What this covers

This is a conversation between Matthew Ball and the host that runs from the economic history of media to the practical obstacles to a metaverse. The history is concrete. In the 1930s and 1940s Americans went to theaters 40 to 70 times a year. Broadcast TV's dependence on advertising and scarce spectrum pushed content toward the lowest common denominator, while cable's direct charging allowed more variety. Ball also argues that consumers do not optimize their subscriptions, which makes incumbents more resilient, and he points to the studios that tried to copy Marvel, including Universal's failed Dark Universe.

The middle of the conversation is gaming. Outside China the industry has doubled since 2007, with 80% of that growth from mobile, where an extra minute of play costs almost nothing. Ball says games monetize poorly per hour compared with cable, and he forecasts that daily television time will fall from five and a half hours to roughly three and a half to four by 2030-2035. He is skeptical of cloud gaming, citing speed-of-light latency and rising per-hour costs. Strauss Zelnick and Phil Spencer are quoted saying it is far off. The Witcher's path from novel to game to Netflix series, and its effect on CD Projekt Red's stock, illustrates IP moving across media.

The last stretch is the metaverse, which Ball defines by Interoperability rather than by virtual worlds or VR. He compares it to the early internet and the hyperlink, and he expects a gradual arrival that Tim Sweeney puts decades away. Ball reads Epic's margin-cutting as a bet on TAM Expansion Over Margin. The Travis Scott concert shows the concurrency limits, and Ball's claim that Tencent is closest to the metaverse is contested.

Sharpest takeaway

Ball argues media competition has shifted from rivals within one category to IP that spans every medium, and that interactive, technology-driven platforms such as games and Epic's infrastructure-first strategy are where the next durable value will form.

  • Scale and engagement advantages (Netflix, Disney, Epic) compound and make rivals' catch-up difficult
  • Gaming grows by adding new segments rather than replacing old ones, and its technology drives content and business models
  • Interoperability, like the early internet, is the core requirement for the metaverse, and it will arrive gradually

The argument · threads10 threads · 83 claims
0.85

Audience attention is shifting from TV and film to gaming and mobile, which monetize it better.

11 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Children in the 1970s acted out Star Wars in backyards with no way for Lucasfilm to monetize that imagination, while today's most successful games hand over as much of the experience as possible to the audience, translating imagination into personal, shareable experiences.

    “there was nothing Disney, or at the time Lucasfilm... could do to access that imagination”

  • The battle for attention has moved from intra-category competition (biggest book, biggest film, biggest game) to a situation where the biggest IP is becoming present in every medium, because audiences want to engage with it everywhere and IP owners feel they must be everywhere defensively.

    “the battle between IP used to be intra-category... We are now seeing the point in which that biggest IP is becoming every medium”

  • The roughly 300 million Americans who spend five and a half hours per day on traditional long-form television will likely drop to about three and a half to four hours per day by 2030-2035, with most of the substitution going to interactive gaming and social media.

    “I don't think that in 2030, 2035 that's five and a half hours a day, I think it's probably three and a half to four hours”

  • Fans duplicate their story experience across mediums and want to experience the same franchise again with small variations, which explains the growing demand for immersive, ever-extending franchises, as shown by Game of Thrones selling 15 million copies before its show and 65 million in eight years afterward.

    “we truly want our stories to never end”

  • Since 2007 the global gaming industry, excluding China, has doubled, and 80% of that growth has come from mobile.

    “Since 2007, the gaming industry globally, excluding China, has doubled. 80% of that growth has been in mobile.”

  • Over a 15-year view, cinema changed little (the first Iron Man versus a 2019 Avengers or Spider-Man film), while gaming changed enormously in graphics, capability, and monetization, so anyone who has been away from gaming for three to five years faces large gaps in every element.

    “If you have taken the past three years, five years, certainly 15 years off in gaming”

  • By some reports, 50% of nine-to-twelve-year-olds in the United States, Canada, New Zealand, and Australia play Roblox or Minecraft, indicating that each generation adopts gaming more deeply and that media appetites grow as they age.

