What this covers

This is a single-speaker interview with archaeologist Eric Cline, organized in chapters that move from the interconnected Late Bronze Age world, through its unraveling around 1200 BCE, to what came after and what it might teach. He opens with the economics: none of the eight major civilizations (Mycenaeans, Minoans, Hittites, Assyrians, Babylonians, Egyptians, Cypriots, Canaanites) was self-sufficient, tin for bronze above all. He describes the network as a small world network in which any two parties were at most three hops apart, with diplomatic and marital ties documented in the Amarna archive. He also notes the limits of the sources, since most surviving records are elite and administrative and the other 99 percent of the population goes largely unrecorded.

The middle of the conversation takes on causes. Cline treats the sea peoples as symptoms, migrants driven by famine, rather than the prime mover, though he argues that the Peleset can be traced to Mycenaean Greek origins through pottery. He lays out a polycausal collapse in which a mega-drought of 150 to 300 years, famine attested in Ugarit and Hittite tablets, earthquakes, and plague (including the smallpox death of Ramses V and a possible early quarantine) fed multiplier and domino effects. The more contested turn is his suggestion that internal rebellion against over-exploitative elites may have mattered more than previously thought, citing burned palaces beside standing commoners' houses at Hazor.

The final chapters ask who fared how. The Hittites and southern Levantine Canaanites vanished, Egypt withdrew and fragmented, Assyria and Babylonia rode it out, and the Phoenicians and Cypriots thrived in a way he calls anti-fragile. Cline argues that "dark age" should give way to Iron Age, since the period brought iron metallurgy and alphabetic writing, and he traces Greece's recovery toward Homer and Hesiod. He then turns to the present, drawing supply-chain parallels with tin, using the IPCC's coping, adapting, and transforming categories, and offering seven lessons. These include redundancy, flexibility, innovation, and keeping workers satisfied. He also forecasts that modern civilization will eventually collapse or transform, a claim he presents as a question of when rather than whether.

Sharpest takeaway

The Late Bronze Age collapse around 1200 BCE resulted from multiple simultaneous stressors (drought, famine, earthquakes, disease, migration, and internal instability) acting on an interconnected globalized network, and societies' differential resilience—determined by geography, leadership, innovation capacity, and adaptability—offers lessons for understanding modern systemic collapse risks.

  • Single-cause explanations (like the sea peoples) are insufficient; polycausal 'perfect storm' with multiplier and domino effects better explains the collapse
  • Societies that survived (Phoenicians, Cypriots, Assyrians, Babylonians) demonstrated resilience through innovation, self-sufficiency, strong leadership, and geographic advantages, while rigid societies (Hittites, Mycenaeans) collapsed despite initial power
  • Modern globalized systems face similar vulnerabilities to the Bronze Age network—supply chain interdependence, climate stress, and leadership quality determine whether societies cope, adapt, transform, or collapse

The claims · ranked38 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

The late Bronze Age, lasting from approximately 1700 to 1200 BCE, was characterized by unprecedented globalization around the Mediterranean where all major civilizations maintained direct or indirect contact through a 'small world network' with at most three hops between any two entities

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“This was a time where people were basically globalized around the Mediterranean in a way that is not frequently seen.”

0.80

None of the eight major civilizations of the late Bronze Age (Mycenaeans, Minoans, Hittites, Assyrians, Babylonians, Egyptians, Cypriots, and Canaanites) were self-sufficient; each required raw materials from others, particularly tin for bronze production, making economic interdependence a structural necessity rather than a preference

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“None of the great civilizations, none of the G8, were self-sufficient at that time, and it's important to realize that. They each needed each other.”

0.80

Scribal record-keeping in Bronze Age societies (Linear B, Egyptian hieroglyphics) was primarily administrative, documenting palace inventories and state business, with Linear B tablets notably failing to record international contacts despite archaeological evidence proving such contacts existed, suggesting a gap between documentary and material evidence

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“Linear B... was only being used by the scribes in the palaces to create inventories... they never mention overseas. The linear B never mentions contacts with Egypt or the Hittites, whatever... I know from the archeology that they are in contact.”

