
Robert Laughlin on the Future of Carbon and Climate 08/09/2010
What this covers
This is a conversation between Russ Roberts and Stanford physicist Robert Laughlin, the 1998 Nobel laureate in physics, built around Laughlin's forthcoming book on energy. It starts with fuel and climate, then widens into innovation, the legal limits on knowledge, and how physics itself is done. Laughlin's method throughout is to work from physical constraints, such as chemistry and quantum mechanics, toward what is economically plausible. He expects cars, planes and electricity to outlast coal and petroleum.
On energy, he argues that synthetic fuel is already proven, citing German wartime plants and South Africa's SASOL, so the obstacle is commercial rather than scientific. Making gasoline from coal roughly doubles the carbon footprint, because part of the coal is burned to supply the hydrogen. He also holds that efficiency gains of about 20 percent will matter only once fuel gets expensive, and that restricting coal mostly shifts demand to natural gas. Roberts pushes back with the history of rising efficiency and growing reserves, which have repeatedly falsified predictions that carbon was ending. The climate discussion rests on a geologic time perspective: rainfall totals, a sea-level drop of about 130 meters during the last ice age, and the unexplained start of the Pleistocene ice-age cycles. Laughlin treats irreversible species loss as the more serious problem. Roberts brings in bootleggers and Baptists to explain unlikely alliances between environmentalists and industry.
The last stretch is the most contested. Laughlin claims innovation is declining, pointing to the flash drive, the blue LED and the flat-panel display, and noting that the display's key advance was a manufacturing process. He argues that knowledge is being sequestered by law and taboo, including the Digital Millennium Copyright Act's ban on decryption, and that treating knowledge as a commodity requires it to be scarce. He closes by arguing that emergence rather than reductionism governs physical law. As examples he gives rigidity, superconductivity and universality, where correct macroscopic behavior can come from incorrect microscopic equations.
Laughlin argues that Earth's geologic timescales make climate change a secondary concern next to species loss, that carbon-based fuels will persist because of their unmatched energy density, and that emergence rather than reductionism underlies physical law.
- Measured against geologic time, the human carbon burst is a brief transient the Earth has absorbed many times before
- Hydrocarbons have the highest energy density of any fuel, so economic pressure will force a switch to carbon sourced from coal, then from air or plants
- Physical laws such as rigidity are emergent properties that appear only at large scales, so reductionism is an incomplete method
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Innovation in flat-panel displays came from a manufacturing process rather than a new physical principle, and the process of many small-loss steps made the invention commercially viable.
“the invention was the process everybody another thing everybody said that you could do that and they just did”
Hydrocarbons have the greatest energy density of any fuel, and quantum mechanics and chemistry show that no fuel will beat them, so humanity will never fully leave carbon-based fuels even after coal and oil are exhausted.
“the energy content of those fuels is optimal there will never be any anything that beats them”
Universality means the same macroscopic behavior, such as superconductivity or superfluidity, arises regardless of the microscopic details, so physicists often get the right answer from wrong equations because the behavior does not depend on the details.
“you can take wrong equations to solve them and get the right answer”
The amount of rain that has fallen since the industrial revolution is about 200 meters, the amount since the Ice Age ended would fill the oceans four times, and the amount since the dinosaurs died would fill them about 20,000 times, so the Earth's timescale dwarfs human history.
“the amount of rain that's fallen since the industrial revolution began is about 200 meters”
Reducing coal use mainly shifts energy production to natural gas, which still emits carbon, so policies that restrict coal without addressing total energy demand will not achieve their goals.
“when you cut down on the coal use you're burning more natural gas okay because that's where the energy comes from”
Coalitions of high-minded moralists and self-interested industries, such as greens and oil companies, form a 'bootleggers and Baptists' alliance, where well-meaning advocates are unknowingly used by more savvy interested parties.
“the coalition of the high-minded high morality greens with the self-interested not so high-minded organized”
Superconductivity and superfluidity in helium are emergent: a handful of atoms does not superconduct or superflow, so the macroscopic behavior comes from the collective organization of the parts, not from their individual properties.
