What this covers

Making Media's mid-year roundup has three hosts, Web, Dom, and Matt, trading the interviews, books, films, profiles, and talks that stuck with them. Each pulls from different ground. Web leans toward film and media craft, Dom toward organizations and manufacturing, and Matt toward psychology and the odd detail about access.

The music and film material is the most quotable. From Rick Rubin's interview, Web takes that a producer is not the name on the record and must serve the artist, and that conventional wisdom breeds conceptual blindness. Matt cites Bruce Springsteen nearly being dropped after two albums, and Seinfeld needing three years to catch on. Web proposes watching films by asking how they got made, applying always invert to screenplays, and notes A24 told Hollywood Everything Everywhere All at Once cost $35 million when it cost $15 million. His claim that Roger Corman's B-movie system trained a generation of filmmakers, and that nothing replaces it today, is contested. So is his view that BlackBerry and the iPhone each had only a 10- to 15-year run. James Cameron's punishing standards get a mixed verdict, since staff leave and then return. Matt adds that "good job" may be the most damaging phrase in English, per a Whiplash discussion, and that a $200 tip to the maître d' at River Cafe bought a table.

Dom covers Taiwan's move from umbrellas to semiconductors at TSMC, chip fabrication at near-atomic scale, and the Skunk Works memoir. He also draws on Morgan Housel on producing alone and Bill Gurley on becoming indispensable to the people who matter. Web adds the J.Crew rise-and-debt story and a comparison of two profiles of power: the one of Bela Bajaria and the one of Chris Licht.

Sharpest takeaway

The hosts argue that the most transferable lessons from 2023 content come from the unglamorous mechanics behind creative work, such as producers serving artists, reverse-engineering how films get greenlit, persistence, and deal-making and access, rather than from the finished products themselves.

  • Jimmy Iovine, Wright Thompson, and Rick Rubin's interviews reveal how careers and craft actually work
  • Low-budget and IP-driven filmmaking reflects how the industry now decides what gets made
  • Behind-the-scenes accounts (restaurant access, the Skunk Works, TSMC manufacturing, Netflix's profile) show how organizations really operate

The argument · threads8 threads · 74 claims
0.63

Cameron's exacting standards and enormous financial bets push teams and budgets to their limits.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Cameron's relentless standards drove his teams to the limit, and when people left he told them they would come back to work for someone with less exacting standards, which they did within two years for True Lies and Titanic.

    “you all can leave, but you'll be back because you're going to work for someone who has less exacting expectations”

  • Making Avatar: The Way of Water required it to be one of the three or four biggest movies in history just to break even, showing how Cameron takes large financial bets.

    “You don't make Avatar 2 without knowing that it has to be one of the three or four biggest movies in history.”

  • Cameron used a microscope to check that the 3D version of Avatar lined up exactly, attending to details no audience would see, which reflects his perfectionism.

    “he had a microscope to look at the film to make sure that it all lined up exactly as planned”

  • Intense, exacting leaders like James Cameron push teams to a limit that produces exceptional work, but the same intensity can be harmful, and departing team members often return because nothing else demands as much.

    “you're going to work for someone who has less exacting expectations and desires, and you're going to want to be driven to the limit again.”

  • One scene in Terminator 2 cost as much as the entire first Terminator film.

    “I think it was Terminator 2, one scene cost as much as the entire first Terminator film.”

0.63

Obsessive craft devotion and serving the artist drive lasting creative work.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • A producer is not the name on the record; the artist is, so the producer has to be of service to the artist, a lesson Web thinks is being lost as producers grow more prominent in producer-driven mediums.

    “if you're a producer, you're not the name. The artist is, but you have to be of service to the artist.”

  • Creatives and businesspeople must remind themselves that conventional wisdom leads to conceptual blindness, a point Web took from Rick Rubin's interview, where the producer learned work ethic from the artist Bruce Springsteen.

    “conventional wisdom leads to conceptual blindness”

  • Whiplash, like Chazelle's other films, asks whether the pain and suffering of obsessive pursuit is worth it, and whether becoming obsessed with craft is a bad thing.

    “Is it worth all that pain and suffering and what drives us. And it's a great question.”

  • Jimmy Iovine's career lesson is to work hard and show up: even someone starting below the studio assistant becomes the new assistant by showing up on Saturday when others don't.

    “work hard and show up. You could be lower than the assistant at the studio. But if you show up on Saturday, you're the new assistant.”

  • Type A people obsessed with their crafts are central to modern culture, and whether that obsession is worth the pain is the question Whiplash asks without resolving.

    “Is it worth all that pain and suffering and what drives us.”

0.57

Reverse-engineering how creative work gets made is a way to learn craft.

7 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The Get Out screenplay is annotated with Jordan Peele's notes on what to reveal and when to avoid ruining the film, and Peele worked on it for about 10 years.

    “He was working on that for 10 years.”

  • Watching films and asking how they got made, using screenplays to reverse-engineer intent versus movie magic, applies Charlie Munger's 'always invert' axiom to film.

    “It's a great example of inverting -- now it's the Charlie Munger 'always invert' axiom”

  • Roger Corman's B-movie system let young filmmakers, including Coppola, Nicholson, Lucas, and Cameron, experiment on films, a kind of training that Web says is largely absent today.

    “We don't have that nowadays where people can really experiment at a young age and learn what their expertises are on film.”

  • Highlighting and holding physical books aids retention better than a Kindle for Web, so he does not take notes unless a project requires it.

    “But it's real best way for me to retain information.”

  • Rick Rubin's curious, open-ended questions, such as asking an actor about a middle school projector, elicit spontaneous and revealing answers that other interviewers miss.