    “50% of nine to 12-year-olds in the United States and Canada, New Zealand, Australia, play Roblox or Minecraft alone”

  • Of the roughly 2.1 billion US leisure hours per day, 75% goes to television, 50% of television time is consumed by people 50 and older, and about 30% by people 65 and older, while the most TV-consumptive demographic plays the fewest video games.

    “the most consumptive demographic of television... is the one that plays the least video games”

  • Music reached 285 million Americans last year for an average of two and a half hours per day, and Spotify users listen an average of 130 minutes per day, making the platform an attention asset that can support many new products such as monetization through talent services, microtransactions, and podcasts.

    “285 million Americans, and for an average of two and a half hours per day”

  • Fortnite's Just Chatting mode lets players who cannot play, such as those driving or on a poor signal, listen in and participate in the social experience, which points to a wider industry push to reach mobile players on the go and bring them into the experience through audio.

    “Just Chatting allows you to listen into the game”

  • On an hourly basis video games monetize at a fraction of standard cable television, which is inconsistent with games' greater immersion, focus, and distractibility, and constitutes a major bullish argument for games on monetization alone.

    “video games are still monetizing at fractions of what even standard cable television is on an hourly basis”

0.69

Business model and technology innovation, not content alone, drive media disruption.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Broadcast TV cannot discriminate customers or charge directly, so it relies on advertising; scarce spectrum limits channels; and the resulting eyeballs business maximizes audience size, pushing content toward lowest common denominator, whereas cable's direct marginal costs enable price discrimination and content diversification.

    “The consequence of not price discriminating and not having competition is it becomes an eyeballs business.”

  • Massive innovation in business model or technology, not content alone, drives disruptive opportunity in media, as shown by Minecraft, Grand Theft Auto, and Fortnite, and by filmmaking, which changed mainly through business model innovation.

    “massive innovation on business model or on the technology, is what drives that disruptive opportunity”

  • Each platform shift from arcade to console, PC, and mobile reduced the cost of runtime and playtime, so that by mobile the cost of an extra minute of play is near zero, while business models moved from pay-per-play to subscriptions to free-to-play.

    “per usage cost of runtime of hardware is at zero. The per unit cost of playtime is at zero”

  • Gaming is outcome-driven, optimizing engagement, monetization, and desired player behaviors that can be tracked, while Hollywood is creative-driven, so gaming resembles YouTube and Facebook more than Disney or Warner Media.

    “The difference in gaming is gaming is actually not like the media industry. It has become more of outcome driven.”

  • All media industries are the product of technology, business model, and content, in which the technology usually comes first, shapes the business model, and drives content, as articulated by Yoichi Wada.

    “all media industries are a product of content, business model, and technology. The technology usually comes first”

0.60

Gaming IP can become the primary franchise engine across film, television, and other media.

7 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Netflix's ideal outcome is expansive new franchises, and a Stranger Things universe spanning games, interactive experiences, and consumer products would be a clear value add, though Netflix's new-IP success to date has been relatively lackluster.

    “I think it would be hard to imagine that the preferred outcome for Netflix is not to have expansive new franchises”

  • The Witcher novel first hit the New York Times bestseller list in 2015 alongside The Witcher 3 game and again in 2019 with the Netflix series; the series tripled the game's concurrent users, more than doubled its Twitch audience, and CD Projekt Red's stock rose roughly 40-50% on the renewed IP value.

    “led the game to triple its concurrent active users”

  • The MCU grew from 1.2 films per year to three per year while average cost per film fell because talent was contracted for multiple films, and the unit average haul rose about 50%, an outcome Ball argues is unprecedented in creative products.

    “the unit average haul has gone up 50%”

  • Gaming IP is becoming a primary contender because it is the only content category that can scale the depth, richness, and audience ownership needed to compete with franchises like the MCU, since film and TV cannot match the volume and immersion.

