What this covers

This is a conversation between Patrick and Christian about how decarbonization works at the level of machines, balance sheets, and supply chains. Christian treats the problem as one of capital rotation: a fossil-fuel vehicle sold today commits its owner to 15 to 20 years of burning fuel, so fleet mix matters. He argues that forecasters have repeatedly underestimated the cost curve learning effect, pointing to International Energy Agency solar and wind projections that actual costs have undercut every year for a decade.

The middle of the conversation is practical. Christian describes how a company starts measuring its footprint: map the supply chain from purchasing data, forecast from what is available, then run a life cycle assessment on the hotspots. Most emissions, often over 90 percent, sit in manufactured goods and upstream materials rather than offices. He says typical companies can find 20 to 40 percent reductions that pay for themselves, and he cites Apple, which cut emissions over 40 percent in absolute terms under a rule that every initiative must show positive ROI. He also expects TCFD-style reporting to become the investor standard, and discusses proposed SEC rules.

The contested territory is wider. He calls de-growth thinking outdated, says U.S. funding is no longer the bottleneck and permitting for generation and transmission is, and reads the Biden climate bill as incentive design for early technologies. He is bullish on nuclear, which he describes as a race between rebuilding lost industrial knowledge and falling solar, wind, and battery costs. He also separates easy sectors from hard ones: aviation is only 1-2 percent of emissions, while industrial heat is far larger and needs R&D.

Sharpest takeaway

Christian argues decarbonization is a capital-rotation problem that is now financeable and in the money for most businesses, so it will be driven by debt finance and corporate action rather than consumer goodwill or new political breakthroughs.

  • Clean technology has reached cost parity or better in many uses, so switching capital stock is now economically rational
  • Banks and corporations are adopting carbon data and climate lines of business because they see financial returns
  • Consumers alone will not drive the transition; pressure from investors, regulators, and sophisticated customers will

The argument · threads8 threads · 61 claims
0.85

Clean energy is cheaper and technically viable, so it wins on economics and is fundable across niches.

13 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Clean energy and clean technology have become less expensive than existing carbon-dependent alternatives, and this is the key shift that customers now recognize, unlike five to ten years ago.

    “clean technology broadly, less expensive than the existing alternatives. And this is the key thing that we visit all the time with our customers of decarbonization is in the money now”

  • For a transition to happen, clean energy must become so cost competitive that it is economical to switch to new capital before the end of life of existing carbon-dependent infrastructure, not merely cheaper on levelized cost for new builds.

    “It has to be so cost competitive, then it is more economical to switch over to new capital, before the end of life of the existing carbon-dependent infrastructure.”

  • The International Energy Agency has for a decade or more projected future solar and wind costs to stay near recent levels, and actual costs have fallen below that projection every year, showing that consensus forecasts have repeatedly underestimated learning effects.

    “the IEA, the International Energy Agency, has for a decade or more, projected the future cost of solar and wind. And the projection is always that it will stay similar to the most recent cost”

  • Decarbonization is a very positive-sum transition, as it is well studied that faster decarbonization benefits the global economy via lower harm and cheaper, more abundant energy and manufactured goods, like a $20 bill on the street.

    “It is almost the example of the $20 bill on the street, where it is so net good”

  • The least expensive energy production globally is solar and wind in geographies that are favorable for them, meaning clean energy has won the cost war in many geographies and gives businesses a simple, straightforward basis for decisions.

    “the least expensive energy production globally is solar and wind in geographies that are favorable for solar and wind.”

  • Climate projects are commodity technologies and businesses that earn debt-style returns rather than venture-style equity returns, which is why big institutions rather than venture capital must fund them.

    “We're often talking here about commodity technologies, commodity businesses. This is not the C-style returns, but this is like debt style returns.”

  • Each climate tech niche, such as carbon removal, baseload energy, industrial heat, grid-scale batteries, and alternative battery types, is clearly fundable and can attract deep talent once capital commitments are made, which draws entrepreneurs like Peter Reinhardt's Charm.

    “if you have carbon removal, you have new baseload energy sources if you have solutions for industrial heat”

  • Peter Reinhardt's company Charm focuses on carbon removal, a niche that was nascent when Charm started and is now producing its first crop of companies, and it may later expand into energy production.

    “Peter Reinhardt's business, Charm, that you mentioned is an awesome example where the business today is focused on this carbon removal technology niche”

  • The company has momentum on rotating the entire electricity grid toward zero-carbon energy production, while electricity cannot supply industrial heat.

    “We have great momentum on rotating our entire electricity grid towards zero carbon energy production.”

  • Most capital flowing into climate goes to physical projects and companies with deep hardware or industrial components, though a lot of software tools must still be built to accelerate the transition.

