What this covers
Bryan Barletta talks with Matt and Dom about why podcasting draws so little advertising money relative to its share of listening. The anchor is the gap between roughly $2 billion for podcasting and about $32 billion for YouTube. Much of the conversation is plumbing. The IAB podcast download standard is a guideline, so hosting platforms process the same raw data differently. Barletta wants an aggressively boring spec, so exact that any host given 30 days of data reports identical numbers. Buyers used to programmatic advertising struggle to purchase podcasts. Matt points out that measurement is shaky across media, and that walled gardens withhold data that can be compared.
The range widens from there. Barletta describes an iHeart player embedded in Subway Surfers ad breaks that counted several downloads per break, which he calls millions of dollars in defrauded spend. He advises buyers to scrutinize web player vs app inventory. On discovery, he argues charts are a trap and word of mouth does the real work. He cites Tom Webster's three listener tiers and suggests episode-level discovery through transcripts, YouTube, and newsletters. He also explains how a public feed paired with a paid bonus feed protects a show's chart ranking.
The forecasts diverge. Barletta says Spotify's acquisitions mattered most for sales teams and attribution technology. Dom raises Ben Thompson's aggregation argument but doubts that the players will align on standards, since a common standard won't help them equally. Bryan expects the big platforms to take podcasting in parts rather than rescue it. Dom predicts the word "podcasting" will fade within five to ten years as video proliferates. Matt adds a tension: standards grow the market, but shows should still sell bespoke sponsorships.
Barletta argues podcasting's ad-dollar gap stems from fragmented measurement and a lack of standards rather than a dying medium, so the industry must standardize download metrics and sell bespoke sponsorships, even as podcasting is likely absorbed into broader audio and video.
- Podcasting's roughly $2B in ad revenue is small next to YouTube's $32B, and buyers can't programmatically buy or reliably measure podcast audiences the way they buy display or social.
- IAB download guidelines are too loose: hosts report different numbers for the same downloads, so standardizing raw-data processing would build advertiser trust.
- Word of mouth and repeated recommendations drive listener growth more than platform discovery, and bespoke, niche sponsorships are where the most value is captured.
Advertisers need a strict, identical download standard before they can trust podcast numbers.
- Advertisers worried about fraud can insist on in-app podcast inventory, discard web plays, and examine the split between web and app plays; if around 20% of a show's downloads come from web players, that show may not be worth buying.
“an advertiser can easily defend themselves by insisting on app inventory or just looking for that split and figuring that if 20% of the show is not in an app, that might not be a show you want to be a part of.”
- The IAB download standard is currently a guideline that Barletta says must be made stricter, and he argues that a loose standard lets hosts report numbers with up to a 20% variance, which advertisers should not accept.
“There should be no reason that someone can't say I download and confidently believe it instead of saying, no, there could be up to a 20% variance.”
- Because the IAB download definition is a guideline rather than a specification, different hosting platforms process the same raw data differently and report different download numbers, creating discrepancies that undermine advertiser trust.
“We could standardize download by making it less of a guideline, which it is today, which creates a discrepancy between how one hosting platform and another track it”
- Barletta's goal is an IAB 3.0 spec so boring and exact that any hosting platform given 30 days of raw data produces identical download numbers, including standardized IP blocklists, user agent lookups, and core database columns, so that migrating hosts does not change reported downloads.
“I want any hosting platform to be able to take 30 days of raw data and get the same exact numbers out of it.”
- Podcast measurement is actually worse than social media influencer marketing, and the lack of a visual component plus uncertainty about audience size further discourages advertisers.
“In fact, measurement in that's actually worse than podcasting. Podcasting, just the lack of visual component is a big issue there and the believed size.”
- Once hosts all report identical numbers, they can compete on unique features; the only differentiator left is stricter filtering, which means a host selling fewer but more accurate downloads must justify why those are more valuable.