    “it is the only content category that can actually scale”

  • Marvel's rising output, planned to reach four films per year plus two to three television series by 2022 (about 40 weeks of content per year), makes the MCU a service that absorbs attention and forces competitors to find substitutes for 15 years of emotional attachment.

    “the Marvel Cinematic Universe will itself be a service”

  • Most studios that tried to copy the Marvel Cinematic Universe never got off the ground, roughly half were cancelled in pre-production, and Universal's Dark Universe was relaunched after Dracula Untold barely hit the box office, with The Mummy precasting five films that also failed.

    “half were cancelled in pre-production”

  • Hollywood misunderstands gaming because most studio CEOs formed their perception during the PlayStation 2 era, remembering games as pixelated, crude products like early Lara Croft, rather than the much more advanced medium it has become.

    “most of the CEOs, their primary exposure was in the PlayStation 2 generation”

0.57

Epic trades near-term margins for metaverse scale through its platform and publishing strategy.

11 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Epic charges a 5% royalty on Unreal Engine but effectively gives Unreal away: if all gaming (about $120 billion per year) used Unreal and sold through the Epic Store, Epic would earn only about $6 billion in royalties plus about $12 billion in store fees, and it net-credits licensees so Unreal is effectively free.

    “Epic actually gives you a net back on your Unreal license so you should be paying 12 plus 5%, but instead, you're just going to pay 12% and you get Unreal for free.”

  • Giving up near-term margins is a convexity play in which outcomes could be extreme and exponential in later years but worse than the current opportunity, and Ball has not seen another infrastructure company take this approach with such focus on TAM lift.

    “I've never seen one that is so focused on TAM lift.”

  • The hyperlink is the key design feature that made the internet thrive, letting people discover new sites, ideas, and writers through chains of linked references, because the internet was built as a shared network for sharing files across public universities and nonprofits.

    “The hyperlink is why you can start reading in the New York Times, end up following a rabbit hole”

  • Unreal Engine is today the most capable, diverse, realistic simulation toolkit available, having been built over about 25 years with a feedback loop from many gaming genres, and its simulation quality now exceeds bespoke tools in most other fields, which is why the US military uses it.

    “the world's most capable, diverse, realistic simulation software toolkit”

  • The metaverse will arrive gradually, with no before-and-after moment, and Epic CEO Tim Sweeney believes it is still decades away, because interoperability requires many companies to integrate and collaborate across device owners, ecosystems, rendering engines, and commerce.

    “there will never be this point where all of a sudden we say, 'This was before, and this is post metaverse.'”

  • Tim Sweeney is pursuing an infrastructure strategy that zeroes out margins across the stack, with revenue at 100% share capped near $12-13 billion, so the only rational explanation is a belief that he can dramatically expand the metaverse total addressable market, which he believes is worth trillions.

    “The only explanation is that he single-handedly believes he can crank the TAM up.”

  • Epic built Fortnite as an extensible, flexible R&D vehicle rather than a fixed game, which is why it could pivot quickly from a zombie defense PvE game to the PUBG-inspired Battle Royale format, while Call of Duty took two and a half to three years to launch its own Battle Royale because it lacks a shared game engine.

    “Fortnite was designed to be extensible, flexible and so when they started to have new formats emerge that might be a better fit, they rapidly pivoted”

  • Epic launched its store by updating the Fortnite app to be the store rather than launching a separate product, reaching tens of millions of devices within a day, and charging commissions 60-80% lower than iOS, PlayStation, and Valve.

    “within one day, Epic Games Store was launched on tens of millions of devices”

  • Epic Games Publishing's deal with Remedy Entertainment cut the publisher take from about 80% of revenue to about 50% until recoupment and let Remedy keep its IP, and Remedy's market value doubled within weeks despite no new game announcements, because its profit potential rose several-fold.

    “the company's value has doubled. They have not released any news”

  • Epic's publishing model argues content should be king, which unlocks value for investors who avoid hit-driven businesses but now see games as platforms with tech multiples, because better economics raise the odds of profitable outcomes for studios.