    “most of the capital that flows into the climate space by far will flow to physical projects”

  • Climate was long seen as stuck and needing a political breakthrough, but it turned out to be a technology problem: decades of R&D made clean technology viable in the late 2010s, and momentum has only recently become broadly recognized.

    “And it turns out that it was a technology problem, where due to just decades of R&D, suddenly in the late 2010s, you have clean technology in the money”

  • Cost curves are more powerful than people realize because as something scales, producers find ways to make it less expensive, easier to operate, and easier to distribute, so forecasts anchored on current costs systematically underestimate declines.

    “Cost curves are more powerful than people realize.”

  • Every climate tech dependency that is knocked down represents a potentially huge business, and climate problems are viewed as so investable and bankable that many R&D shops and entrepreneurs are attacking them.

    “every one of these climate tech dependencies that you knock down is a potentially huge business.”

0.62

Banks, investors, and corporate governance now treat climate as a standard business and financial risk topic.

9 pointscentrality 4/5
  • A single grid-scale solar or wind site of a gigawatt or more is a hugely capital-intensive financing undertaking, which is why banks are central to the energy transition.

    “Grid scale, solar or wind, maybe a gigawatt or multi-gigawatt site, that is a huge financing undertaking.”

  • Large banks have become motivated on climate largely because they see financing the energy transition as a new line of business rather than as charity.

    “what has gotten them really motivated around climate is seeing what an opportunity it is for a new line of business”

  • Climate has only recently entered the investable mainstream, driving a large wave of venture and project finance, after a previous stereotype that climate and business priorities conflicted suppressed investment.

    “It is only in this past year or so that climate has firmly entered the overtone window of very investable and an exciting area for business.”

  • Decarbonization will be financed mainly through debt finance and banks taking bets on projects, which runs counter to the popular image of climate action as driven by idealists against capitalism.

    “The tagline that I like for this is that decarbonization will be brought to you by debt finance.”

  • For decades a stereotype that climate priorities and business priorities trade off had a chilling effect on climate investment and startups, and accumulating case studies of climate being good for business is what is dissolving it.

    “It is only in this past year or so that climate has firmly entered the overtone window of very investable and an exciting area for business.”

  • Climate has shifted from being scattered across organizations to a standardized first buyer in the CFO's office, where it is treated as a governance topic alongside financial and regulatory risk.

    “the transition in our customer base to a standardized first buyer in the CFO's office, seeing this as a key governance topic”

  • The future structure for corporate climate work is a hub-and-spoke model in which a small central team in the CFO's office tracks climate data and forecasts the business's climate trajectory, while teams across the company incorporate that data into daily decisions without it being their full-time job.

    “you typically see a hub-and-spoke model where in the CFO's office, climate data is tracked centrally”

  • TCFD reporting is likely to become the standard report investors and stakeholders expect, combining carbon-denominated emissions data across the supply chain with dollar-denominated climate financial risk figures.

    “I think TCFD reporting is likely to become a standard or maybe even the standard”

  • Carbon data is being tracked alongside financial data as a key indicator of long-term financial risk, investability, and supply chain strength for companies.

    “carbon data is tracked alongside other financial data as one of the key indicators of long-term financial risk, investability, supply chain strength”

0.57

Carbon-aware software and purchasing data expose supply-chain hotspots where companies can cut emissions profitably.

13 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Typical companies, whose emissions span their whole supply chain, can find in-the-money initiatives that reduce carbon by 20% to 40% today, though not all the way to zero without more R&D.

    “your typical company whose carbon comes from across its whole supply chain, energy, manufacturing, et cetera, can find in-the-money initiatives to reduce carbon 20%, 40%, not all the way.”

  • Climate software serves three audiences: the projects building physical assets, the financiers deciding what is most investable, and the businesses that purchase or offtake climate-friendly technology, with Watershed focused on the financiers and purchasers.

    “If you think of the three customer audiences for software tools, you have the projects”

  • For companies new to climate work, most carbon, often over 90 percent, comes from manufactured goods and the long supply chain of energy and raw materials rather than from the physical plant of offices.

    “it's typically surprising to the customer, how much of the carbon 90-plus percent is coming from manufactured goods”

  • Watershed serves both business customers who generate climate disclosures and finance customers who consume them, and having a standard that interoperates between the two has been powerful for the company.

    “we're often sitting on both sides of this disclosure, helping a business customer of ours generated and helping us finance customer of ours consume”

  • Measuring a company's climate footprint starts by integrating existing financial purchasing data to map the supply chain, then forecasting from available data and drilling into hotspots with detailed life cycle assessments to model trade-offs.