    “Rick is a really curious guy. ... Rick brings a different perspective.”

  • Good podcasts treat the listener as a participant in a real conversation, mentioning names like Doug Morris without explaining them, rather than dumbing content down.

    “They're not dumbing it down. They're having a conversation. You are the listener, and I think that, that's important.”

  • Fake documentaries and mockumentary-style formats, shot with long lenses for a raw look, are having a moment, as seen in Nathan Fielder's Rehearsal and Jury Duty.

    “Fake documentaries, they're having a moment, too, with Nathan Fielder's Rehearsal or Jury Duty.”

0.45

Long-form profiles reveal leadership alignment versus ego, separating good PR from damaging coverage.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • A year-long, reported profile where the writer travels with the subject can make a person and company better understood, and avoids the feel of PR when the subject is granted candor.

    “this is one of the better examples of a year-long profile where it's reported out and the writer travelled with Bela everywhere. That makes someone better understood.”

  • The New Yorker profile of Bela Bajaria shows a company whose leadership is aligned and has been stable since Ted Sarandos joined in 2002 or 2003, in contrast to other profiles centered on ego.

    “Their leadership has, for the most part, been intact since Bela joined... Ted Sarandos has been there since 2003 or 2002.”

  • Reading the New Yorker's Bela Bajaria profile against The Atlantic's long Chris Licht profile illustrates the difference between good PR, which feels reported rather than promotional, and career-damaging profiles of power.

    “I think it's a difference of how do you get good PR versus bad PR, how do you get information out there while it not feeling biased or feeling like propaganda”

  • A company whose leaders remain aligned and avoid public sniping about predecessors projects a united front, which Web sees as the main difference between Netflix and profiles of more turbulent organizations.

    “And you don't see Bela Bajaria talking s*** about Cindy Holland. It's just a new era.”

0.40

Netflix's fast, global, scale-driven strategy sets it apart from other streamers.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Netflix made fast decisions after a major stock drop, launching an ad-supported tier in roughly eight months and changing its programming over the prior three years.

    “They launched in the span of like eight months an ad tier.”

  • Netflix is becoming a television company with a global, mass-market approach, different from HBO's creator-driven, point-of-view programming, and Web sees Netflix's reality-based strategy as smart scale-driven thinking.

    “They're becoming television and not necessarily HBO.”

  • Netflix is operating on a different level from other streamers in reach and its ability to make shows happen, going global and expanding into unscripted and regional content.

    “They're so far ahead of everyone else that it's shocking just to see the scale of it from the article.”

0.31

Cheap, original films and strategic misdirection can build careers and outperform blockbusters.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • A film made for $5 million or $10 million can make a career, as Get Out did for Jason Blum's Blumhouse model, which lets studios take cheap bets on original concepts.

    “it's something that you make that movie for $5 million or $10 million, and it makes your career.”

  • Everything Everywhere All at Once cost $15 million, but A24 told Hollywood for a year that it was $35 million, a deliberate misdirection that Web calls part of the genius of A24.

    “the movie cost $15 million, but they didn't say that. They told Hollywood for a year that it was $35 million.”

  • The $5.5 million BlackBerry film shows that economical filmmaking can work against blockbuster budgets like Killers of the Flower Moon's $200 million, and that awards matter more for careers than for a movie's success.

    “At $5.5 million, that's like nothing compared to Killers of the Flower Moon's $200 million. And it works.”

  • BlackBerry, a $5.5 million Canadian film by Matt Johnson, is a founder story that blends the intensity of The Social Network with the humor of The Office, examining how far founders will bend their principles.

    “BlackBerry is closer to The Office meets Social Network, made by a guy named Matt Johnson, who also acts in it, Canadian film”

0.31

Growth through capital and scale carries tradeoffs that can hurt companies and brands.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Restaurants decline because of bad service, not just fads, bad management, or bad ownership, a factor Web rarely thinks about but that often explains the decline.

    “normally, it's either fads, bad management, bad ownership. I rarely think about bad service. And a lot of times, that's what it is.”

  • Companies do not stay on top for long without continuous innovation, and both BlackBerry and the iPhone have had roughly 10- to 15-year runs, which makes a device's rise look more like a flash in the pan than a lasting superpower.

    “Companies don't last in power that long if they're not continuously innovating.”

  • Raising more money and scaling can hurt a brand, as J.Crew competed with Gap, which at one point had roughly four times J.Crew's retail footprint.

    “it's a story about evolution and what growth can do both from raising more money, but also how it can hurt”

  • J.Crew's story includes debt, selling 80% of the company, and shifting quarterly expectations, which show the tradeoffs of growth from raising capital and competing with larger retailers like Gap.

    “how it can hurt and competing with the Gaps of the world who, at one time, have 4x the amount of retail than J.Crew.”

0.13

Visionary founders and constructed origin myths give brands lasting identity.

3 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Barnes & Noble has improved by curating less around what is new and more around what people will understand or want to read, which is a more reader-oriented strategy.

    “Barnes & Noble has actually done an amazing job in the last couple of years curating less by what's new and more of what people might understand or might want to read.”

  • J.Crew's story shows a visionary founder creatively building a lifestyle image, turning a catalog business into a magazine-like brand and then scaling into retail, with the father handling business and the daughter the vision.

    “The father ran the business side of it and the daughter was a visionary.”

  • Myth building is central to companies and music, and it is a compelling part of how a brand's origin story is constructed, as seen in J.Crew's company name origin.

    “I love myth building. ... there's a lot of myth building going on, and I love it, whether it's in music or in company myth building.”