    “what Epic is basically saying is: content should be king”

  • Epic Online Services gives other developers matchmaking, cross-device deployment, social graph, leaderboards, data protection, and entitlement management for free, excluding server hosting, unlike Microsoft, Amazon, and Google, which charge for similar capabilities, and unlike Valve's Steam, which requires integration with its store.

    “Epic Online Services... Fortnite in a box”

0.41

Transmedia storytelling and live shared experiences are media's most important unexplored opportunity.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Transmedia storytelling, a cohesive narrative that spans every medium and eventually a persistent universe, is the most important unexplored idea for the next decade, illustrated by Pokemon Go, Star Wars' The Mandalorian, and planned DC and Marvel television, and may someday be realized as a persistent metaverse.

    “transmedia storytelling says that there is some cohesive narrative that goes everywhere with you”

  • Reality TV like The Bachelor and American Idol loses most of its value when binged, because suspense and social communal experience are the core value and require live timing, which is why no one has innovated reality TV for an on-demand era.

    “what you give up by bingeing The Bachelor, bingeing American Idol, is most of the value. It's the suspense, it's the social element.”

  • Good storytelling elements are well understood through Joseph Campbell's monomyth, which George Lucas, the Wachowskis, and J.R.R. Tolkien are said to have followed, though executing good characters and stories remains very hard.

    “Joseph Campbell wrote that in The Monomyth and The Hero of a Thousand Faces.”

  • HQ Trivia showed that a modern version of the $64,000 Question would be live rather than prerecorded, interactive rather than passive, and focused on the audience rather than the contestant, though it was technologically modest and the company could not find a sustainable model.

    “HQ Trivia basically proved three things”

  • Disney holds about 65% of the roughly 36-38 billion-dollar films of the past 15 years and succeeds where rivals failed (Peter Pan, Robin Hood, Jungle Book, Hercules) because it has both a superior storytelling skill set and the best ability to extract value through distribution, merchandise, and theme parks.

    “Disney has 65% of them. Most of which have been in the past three years.”

0.38

The metaverse is defined by interoperability of items, identity, and engines across platforms.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Today's virtual worlds like Call of Duty, Fortnite, Minecraft, and Facebook Horizon are like a mall where each store requires different identity cards, sizing schemas, and currencies, so friction blocks the economic activity that would otherwise flourish across shops.

    “it's a version of a mall where J Crew requires a different identity card to let you into the store”

  • The metaverse is not just a virtual world, UGC platform, avatar, VR, or app store; it is the core idea of extensive interoperability across virtual immersion and the real world, so that items and identity built in one place can be used in another, analogous to how the internet is defined by interconnected networks and standards.

    “the core idea of the metaverse is elements of more people in a virtual space... But the core idea is extensive interoperability”

  • Payment platforms and blockchain are the areas Ball most needs to understand, and he believes companies like American Express and Mastercard are unlikely to run metaverse payments, which will instead require whoever can manage data and entitlements.

    “you can virtually guarantee AmEX and MasterCard are probably not going to be running the payment systems of the Metaverse”

  • Hong Kong International Airport was built using Unity so that planners could simulate fire, storms, delays, and runway backlogs in design, showing game engines are used for serious simulation and foreshadowing metaverse interoperability as local shops and devices adopt the same engine.

    “The new Hong Kong International Airport was built in Unity”

0.30

Cloud gaming and persistent shared worlds face hard physical, cost, and scale limits.

6 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Achieving mass concurrency is a core metaverse technical barrier, illustrated by Fortnite's Travis Scott concert, where the technology could not reliably support more than 12.5 million simultaneous participants and the participant list had to be capped.

    “They had to cap that participant list at 12 and a half million, the technology could not take more reliably.”

  • Massive interactive live events (MILES) that combine large simultaneous participation with cloud-streamed simulation for collective experiences rather than competitive play represent a promising direction for cloud gaming, and Ball and Gavin Baker share a portfolio company working on them.

