What this covers

Matt Reustle interviews Josh Zegen about how Madison Realty Capital was built. The story begins with an open-ended fund that had a sound strategy but a structure that broke under redemptions in the financial crisis. The firm rebuilt by adding property, asset, and construction management to its lending. Zegen contrasts the pre-2008 era, when Corus Bank and Fremont wrote 80% non-recourse construction loans and Lehman Brothers supplied 90% of the capital stack, with the regulated aftermath. Banks then retreated to 50-60% loan-to-cost. Madison's whole loan goes to 65-75%, and it then levers that loan with banks, so borrowers see one lender.

The conversation then ranges across the market. Zegen says about 95 of roughly a hundred real estate private credit firms do the same transitional lending, while customized construction work earns a premium. He explains why buying a loan differs from originating one, citing foreclosure timelines of about three years in New York against about 60 days in Texas. He also covers how Madison treats defaults, preferring extra time, collateral, or guarantees to a heavy hammer.

The contested parts are the market calls. He argues that 10-year Treasury volatility matters more than rate levels. He expects office to take two to four years to work through, with only some buildings convertible to residential. He also says post-2023 bank pullback has opened a back leverage gap. Shorter turns cover expiring rate caps, the scarcity of performing loans for sale, retail's recovery, and why locked-in mortgages keep housing supply thin.

Sharpest takeaway

Madison Realty Capital's history shows private credit in commercial real estate grew from filling gaps banks left, into a vertically integrated, customized lending model whose leverage and flexibility depend on stable rates and access to bank and private-credit back-leverage.

  • Post-2008 bank regulation pushed construction leverage down to 50-60% of cost, creating room for non-bank whole-loan lenders to offer 65-75% LTC and then lever with banks
  • Vertical integration (servicing, asset management, construction management) lets a lender take over projects in downturns, which Madison argues is a competitive advantage and a scalability requirement
  • Banks' retreat after the March 2023 banking crisis created a back-leverage gap that Madison fills with loan-on-loan, A-note, and non-mark-to-market facilities

The argument · threads2 threads · 67 claims
0.75

Repayment, not asset ownership, is the goal, so borrower completion must be closely monitored.

2 pointscentrality 5/5
  • COVID combined major inflation with supply chain delays, forcing extreme asset management to confirm borrowers could finish projects, and most of the firm's projects got out and withstood the shock.

    “All of a sudden you had a huge inflationary period where you had two problems going on.”

  • A scalable lending business cannot constantly take over real estate, so the primary goal is getting paid back on the loan rather than owning the asset.

    “And you can't have a scalable business if you're constantly taking over real estate.”

0.57

Bank sourcing, residential focus, and institutionalized sponsors shape the firm's lending franchise.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Sourcing performing and non-performing loans from banks depends on knowledge of banks and relationships with the right people there, and the firm has bought only three loans totaling about 250 million this past year.

    “It's usually having knowledge of banks and just dealing with the right people at banks.”

  • Developer and sponsor structures have changed materially over 20 years, as the largest sponsors now borrow from private credit institutions and the asset class has been institutionalized for both investors and borrowers.

    “the largest of sponsors are borrowing from private credit institutions.”

  • The firm has done substantial hospitality credit through an operating partner, while its core focus has been residential-related real estate across multifamily, condo, build-to-rent and single-family for-sale housing.

    “Hospitality is something we've done a lot of and we have an operating partner who helps us execute on hospitality credit”