0.78

The Bronze Age collapse was not caused by a single factor such as the sea peoples' invasions, but rather resulted from a 'perfect storm' of multiple simultaneous stressors—drought, famine, earthquakes, disease, migration, and internal instability—that created both multiplier and domino effects, where each factor amplified others and disruption in one area cascaded throughout the network

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“There have been a number of other suggestions that scholars have made over the years... In the end, I thought the answer was yes. It's all of the above. It's a perfect storm.”

0.78

The collapse of the late Bronze Age was followed by the emergence of Greece as a distinct civilization: the Mycenaeans were devastated and had to rebuild from ground zero, but by the 8th century BCE (776 BCE, the first Olympic Games), Greek civilization had recovered and was about to produce Homer, Hesiod, Sappho, and the development of classical Greek culture that forms the foundation of Western civilization.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“they had to rebuild from the ground up. They do it successfully, but it takes quite a while. And that's why I end after 1177 BC with 776 BC, which is the first Olympics. And by that point, everything in Greece is back up and running, and we're very quickly going to get them using the new Greek alphabet. We're gonna get Homer, we're gonna get Hesiod, we'll get Sappho, we'll get the Archaic poets and Greece is off to the races.”

0.76

Disease, particularly plague, was a secondary but significant stressor during the Bronze Age collapse: the Hittites experienced a plague brought by Egyptian prisoners of war around 1350 BCE, and Egyptian pharaoh Ramses V (circa 1140 BCE) died of smallpox as documented in the Turin papyrus, which describes a 16-month quarantine period—possibly history's first organized quarantine protocol

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“There was a plague that hit the Hittites earlier, about 150 years before the collapse, back in the time of my favorite Hittite king, Sufi Lulu-Luma I, who ruled about 1350 BC, and we are told by one of his successors that he and most of his immediate family died as the result of a plague that was brought to Anatolia, courtesy of Egyptian prisoners of war”

0.75

Neo-Assyrian and Neo-Babylonian societies maintained continuity of governmental, religious, and writing systems throughout the collapse, suggesting that geographic isolation (inland position relative to sea peoples, access to Tigris-Euphrates irrigation limiting drought impact), existing bureaucratic infrastructure, and strong succession planning allowed them to 'ride out' the collapse with minimal disruption

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Cline

“The Assyrians and the Babylonians... they are better than the Egyptians... They didn't do as well as the Phoenicians and the Cypriots who I would give a gold star rating to... but they have survived the collapse, pretty much intact.”

0.74

A 'systems collapse' occurs when a complex civilization's core components—centralized government, elite structure, trade networks, writing systems, and monumental architecture—simultaneously fail, typically followed by a 'dark age' (now more accurately called the Iron Age) lasting 200-400 years during which populations revert to lower socioeconomic and political organization before eventually rebuilding

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“You've got your central economy collapses, your upper elite, the 1% go away. You've got the government, the centralized government collapses. You have all these hallmarks of what had made your society so vibrant and thriving, they now all go away.”

0.74

Diplomatic and marital ties between Bronze Age G8 leaders (particularly documented in the Amarna archive) show that international relations, alliances, and treaty renegotiations upon succession were routine administrative functions, making the sudden cessation of diplomatic contacts one of the hallmarks of collapse

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“We've got the archive there of his records and his father, Amenhotep III, writing to these kings. And we can see whenever there's a new king over in Mitanni... or a new king in Babylonia, they had to renegotiate the treaties with the Egyptian pharaohs and with those renegotiations came the new marriages.”

