What this covers
This is a founder's conversation that moves between two businesses: Lob, which turns direct mail into something a developer can call through an API, and Alt, which prices and trades sports cards. The Lob material is practical. Early on the founders printed and mailed by hand from an apartment so they would feel the problems firsthand. Lob later split a technology license from commoditized print and postage, which put its commodity price at 42 cents against the USPS 45-cent rate. Its routing engine weighs color, destination, content and printer capacity before sending each job to a partner printer, usually the one nearest the recipient. There is also a defense of USPS during the 2020 election: ballots are under one percent of daily volume, and Lob's data showed no delays.
The collectibles half is where the argument turns speculative. Raw eBay sold data is distorted by bid inflation and canceled sales, so Alt prices cards by triangulating from verified transactions and keeps its own index, comparable to the S&P 500. From there the speaker predicts that collectibles will be a standard retirement-portfolio holding within five to seven years, that DCF-style valuation can apply to culture assets such as the Mona Lisa, and that eBay's roughly 10 percent fees will fall below 2 percent within a year. Several of these forecasts are contested or fringe.
Along the way come shorter detours: negotiation, where scarcity beats leverage for unique items but reputation outweighs any single win; judging investors by Sharpe ratio and process rather than outcomes; and retaining employees through personal as well as career goals.
Avidar argues that APIs succeed by selling time-saving 'superpowers' to developers, that physical-world operations can be made programmable behind a black box, and that collectibles are becoming a financial asset class once verified pricing and liquidity infrastructure exists.
- APIs hide manual physical workflows (printing, inserting, mailing) behind code, so customers buy time saved
- Verified transaction data makes collectibles priceable, which allows insurance, liquidity, and fund products
- Transaction costs in collectibles will collapse as competitors multiply, pushing toward open infrastructure
Collectibles are maturing into a large, liquid, mainstream financial asset class.
- Every generation has a set of culturally representative assets that people collect, and today's collectibles are the next generation's culture, so buyers pay to own a piece of the culture they grew up with.
“I do think that these cards or these collectables are the next generation's culture. So everyone wants a piece of their culture”
- Owners of appreciated collectibles want liquidity without giving up possession, so a financial mechanism that lets them borrow or monetize holdings while keeping physical possession would meet a real market need.
“people want to get liquidity but they don't want to give up possession.”
- The five alternative asset categories Avidar listed (sports cards, trading cards, shoes, watches, art, domain names and similar) total more than $160 billion, with some markets doubling year over year, excluding antique cars and furniture.
“If we just talk about the five that I just mentioned it's $160 billion plus, and some of these markets are doubling year over year right now”
- Sports cards are the most direct way to invest in a specific player's upside, and as gambling on sports becomes more commercialized and legal, cards offer an alternative way to get exposure to players.
“The sports card is the most direct way of actually investing on the upside of a specific player.”
- Collectibles are turning into a financial asset in the same way the stock market in the 1970s and 1980s, FX, and cryptocurrency each became financial assets, and this shift is expected to continue.
“I really believe that this collectibles industry is going to start turning into a financial asset.”
- The sports card industry is centered on true hobbyists who collected as kids, and over time hybrid buyers who see both hobby and investment value have entered, bringing institutional money and fund structures.
“It started with true hobbyists... Over time you're starting to get these hybrid people in who are thinking about it both from like a hobby perspective and for making money.”
- Many companies are fundraising to build in the collectibles space, and those without a niche will compete in a way that drives transaction prices down, which Avidar considers a good outcome for liquidity.
“if people need to find their niche, otherwise they're going to be competing in a space that basically is going to drive transaction prices down, and we want that.”
- Transaction costs on eBay for collectibles are about 10 percent today, and Avidar predicts they will fall to under 2 percent or zero within a year, as competition drives transaction costs down.
“for example, if you buy things on eBay, it's 10%. ... I will put a prediction that in a year from now it will be less than 2% if not zero.”
- Trading cards and video games will experience explosive growth as collectibles because of nostalgia, and sealed original cartridges show how an item's history of non-use adds to its story and value.
“I think trading cards in general are all going to experience explosive growth. I think video games, again, the nostalgia factor.”
- For something to be a true collectible it must be standardized so that people can assemble sets and compete to complete them, which is why video game cartridges and similar items can become investable collectibles while highly unique items cannot.
“For something to be collectible there has to be this standardization of what that collectible is, because if it's so unique, then it's really hard to put in a collection together”
- Within five to seven years, collectibles will be treated as a pure asset class alongside equities, bonds, and real estate in retirement portfolios, becoming a staple exposure for most investors.