“if you just get five or six helium atoms to see about where this behavior came from this amazing behavior you find it's not there”
The physical world has laws, such as the rigidity of matter, that are emergent: they arise from collective behavior of many atoms and do not exist in a few atoms, so the properties at the top level are not reducible to the parts.
“if you take a small bunch of atoms and do nanoscience on them to see what their properties are you find they're not rigid”
All physical laws we know may be emergent, meaning they hold only at large scales and their microscopic constituents become invisible to measurement, so the experiments succeed without needing to know the underlying details.
“this is the origin of all law not just some of them in other words our concept of the law”
If knowledge is the currency of the economy, it must be scarce, because no one pays for what they can get free, so a Jeffersonian world of freely shared knowledge turns into a society of secrets sustained by the need to charge for information.
“if you live in the world where knowledge is the currency there must be less of it why well because no one will pay for something you can get for free”
Emergence, in which systems have properties not present in their parts and not managed because not understood, is common at the most primitive levels of nature, not just in economies or governments; reductionism alone cannot explain behavior of complex systems.
“there are things that happen in systems that you don't manage because you don't understand them that this should happen in economics or humans human creations like government is obvious everyone knows this but it's not so obvious is that it happens at the most primitive levels of nature as well”
Synthetic fuel technologies, first built by the Germans in World War Two and still operated by South Africa's SASOL, already exist, so the barrier to switching fuel sources is commercial rather than scientific.
“there technologies to replace oil basically to make gasoline from other things already exist”
Energy efficiency technologies will not be adopted until fuel becomes expensive, because cheap fuel makes conservation uneconomic, so efficiency gains of about 20 percent will become relevant only as carbon fuel gets scarce and its price rises.
“the economics of fuel use precludes it because fuel is so cheap that it doesn't pay to conserve it”
The Digital Millennium Copyright Act makes it illegal to decrypt, which in practice criminalizes understanding technical material, since for a programmer decryption and understanding are the same thing.
“making it illegal to understand things understand the word we use is decrypt”
Loss of species is irreversible and therefore a far more serious problem than the roughly four-degree warming of carbon, which Laughlin considers a less severe difficulty than speciation loss driven by human population pressure on habitat.
“there's losing the species is forever”
Ecosystems have adapted to past climate shifts: the redwood forests of Eastern Oregon died out when the Cascade range created a rain shadow, while plants in other areas survived by moving, so the species that cannot move are the ones at risk.
“the Cascade ranges came up and made a rain shadow and they are no more”
About three million years ago something began the Pleistocene ice-age cycles that nobody understands, a gigantic climate effect with no known cause, and it occurred before there were any humans, demonstrating that natural climate swings happen without human influence.
“something happened that people didn't cause and the reason you know that is there weren't enough people on the earth at the time”
Synthetic gasoline from coal roughly doubles the carbon footprint because splitting water for hydrogen requires burning part of the coal for energy, and the remaining coal supplies the carbon, so total carbon consumption is roughly doubled.
“so basically the carbon consumption is doubled”
Sea levels rising by one meter, the worst case discussed for climate, is small compared with the roughly 130 meter drop in sea level about 20,000 years ago when water was locked in ice over Scandinavia and Canada, a change about 100 times larger.
“that's an effect on the sea levels that is 100 times bigger than the one you're contemplating as your worst case scenario”
Scientific breakthroughs like the blue LED were made by people who ignored the textbook belief that blue diodes were impossible, showing that expert consensus can be wrong about what is physically achievable.
“when I went to school we all learned that you couldn't make blue diodes because the energy gap of the the silicon wasn't big enough”
Laughlin claims that innovation has decreased rather than increased, since the innovations behind the flash drive, blue LEDs and flat-panel displays came from Japan and elsewhere, and American innovation is overstated.
“the pace of innovation has actually decreased”
Knowledge is being sequestered: areas of science such as nuclear weapons, biological agents, cloning and intellectual property are increasingly placed off-limits by legislation or taboo, and even university teaching is constrained.