“If the thing you're selling is less downloads because you're more accurate, you got to back up why that's more valuable.”
Industry bodies like the IAB and Sounds Profitable must build podcasting's standards, scale, and buyer community.
- The IAB was built to serve industries worth around $20 billion, so podcasting at $2 billion gets less support, and Barletta's plan is to grow the industry enough that the IAB can serve it better.
“It's not awesome because IAB was built to deal with $20 billion industries.”
- The IAB was the first organization to agree to build a podcast standard, while MRC said no; Sounds Profitable has since joined the IAB as a member and Barletta is committing considerable time to its panels and committees.
“The IAB was the first organization that said yes to the podcast industry to build a standard. MRC actually said no.”
- Podcast Show London in May is the event Barletta says everyone should attend if they can only go to one, and Podcast Movement's two annual events are the next best options.
“Podcast Show London, I think if you could only go to one, right now it's where I feel everybody should go”
- Sounds Profitable operates as a research and advocacy firm functioning like a trade organization, fully owned by Barletta and Tom Webster with no outside investment, no equity or advisory board seats with companies, and no commission-based work.
“We both own the company fully. We have no outside investment. We don't take equity or advisory board seats with any company. We don't work on commission”
- Podcast industry events lack enough brand and agency buyers, so Sounds Profitable invites buy-side clients to free quarterly events attached to larger conferences, because the industry needs hundreds or thousands of them.
“There's not a great place today yet where the buy side, the brands and bigger-than-podcasting agencies are coming.”
- Sounds Profitable gets about 300 downloads per episode per month, and its newsletter has 8,000 readers, which Bryan argues is a meaningful number for a B2B audience of people in the podcast business.
“Sounds Profitable gets 300 downloads an episode per month, not a ton, but how many people are in the business of podcasting? Our newsletter gets 8,000 people”
- The industry needs something like a podcasting association in which half of each platform's advertising promotes podcasting as a whole and the other half promotes the platform's unique offering, since every platform is incentivized to grow only its own side.
“The best thing we could do is come up with something where it's like a podcasting association where when they advertise for half the ad is about growing podcasting.”
Podcasting's ad gap comes from pricing models, missing programmatic buying paths, and weak conversion of web clicks.
- YouTube earned about $32 billion in advertising last year while podcasting earned about $2 billion, a gap that shows how far podcasting lags in the advertising mix despite its large listening share.
“YouTube was $32 billion itself last year. Podcasting was $2 billion.”
- Selling podcasts bundled with newsletters, video, and social media at a fixed price, as Dear Media does, is a publisher benefit compared with CPM pricing per 1,000 downloads, which is an advertiser benefit, and bespoke sponsorship is what creates the most value.
“CPM advertisement per 1,000 downloads and a fixed price on that is an advertiser benefit. Sponsorship is the publisher benefit that's in your end.”
- Podcast technology is constrained by the same degradation of cookies and mobile device IDs that affects the web, and podcast apps do not collaborate with podcasts, so no single technical improvement can fix the advertising gap.
“It's like a website and a web browser. If all the websites in the world got together and told Chrome how to operate, Chrome might still not listen.”
- Programmatic ads that drive listeners from a web click to a podcast player convert only about 2% to 7% into long-term followers, which is acceptable as a form of audience acquisition if advertisers understand they are buying listens rather than followers.
“we're talking about 2% to 7% of those people then end up converting and being also followers of the show in sticking on long term.”
- Some podcasts with only thousands of listeners earn $0.5 million to $1 million a year because their niche audience is so valuable to specific advertisers, such as technology-focused B2B sponsors.
“There are a podcasts out there with a handful of listeners, thousands of listeners maybe that do $0.5 million to $1 million a year because the niche is so valuable.”
- Advertisers used to buying through programmatic platforms like The Trade Desk struggle to buy podcast ads the same way, because podcasting has no easy programmatic buying path and its measurement is harder, so agencies with thinner margins default to bigger channels.