0.74

Famine followed directly on the heels of the drought in the late Bronze Age, evidenced by cuneiform tablets from Ugarit (dated around 2016 in French, later in English) that explicitly state 'there is famine in our city, please send us help,' and by Hittite tablets from Anatolia dating as early as 1250 BCE requesting grain relief from Egypt.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“There have been tablets that have been published fairly recently, like in 2016 in French. And then a couple of years later in English, in which they say there is famine in our city, please send us help. I mean, they come right out and say it.”

0.73

The sea peoples were not the primary cause of the Bronze Age collapse but rather were symptoms of it: they were migrants fleeing drought and famine in their origin regions (likely Western Mediterranean, northern Italy), driven by starvation to seek new lands, and while they did attack Eastern Mediterranean sites, they were as much victims of systemic collapse as perpetrators

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Eric Cline

“I kind of agree with my colleagues who have suggested that they were as much victims as they were oppressors, and that they're more like a symptom of what's happening than they were the cause of it.”

0.73

Internal rebellion and class conflict may have been a more significant driver of Bronze Age collapse than previously recognized: over-exploitation of lower classes by elites created internal instability where commons might have welcomed palace destruction, with evidence including burning of palaces while commoners' houses remained standing (e.g., Hazor) and possible deliberate refusal to support elite military efforts

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Eric Cline

“It might have been internal rebellion by the locals rising up, precisely because they're starving, because there's no water, there's no food, anything like that.”

0.73

The collapse was not uniform across all societies: some completely disappeared (Hittites, Canaanites in southern Levant), some merely coped or adapted minimally (Egypt, Mycenaeans), some transformed successfully (Phoenicians, Cypriots, Assyrians, Babylonians), and some emerged as entirely new political entities (Hebrew kingdoms, Greek city-states), making it incorrect to speak of 'the collapse' as a single phenomenon affecting all societies equally

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“The Hittites do not [survive]... The Egyptians while they don't do well, they do muddle through... The Phoenicians... are among the people that do the best... So we actually, we need to be specific here and differentiate between the different societies as to how well they did or didn't do.”

0.72

The Iron Age (formerly called the 'dark age') was an era of innovation and invention, not regression, with the development of iron metallurgy and alphabetic writing making it intellectually dishonest to call it a 'dark age'—the term should be replaced with 'Iron Age' to reflect the actual character of the period

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“One of my colleagues has said that any age that sees the invention of iron and the standardization of the alphabet cannot be considered to be a dark age.”

0.69

The IPCC framework identifies three levels of response to systemic crisis: coping (short-term survival until tomorrow), adapting (medium-term adjustments for weeks or months ahead), and transforming (fundamental systemic change to prevent recurrence), with transformation being the most resilient but most difficult response

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Eric Cline

“There are basically three things you can do. You can either just try to survive until tomorrow, which basically means that you're coping, right? You're trying to make it until the sun comes up again. But you could also do a little bit more. You could adapt... But they also said there's a third thing... they said that's the top of the heap, basically.”

0.68

The Egyptians adopted a survival strategy of partial withdrawal from international involvement during the 12th-11th centuries BCE (the Third Intermediate Period), during which political fragmentation (up to four competing pharaohs in different regions) reduced their international influence but allowed domestic resource concentration, suggesting retreat and consolidation as an alternative to outward-facing resilience

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Cline

“Egypt is supposed to be one king, one ruler, one country... we've got not just one, not just two, but three, and sometimes even four, people all saying that they are the pharaoh of Egypt at the same time, but in different areas of Egypt.”

0.66

A mega-drought lasting 150 to 300 years, evidenced by stalagmite growth cessation, dried-up lakes and riverbeds, and pollen analysis showing increasingly arid plant species, occurred from approximately 1200-1250 BCE to 850-900 BCE across the entire Mediterranean and Near East region, with multiple independent data sources confirming the phenomenon

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“It's a mega drought. It's 150 years at the minimum and 300 years at the maximum. So say from 1200 BC or 1250 BC down to 900 or 850 BC, I mean, it's a long, long, long time.”