    “week 1 is about integrating existing data sets in the Watershed. First and foremost, your financial data around what are you purchasing and from who.”

  • Block's carbon hotspot was the manufacturing of its physical point-of-sale card readers, which led to detailed life cycle assessments and potential substitutions of lower-carbon raw materials.

    “in areas they prioritize, this is public, you can read it in their climate report, has been around the manufacture of the physical square hard readers”

  • European customers show much more consumer and individual climate consciousness than in the United States, so every European business tends to have climate-savvy staff across functions, and Watershed's European customers get productive faster while US customers need basic climate education.

    “Europe has much more consumer consciousness and individual consciousness around climate as a key issue than we're familiar with in the United States.”

  • Early vendor choices such as cloud provider are hard to reverse, so a startup should consider carbon intensity upfront; Watershed chose Google Cloud because it was furthest along in operating at zero carbon at the time.

    “The biggest such decision that we made as a software company was our cloud provider.”

  • A product that searches vendors and suppliers by carbon footprint would help early-stage companies make decisions that are hard to reverse, such as logistics, manufacturing, and sourcing choices.

    “One product, I would love for Watershed to build someday would be a search engine over all the products out there from a carbon perspective.”

  • Watershed started in late 2019, and when founders mentioned building a climate company to people in tech, the reactions were mildly surprised skepticism.

    “when we started on Watershed in late 2019. And I mentioned to people in this tech world of ours that we were going to build a climate company.”

  • The logistical complexity of physically complex supply chains, such as those of Walmart, restaurant chains, and apparel companies, is mind-boggling for software people and is much harder than knowing it intellectually.

    “it is obviously mind boggling the logistical complexity that goes into delivering an amazing consumer experience”

  • Watershed is an enterprise climate platform that tracks and forecasts carbon emissions for businesses and integrates financial and carbon perspectives into decisions.

    “The enterprise climate platform that is tracking and forecasting for these businesses”

  • Every new vehicle sold with a fossil-fuel engine represents a 15 to 20 year commitment to burning fossil fuels, the expected life of a median US vehicle, which is why fleet mix shifts are central to logistics decarbonization.

    “that's a 15- to 20-year commitment to burning fossil fuels.”

0.55

Business pressure from investors, regulators, and customers, not consumers, drives decarbonization.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The transition is threatening to existing business models, not all businesses, and this incumbency effect has done much to slow it, since oil and gas companies must work out which investment and technology strategy keeps them viable in a zero-carbon future.

    “The smartest businesses will adapt but is this incumbency effect that has done a lot to slow the transition?”

  • Starting around late 2020 and early 2021, cold outbound calls to random enterprises increasingly found companies already discussing climate with their CFO or board, indicating the market was starting to run away faster than climate tech could scale.

    “There was this inflection point in late 2020, early 2021, where, as we did outbound sales effort”

  • Consumers alone will not drive the decarbonization transition; it must come first from businesses under pressure from institutional investors, regulators, and sophisticated corporate customers, with consumers benefiting later from lower-carbon goods.

    “consumers alone are not going to drive the decarbonization transition. We believe at Watershed that this comes first and foremost from businesses.”

  • The main reason companies decline climate programs has historically been a not-now attitude, either not being ready to get serious about climate or not being ready to move away from consultant-heavy models, and those objections are becoming less common.

    “The biggest reason historically has been the not now of, I'm not now ready to get serious about climate”

  • Walmart had reported carbon emissions for its supply chain for over a decade, and now every large company is joining the disclosure trend.

    “Walmart has been ahead of this curve, reporting for a decade plus on the carbon emissions of its supply chain.”

  • Every one of the top five leading banks in the US and Europe is ambitious in climate finance, indicating the topic has gone mainstream in finance.

    “if you look at top 5 leading banks, U.S. and Europe, every single one of them is ambitious in this space right now.”

0.37

Regulation, not government funding, now bottlenecks the transition, so climate incentives should fade at scale.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Government funding is no longer the bottleneck in the United States for the climate transition; the bottleneck is now regulation that slows the build-out of energy generation and long-distance transmission infrastructure.

    “Government funding is no longer the bottleneck in the United States to the climate transition.”

  • Climate-specific incentives are appropriate for early R&D and incubation of nascent clean technology, but at scale the climate specificity should fall away so that the technology competes on its own merits.

    “In the scale moment, the climate specificity should fall away a little bit, but you want to see a technology that's getting out of the market on its own momentum”

  • The Biden climate bill is an incentive design that uses tax credits, R&D incentives, and targeted loans to artificially put early-stage clean technologies in the money, so they can scale and come down the cost curve.

