#389: The Founder of Jimmy Choo: Tamara Mellon
What this covers
David Senra reads through Tamara Mellon's memoir and stops to compare her story with other founders he has studied. The first half is about how the brand was built. Because Mellon was her own target customer, she knew where similar women shopped and which magazines they read, an instance of Founder as First Customer. The first store went on Motcomb Street, where the rent was higher but foot traffic was heavy, and Senra ties this to Steve Jobs paying for Apple store locations. He treats this placement as part of Ambush Your Customers. The tactics include the Sex and the City "I lost my Choo" line and gifting shoes to celebrity stylists rather than to the celebrities.
The second half covers the sale of the company and what followed. Jimmy Choo himself sold his stake in 2001, and the Mellons took a 50% deal that she later called her fatal mistake. The company then passed through several owners, ending with Michael Kors at $1.2 billion. Senra's account of the damage is concrete: a cap on leather costs per square meter, a cancelled film-awards sponsorship that would have dented EBITDA, and management repeatedly preparing the company for sale. He sets these against Bernard Arnault's long horizon and James Dyson's full ownership.
Senra also brings in Morita, Buffett, and Bezos on differentiation and mediocrity. He adds Mellon's difficult childhood with her mother as a source of her drive for financial security. His claims about private equity are contested.
Senra argues Tamara Mellon's memoir shows that founders who love the product should keep majority control, because private equity owners optimize for short-term exits and erode brand quality.
- Mellon's customer-first, media-driven launch of Jimmy Choo worked because she designed for herself and placed the brand where her customers gathered
- Selling 50% to private equity in 2001 and then accepting a 50/50 split with no control led to short-term cost cutting, lost brand quality, and her eventual exit in 2011
- The core lesson is retention of total control, which Senra connects to Dyson, Jobs, Morita, and Buffett
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Steve Jobs put Apple stores in expensive high-traffic locations because people will not drive 20 minutes to a store but will walk 20 footsteps into one they pass, so convenience beats cheap rent, unlike Gateway's out-of-town warehouse stores that failed.
“the real estate was a lot more expensive, but people didn't have to gamble with 20 minutes of their time. They only had to gamble with 20 footsteps of their time.”
Jimmy Choo appeared on Sex and the City on July 5, 1998, with the 'I lost my Choo' line, and the show's creator put the reference in because she had loved the London store, giving the brand free national exposure that was mentioned 34 times.
“Ultimately, Jimmy Choo would be mentioned on the show 34 times.”
Mellon recognized that a luxury brand gives its owner the chance to profit from ideas and image, and image can travel across the world and migrate to other products, which Bernard Arnault understood early.
“a luxury brand offered the owner the opportunity to profit from ideas and image.”
The main lesson from the book, and from many founder autobiographies, is that a founder who loves the product should never give up control, because control is what lets a founder build the best product rather than optimize for an exit.
“if you're a founder and you love what you do, never, ever, ever give up control.”
Private equity owners maximize EBITDA in the short term because they plan to sell the company within a few years, which is the opposite of how a missionary founder would run it.
“we're gonna buy this company. We're going to, in the short term, maximize EBITDA because we're going to sell it to another private equity company in a few years.”
Jimmy Choo was sold repeatedly: Lion Capital bought it for $101 million in 2004, Tower Brook Capital sold it for $185 million, Leblo bought it for $525 million, it IPO'd at a $546 million valuation, and Michael Kors acquired it for $1.2 billion.
“Three years after that, Michael Kors holdings acquires Jimmy Choo for $1.2 billion.”
Akio Morita of Sony insisted on spending about $2 million on a new product's campaign and threatened to fire a marketing executive who resisted, because he treated brand investment as a long-term asset since Sony would outlive him.
“if you don't spend $2 million in this campaign, you're fired. Akio understood that as a long-term investment because Sony was going to outlive him.”
Remarkable careers often come from finding an earned secret and exploiting it for two to three years, or decades, as Cedric Chin argued in a tweet Senra admired.
“one type of remarkable career, and certainly the most interesting type, comes from finding an earned secret and then exploiting the hell out of it for the good part of two to three years. Decades.”
Gifting shoes to celebrity stylists and agents is more effective than gifting celebrities directly, because one stylist works with five or ten celebrities, giving many more chances for placement.
“if you can build a relationship with a stylist, that stylist might have a relationship with five or ten of the celebrities that you want to reach.”
Successful brands must ambush their customers by placing stores and product in high-traffic locations and media where target buyers congregate, even when it costs more than conventional placement.