0.66

Most historical records from the Bronze Age derive from elite/scribal sources (the '1%'), documenting kings and central authorities, while the experiences of 99% of populations (farmers, peasants, commoners) remain largely unknown until recent archaeological excavation of villages and small settlements across the Bronze-Iron Age transition

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“Most of our records are from the 1%. They're from the elite. We know how the kings did and the central authorities... We don't know as much about the 99% if you wanna call them that, about the farmers and the peasants out in the fields in Messinia in Greece or the Hinterlands in Anatolia.”

0.62

Modern global society will eventually collapse or transform dramatically, not as an open question but as a certainty that has happened to every civilization in history; the question is not 'whether' but 'when,' with possible timeframes ranging from weeks to decades, and the degree of preparedness will determine whether societies are fragile, vulnerable, or anti-fragile in the aftermath

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Eric Cline

“Every society in the history of humankind has either collapsed eventually completely or has transformed so much that they're almost unrecognizable in their new form. And to say that that's not gonna happen to us, I think is just foolish, hubristic for sure.”

0.60

The Phoenicians and Cypriots were 'anti-fragile' in the Bronze Age collapse, meaning they actually flourished in conditions that devastated others by taking advantage of the disruption of competitors' trade networks, with the Phoenicians spreading across the Mediterranean and becoming the dominant maritime traders once Ugarit and Egyptian naval power declined

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“I would put the Cypriots and the Phoenicians in the top category. They not only transform, but they're actually anti-fragile. Now, this is a phrase that Nicholas Nassim Taleb has used... what he says is that anti-fragile is something that actually flourishes in an age of chaos.”

0.60

The Peleset (Philistines) mentioned in Egyptian records as invaders around 1177 BCE are identifiable as Mycenaean Greeks based on archaeological pottery evidence (Philistine pottery appears to be degenerate Mycenaean style made with local Levantine clay), suggesting that at least one 'sea peoples' group can be traced to a specific origin

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“The Peleset are the Philistines... It really looks like they are Mycenaeans from Greece who have fled Greece and come over to the Eastern Mediterranean because Philistine pottery looks like degenerate Mycenaean.”

0.59

Modern supply chain vulnerabilities parallel Bronze Age trade dependencies: tin was to the Bronze Age what oil/lithium is to modern civilization—the loss of tin supply routes crippled bronze production; the COVID-19 pandemic revealed similar fragility when supply chain disruptions led to shortages of computers, cars, and microwave components; and a 2008 Wall Street financial crisis occurring simultaneously with COVID in 2020 would likely have triggered societal collapse.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Eric Cline

“tin back then has been compared to oil today, petroleum gasoline, and their need for tin back then is much like our oil today... If something happens to the supply chain and we are not able to get that, I mean, and remember what happened during the pandemic, during COVID, which wasn't that long ago, that we had such supply chain issues, and all of a sudden there was problems getting everything from computers to cars.”

0.58

Seven practical lessons for modern resilience emerge from Bronze Age collapse analysis: (1) implement redundant systems across critical functions; (2) maintain military capacity to resist invasion; (3) know and maintain alliances; (4) remain flexible and avoid rigid adherence to tradition; (5) balance self-sufficiency with alliance interdependence; (6) prioritize innovation and invention during crisis; (7) keep working classes satisfied to prevent internal rebellion

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Cline

“You need to have redundant systems in place. We talk about that all the time today, but I think it's incredibly important... Be strong enough to resist invasion if you can. Know who your friends are and who they aren't... be resilient enough to go with the flow as you need to be.”

0.54

Knowledge of historical collapse patterns is practically useful for navigating present-day crises and future challenges: 'you need to know the past to deal with the present and go into the future. Otherwise, we're just doomed to repeat the past again and again,' and the alternative to repeating history is to learn from patterns of resilience and adaptive response.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“If we're willing to listen and to learn from the past, then we can deal with what's happening in the present and that will affect our future. So you need to know the past, to deal with the present and go into the future. Otherwise, we're just doomed to repeat the past again and again and again.”

