What this covers

The conversation pairs Matt and Dom with Nathan Barry, founder of ConvertKit, and starts from a distinction: most social media is pull, so audiences must remember to check it, while email and RSS deliver content to them. From there it builds a Hub and Spoke Distribution model, with the email list as the controlled hub and algorithmic platforms like TikTok or Twitter as spokes. It also states a Discovery-Fidelity Tradeoff: the stronger a platform's recommendations, the weaker the bond with followers.

The email industry gets concrete treatment. Gmail accounts for about half of ConvertKit's opens, yet interactive features break in Apple Mail, Yahoo and Lotus Notes. Mailchimp's roughly $1 billion run rate dwarfs ConvertKit's $34 million. Nathan argues that platforms taking any paying customer, as Infusionsoft did, wreck deliverability. Programmatic ad systems like The Trade Desk suit email poorly because an email must fix one ad at send time. Matt forecasts Spotify turning its player into an interactive destination.

The later stretch covers running a creator business. Nathan describes a Content Flywheel in which every episode triggers a fixed process, treats timely and timeless as independent axes, and uses Format Over Host to explain why Business Breakdowns survives rotating hosts and why brand podcasts stall. He credits Deliberate Network Building through conferences and replies, including with Harley Finkelstein. He also defends public metrics, citing a 7 percent churn benchmark and his own salary-negotiation story, and admits he should have hired an executive search firm sooner.

Sharpest takeaway

Barry argues that email is the strongest push channel for creators, that durable growth comes from pairing an owned list with a discovery platform in a consistent flywheel, and that deliberate relationship-building and disciplined transparency matter more than one-off tactics.

  • Email gives creators direct, controllable push distribution, while discovery algorithms weaken follower relationships
  • Consistent, systematized content and promotion compounds over years, while one-off promotion does not
  • Conferences and guest-hosting build the personal network that drives creator growth

The argument · threads10 threads · 73 claims
0.85

Creators should own email as the core channel, with discovery platforms feeding new people into it.

11 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Email has gone through roughly three popular resurgences in the last decade, and the current wave is either at its peak or cooling into steady execution after Facebook shut down Bulletin and Twitter shut down Revue.

    “e-mails have like, I don't know, maybe three resurgences in popular media in the last 10 years”

  • Programmatic ad platforms like The Trade Desk do not work well for email because they decide ads at page load and may switch them mid-session, while an email sent to a list must fix one ad for all recipients at send time.

    “they want to decide on page load which ad, and they might even switch it out in the same viewing session, and you just can't do that in e-mail”

  • Arnold Schwarzenegger's daily email, Pump, was converted into a daily podcast read in an AI-generated version of his own voice that listeners struggle to distinguish from the real thing, illustrating how email content can be repurposed across formats.

    “He trained a model on his voice. You can't tell.”

  • Email is the best medium on the web for pushing content to readers because creators control who receives what, in what format, and can segment messages by membership status, so email will remain dominant until something supplants push delivery.

    “It's the best medium that exists today on the web for pushing content to readers”

  • Podcasts cannot be pushed to audiences the way email can, since creators cannot send breaking-news notifications, but podcasts deliver far higher-fidelity connection through voice, which makes the email-podcast tradeoff a matter of push control versus fidelity.

    “But the content itself is so much higher fidelity”

  • Gmail accounts for roughly 50 percent of ConvertKit's email opens, but interactive email features that work in Gmail do not work across Apple Mail, Yahoo, and legacy enterprise clients like Lotus Notes, making backward compatibility the hardest constraint.

    “Gmail is totally dominant, something like 50% of all e-mail opens”

  • RSS is a straightforward protocol with limited innovation potential, but dynamic content and ad insertion in email are underexplored, and personalized digests from a content library are about as advanced as RSS usage gets.

    “I haven't seen much there that's interesting. It's a pretty straightforward protocol.”

  • Most social media is pull-based, requiring consumers to remember to check for new content, whereas email and RSS are push channels that deliver content into the audience's inbox or feed.

    “there's basically two formats, push and pull”

  • Creators need two things: one place for direct push to fans with full control, which should be the email list at the hub, and one place with strong discovery algorithms, such as TikTok or Twitter, as spokes that bring new people in.

    “So I think of it as a hub and spoke. I put the e-mail list at the hub.”

  • A local newsletter with about 10,000 subscribers in Boise could feature a local coffee cart and produce its busiest weekend, showing how hyperlocal email distribution can drive offline business value.