“I think people are going to start thinking about it as real estate, a pure asset class.”
- Buying the LeBron James card is comparable to buying Apple stock to gain tech market exposure, because it is an investment thesis about the card market as a whole, not just one item.
“it's basically buying the Apple if you're thinking you want to have market exposure to tech.”
- Alt's goal is to increase the transparency and liquidity of alternative assets by becoming a central repository where collectors manage a full alternative portfolio, including insurance, valuation, vaulting, and financing.
“Alt has a very succinct vision of increasing the transparency and liquidity of these alternative assets.”
- Alt's fund pursues two strategies: buying cards whose prices are undervalued according to its valuation, and building diversified market portfolios across many players so it benefits whichever players win MVP or Super Bowl titles, rather than betting on individual players.
“We're less taking bets on specific players and setting up a portfolio based on a system of bets”
Software and API infrastructure, rather than headcount, make companies and developers most valuable.
- Lob has a direct partnership with USPS that lets it extract metadata as each piece moves through the postal system, giving the same kind of tracking insight as a package shipment.
“we have a direct partnership with USPS that allows us to extract metadata as that piece of mail goes throughout the system”
- An API does two things for a developer: it helps them solve business problems faster, which accelerates their career, and it saves time, which lets them spend more time with friends and family; time savings is the superpower being sold.
“So for a developer an API can help them solve business problems faster... So that value prop, saving time, is the superpower.”
- Direct mail was not data-driven in 2013, so Lob had to build the infrastructure that lets marketers treat physical mail like any digital channel with measurable data.
“direct mail was not data driven in 2013. So we had to build all the infrastructure so that people can actually think about this channel just like they do any digital channel.”
- An API works like a black box: the input is content in HTML plus an address, the black box handles all the physical production and delivery, and the output is a physical mail piece in a mailbox, so the customer does not need to care about the intermediate steps.
“There is an input and an output. So the input that we take, we take content in the form of HTML and an address. The black box does everything that you need and then the output is that a physical mail piece actually ends up in a mailbox.”
- USPS delivers well over 100 million pieces of mail every day, so ballot volume in the 2020 election is less than one percent of typical daily volume, and Lob and Shippo data showed no delivery delays.
“It's in way excess of 100 million. ... The ballots is less than a percent of the typical volume.”
- Lob's routing engine takes each API request, weighs dimensions such as color, destination, content type, and printer capacity, and routes the job to a partner printer, generally the one closest to the destination to optimize speed.
“Was it black and white? Where is it going? What kind of content? Is there capacity at which one of our printers? And we basically figure out who gets that letter.”
- Developers are finally becoming a front office of companies rather than back-office or IT, because APIs make them the people who directly deliver business capability.
“Developers are finally going to be a front office of a company as opposed to what was considered back office or IT.”
- The most valuable things to automate are tedious, high-frequency back-office workflows, because once automated they stop requiring any mindshare and simply happen.
“I like the boring things, the things that no one thinks about that just takes up a lot of time... when you automate it you'll never really think about it again.”
- A technology company is one that solves problems with software first rather than with people, so an operation that adds headcount to solve problems is not a technology company, and Alt's team skews toward product engineering and data science.
“technology companies solve problems with software first. A non technology company solves it generally with people.”
- The next trillion-dollar company, within ten years, will be an API or infrastructure company.
“I believe the next trillion-dollar company in 10 years will be an API company, will be an infrastructure company.”
- Over the next five years the API industry will consolidate as more companies go public, because companies with signed MSAs and trusted documentation and support become distribution channels they can extend by buying smaller assets with large cash balances.
“There's going to be consolidation over the next five years as more of these companies go public. Once you have the MSA signed people trust your API documentation”
Alt solves collectors' core problems by building trust and open infrastructure for others.
- Collectors currently track holdings in Excel, struggle to insure physical collectibles because no one is recognized as an expert appraiser, and cannot raise liquidity without giving up possession, and Alt is built to solve all three.
“Alt is solving three core pain points. One is that everyone keeps track of all their collectibles in Excel.”
- Alt bought one of the most expensive basketball cards ever, a LeBron James card, and stored it in its vault next to customers' cards to show it has skin in the game and is a trustworthy custodian.
“We went out and bought the most expensive card in basketball history, and we put it into our vault and we said, 'Hey, your cards are right next to our LeBron James card in our vault.'”
- Alt intends to be an open platform that provides infrastructure for other collectibles companies rather than competing as an exchange, and it wants to integrate with securitization players like Rally and art platforms like Masterworks.