0.52

Preparedness for collapse can take tangible forms including: preparing for extreme weather events (mega-droughts, intense hurricanes) even if they don't materialize (so the preparation itself is not costly); carefully managing water resources and monitoring water scarcity; shifting away from tin-equivalent dependencies (like lithium for modern electronics) by developing alternative materials and supply chains in advance.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Cline

“prepare for extreme weather events, because then if they come, like intense hurricanes, then you're prepared. And if they don't come, what have you lost? Not much.”

0.52

Computer modeling of Bronze Age network collapse, conducted with the US Army Corps of Engineers, identified only two scenarios that would completely collapse the entire globalized network: (1) simultaneous collapse of Egypt and the Hittites, or (2) simultaneous collapse of Ugarit and the Hittites, suggesting these nodes were disproportionately critical to network stability

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Eric Cline

“After I published 1177 BC, I was approached and got together with colleagues from the US Army Corps of Engineers and we ran scenarios through a computer trying to figure out which of the G8 or others in which order would it have taken for them to fall to collapse the whole network.”

0.48

The Hittites completely disappeared as a political entity and empire; they had internal schisms in the royal family, their capital Hattusa was abandoned even before the final collapse, and even though they were the world's second superpower before the collapse, they are the only one of the four major river-based empires (Egypt, Assyria, Babylon, Hittites) without major river access, which Cline argues was not coincidental to their complete failure

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Eric Cline

“The last category, that's the Hittites. Don't be a Hittite. The Hittites do not do well at all, in part 'cause they've already got internal problems. We know that there was a schism in the royal family and that one part moved. We also know that the Hittite capital city, Hattusa, was actually already abandoned before the end came.”

0.48

The post-collapse Iron Age saw the emergence of the Phoenician alphabet as a standardized, exportable writing system that spread throughout the Mediterranean and became the ancestor of Greek and Latin scripts—this was not an invention but a rationalization and dissemination of a pre-existing concept, yet the standardization and commercialization by Phoenician traders had civilizational significance.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“The Phoenicians standardize the alphabet. They don't invent it, it's already been around, but they standardize it, they bring it over to Greece and they bring it over to Italy, and it becomes the Greek alphabet and it becomes the Latin alphabet, which we're still using today.”

0.48

Shishak (pharaoh of the 22nd dynasty, likely Libyan in origin) represents a post-collapse high point for Egypt, successfully campaigning into Israel and Judah and attempting to recreate Egypt's imperial power, suggesting that even Egypt's diminished Iron Age state maintained ambitions for regional dominance

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“One of the pharaohs, a guy named Shishak, Shishak of the Bible, probably. He's Libyan, he's the founder of the 22nd dynasty. And he actually tries to recreate the good old days, leaves us an inscription where he went up to Israel and Judah and campaigned up there.”

0.48

The trade in luxury goods (solid gold daggers inlaid with lapis lazuli, leather shoes from Crete to Babylon) between Bronze Age rulers demonstrates elite-level commercial networks distinct from mercantile trade, indicating status competition and gifting protocols that linked geopolitical relationships to material exchange

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“We have what we call gift giving at the highest elite levels. And then we've got commercial mercantile stuff at slightly lower levels... we're talking about solid gold daggers inlaid with Lapis lazuli. These are obviously things that the kings are giving each other.”

0.48

Ramses III's inscription stating 'I settled them in strongholds bound in my name' regarding the defeated sea peoples suggests that he incorporated some foreign invaders into Egyptian military/administrative structure rather than executing them, indicating either pragmatic force recruitment or assimilation policy

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“Ramses III says, 'I settled them in strongholds bound in my name.' Meaning he settled the defeated sea peoples in Egypt and in the region of southern Canaan, which the Egyptians controlled at that time.”