    “it's 10,000 people in Boise on an e-mail list, and we're able to do a big feature on his coffee cart”

  • First-time founders focus on product, while second-time founders focus on distribution; Barry owns a 22,000-subscriber Boise newsletter as distribution he can use later.

    “first-time founders care about product, second-time founders care about distribution”

0.57

Conferences, guest appearances, and casual online interactions build networks that amplify reach and distribution.

11 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Every podcast guest should be asked which communities they belong to, and the creator should log those communities and pitch repurposed content to them, which grows audiences across niche groups.

    “what communities are you part of right now talking about similar things?”

  • The two best ways to build a creator network are conferences, where people meet offline, and hosting or guesting on podcasts, because these interactions lead to ongoing online relationships that later amplify posts.

    “the two best ways that I found to do it, assuming table stakes you're creating great content”

  • Hiring a speaking coach for every conference speaker, including first-time speakers, makes them deliver polished talks; Levi Allen's first talk was praised as if he were a seasoned speaker.

    “if you hire a speaking coach for someone, they'll crush a 20-minute talk”

  • The stronger a platform's discovery algorithm, the weaker the follower or fan relationship it produces, because algorithm-driven feeds show content to strangers and reduce how much content reaches existing subscribers.

    “Usually, the stronger the discovery algorithm is, the weaker the follower or fan relationship is”

  • Podcasts take years to build an audience, often producing only hundreds of downloads per episode early on, and brands tend to cancel shows because the cost per listen looks unjustifiable, while individual creators persist because they need less immediate return.

    “The first 3 years of the podcast maybe it's terrible, maybe it's getting 500 to 1,000 downloads an episode”

  • Small casual interactions with people online, such as a Shopify executive replying to tweets, accumulate into a network that shares posts, so a single published piece reaches far more people than it would alone.

    “it adds up to then when you write a post, someone thinks this is good, then a whole bunch of those Twitter friends are applying to it”

  • Pairing email with a podcast is difficult because podcasts lack a strong discovery algorithm, so podcasters must either be strong guests on other shows or drive traffic from YouTube, TikTok, Twitter or LinkedIn.

    “podcasts don't have a great discovery algorithm”

  • ConvertKit's Craft + Commerce conference in Boise is a costly customer-acquisition channel, but it generates intangible value, with 60 to 70 percent of attendees being ConvertKit customers and the rest prospects or creators.

    “I'd say about 60% to 70% of people who attend are ConvertKit customers”

  • Nathan's podcast exists primarily to meet people, and he argues a weekly interview show creates a flywheel of meeting interesting guests, which builds the creator friendships that later amplify posts and content.

    “It is entirely to meet people. It's a whole purpose.”

  • Barry selects side projects based on whether he is learning, whether he helps friends make money, and whether they involve offline work, which is why he runs Airbnb rentals with friends.

    “I'm really optimizing on those for am I learning? Am I helping friends make money? And am I doing something offline?”

  • Casual relationships built through conferences, guest appearances, and social media replies, such as with Shopify's Harley Finkelstein, gradually accumulate, so that when you publish, many of those contacts apply, respond, and share, making deliberate friend-making online essential.

    “it adds up to then when you write a post, someone thinks this is good, then a whole bunch of those Twitter friends are applying to it”

0.55

Creators should serve small, engaged audiences of operators rather than large casual audiences.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • ConvertKit deliberately grew in music and documentary filmmaking after acquiring FanBridge, bringing in roughly 1,000 to 1,200 musicians, to craft a creator-focused narrative and avoid direct-response marketers.

    “the acquisition of FanBridge was a great way to bring on 1,000 to 1,200 musicians”

  • Mailchimp is a roughly $1 billion run-rate company with about 30 percent market share, while ConvertKit's $34 million in annual revenue is only about 3.4 percent of Mailchimp's revenue, showing how small even fast-growing newsletter platforms remain relative to the broader email market.

    “we're $34 million a year in revenue. And so I have to remind our team like we've come a long ways, but we are at 3.4% of Mailchimp's revenue”

  • Creators should decide who their ideal listener is and value a small, engaged audience of operators over a large audience of beginners, since a few hundred deeply interested listeners can be more valuable than 50,000 casual ones.

    “I'm not going for 50,000 downloads of someone who's like, Okay, how do I make money in the Internet?”

  • Brand-driven podcasts usually stall because listeners connect with individual hosts rather than companies, and brands with higher budgets and polished production often fail to build the same creator-fan relationship that individuals do.