“there's an increasing Sequoia call it a sequestering of knowledge”
Examples of innovation that displaced older industries include the EEPROM-based flash drive that destroyed film, the blue LED that enabled white lighting, and the flat-panel display whose key invention was a manufacturing process, which together with the cathode-ray tube's disappearance show innovation as process-driven rather than fundamental.
“the flat panel display which was an utterly brilliant Japanese invention it isn't wasn't based on anything new that what they invented was a process”
Rising fuel efficiency (GDP per BTU) and the consistent growth of known reserves mean past predictions of carbon's end were wrong, so future efficiency gains and resource discovery could reduce scarcity pressure.
“in 1970 when scientists were forecasting the end of carbon by 2000”
The Energy Information Agency's data show that new oil discoveries, including large Brazilian finds, cannot offset declining US production, so the draw on Middle East reserves is rising and the crunch time can be calculated from their depletion rate.
“the amount of new strikes of oil big as it is including the big Brazil ones it's not enough to offset the declines in the US production”
Oil reserve figures from BP are understated because they excluded the Venezuelan oil sands, which are vast, so the true reserve position is more favorable than the official numbers suggest.
“the reserve numbers are way off at least the BP ones that I know of because they didn't include the oil sands of Venezuela which are vast”
The capital of hardware innovation is Japan rather than America, and American innovation is overstated because proponents are not telling the truth; the iPhone is an American software-centered innovation, but the hardcore manufacturing innovation is elsewhere.
“the capital of innovation is Japan not America that's just the way it is”
When fossil carbon runs out, plants will be the cheapest source of carbon because they have spent 600 million years refining the process of extracting carbon from air, so a new branch of agriculture will grow to supply feedstock for fuel production.
“basically they've been honing their skills for 600 million years and they really know how to do it”
Once carbon-based fuel plants are built, the same factories can be switched from fossil carbon to biomass or air-captured carbon, because the capital costs are already sunk and the processes are the same.
“the plant that makes fuel out of coal is the same as the plant that makes out of grass clippings”
The moral argument for leaving coal in the ground is fictitious and merely metaphorical, since people do not make hard choices on energy when it affects their comfort, so moral rhetoric about energy rarely changes behavior.
“the moral argument is fictitious it is it is of actually it's a metaphorical argument”
Concern for the integrity of the Earth is at least partly a religious principle built into Western religions, which explains why people react to climate change through the metaphor of leaving a campsite as one found it, rather than through the science of the Earth.
“for yourself the integrity of the earth is at least in part a religious principle”
Working backward from the problem, humans will never enter a post-carbon era: even after coal and oil are gone, people will still use carbon-based fuels and will make them artificially if necessary.
“we will never go into a post-carbon era that is to say even when the coal and oil are gone human beings will still use carbon-based fuels even if they have to make them”
Elite universities sell access to a peer group and a gateway to knowledge networks rather than education itself, since the actual teaching is generic and could be obtained by reading books.
“the business model of elite universities is not education it's access to the peer group”
In Confucian cultures, monism (the belief in a single correct truth) is seen as childish and a source of conflict, and peace comes from accepting multiple truths, which contrasts with the Western insistence that one correct answer exists.
“in Confucian cultures that worldview is called monism and it's pejorative it means that you're a child”
Ideology in science is a problem: the belief that you can understand all things by taking them apart (reductionism) is an ideology that scientists cling to despite facts, and it is detrimental, so physics needs to look more at emergence and collective law.
“one of them one of those ideologies turns out to be that you can understand all things by taking them apart”
Since the 1970s, the US decided to offshore manufacturing and become an information society; this shift makes knowledge restrictions such as the Digital Millennium Copyright Act and expanded patent law a response to lost industrial jobs, as desperate Congressional efforts to protect remaining livelihoods.
“back in those days we collectively made a decision that it was okay to send make the process of making things abroad because you were going to be an information society”
Because the Earth's timescales are so long, the planet only cares whether all the coal and oil is burned, not whether that takes 200 or 300 years, so anyone truly concerned about the Earth rather than themselves would have to bring carbon consumption to zero on the scale of people.