“Alt our goal is to not be an exchange. We want to be an open platform, so we're providing the infrastructure that allows all these other companies to succeed.”
- After running into the same headaches as a collector, Avidar decided that a problem worth solving for himself should be solved for everyone, the same approach he used at Lob.
“why just solve the headache for yourself, why not solve it for everybody so that no one has this headache ever again?”
Lob grew through iterated pricing and product changes, programmable tooling, and unexpected large deals.
- Lob's original all-in-one pricing made it look more expensive than USPS's 45-cent rate, so separating a license for the technology from the commoditized print and postage made Lob's commodity price (42 cents) lower while keeping value-added services as the differentiator.
“So the next variant of our pricing model is we actually separated it out... they see that we are charging 42 cents, so we're actually cheaper on the commoditized products”
- Pricing always involves a dichotomy between simple pricing that customers like and pricing that creates a sustainable business, and the right answer is found by iterating between the two.
“There's always a dichotomy. My big thing is I like simple pricing and I want to price it in a way that customers really like, and then I also want to price it in a way that's going to create a sustainable business.”
- Requiring customers to commit and pay upfront for all planned mailings felt like a loss to them when volume went unused, similar to expiring phone minutes, so Lob moved to upfront license fees plus end-of-month usage billing, which better matches customers' pay-as-you-go expectations.
“It's almost like back in the day about these rollover minutes... So we said, 'Okay, we're going to keep the license fee paid upfront'”
- Lob's first big break came when Benefitter sent an API request for 30,000 mailings that exceeded what the founders could print in their SLA, forcing them to partner with a print shop and learn insertion machines, which allowed them to fulfill the order within a weekend.
“They sent in an API request for 30,000. So this was our first big break because it was the first time that we couldn't print as much and get it out within our SLA.”
- Lob's engagement with Ubiquiti Networks, a public company it initially did not realize was public, became its first large enterprise deal and led to a formal enterprise offering and a shift toward enterprise sales.
“That was our first really big deal. We had worked with a guy named JT back then, and really kind of created our first enterprise offering.”
- The founders' original goal was not to build a company but to sell an automation tool to Microsoft for about $8,000 so they could go back to playing video games, and they only later realized that everyone had the same problem.
“we could sell it to Microsoft for $8,000 and then we can start playing video games. That was the goal, it wasn't build a company around it.”
- Lob originated when a co-founder's Microsoft direct-mail campaigns took 60 to 90 days because of cumbersome partner management, and the speaker, who had used Amazon's API to send a million emails with a Python script, realized the market lacked a programmable direct-mail tool.
“You guys are Microsoft, how do you guys not have a tool that sends out direct mail at scale?”
- Lob does not own printing; it builds software that runs on commercial printers, such as HP Indigo presses and iGens, and partners with printers that are experts in manufacturing printed mail.
“They are experts in basically the manufacturing of printed mail, and we are the experts at software.”
- Lob has gone through four distinct pricing models, reflecting that early pricing must be launched and then iterated based on customer feedback.
“For example, at Lob we've had four different business models on pricing.”
- Lob applies the same model as Stripe, hiding complex work behind a simple code interface, but for physical mail rather than payments.
“So sort of like Stripe is hiding all sorts of hard, complex work behind a simple front end of code. You're doing the same but for physical mail.”
Strong people, partnerships, culture, and authenticity drive execution and retention.
- The hard part of building a physical-world business was not the physical operations themselves but the founders' lack of print experience, which required open-minded learning about manufacturing intricacies.
“The physical world part hasn't always been tough. It's more about understanding it. Had no print experience beforehand.”
- Renaming external suppliers from 'vendors', which implied transactional and replaceable relationships, to 'partners' shifted the company's mindset, because partners are equally important to success and the company moved faster once it saw itself as in business together.
“The word vendor was they work for us, it was very transactional, and then when we shifted it to partner it really shifted our entire mindset as a company”
- Lob's culture rests on three pillars: every employee should feel impact and connect to the mission, employees should be their authentic selves, and companies must invest in both professional and personal goals since modern employees want more than transactional pay.
“A company who can invest in an employee, help them build a career but also help them kind of grow their skillset or help them define what happiness means outside of work is ultimately going to allow people to keep employees much longer”
- Operating Lob and Alt simultaneously lets Avidar maximize learnings twice as fast, and it forces him to delegate well and hire people who are the right fit.
“I feel like I'm maximizing learnings but twice as fast right now, kind of operate both businesses. I've learned how to be very disciplined on my time, be really good at delegating and trusting others.”
- Avidar wants Lob to reach IPO readiness by 2024 and plans to pursue M&A and financial engineering as it scales.
