to 5,000 percent returns typically include a lengthy period where nothing good happens and extreme political or economic volatility, pushing investors to question whether they made a terrible mistake.

    “what you typically find is that there's this lengthy period where sort of nothing good happens to your investment”

0.50

A stable countercyclical capital base lets managers buy depressed prices, unlike committee-bound institutions.

9 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Most funds are pro-cyclical: money flows in when performance is good and out when it is bad, so managers become forced sellers at the worst point in the cycle, similar to a margin call.

    “You become forced sellers. It's almost like a margin call.”

  • Batt treats his fund like a pre-FDIC bank, where the stability of the LP base determines whether the fund can survive and capture long-cycle returns.

    “I thought of the fund as a bank pre-FDIC, pre-Great Depression”

  • A countercyclical fund whose investors add after overreactions lets the manager buy when prices are depressed, which is the core advantage of Batt's structure.

    “if the market reacted in an exaggerated way, if it sold off more than was justified by the event, then they would be inclined to add”

  • Fund survival depends on adjacency risk: when a single seed investor holding half or more of a fund withdraws, all other LPs are steamrolled, so LPs should check who else is in the fund.

    “So you could have one LP that is half the fund, or more than half to fund it. That LP pulls, game over.”

  • Batt's LPs are sophisticated, often fund managers themselves, and they ask about adjacency risk, while the average LP probably would not think to.

    “I found that our LPs are very sophisticated people. They tend to be fund managers themselves.”

  • Investors who want frontier-market transformational returns must either invest on their own or find funds that refuse institutional money or take only a small share of AUM from institutions.

    “it's either they have to do it on their own, or find a fund that won't take institutional money”

  • High-net-worth family office investors have the agency to decide alone and do not fear looking foolish, making them better LPs than committee-driven institutions for contrarian frontier investing.

    “they were able to determine themselves without consulting anyone”

  • Institutional investment committees face asymmetric career risk: a successful contrarian bet like Iraq yields no reward, while a failed one can cost the committee member a job, so they avoid such ideas.

    “there's very little upside if it works”

  • Most funds are structured with reporting cycles and LP expectations of six months to a year, which makes it nearly impossible to hold through the long periods of nothing that transformational returns require.

    “I'm not sure that it's possible for funds to capture those types of returns given the constraints that they face.”

0.49

Transformational returns require holding through long stretches of nothing good happening.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Transformational returns come from historic equity re-ratings that can take 10 to 15 years to play out, and Japan's post-war bull market ran roughly 40 years with about a decade of no progress.

    “these sorts of historic equity re-ratings that produce these returns can take 10 to 15 years to generate those results”

  • After ISIS took Mosul and the market sold off, Batt's team explained the situation objectively to investors and received net inflows, because they showed ISIS capability was exaggerated and Baghdad and the oil south were not at risk.

    “we added net inflows into our fund after an event like that”

  • Holding through a decade of nothing good happening, amid political or economic turmoil, requires temperament, conviction, and analytical ability to separate fear from a thesis that still holds.

    “You have to be able to have the temperament, and the conviction, and the analytical ability to see through all of the fear and emotion”

0.45

Frontier equities trade at deep discounts and can re-rate as economies reform.

7 pointscentrality 3/5
  • When shops take payment in dollars rather than local currency, it is a bad sign for the local currency, while payment in local currency signals some confidence in it.

    “If they're paying in dollars, that's not necessarily a good sign.”

  • Places with decades of terrible experience produce entrepreneurs who are more resourceful out of necessity, and the best of them are as impressive as those found anywhere in the world.

    “the entrepreneurs there are in a way more resourceful out of necessity than they would be in a stable environment”

  • Iraq's mixed-owned enterprises, hybrids of state and private ownership, sometimes had market caps near 10 million dollars against 150 million dollars of land and traded at 0.1 to 0.2 times tangible book.

    “they maybe had market caps of like 10 million bucks and they had $150 million worth of land or something”

  • A local businessman bought Baghdad Soft Drinks' defaulting Pepsi loan, converted it to equity, took control, cut workforce from 3,000 to 1,000, and instituted performance pay, leading to Pepsi quality certification, tripled production, and first profit within a year.

    “So he bought the loan from Pepsi and converted it into equity. Took a controlling stake, fired management.”

  • Sberbank traded near 1 times earnings in 1999 and 20 to 24 times by 2007, as Russia moved from central planning to capitalism, with earnings growth contributing alongside the multiple expansion.

    “Sberbank, I believe in 1999 was trading at a P/E of about one.”

  • Iraq's biggest remaining obstacle to foreign money is the absence of a third-party custodian, so the exchange itself acts as custodian.

    “the key problem we face now is custody. They don't have a third-party custodian”

  • Iraqi stocks trade around four times legitimate earnings, and some banks yield 10 to 15 percent dividends while trading at one fifth of tangible book value, with liquid balance sheets.

    “banks that have anywhere from 10 to 15% dividend yields trading at a fifth of their tangible book value”

0.24

Iraq's matured exchange and settlement infrastructure is drawing foreign investors back.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Iraq's equity market capitalization grew from about 1.8 billion dollars in 2008 to roughly 5 to 6 billion dollars today, with trading expanded to five days a week and mobile telecom IPOs adding size.

    “the market cap is around five or 6 billion today.”

  • Foreign investors entered Iraq in 2013 during a rally, left abruptly when ISIS advanced, and are now slowly returning, including interest from an analyst at a major American bank.

    “the moment things went to hell with ISIS, they were gone, never to be seen again.”

  • In 2008 to 2009 the Iraqi exchange traded three days a week in short sessions on whiteboards, with 60 to 70 listed companies, about 20 suspended for missing annual reports, and only five to ten investible names.

    “There were maybe 60 or 70 companies listed, but maybe 20 of them were suspended from trading”

  • Iraq's exchange has no margin trading, no short selling, T+0 cash-based settlement, and no failed deliveries, with zero discrepancies in 11 years of daily custodian reports, so settlement risk is very low.

    “Since there's no margin trading, it's a completely cash-based market and settlements T+0. There's no short selling.”

0.21

Surviving crises reveals durability that makes countries and institutions more investable.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • A country that survives repeated crises, such as Iraq's civil war, ISIS, and an intact election, reveals underlying social durability, making it more investable than it looks from the outside.

    “the more battle-tested something is the more information you have about it.”

  • Democratic transitions take a long time and are violent, with no historical case lacking massive violence, so current Middle East turmoil may be a messy transition rather than permanent failure.

    “you can't point to a single one where there wasn't incredible violence on a massive scale.”

  • Institutions that survive crises intact, like JP Morgan during 2008 without needing TARP, earn reputations that make them the preferred holding, and Iraq's survival of crises is analogous.

    “It's like a bank going through 2008 not needing tarp money or something. Now you know, wow, this bank is incredibly durable and strong.”