“all it cares about is whether you burn up all the coal and oil it doesn't care whether you take 200 years to do it or 300 years to do it”
Scientists must separate the issues of the Earth from the issues of people, because the human timescale of concern (a few generations) is irrelevant to the Earth, so the carbon episode will play out in about two centuries, a flash of geologic time.
“you must separate the issues of the Earth from the issues of people because there are different timescales”
Physics is fundamentally about law, meaning reproducible quantitative relationships among measurements, rather than about reductionism, and the Western belief in law has roots in religious thinking that a lawgiver establishes order.
“physics is really about law it's not about reductionism it's about law”
A 2007 Energy Independence Act provision requiring alternative fuel procurement by the Air Force was modified by a rider from a coalition of greens and Big Oil, which required the alternative fuel not to emit more carbon than petroleum, effectively excluding coal-based fuels and protecting oil companies.
“a coalition of greens and Big Oil put a rider on that clause which was that the alternate fuel so procured must not put more carbon into the air than petroleum distillates would have”
Middle East oil reserves are being drawn down, so when they reach zero there will be an economic event and price fluctuation, roughly 60 years out at the current drawdown rate, though it may not mean the end of oil.
“that point is roughly 60 years out so now at current drawdown rate”
Western discomfort with emergence is rooted in Judeo-Christian top-down conceptions of law, which treat law as a commandment imposed from above, whereas emergence is a bottom-up committee-like process; the Bible contains no emergence, only top-down authority.
“if you open up the Bible you will find at the beginning there isn't any emergent anything okay there is top-down”
Energy companies do not build synthetic fuel plants because the cutthroat competition keeps gasoline cheap, and their strategy is to block competitors from building the capital-intensive plants, a logic Laughlin likens to John D. Rockefeller's approach.
“the energy business is cutthroat that's the key thing to understand”
The transition will happen in two stages: first a price crossing from oil to coal-derived fuel, then roughly 150 years later a crossing into plant-based carbon sources, because the cheapest carbon source will win in the competitive energy market.
“there will be first a crossing to coal followed a hundred and fifty years later or so by a crossing into other carbon sources from plants”
Fossil fuel use is a historical accident, both because the fuel happens to be in the ground and because present-day prosperity was built on it, so it cannot be abruptly stopped without causing mass death through starvation or war.
“you cannot simply wave a magic wand and stop that use of the resources without causing mass death either through starvation or just plain war”
In the 1970s the United States decided it was acceptable to offshore manufacturing because it would become an information society, a choice that hollowed out production and transferred the capacity to make things, along with the knowledge, overseas.
“back in those days we collectively made a decision that it was okay to send make the process of making things abroad because you were going to be an information society”
Governments lack the willpower or the means to artificially hold up fuel prices through taxes, because attempts to raise fuel taxes trigger strikes, as with British truckers, so price changes will be driven by market competition instead.
“governments anywhere have the willpower to do what it takes to to get get the prices to adjust artificially”
Korean companies have quietly built pilot synthetic fuel plants near Chinese coal mines so they will be ready when coal-to-liquid prices cross the oil price, illustrating how firms prepare for price-driven switches.
“numerous Korean companies had quietly been building pilot plants near Chinese coal mines”
Cap-and-trade or other carbon-reduction laws that cut usage by 20 percent only extend the time to exhaustion by 20 percent, so meaningful policy must reduce carbon use to zero rather than marginally.
“if you make cap-and-trade you cut down on your carbon use coal use by 20% that merely extends by 20% the time it takes to use it up”
The Earth's climate history shows it is a fairly resilient system with life surviving many climate swings, although mass extinctions (such as a large asteroid impact darkening skies) show that some species do not survive such events.
“the Earth's had a lot of climate swings in its existence”
The Higgs boson is a collective motion in a vacuum that is filled with elastic stuff rather than empty Newtonian nothingness, and gravity is that elasticity; the experiment base refutes the idea of empty space.
