What this covers
This is a conversation between Patrick and Chuck Akre about the framework his firm calls the three-legged stool: business quality, the integrity of management, and a record of reinvestment. Akre grounds it in the roughly 9 to 10 percent long-run return of US stocks, which he says tracks return on owner's capital. He also cites Thomas Phelps's 100 to 1 in the Market, which found 350 companies that could have returned a hundredfold between 1935 and 1971, so that the only real difference among winners was the rate of compounding.
Most of the range comes from worked examples. Bandag earned several times the returns of other tire companies because its real business was a loyal dealer network selling retreading, and it passed savings to those dealers after the 1970s oil embargo. International Speedway looked debt-free, yet its notes showed deferred ticket revenue and owners who raised prices only every four or five years. O'Reilly's service to independent garages demands a denser distribution network than AutoZone's. It also bought back about 40 percent of its shares. American Tower is framed as a tollbooth on wireless growth, and in 2002 its main risk was dilution rather than bankruptcy.
The contested turns come late. Akre rejects purely quantitative methods, pointing to James Simons's tens of thousands of inputs. He attributes falling business returns over the last 10 to 15 years to lower interest rates, while conceding the link is not mechanical. He argues that the hardest discipline is not selling, and that imagination and curiosity matter more than raw intelligence.
Chuck Akre argues that long-term investment returns come from owning businesses with high returns on owner's capital, run by trustworthy managers who reinvest well, bought at modest valuations and held through volatility, and that simple, judgment-based analysis of these three qualities beats complex quantitative models.
- Returns on common stock track the return on owner's capital, so high-ROE businesses compound wealth fastest
- Managers who treat shareholders as partners and reinvest well are a separate, necessary condition alongside business quality
- Simple, top-down judgment and patience beat complex quantitative modeling, and the hardest part is not selling great businesses
Management's record and reinvestment opportunity form the stool's third leg, shown by American Tower's acquisitions.
- The third leg of the stool is management's record and opportunity for reinvestment, which American Tower illustrates through its ongoing acquisitions of towers across the world.
“And that's the third leg of the stool.”