Best Books, Movies, and Podcasts of 2023
What this covers
Web, Matt and Dom work through a year-end list of books, films and podcasts, using each pick to ask what makes media or service worth someone's time. Two items anchor the discussion. One is a New Yorker profile of art dealer Larry Gagosian, praised for leaving readers to judge his methods. The other is Will Guidara's book on Unreasonable Hospitality, which traces Eleven Madison Park's climb from 46th place at the 50 Best ceremony to the top. Dom stresses that much of good hospitality costs little: listening, noticing, making a guest feel seen. Web adds that service is hard to quantify and is the first thing to fail without buy-in from the business side, investors and kitchen.
On film, Matt reads David Fincher's The Killer as dark satire of over-optimization, with Michael Fassbender's calm visuals set against his internal monologue. Web argues Netflix barely promotes Fincher's films, and credits Oppenheimer's propulsive score and heist-meets-horror pacing for making three hours feel like two. The podcast picks include Rick Rubin's show, which the speakers say works because of open questions and shared context. They also cover Hodinkee's Talking Watches and Blank Check's long Fincher series.
The most contested turn is marketing. Citing Rory Sutherland on Rubin's podcast, they call performance marketing Newtonian in a Darwinian world. Matt argues that demanding direct cause-and-effect lines discards most of the world's value. Art-market prices and William Morris's role as a talent factory serve as side evidence.
Web, Matt and Dom argue that the strongest media and business work of 2023 lets audiences decide for themselves and delivers value beyond what is measurable, while formula-driven, over-optimized marketing misses that value.
- The New Yorker profile of Gagosian works because it lets readers judge the conflicts of interest rather than telling them what to think
- Unreasonable Hospitality shows that service value is hard to quantify and depends on alignment across business, investors and staff
- Rory Sutherland and Rick Rubin argue that performance marketing cannot capture cause and effect in creative and human outcomes
Famous people discussing unrelated subjects reveal more than straight professional interviews do.
- Famous people discussing something unrelated to their known work produces more vulnerable and revealing content than straight interviews about their profession, so this genre is the favorite kind of podcast.
“this is probably my favorite genre of podcasting where you get famous people to talk about something totally different to what they're known for.”
- Hodinkee's Talking Watches format works because discussing objects of personal significance draws out stories about career inflection points, and this reveals how famous people think, beyond what they are known for.
“it descends more into a story about why they got this watch and at what point in their career were they”
- Talking Watches with Ed Sheeran and John Mayer may draw bigger numbers than Hodinkee's core shows, and a similar pattern appeared when Charlie Munger and John Collison drew Acquired's biggest audience.
“it's funny to see two people who aren't employed by Hodinkee will probably post the biggest numbers for their iconic show”
- Watching Ed Sheeran talk about why he bought certain watches at career inflection points, and why he would keep the cheapest one on a desert island, gave listeners a picture of him beyond his stage persona.
“you get more of a mental picture about this person who most of the time you see on stage singing”
Screen adaptations and film-year quality verdicts are more mixed than headlines suggest.
- Because All the Light We Cannot See revolves around radio, it engages audio-minded viewers in ways that visually driven war dramas do not.
“The other thing I'd say is that it all hinges on radio, which as an audio person, I enjoyed”
- Movie year quality claims must be qualified: the first half of 2023 was not universally good, so the strong run is mainly September through December plus July.
“It was not a universally good year for movies.”
- The Netflix series All the Light We Cannot See changes the book by having the two protagonists kiss, which they never do in the novel, and by ending on a happier note, reflecting what audiences value in a streaming adaptation.
“The boy and the girl, the main protagonists, they end up kissing but they never actually kissed in the book.”
- The Netflix series received very polarized ratings, with Rotten Tomatoes and IMDb disagreeing sharply on its quality.
“it's got a very polarizing views between Rotten Tomatoes and IMDB”
- All the Light We Cannot See was made as a four-part series rather than a movie so it could add more characters and stay truer to the book.
“doing it this way, enabled them to add in more people and be a bit more true to the book”
Good media and hospitality depend on respecting audience attention and understanding who is being served.
- Will Guidara's book Unreasonable Hospitality shows that pursuing the best possible result, even at unreasonable length, is what turned Eleven Madison Park into the world's best restaurant after a 46th-place finish at the 50 Best ceremony.
“we came 46th or something, and we just left almost in tears about how disappointing that was”
- Much of the value in excellent hospitality costs little money; it comes from listening, watching, understanding who you are serving, and offering something delightful that makes them feel seen, which most one-directional media fails to do.
“some of it is expensive, but it doesn't have to cost you a lot of money. Most of it is just listening and watching”
- Movies should be shorter, and the film industry should set a maximum runtime, since the best films compress their material into a tight length; the art is in the compression.
“I am on the side of the argument to say that movies should be short today”
- Long podcasts with slow starts are hard to grow and share, because listeners who do not get to the point within the first 15 to 20 minutes will tune out, as Dom experienced with the Marc Maron and Todd Field episode.
“It sounds like a very good example of why podcasts are difficult to grow and share”