“you need to ambush your customers.”
Buffett argued that businesses settle for a notch or two above mediocrity and that there are too many .240 hitters in business, so mediocrity is invisible until passion shows up and exposes it.
“There are way too many .240 hitters in business.”
Steve Jobs said in a 1985 Playboy interview that they built the Mac for themselves and did not do market research, and Senra argues that entrepreneurs with soul in the game build quality the way a carpenter refuses to use plywood on the back of a chest of drawers.
“We didn't build Mac for anybody else. We built it for ourselves.”
Jeff Bezos argued in his final shareholder letter that differentiation is survival, because the universe pushes everyone toward being typical and it takes deliberate energy to keep what makes you special.
“he says that differentiation is survival. And the universe wants you to be typical.”
A founder who is the customer knows where similar buyers shop, what they admire, which magazines and TV shows they follow, and can design products for them, so Mellon's own tastes gave Jimmy Choo a built-in understanding of its market.
“I was the customer that I wanted to reach.”
In 2001 Jimmy Choo sold his 50% stake for roughly $8 to $10 million to Phoenix Equity Partners and left the business, and the Mellons accepted a 50% deal rather than the 51% control buyers wanted, which Mellon later called her fatal mistake.
“Jimmy sells his 50% share for around 8 to 10 million dollars to Phoenix Equity Partners”
Bernard Arnault of LVMH represents the opposite of Mellon's private equity partners, because he thinks in long-horizon terms, and he recognized early that a luxury brand's image can travel across products and markets.
“One of the very first to see the opportunities here was Bernard Arnault.”
If you are a founder who loves what you do, never give up control, since founders who keep total control avoid the value extraction that happens when outside owners take over, as James Dyson did by keeping 100 percent ownership.
“if you're a founder and you love what you do, never, ever, ever give up control.”
Jimmy Choo placed its first store on Motcomb Street, a high-traffic location near where its target women worked and shopped, paying more rent rather than choosing cheap out-of-the-way space, because customers will walk 20 footsteps but not drive 20 minutes.
“I found the perfect spot on Motcomb Street for a certain kind of woman: me.”
Working with the absolute best people possible matters because small decisions made over years of working together compound, and talent matters beyond big decisions.
“you need to work with the absolute best people that you can. Talent really matters.”
When Jimmy Choo resisted manufacturing and fought the partnership, the Mellon father suggested buying out his shares, an option Senra argues would have been the best possible outcome for the company.
“We should just buy out his shares. Why don't you just tell us what you want for the shares? If that would have happened, it would have been the best possible thing for them.”
Private equity owners imposed a cap of 30 euros per square meter on leather costs to improve margins, pushing factories to cut materials and manufacturing quality, which Senra argues produces mediocrity that will not work long term.
“They told us we could no longer use leather that costs more than €30 a square meter.”
Because owners kept selling the company every few years, management had to prepare it for sale and facilitate due diligence, a tiresome second job that distracted from quality and innovation while competitors stayed focused on product.
“facilitating due diligence had become a tiresome second job. Meanwhile, our competition wasn't necessarily going through the same kinds of distraction”
Mellon's mother psychologically tormented her as a child, and combined with her demonic drive for financial security, that abuse drove Mellon to build wealth to escape her mother's control.
“One of the driving forces was my mother and the enigma of why she always despised me. The other force at play was a demonic drive for the financial security I hope would keep me out of her clutches.”
Parents who attack their children's self-worth are usually unhappy people who cannot fix their own lives, and this pattern repeats across generations, as Senra sees in his own family where his grandmother's abuse was followed by addiction in her children.
“these are just unhappy people. They're either unable or unwilling to fix their own lives.”
CEO Robert canceled Jimmy Choo's sponsorship of a prominent British Academy of Film and Television dinner, which would have cost about $200,000 and temporarily reduced EBITDA, a short-term decision Senra calls foolish.
“Robert doesn't want to because he sees this, hey, it's going to cost us $200,000. That's going to temporarily decrease our EBITDA.”
Mellon chose a London store location on Motcomb Street because Manolo Blahnik's store was 20 minutes from the nearest tube station, and she wanted a shop accessible to working women during lunch breaks.
“the Manolo Blahnik was 20 minutes from the nearest tube station. God forbid that a customer has an actual job in an office”
A Saks Fifth Avenue buyer, Julie Townsend, placed a 3,000-pair order at a trade show after seeing the samples, which validated the company when its plan had assumed about 20 pairs sold per week.