“a lot of these people are looking to have their junior buyer go into Trade Desk, going on another solution and buy it all in the same way, measure it all the same way. Podcasting isn't quite there yet.”
- Advertisers buying from a single umbrella such as Spotify or SiriusXM get convenient reach from one source with one metric, but advertisers should buy across multiple sources and not trust one vendor's numbers.
“you shouldn't ever buy one channel just from one source. You can't trust that the numbers are the same today.”
Trusted endorsement and episode-level discovery, not marketing spend or charts, drive listener growth.
- Word of mouth from people someone follows or trusts is the most powerful way content is discovered across all media, and content that lacks such endorsement is effectively unseen.
“So word of mouth is the most powerful thing for all mediums.”
- A podcast recommended once by a spouse was ignored, but after two friends independently recommended it, the listener subscribed and binged the show, suggesting that repeated endorsement from trusted sources drives conversion.
“it was the second recommendation that got it. That matters.”
- Marketing can make even bad content get attention, but content that is not good and lacks the trust of its audience will not grow, and listeners who sample a show without staying become someone's fifth or sixth show.
“If your content is not good, and even bad content can be marketed well. But if your content is not good and you don't have the ear of the people and you can't get people riled up about it, it's not going to grow.”
- Listeners value podcasts that feel obscure and personal, and a show that is only slightly different from the mainstream can be loved more, because being an early fan of a niche show confers identity and advocacy.
“People love obscure. ... there's something just 10% different and everybody loves that one more.”
- Giving self-identified superfans enamel pins or similar identifiers creates visible signals that prompt others to ask what the group is, converting fans into ambassadors who generate word of mouth.
“Why not get them cool pins to put on their collars or something like that? ... Now it's word of mouth.”
- Discoverability is a trap: platform charts and recommendation pages are so long and impersonal that being placed on a list yields little, unlike bookstore or word-of-mouth discovery that depends on trusted people.
“Discoverability is a trap. Apple to comply with people pushing for discoverability, there's 700 pages you can scroll through.”
- Tom Webster describes three tiers of podcast listeners: people who come for the medium, people who come for a show, and people who come for a single episode, and episode-level discovery via transcripts, YouTube, blogs, and newsletters is a way to attract the third group.
“Tom Webster, he wrote about the idea that there are three tiers of podcast listeners.”
- Episode content that answers a searchable question, such as a how-to for a home repair, can be the endpoint that people rely on even if they never subscribe, and such resource episodes can become a show's most popular episode through sharing.
“if you can be the endpoint for that, that's a really powerful thing.”
Subscriptions should be accepted in-app and used to point listeners toward the creator's own platform.
- Offering subscriptions in-app through Apple Podcasts or a similar service removes friction for listeners, and podcasters should accept a subscription in the app even if they do not receive the subscriber's data, then point listeners toward their own platform with incentives.
“any service that offers a way to do it in app, you should do it because it removes friction.”
- Offering a public feed with all episodes and a paid feed containing only bonus content protects a show's public ranking, because subscribers listening through the private feed no longer count toward listed charts on Apple or Spotify, yet the show still earns from paying fans.
“By giving me that subscription feed and only putting the bonus content there, I don't have to subscribe or follow one show, subscribe to another.”
- Subscription payments will never be seamless across all podcast platforms and will not become a universal standard, because integrations benefit each platform differently and not all of them benefit equally from standardizing.
“It will never be seamless. ... it will never be a standard between all of them. It doesn't benefit all of them to do.”
- Barletta's family uses Amazon Music's ad-free availability for a kids' podcast, and he says subscribing through a platform can change listening habits and which app a listener uses.
“Then it was free with Amazon Music and so I switched over to that.”
Doom narratives ignore real podcast growth and the valuable sales and ad-tech assets Spotify acquired.
- Media coverage declaring podcasting doomed focuses on high-profile failures like Spotify's Hollywood-style purchases and executive departures, while ignoring that podcasting grew substantially and that Spotify also acquired valuable technology and sales teams.