0.44

Archaeological evidence from destroyed Late Bronze Age sites includes weapons (arrowheads in walls), mass casualties (bodies in streets), and destruction patterns (collapsed buildings, charred remains), distinguishing between destructions caused by human siege warfare versus natural disasters like earthquakes (where bodies are buried under collapsed walls rather than surrounded by weapons)

definitionestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“There are bodies in the streets, there are arrowheads embedded in the walls... Sometimes it's obvious. I mean, if you find bodies in the streets with arrowheads sticking out of them, it's probably humans and not an earthquake.”

0.43

Diplomatic and political ties in the late Bronze Age were cemented through marital exchanges where Great Kings married off their daughters to each other, but notably this practice was not reciprocal—Egyptian pharaohs like Amenhotep III and Akhenaten received princesses from Mitanni, Babylon, and other kingdoms but did not send Egyptian princesses in return.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Eric Cline

“when the great kings, the G8, when they sign treaties with each other, when they made diplomatic advances, frequently they would marry each other's daughters to cement the treaties... Amenhotep III and Akhenaten, the two pharaohs of Egypt in the 14th century BC, they each had multiple wives in their harems who were the daughters of the other kings... The one thing that's interesting is it was not reciprocal. The Egyptians did not send their princesses to the others.”

0.41

Discoveries in biblical archaeology are continuously updating understanding of the Iron Age emergence of Israel, Judah, and other Levantine kingdoms, and Cline expects new archaeological findings every week, month, and year to fine-tune how societies are ranked in terms of their post-collapse resilience, making archaeology a living, constantly-evolving discipline

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“I think that the new discoveries that we're making every day, every week, every month, every year, especially in biblical archeology, are going to get us to alter things just like we've altered. Now what we think caused the late Bronze Age collapse will be able to fine tune how everybody did in the aftermath.”

0.40

The North Anatolian fault line has produced repeated earthquake sequences since the 1930s in modern Turkey, demonstrating that the region is currently seismically active, supporting the interpretation that similar earthquake storms could have occurred in antiquity and contributed to Bronze Age destruction patterns

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Eric Cline

“We see that today. It's been happening across Turkey since like the 1930s.”

0.39

Egyptian cross-breeding of cattle to favor Zebu breeds (which thrive in arid conditions) during the Late Bronze Age represents an adaptive response to recognized drought stress, suggesting that ancient elites had some environmental awareness and attempted technological adaptation even during the crisis period

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Eric Cline

“The Egyptians, for example, were trying to cross-breed their cattle. Their normal cattle was Zebu or Zebu cattle who thrive better in arid conditions.”

0.27

The fall of the Roman Empire occurred approximately 1500 years after the Bronze Age collapse, and another 1500 years have passed since Rome's fall, suggesting a potential cyclical pattern of civilizational collapse at roughly millennium-and-a-half intervals, though Cline acknowledges that 'history rhymes but does not repeat' and warns against deterministic assumptions

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Eric Cline

“There was about 1500 years between the collapse of the late Bronze Age and the fall of the Roman Empire. And it's been about another 1500 years since the Roman Empire fell... And so I'm not saying that we're necessarily do for another collapse, but history does rhyme even if it doesn't repeat.”

0.25

Some scholars have argued that the large empires of the Bronze Age were 'a failed experiment,' suggesting that smaller city-states and kingdoms are the natural or preferred political scale, but Cline disagrees, noting that the Bronze Age system survived for 500 years, which is 'pretty good' even if it ultimately failed

normativespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Eric Cline

“Some scholars have suggested that maybe that's more than natural order of things, to have smaller city-states and smaller kingdoms and that the empires of the Late Bronze Age were, as one person has put it, a failed experiment that they tried and it didn't work all that well. I think I would disagree with that. I mean, that system survived for 500 years. I think that was pretty good, but it has no place now in the aftermath and we get all of these smaller city-states that are now flourishing.”