“She does an order for 3,000 pairs of shoes. And Tamara says, just like that, we were in.”
Jimmy Choo was a cobbler with no interest in design, so the founder had to become the creative head, drawing inspiration from flea markets and combining ideas, including materials like feathers, glitter, and studs, into new designs.
“Jimmy, it turns out, had no interest in becoming a designer. He was just a cobbler.”
Jimmy Choo and the Mellon family started the company with $150,000 from her father, on a 50-50 split, and the business was profitable from day one and needed no further outside capital.
“Her dad puts up $150,000. That's all they start with the company. The company's gonna be profitable from day one”
The founders had modeled selling about 20 pairs of shoes a week from their shop, but a single Saks Fifth Avenue buyer's order for 3,000 pairs gave them positive cash flow almost immediately.
“she does an order for 3,000 pairs of shoes.”
A brand should identify where its customers gather, whether magazines, TV, podcasts, award shows, or dinners, and place its product directly in front of them.
“just identify the media, whether it's magazines, TV, podcasts, radio, award shows, dinners—where are your customers congregating?”
Mellon's father died on April 19, 2004 after an aneurysm, removing the mentor and business partner who had been the one solid rock in her life, when she was about 36 years old.
“Her father dies unexpectedly on April 19, 2004.”
Mellon gave her notice on August 1, 2011, fifteen years almost to the day after her first trade show in New York, feeling anger, relief, mourning, and profound loss.
“On August 1, 2011, 15 years almost to the day, since I'd gone to that first trade show in New York”
Three experiences before Jimmy Choo, prestige retail, public relations, and fashion media, supplied the skills and industry knowledge that later drove the company's success.
“she worked in a prestigious retail store, she worked in public relations, and she worked in fashion media”
Magazines discovered that featuring actresses instead of models on covers sent newsstand sales sharply higher, because a single feature can reach hundreds of thousands of potential customers.
“they realized that featuring an actress instead would send their newsstand sales through the roof.”
Mellon's father gave her a kitchen MBA of business lessons over the dinner table once they were adults, which built a close bond and made him her advisor and co-founder.
“her father gave a sort of kitchen MBA, steady drips of how to think about business over the dinner table.”
Mellon learned at an early age to shut down and show no emotion, a habit of avoidance that later affected her fights with business partners.
“at a very early age I simply learned to shut down and never show any emotion, either happy or sad.”
The idea that 'it's not personal, it's business' is false for founders, because the company is part of their life energy and the emotional stakes are personal.
“This is why I always tell you it's bullshit when people say, oh, it's not personal, it's business—for founders, it's always personal.”
Like Quentin Tarantino, who was obsessed with movies for two decades before making his own, Mellon made the shoes she wanted to see in the world, and that approach paid off commercially.
“So I'll just make what I want to see in the world, and it winds up paying off.”
In 1998, Kate Winslet mentioned wearing Jimmy Choo shoes at the Oscars, which had a strong positive effect on sales and led the company to make Oscar night a major focus every year.
“Kate Winslet, who was nominated for best actress for Titanic that year, she mentions that she's wearing Jimmy Choo shoes.”
Parents who psychologically attack their children are unhappy people who are unable or unwilling to fix their own lives, and their cruelty is a way to make others unhappy, which does not excuse it but helps explain it.
“these are just unhappy people. They're either unable or unwilling to fix their own lives.”
A parent who cannot get their life together through addiction is failing a child who idolizes them, and the speaker argues that a parent should change for the sake of children who will one day judge them.
“One day, when he's old enough, he's going to take the measure of the man. And when he's able to do that, what do you want him to see?”
Mellon's husband's cocaine and alcohol abuse, which became psychosis, meant she worried about him freebasing while she ran board meetings and gave birth, and the host argues that his inability to get sober devastated his family.
“We had a board meeting at my house a week after I gave birth. And all the while I was worried my husband might be freebasing in the kitchen.”
Jimmy Choo sued the Mellon side for 22 counts of breach of contract and decided to sell his 50% stake to a private equity firm instead of to the Mellons.
“Jimmy's response was to sue them for 22 counts of breach of contract.”
The first samples from the factory were covered with scuff marks and had poor stitching, so they could not be used, and Mellon could not sell from sketches, forcing the team to learn quality manufacturing.
“They were covered with black scuff marks and the stitching was awful.”
Jimmy Choo's EBITDA of 2.9 million at deal close was not a distressed asset, yet the new owners pushed for aggressive short-term profit, which showed how a company with a household name can be harmed by financial owners.