“I want to get Lob to an IPO state by 2024. So as that gets bigger I'd love being able to buy companies, maybe do some things through M&A”
- Avidar has hired a strong management team to run Lob day-to-day, so he can focus on vision and on Alt, while still doing some investment committee work for decompression.
“I've actually hired a really strong management team that runs day-to-day. So this is for me I'm just kind of shaping the vision.”
- The kindest thing someone did for Avidar was telling him early in life that people would appreciate him for both strengths and weaknesses, which gave him confidence to be authentic.
“someone telling me that people will appreciate me for both my strengths and weaknesses, and just accepting myself for who I am”
- Retention in a competitive Bay Area market depends on giving every employee, regardless of tenure, a real sense of impact and a clear line from their work to the company mission.
“So I want every person, no matter how tenured they are, to always have that feeling of impact.”
- Employees do their best work when they can be their authentic selves at work, because not having to maintain a facade removes mental overload.
“you don't want that mental overload of trying to be somebody that you're not.”
- Modern employees seek both professional and personal goals from work, so companies keep people longer by investing in both career development and fulfillment outside work, unlike the purely transactional trade of a decade ago.
“I think these days the modern employee is coming with professional goals but also personal goals, and it's the company's job to actually make sure that they excel at both of them.”
Negotiation leverage comes from practice, reputation, scarcity, and framing that shape deal outcomes.
- Yelling and screaming in negotiation does not yield the best outcome, and being a kind negotiator can achieve higher outcomes, based on many negotiation reps and recorded results.
“I learned really early on from all these at bats that yelling and screaming does not yield the best outcome. Actually being a really kind person in the negotiation can actually yield higher outcomes.”
- Buying and selling on eBay every day gives a person many small negotiation 'at bats', and these reps translated into skills for running real business negotiations.
“So one of the things I do every single day is I buy and sell stuff on eBay. I call these the at bats.”
- When negotiators need to win at the other side's expense, they hurt their reputation, which reduces future deal flow, so a long-term, holistic view of reputation across negotiations beats optimizing a single short-term win.
“you got to think about negotiation as the long term. So you may have gotten one short-term win, but you lost out on everything else because your reputation for negotiating makes it so that no deals come your way.”
- In collectibles, scarcity is a stronger source of negotiating power than leverage, because when only one unique item exists, a buyer who walks away from a deal may pay about double later, since the seller knows there is no substitute.
“If there's only one thing in the world, if you miss out, you're going to start paying for it massively later on. So I think scarcity even trumps leverage to be quite honest.”
- Leverage in negotiation comes from having a strong best alternative to the deal, since that gives optionality and the ability to walk away, and time pressure generally translates into a loss of leverage.
“If you have leverage you'll always have the upper hand because your best alternative to negotiating antics is always going to be stronger, because you can just walk away”
- Avidar's weakness is marketing, which he sees as undervalued, and he believes that how a product is articulated and language choices can change the dynamics of a product.
“I love product marketing, how language and literally articulating something can change the dynamic of a product.”
Verified transaction data and comparable-based triangulation make collectible pricing accurate.
- Alt partners with exchanges to verify transactions, building what he calls the world's largest database of verified collectible transactions, which allows modern valuation methods to be applied to collectibles.
“So now that we have a set, the world's largest database of verified transactions, we can apply a lot of modern principles on valuation.”
- Raw eBay sold-item data is unreliable for pricing because of bid inflation, canceled purchases made to inflate prices, and misreported transactions, so true card prices must be cleaned up with verified transactions.
“There's a lot of manipulation in this industry. If you go look at eBay sold items, you're going to find a lot of things that either were bought and then canceled”
- Insuring physical collectibles is cumbersome because there is no recognized expert appraiser, so the owner must define market value, which changes daily, and therefore must communicate with the insurer every day to stay fully insured.
“without an appraising you are the one who has to define the market value... you're communicating with the insurance company every single day”
- Alt can price any card, even without a direct data point, by decomposing it into components and triangulating from comparable transaction data, including a custom sports card index analogous to the S&P 500.
“we can create our own version of the S&P 500 for sports cards, and we can actually triangulate what the price based on the dataset is of that card.”
Good investing is judged by disciplined, risk-adjusted process and complementary investor skills, not outcomes.
- Rather than betting on which player will become the next star, a diversified portfolio of market cards gives outsized returns whoever wins the next MVP or Super Bowl, because it captures systemic market performance.