    “you usually don't connect to the host in the same way, and it usually stalls out”

  • ConvertKit uses no stock photos on its website, relying entirely on photos of creators using the product, and it produces documentaries and a book every two years as part of a storytelling flywheel.

    “there's not a single stock photo on the ConvertKit website”

0.44

Strong executive teams and disciplined measurement matter more than headcount growth for building companies.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Some brand investments such as conferences and documentaries cannot be measured cleanly, and trying to measure each one directly can kill them, so the team measures ticket rebuys and attendee energy instead.

    “if you try to measure them, you're going to kill them off”

  • A highly defined show format, such as Business Breakdowns, can make a brand show succeed even with rotating hosts because audiences follow the format rather than a single personality.

    “the format is king”

  • Culturally, companies talk about headcount growth more readily than revenue, so founders subconsciously optimize for hiring rather than profit, and many tech layoffs in 2023 reflect that misaligned metric.

    “subconsciously, you start optimizing not for revenue, not for profit, but for number of employees”

  • After a VP of Growth departed and Barry spent about five months trying to recruit internally, paying roughly $100,000 to $150,000 for an executive search firm produced candidates at the level he wanted, a decision he says he should have made on day one.

    “I should have just done that on day 1”

  • Hiring a speaking coach for 100 percent of conference speakers, including first-time speakers, lets unknown speakers deliver polished 20-to-40-minute talks, and ConvertKit deliberately mixes big-name keynotes with unknown creators who turn out to be strong.

    “we hire a speaking coach for 100% of our speakers.”

  • The biggest takeaway from the previous year is how important a strong executive team is, since being down a leader makes operations hard and founders tend to step into the gap themselves.

    “I think my biggest takeaway from last year is just how important a great executive team is.”

0.38

Durable growth comes from repeatable flywheels that keep producing archived, referenceable content.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Creators who do well often record more than their own show, using a third recording slot for appearances on other people's podcasts, and they book guest slots in advance by month to keep cross-promotion consistent.

    “they're very deliberately recording three times a week”

  • Podcasts built around archived, referenceable episodes, such as Business Breakdowns, keep generating value and referrals over time, while news-commentary shows that address current events have shorter shelf lives.

    “are you making a moment in time show or are you making something that people really refer back to”

  • The most durable creator strategy is to produce good content for years inside a repeatable flywheel where every episode triggers a fixed promotion, guest, clip and repurposing process, rather than one-off promotional bursts.

    “to do it in a flywheel where you're not doing one-off activities”

  • Timely and timeless are not opposite ends of one spectrum but two independent axes, so content can be both timely and timeless, timely but dated, or neither.

    “timely and timeless are not opposite ends of the spectrum. It's an X and Y axis”

0.27

Hype cycles and private-equity consolidation are reshaping the email and podcast markets.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Some operators repeatedly jump between hype trends, such as ICOs, NFTs and then AI newsletters, and the trends that get hyped often remain small relative to the overall market.

    “some people are really good at jumping between the trends”

  • Private equity owners of Campaign Monitor acquired Delivra, Sailthru, Emma and other email providers, and across this group of eight major providers Barry estimates revenue of $500 million to $600 million a year.

    “bought Campaign Monitor and then went through and bought Delivra and Sailthru and Emma”

  • Community funding rounds are a good idea but can damage reputations when companies raise large sums through them despite not needing the money, as in the case of a large community round after a $650 million raise.

    “The community round after the $650 million raise is not the best look”

  • Small email startups with high valuations relative to revenue are hard to acquire unless they stall, so consolidation tends to target firms whose growth has already slowed.

    “have such high valuations for their revenue. You can't really acquire them unless they truly stall out”

  • HubSpot is acquiring or buying rights to established podcasts rather than incubating new shows, a private-equity-style approach to podcasting, but it is unclear whether the shows it incubates perform as well as its acquisitions.

    “We're doing the private equity approach to podcast”

0.27

The creator economy boom has greatly expanded audiences, earnings, and ways to make a living.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • A successful professional creator a decade ago had roughly 10,000 to 20,000 email subscribers and earned $100,000 to $300,000 a year, while today an average successful creator has about 100,000 subscribers and earns $1 million to $3 million a year, so audience size and revenue are both about 10x higher.

    “audience sizes are about 10x what they were a decade ago and revenue is about 10x what it was a decade ago”

  • The creator economy boom has been very good for creators because it created more ways to earn a living, and platforms like TikTok were forced to start paying creators, although YouTube remains the only major platform paying meaningful ad revenue.

    “It's been very good for the creator economy. There's so many more ways to earn a living.”