    “massive interactive live events," that are based on that premise”

  • Cloud gaming faces physical limits, not just engineering limits: fast-twitch first-person shooters cannot work when video must travel to servers 200 miles away, because the speed of light constrains round-trip latency.

    “it's actually not a question of technology or evolution or broadband availability, it's literal physics”

  • Maintaining a persistent, continuous shared simulation that connects private instances to the rest of the world is a hard technical problem for which blockchain and distributed computation may be the best application, since instanced games that reset are much easier.

    “blockchain and distributed computation actually might be the best application”

  • Because billions already can play free-to-play games like Fortnite, cloud delivery of those games does not expand the total addressable market, since no large audience would pay $15 per month to access remote hardware they already could reach for free.

    “cloud gaming doesn't make Fortnite cheaper... just having cloud-based delivery... doesn't actually expand the TAM”

  • Cloud gaming reverses the historical trend in which per-hour runtime cost falls toward zero, because it requires renting distant servers, expensive bandwidth, and real-time data transmission, so its costs rise per unit of play.

    “The cost of hardware runtime actually goes up enormously, because now you need to rent spot servers that are far away”

0.25

Gaming's market structure and funding concentration differ from other media industries.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Creating a new media business is easier than ever in capital and distribution friction, but app store saturation means very few people find even superb content, and Series A valuations are expensive while pre-seed and seed are underfunded.

    “there are more apps than ever before. It doesn't mean that anyone knows you exist”

  • Unlike music or video, where new formats replaced old ones (vinyl to CDs to downloads to streaming), gaming has grown like geological strata: arcade is still as large as ever, and each new platform (console, PC, mobile, live services) added segments without replacing prior ones.

    “It has added on top. We have not replaced prior segments. We have unlocked new segments.”

  • Tencent is the company closest to the metaverse today because its stakes, scale, social platforms, and regulatory position in China let it publish almost everything virtual there, while most Western publishers and Nintendo cannot operate in the market, and the West cannot match that position.

    “if you actually said, 'Who is closest to the metaverse today?' The simple answer is not Fortnite or Minecraft. It's actually Tencent.”

  • Gaming has three console platforms, two PC stores, two general-purpose mobile platforms, about ten Western AAA publishers worth $3-10 billion each, and two engines with under a third of the market share, which contrasts with the three record labels, three wireless carriers, and five major studios that dominate other media.

    “There's 10 Western AAA publishers worth 3 to 10 billion.”

0.22

Streaming incumbents' scale and consumer habits make them resilient against competitors.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • No competitor can reach Netflix-comparable scale within the relevant time horizon: Disney's five-year goal was 60-90 million subscribers, Netflix had 165 million globally when Disney+ launched, HBO leaked a 50 million target for 2022-23, and Peacock targets 35-50 million, so competitors would need to outgrow their own leaked ambitions by two times or more.

    “Netflix at the time Disney+ launched, had 90 million subscribers just outside of the United States, and 165 million globally”

  • Consumers do not rigorously optimize subscriptions or leisure spending; a rational user would cancel and resubscribe monthly, saving more than 10% of the fee, but people instead keep subscriptions and accept good-enough content, which makes incumbents' positions more resilient.

    “consumers aren't rigorously price or leisure optimizing”

  • Netflix's frequency of use and engagement lets it launch content to success more reliably than competitors; Tiger King would likely never have popped on HBO, Starz, Showtime, or CBS All Access because those services are opened less often and reach fewer subscribers.

    “Tiger King, had that been on Stars or Epics or Showtime, probably would never have popped”

0.19

Traditional long-form film formats keep their value even as theatrical distribution changes.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The two-hour narrative film is a durable format that audiences will keep valuing regardless of whether theatrical release survives, because longer or more expansive narratives do not necessarily add value.

    “People still like the two hour narrative”

  • In the 1930s and 1940s the average American went to theaters 40 to 70 times per year, with about a fifth of the population attending more than 100 times, because theaters served as the video, news, education, and entertainment source of the era.

    “the average American was going to the movie theaters 40 to 70 times per year”