“we can't predict who the next hot quarterback is going to be... we have a very diversified portfolio that allows us that whoever is going to win that next MVP”
- Avidar claims his personal collecting returns exceed 150 percent IRR over five years, driven by arbitrage on undervalued cards, while Alt's fund also uses undisclosed alpha strategies beyond beta exposure.
“my return over the last five years has been in excess of 150% in IRR over the past five years. That's due to a lot of arbitrage opportunities.”
- A good investor should be judged by return per unit of risk, measured by the Sharpe ratio, not by raw returns, because a manager who matches the S&P 500's risk and beats its return has demonstrated skill while a high-return manager who took more risk has not necessarily done better.
“The Sharpe ratio... tells you the amount of return you did for a unit of risk. If a fund manager took the same amount of risk that the S&P 500 did and outperformed it, that is a good investor”
- Good investors have strong discipline, removing emotion from buying and selling and exiting losing positions when their thesis is disproven, rather than holding until break-even, because losing money is inevitable and decision quality matters more than outcome.
“Good investors lose a lot, they just know how to exit the position when their thesis is disproven.”
- Avidar's sports card collecting started with childhood nostalgia, and he resumed buying in 2016 when he could afford packs, then became serious in 2017 after spotting arbitrage opportunities in the card market.
“I started seeing a lot of different arbitrages, and I always talk about arbitrages in the wild.”
- When choosing investors to work with, Avidar prioritizes complementary skill sets that fill his weaknesses, such as marketing, and kindness, because long-term business partnerships last longer than many marriages.
“I look for complementary skillsets because at the end of the day I believe that investors want to be able to help... I care a lot about kindness”
- Results can be unreliable in the short run, so investors should judge their decision-making process rather than outcomes, following the book Thinking in Bets, because disciplined decisions produce better results over the long term.
“It's less about the end result, it's about the decision making. So if you have very disciplined decision making in the long term you're going to have better results”
- The ideal investor is one who brings complementary skills, since investors want to help and a founder needs room for that help; the speaker's weakness is marketing and he seeks an investor who can teach him that.
“I look for complementary skillsets because at the end of the day I believe that investors want to be able to help, so you have to give them room to help.”
Culture and collectibles have intrinsic value that can be priced with DCF-style models.
- In the future, every product will have a transparent value that can be derived, and people will loan them to one another, turning culture into a securitized, financialized asset class.
“Every product will have a transparent value and people will be loaning them one to another.”
- A culture asset such as the Mona Lisa has an intrinsic value equal to the admissions appeal it generates, so the fair loan price should equal the long-run admission profits it could produce, meaning every culture product can in principle be valued with a DCF-like function.
“So if someone were to loan it out, the amount that they would charge for the loan should be in the long run equivalent to the profits that they would generate from sharing admissions to it.”
- Patrick argues that gold returns depend on future collective sentiment since it is held for its own sake, while Avidar responds that collectibles, like precious metals, have a utility of appeal that can be modeled, and that Patrick's Mona Lisa framing unlocked the logic.
“Yeah, and a precious metal has its own utility. This just has a utility in a different way.”
- The speaker believes intrinsic value in collectibles has been cracked, which would allow discounted cash flow pricing and passive income, unlike gold whose return depends only on what others will pay in the future.
“I think I have cracked the code on there is an intrinsic value to collectibles. So once there is an intrinsic value, then basically you can do a DCF”
- Precious metals have their own utility, while culture assets have a utility of attracting people's attention and admission, so a pop-up museum analogy shows what makes an object worth paying to see.
“a precious metal has its own utility. This just has a utility in a different way.”
Founders learn problems firsthand and grow through fast customer feedback loops.
- Doing the work manually in the early days, such as printing and mailing from an apartment, is deliberate because founders need to feel the problems firsthand, which gives them customer empathy when they later build the software.
“The reason we did everything ourselves is wanted to understand the intricacies, we wanted to feel the problems. So when we were actually building out the solution we were building it for ourselves.”
- Growth is fundamentally the process of getting customer feedback, responding to it, and running that loop over and over, so getting the loop started very early is critical to scalable growth.
“Growth is actually getting customer feedback, responding to that customer feedback, and getting that loop to go over, and over, and over again.”
- In the early days of a company, the goal is to maximize learnings rather than perfection, so making mistakes is a key part of growth, and launching a first version that is not perfect is necessary to start the customer feedback loop.
“I optimize for learnings over making perfection. I actually think in the early days you want to maximize learnings, not to maximize being perfect.”
- Bay Area companies typically keep employees for roughly one to two years, which Avidar saw as a problem to differentiate from at Lob.
“everyone is keeping people for 1.X years. You got to do something different.”