  • Barry hopes investors do not feel burned by the creator economy and shift capital to traditional B2B software, because sound creator companies raising at sound valuations serve the ecosystem better than opportunistic investing.

    “What I hope doesn't happen is that investors feel burned on the creator economy wave”

  • There are better ways to monetize a creator platform than subscription revenue, such as advertising and sponsorship networks, and ConvertKit's north star is to pay creators as much as possible, with a new business section whose metrics it will not publish.

    “At the very highest level, there's better ways to monetize than subscription revenue.”

  • ConvertKit grew from $2,000 a month to $100,000 a month in twelve months after momentum took off, and Nathan says this was double the growth he had hoped for after reading Customer.io's founder account of going from $2,000 to $50,000 a month.

    “we went from $2,000 a month to $100,000 a month in 12 months.”

0.25

Platforms must selectively acquire customers and differentiate products to protect reputation and audience.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • ConvertKit lets creators edit a link's destination after an email is sent, because links are tracked through its server, a capability Barry says no competitor has copied despite fixing broken-link errors.

    “you can just go edit the link after the e-mail has been sent and change the destination”

  • Email platforms that accept any paying customer, like Infusionsoft, suffer spam complaints and declining deliverability that damage the entire platform's reputation, which is hard to reverse, so selective customer acquisition is necessary.

    “they ended up damaging the reputation of the entire platform. And it's really, really hard to ever get that back”

  • ConvertKit transcodes YouTube videos for email so Apple Mail users see playable video, while other clients receive a roughly 10-second GIF fallback that opens the video on click.

    “in Apple Mail, it'll play a full video. And then in others, it'll fall back to like a 10-second GIF”

  • A business cannot be built by avoiding a type of customer; it must define and move toward a positive target audience, such as educators, entertainers, podcasters, musicians, and filmmakers.

    “You can't build a business avoiding something. You have to go towards something else.”

0.22

Acquisitions and fundraising on fair economic terms serve the ecosystem better than opportunistic deals.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • ConvertKit raised $25 million from institutional investors and offered a $5 million community round on the same terms, justified by economics rather than a 30x revenue valuation that professional investors would not accept.

    “Here, we're raising $25 million from institutional investors, all the economics support it entirely. And here's a $5 million round as part of that”

  • ConvertKit acquired FanBridge, a music-focused email company that had stalled after raising VC funding, bringing roughly 1,000 to 1,200 musician customers, and it was a cash deal with an earnout that was not a huge acquisition but worked on revenue and brand.

    “the acquisition of FanBridge was a great way to bring on 1,000 to 1,200 musicians”

  • Nathan cold-called FanBridge, pretending to be a music manager, and got the general manager on the line immediately, which led to a conversation that helped him learn the business and eventually open acquisition talks.

    “I just said I was a music manager looking for e-mail stuff for perhaps some new artist.”

0.16

Sharing founder metrics helps others benchmark, though withholding some details can make sense.

6 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Shared founder numbers, such as monthly revenue and churn, let other founders benchmark their own situation, since without context advice like a product launch that did 'really well' is uninterpretable.

    “is really well $500, $5,000, $500,000? I don't know”

  • Public metric transparency works as marketing that can be used for a season, such as sharing a $10 million ARR milestone to earn podcast headlines, or as a mission-driven practice that helps other founders benchmark and make better decisions.

    “It's either marketing-driven or mission-driven. Transparency can be very effective marketing.”

  • ConvertKit is at $34 million a year in revenue and adds about $1 million in revenue every 60 days, with a goal to shorten that to every 55 days, and Barry argues this metric is better to publicize than headcount.

    “We're adding $1 million in revenue every 60 days. I'm trying to get that to, now we're doing it every 55.”

  • Nathan withholds details of new business lines because publicly calling a shot about a market shift lets competitors adapt, and he weighs the cost of announcing predictions against the benefit of changing the industry's expectations.

    “I don't think it's probably useful to telegraph that to competitors.”

  • A public real-time metrics dashboard lets a founder at around $20,000 in monthly revenue compare a 7 percent monthly churn against ConvertKit's own history, such as its June 2015 churn, which showed that the company was able to survive that level.

    “We're at 7% monthly churn, everyone's saying that our company is going to totally die”

  • Lack of salary transparency left Nathan unable to judge whether $40,000 or $60,000 was a fair offer for a design position early in his career, and it took someone telling him what to ask for to change his approach, which is why he shares data openly.

    “there's not transparency, and so you just don't know.”