“All we're hearing is Spotify let go of Dawn Ostroff, who came in with this Hollywood mindset, yes, that maybe didn't work exactly, but it grew podcasting substantially, and we don't talk about the technology.”
- The pandemic-era surge in podcast investment, sales, and listening, fueled by free time and zero-interest loans, was a temporary blip; companies that refused to bank on that extra growth are thriving now while those that extrapolated it are struggling.
“every company who's looked at that and said, cool, I know what it takes to run my business. I know what standard growth is and all this extra growth I'm going to put to the side and not bank on it, those companies are thriving right now.”
- Spotify's acquisitions of Megaphone, Whooshkaa, Podsights, and Chartable were valuable for their sales teams, ad technology, and attribution capabilities, which get less attention than the media properties it bought.
“Megaphone for the sales team, Whooshkaa for the technology, Podsights and Chartable for the attribution.”
- Spotify's acquired Megaphone sales team landed NPR as a seller of its inventory, though NPR still sells direct and requires ad creative in NPR voice rather than host voice, showing the sales team's business development strength.
“They landed NPR to sell their inventory. NPR is still selling it direct, but that's the second seat there.”
Podcasters should experiment across formats and tailor marketing to each show instead of following playbooks.
- There is no universal podcast marketing playbook because what works for one show does not transfer to another, so marketing advice should be tailored to each show.
“podcast marketing is unique to each show. The things that work on one show definitely don't work on the other.”
- Streamers should sell paid audio versions of cancelled serialized shows with the six-episode ending that fans never got, because fans would pay a small monthly fee to hear how the story concludes.
“Charge me $299 extra a month, give me a six-episode ending to every Garth Wood show that you've killed on Netflix as audio.”
- Podcasters should experiment across mediums and partners, because even a failed deal provides learning, and a monetization structure that works on paper should be tested rather than avoided.
“If some of these partners come and say, we have the opportunity to work with Audible and make it an audio book, do it, do it. Well, what's the worst that could happen?”
- Podcasters do not need to pay for expensive tools because no hosting or production platform will make a show famous; they should use whatever tools excite them and focus on the quality of the content.
“None of them are going to make you big and famous. None of them are going to immediately blow it up.”
The iHeart Subway Surfers scheme was a bad, narrow fraud case, not an industry-wide problem.
- iHeart has admitted the Subway Surfers ad-download scheme was carried out by a small group within its team, though Barletta still calls the episode bad for the space and a bad look for everyone.
“This specific example, iHeart has admitted that it was a small group on their team that did it.”
- iHeart placed a podcast player inside a web version of the mobile game Subway Surfers's ad breaks, where an episode began playing at about three seconds into 10-second ads, so each ad break counted as downloads for three or four ads, which Barletta says amounted to millions of dollars in defrauded spend.
“iHeart basically was buying a website player in there that was a podcast player that had an episode in each of those 10 seconds. The audio started playing around the three-second mark”
- Ad fraud in display, social, search, and video is staggeringly larger than the podcast fraud exposed by iHeart, so podcasting's problem is narrow rather than a rampant industry-wide issue.
“Fraud in other channels, in display, in social search, in video is staggeringly larger than that.”
Audio-first listening is being pulled away by video and by where listeners actually discover shows.
- Barletta does not want video in his audio app, argues that video pulls platforms away from audio-first use, and says that while Spotify should experiment, video moves it away from audio-first listening.
“So when video is on there, I don't know, I think that's a different flow. ... It moves you away from audio first.”
- In an Adopt-a-Listener day in New York run by Lauren Passell, Tink Media and Arielle Nissenblatt, people asked about their listening habits mostly named Spotify and YouTube, not Apple Podcasts, which the industry focuses on.
“And they said that most people talked about Spotify and YouTube. We in the industry think about Apple Podcasts”