“Our EBITDA going in when the deal was completed was 2.9 million.”
Mellon's husband Matthew Mellon became a cocaine and crack addict who partied through their wedding night, and she had to support the family while tracking him down, including once finding him in a crack house.
“I was in the office every day, working hard, and Matthew had nothing but free time on his hands”
Mellon's mother sued her for more money from Jimmy Choo even though she had no role in building the company, and the case ended with the mother withdrawing and each side paying its own legal fees, with Mellon recovering $4 million, half of which went to her lawyers.
“Half the $4 million I've recovered went to my lawyer's fees.”
Jim Simons, founder of Renaissance Technologies, said looking back on his life that getting fired can be good for you, as long as you do not make it a habit.
“getting fired can be good for you. You just don't want to make it a habit.”
When Phoenix bought in, Jimmy Choo had about $2.9 million EBITDA with only nine employees and was a household name with product flying out of stores, so it was not a distressed asset.
“Our EBITDA going in when the deal was completed was 2.9 million. Jimmy Choo was not a distressed asset.”
Mellon proposed refurbishing the stores after more than a decade, arguing that the brand is the most enduring asset to protect, but the owners said the investment would not pay off within their time horizon.
“We need to constantly nurture and protect the most enduring franchise and valuable thing that we have, which is our brand. And their response is, that's not going to pay off.”
Mellon's memoir presents breaking the cycle she was born into as its most important lesson beyond retaining control, and her daughter's secure upbringing is her proof that she rescued herself and her family line.
“it's breaking the cycle that she was born into.”
Mellon's most fundamental advice is to follow your instincts, since being blown back and forth by conflicting opinions gets you nowhere, and wrong instincts become evident soon enough so you can change course.
“My most fundamental piece of advice is to follow your instincts.”
Getting fired from Vogue was probably the best thing that could have happened to Tamara Mellon, because hitting rock bottom left only one direction to go, which was up, and it led her to found Jimmy Choo.
“this winds up being probably the best thing that could have possibly happened to her”
When children are attacked by parents or grandparents, they either fight back or let the abuser win, and in Senra's family the children who did not fight back turned to drugs.
“You can either fight back or you let them win.”
Jimmy Choo initially rejected a partnership but agreed after Mellon spent three months working alongside him in his shop, which he required to judge her commitment and get a sense of her as a person.
“He wanted me to, quote, smell the leather.”
During rehab, therapists tried to narrow Mellon's ambitions, calling her an alcoholic or addict who could not do anything special, and suggesting she take a job in a shoe store instead of starting a luxury brand.
“perhaps you might just want to take a job in a shoe store.”
Self-help advice to ask what you love and what you are good at led Mellon to her idea of building a shoe business, because she was good at fashion and fixated on shoes from her time at Vogue.
“ask yourself, what do you love and what are you good at? Her answer leads her directly to this idea”
Mellon's father had helped scale Vidal Sassoon and sold that business for $72 million shortly before they founded Jimmy Choo, which gave him free time to become her advisor.
“he had helped scale and build Vidal Sassoon. So they just sold right before they found Jimmy Choo. ... he had just sold the business for $72 million”
Lacking manufacturing experience, Mellon found a list of Italian factories and cold-called them door to door, as two young women representing an unknown brand with no orders.
“So we went to Italy cold calling and knocking on doors”
James Dyson's autobiography teaches retention of total control, and he now owns 100% of his company and reportedly takes out a couple billion dollars a year, according to what Senra has heard.
“From what I hear, James Dyson owns 100% of his company, and from what I hear, he's pulling out a couple billion dollars a year.”
Mellon's team believed a single photo of Madonna leaving a store could be worth millions of dollars in promotion, so influencer-style marketing could be excessively valuable and was not new.
“So they talked about a single picture of Madonna coming out of a store was worth millions of dollars to them.”
Mellon experienced massive anxiety attacks, night sweats, and an inability to make decisions as partner conflicts, a lawsuit, a divorce, and motherhood piled on simultaneously.
“I've been having massive anxiety attacks and night sweats. I couldn't sleep.”
Founders who build a company while facing a family drug addiction, a controlling parent, and short-term partners face compounding pressure, and building a successful company by itself is already unbelievably difficult.
“She's got to deal with the problems of building a successful company, which by itself is unbelievably difficult.”
After manufacturing specs declined, Mellon's colleague Anna sent her the message 'It's the beginning of the end,' signaling the company's shift away from its original quality.
“Anna saw the decline in manufacturing specs being approved. She sent me this message: It's the beginning of the end.”