“the entire idea of the space is empty Newtonian nothingness is actually refuted by the body of experiment that we have”
Carbon is the only industrial pollutant that is not poisonous, since plants need it to grow, so the usual vilification of carbon is misplaced.
“it's the only industrial pollutant that isn't poisonous right fact plants need it to grow”
Ancient Greek atomism and emergentism entered Christian thought and were blended with Jewish religion, so that Western culture contains both a top-down law tradition and a bottom-up emergent tradition.
“a big chunk of them is Greek yeah sure and in particular Greek stoicism”
Living requires some harm to the environment, so the absolutist position of not harming nature is one end of a spectrum; real life is a trade-off between harm done and the harm needed to live.
“real life is a balance between minima between the harm you do on the one hand and and the need to do a little bit of harm in order to live”
Manufacturing has moved to East Asia: flat-panel displays are made in South Korea and Taiwan and increasingly mainland China, flash memory now comes from China rather than Korea, and innovation can be separated from manufacturing, so where something is made matters less than who uses it.
“the flat panel displays that you buy are not made in Japan even though the invention comes from there and made mostly in those countries and now increasingly from mainland China”
Fuel prices will rise steadily rather than fluctuate wildly as scarcity begins, and the first sign of oil scarcity may be price volatility rather than an explosive price spike, due to buyer response patterns.
“the first sign of the oil scarcity isn't price going up crazy its price fluctuating like crazy”
During the California energy crisis people became irrational, and the public did not talk about saving the Earth or blue skies once the lights went out, so politically the lights cannot be allowed to go off.
“when we were in that crisis no one talked about saving the earth the ecology or the blue sky”
The only moral argument against using coal, that it should be left where nature put it, does not hold up; plastic bags made from oil are not morally worse because the carbon was merely returned from underground, and most people's moral positions on energy collapse when pressed.
“it's immoral to use the coals so we should leave it where God or nature put it”
The Western law-based worldview, including the Greek logos idea of a single rational order, is an invention that produces good outcomes rather than a self-evident way of living.
“the embody that logos which is what that idea is is an invention when it comes to the application of it into the laws it's not a self-evident way of living”
The transition away from carbon will involve significant economic instability when it occurs, and managing that instability is one of the key challenges, as people will delay costly retooling until forced by scarcity.
“there'll be a lot of economic instability it happens when it occurs”
Human civilization is part of the Earth, so it will continue beyond the coming two centuries of carbon crisis in some form, and it is already about 5,000 years old with a future vastly longer than that.
“you can predict with immense confidence that that there will be people around after the crises are all through”
Germany's cap on coal, combined with its nuclear phase-out, implies it must pay Russia more for natural gas, which officials sidestep; Laughlin speculates Russia may be behind energy policy because of its natural gas supply.
“doesn't that mean you're gonna have to pay the Russians more for natural gas and she says that's a problem and then change the subject”
Carbon-based fuel will be needed for aircraft in the long run, so the carbon will have to be extracted from the air or from plants, and this is a near-certain outcome rather than a scenario.
“it's actually more than a scenario going to happen with 100% certainty and the reason why is you can't make airplanes fly without carbon”
Humans are the most adaptable form of life that has ever existed, so people will likely do well under warming even though other species may struggle more, since temperature changes are harder to predict for ecosystems.
“humans are the most adaptable form of life that has ever existed on earth”
Concern about climate is a legitimate question of quality of life on Earth, not of planetary survival: the Earth itself will be fine, but the question of what life will look like for people and other species in the next generations remains open.
“we care more than just about the earth rotating or going around the Sun right so we care about the quality of life on Earth”
Roberts counters that elite universities and open access show knowledge is not stuck: people pay large sums to acquire knowledge, and innovation remains healthy, so the scarcity thesis is incomplete.
“people are paying a great deal of money to acquire knowledge that they presume is useful the pace of innovation is pretty healthy”
Laughlin defers to the IPCC on climate policy and avoids conflict with climate scientists, positioning himself instead as a problem solver focused on energy and resource questions rather than climate science itself.
“I basically want to defer to the IPCC if you want advice about what to do with your economy or what laws to write”