The Past, Present & Future of ETFs
What this covers
Eric Balchunas walks the host through the history, mechanics, and open risks of the ETF industry. He begins with structure. Creation/redemption was adapted by Nate Most from commodity warehouse receipts. It lets holders swap shares for underlying baskets without a taxable event, which is why capital gains distributions are almost zero across ETF history. The exceptions are currency-hedged and frontier market funds. He also puts the industry's size in context: ETFs own about 7 percent of the stock market, passive in total about 16 to 17 percent, and active mutual fund assets grew more than ETF assets over eight years because market gains swamp flows.
The middle of the conversation covers the most contested ground. Balchunas calls smart beta active management repackaged into an index, and argues that stocks with no index representation tend to be poor performers, so active investors are leading the index. He warns that innocuously named products like USO carry roughly 30 percent annual roll costs. He treats Jack Bogle's critique of liquidity as the most valid criticism of ETFs, citing German data on heavier trading. Vanguard investors kept buying through October 2008. Other examples include equal-weighted theme ETFs as a legal performance-enhancing drug, ESG's press coverage outrunning its flows, and WisdomTree's DXJ as single ticker marketing.
Looking ahead, he expects factor-based bond ETFs to be harder to build than equity ones. He predicts alpha through beta products, with advisors becoming the new portfolio managers. He reads XIV as the visible tip of a much larger short-volatility trade. He urges active managers to put their best people forward publicly to shape the narrative. His closing priority is teaching investors to do nothing.
Balchunas argues ETF growth is driven by fee and structural advantages, with flows concentrating in the cheapest products and in performance-chasing 'shiny objects,' and that the biggest threat to investors is their own trading behavior rather than the ETF wrapper itself.
- Roughly 90% of flows go to products charging 20 basis points or less, while high-performing shiny objects attract assets regardless of fee
- Creation/redemption lets ETFs avoid capital gains distributions, but the structure's regulatory and behavioral risks are underappreciated
- Smart beta is repackaged active management, so the active/passive divide is less meaningful than fees and structure
ETF structure beats mutual funds and active managers on cost, tax, and transparency.
- ETFs were launched in 1993 by the American Stock Exchange, which was in third place behind NASDAQ and NYSE, mainly to generate exchange trading volume, and Barclays and iShares later turned them into retail asset-gathering products.
“that's really why the ETF was launched back in '93. They just wanted to get more trading on the exchange.”
- The five big ETF advantages are transparency, price, fees, tax efficiency, and liquidity, and the tax feature alone can be enough to move an investor out of mutual funds.
“That one feature alone is almost enough to move someone out of the other structure.”
- For plain beta products, fee is the main differentiator, since new entrants mostly try to undercut Vanguard.
“On the beta side, I think a lot of it just comes down to fee because all the new beta products coming out, the only thing they're really doing is just trying to undercut or Vanguard the next person.”
- In 2008 only about a third of active managers outperformed, and there will be no magic bullet for active equity managers who sidestep crashes by moving to cash, because it is hard to predict the future.
“In 2008, about, only about a third of them outperformed in other words, the same as always.”
- Stocks with no passive index representation, often new IPOs or stocks that have fallen out of indexes, have been awful performers, so avoiding the passive bubble by owning them would hurt investors.
“we've looked at stocks that have literally no representation in passive indexes and they're awful.”
Public narrative and communication shape asset flows, so active managers must engage publicly.
- MOO is the best ETF ticker because it is a verb and a synecdoche, friendly and self-explanatory, so it represents the whole agribusiness category in a single word.
“So to me the Mona Lisa of ETF tickers... is MOO.”
- ESG receives the most positive press relative to its flows, the widest media-to-flow ratio Eric has seen, while iShares Russell 1000 Growth gets almost no coverage despite about 45 billion dollars.
“ESG has the widest ratio ever on the flip side is something like the, iShares Russell 1000 growth.”
- Learning the technology, such as operating a video camera, gets younger people into bigger meetings because senior people often cannot use it as well.
“if you can just learn the technology, you'll probably get into bigger and better meetings because the old guys can't use it as well.”
- Narratives get stuck and can move assets, so active managers losing outflows should have their best people engage publicly, since thought leaders influenced by connectors can shift the narrative and keep investors from switching to cheaper funds.
“The narratives get stuck and they're hard to break and the assets can follow the narratives, it's real.”
- The PR triangle method puts the main message at the center of a triangle, with supporting attributes on each side and sub-points beneath, and always ends statements by tying back to the central message, making it useful for job interviews and crises.
“this triangle method where you draw a triangle and the middle, you put your main message”
Active and hedge strategies keep room through exclusivity, active share, and star managers.
- When evaluating smart beta, first check the original exposure and active share versus a plain cap-weighted fund like XLK, then check correlation, standard deviation, and the weighting methodology, since equal weighting acts as a legal performance enhancing drug.
“the first thing I look at is what's the original exposure, how much active shares we say we get”
- Hedge funds sell exclusivity, which institutions value and ETFs cannot offer, so there will always be room for hedge funds even as ETFs democratize the strategies.
“An ETF is like the public pool down the street. And there's just always going to be big investors who just do not want that.”
- If AQR converts its market neutral mutual fund into an ETF, the star power could make the market neutral category pop.
“AQR to me is fascinating... if AQR converts their market neutral mutual fund”
- Companies like Amazon, Tesla, and Google are hard to assign to one sector, so Cathie Wood's approach of picking innovation regardless of sector made sense, though it concentrated her portfolio in FAANG and high-flying names.
“companies like Amazon and Tesla and Google, it's really difficult to peg which sector they're actually in.”
New ETFs like Bitcoin should launch now and let investors test real-world resilience.
- Regulators should approve a Bitcoin ETF now using a launch-and-learn approach, because waiting for Bitcoin to be perfect could make the product pointless by the time it is approved.
“I just think it's almost a launch and learn type situation. If you wait until Bitcoins perfect before approving one, it might just be pointless”
- ETFs do not need more testing; investors do, because ETFs are used by many market participants, and allocators' use of core products held up in Q1 2018 volatility, but whether investors can hold through a 2008-style crisis is still unknown.
“it's not ETFs that need testing... It's investors an ETF investors that need the testing.”