    “Let's construct these incentives that put it in the money artificially. And then as it gets to scale, technologies that scale come down the cost curve”

  • Proposed SEC climate reporting rules in the US would be about as ambitious as many existing European climate laws, narrowing a previously expected divergence where Europe regulates heavily and the US relies on private market investment.

    “these proposed SEC rules in the U.S. shifted that narrative a bit”

0.28

Hard-to-abate sectors and nuclear need further R&D and rebuilt capacity before decarbonization can be complete.

6 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Decarbonization resembles rebuilding a plane in mid-air, as engineers must keep a production system running while executing a transition, because the world cannot pause the economy to switch energy and manufacturing systems.

    “Decarbonization is the ultimate example of what you talk about in the technical debt context of wanting to rebuild the plane in mid-air.”

  • Hydrogen is one technology people point to as a possible solution for industrial heat, but it is not yet known whether it will work, and many startups are attacking the problem.

    “Maybe it will be hydrogen, for instance, is a technology that people sometimes point to, to solve industrial heat. We don't know today”

  • Nuclear energy is one of the best climate options and could be better for the climate in some narrow ways than solar and wind; the race is whether nuclear can rebuild its scientific and industrial capacity faster than solar, wind, and batteries keep falling in cost.

    “It's going to be a technology race of can nuclear rebuild itself as an industry, faster than solar and wind and battery technology can continue to come down the cost curve.”

  • The nuclear industry stagnated in recent decades largely due to public relations issues and pressure from threatened incumbents, causing loss of career nuclear engineers and scientific knowledge that existed in the 1950s and 1960s.

    “entirely due to these public relations issues as well as to pressure from threatened incumbents, the nuclear energy industry has stagnated”

  • Aviation is hard to decarbonize because batteries cannot match its energy density, but it is only about 1-2% of global emissions and can be among the last to transition, whereas industrial heat, at roughly 7 of 50 gigatons of global carbon, is a substantial fraction requiring R&D.

    “Industrial heat is around 7 giga tons out of 50 giga tons of global carbon production.”

  • Getting to zero carbon is fundamentally a question of how quickly the global capital stock across energy, manufacturing, and agriculture can be rotated out of carbon-dependent processes into clean alternatives, and without that rotation there is no other momentum to global warming beyond the inertia of capital.

    “It means a complete substitution of the global capital stock.”

0.23

Apple shows climate results can coexist with positive-ROI business priorities.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Apple brought in Lisa Jackson, former EPA head under the Obama administration, around 2015-2016 to lead its climate work, which Christian credits as a driver of its results.

    “they brought in Lisa Jackson, who is the Head of the EPA during the Obama administration, and now leads the climate work at Apple.”

  • Apple has cut carbon emissions by more than 40 percent in absolute terms since about 2015-2016 while growing substantially, under a top-down mandate that every climate initiative must have positive ROI for Apple as a business.

    “they've cut carbon by 40-plus percent in absolute terms, while growing by whatever wild multiple Apple has grown by since 2016.”

  • The climate transition is like a chemical reaction that is energetically favored but so slow it does not occur in practice; it is in the money for nations, businesses, and the world, but that does not mean it will happen fast enough to matter relative to consequences.

    “chemical reactions that are energetically favored, but are so slow that in practice, they just don't have”

  • Requiring every climate initiative to be positive ROI for the business shows that climate and business priorities are not in tension, as demonstrated by Apple's quiet achievement of large climate results alongside strong business results.

    “It just completely unravels the narrative that there's a tension between the business priorities and the climate priorities”

0.09

Doomerism obstructs climate progress because public sentiment lags behind good expert news.

4 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Individuals closest to the climate problem are swinging toward optimism because of a renaissance of progress across national governments, but general public sentiment, including doomerism, has not caught up with expert sentiment.

    “The individuals closest to the climate problem are penduluming towards optimism right now.”

  • The de-growth or doomer view that climate requires reducing economic activity was plausible twenty years ago when zero-carbon alternatives were not visible, but now that a path to expand the economy while cutting emissions exists, it is outdated and obstructs needed infrastructure build-out.

    “Now that we have that path forward, the de-growther or doomer view is not only out of date, but it's become a source of pushback”

  • Doomerism, the belief that humanity will go extinct from climate change, is one of the biggest enemies of climate progress right now because it discourages the building work that speeds the transition.

    “That doomerism is one of the biggest enemies of climate progress right now.”

  • Public sentiment lags expert optimism, and doomerism among the general public is one of the biggest enemies of climate progress, because the news on the transition is actually good and should motivate people to help build out the capital transition.

    “The individuals closest to the climate problem are penduluming towards optimism right now.”