What this covers

This is the opening statement from the 2009 Intelligence Squared debate on whether the Catholic Church is a force for good in the world, delivered by Christopher Hitchens alone, in about twenty minutes. He builds his case around the Church's own record of apology. Pope John Paul II made dozens of public acknowledgments, covering the slave trade, Galileo, torture during the Counter Reformation, silence during the Holocaust, and the burning of Jan Hus. Hitchens finds them hollow. He points to the phrase "some Christians" as an Evasive Euphemism for official policy, and to Bishop Piero Marini's remark that, given twenty centuries of sins, the Jubilee apology had to be "rather summary."

The historical range is wide. He covers the sack of Constantinople in 1204 and the anathema on Orthodox Christians, which was not lifted until 1964, and the charge of deicide against Jews, which stood as doctrine until the same year. He then turns to fascism: the Lateran Pact with Mussolini, the concordat with Adolf Hitler, the priest Tiso in Slovakia, Croatia's Ustashe, Franco, and Salazar. He also raises the Church's role in Rwanda.

The most pointed material is recent and contentious. Cardinal Bernard Law was moved to Rome rather than prosecuted, which left him eligible to vote in the 2005 conclave. Pope Joseph Ratzinger readmitted the Holocaust-denying bishop Roger Williamson. Hitchens also attacks the claim that abuse stems from homosexuals in the priesthood, and he condemns the teaching on condoms in Africa, the doctrine of limbo, and the Church's treatment of gay people under the line "hate the sin, love the sinner." Underneath these specifics he locates one cause: a belief in divine warrant, a Mandate of Heaven, to dictate how people live. He ends with a call for a world in which no one claims infallibility.

Sharpest takeaway

Hitchens argues the Catholic Church cannot claim moral authority because it refuses to genuinely apologize for systematic institutional crimes—child abuse, complicity with fascism, anti-Semitism, and harmful doctrines—instead offering evasive euphemisms that preserve the underlying belief in its divine right to dictate morality.

  • The Church's apologies are evasive and euphemistic, preserving the core doctrine that justifies the crimes
  • Institutional child abuse, covered up and enabled by Vatican appointments, demonstrates ongoing moral failure
  • The Church's doctrines on contraception, homosexuality, and indulgences cause measurable harm while claiming divine warrant

The claims · ranked31 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.78

Anti-Semitism was preached as official doctrine of the Church until 1964, teaching that Jewish people were collectively accused of deicide—the crime of murdering God in the figure of Jesus—and this anathema was not lifted until well after the Holocaust perpetrators had stood trial in secular courts.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“anti-Semitism was preached as an official doctrine of the church until 1964 do you think that might have something to do with public opinion in Austria and Bavaria and Poland and Lithuania that the the Jewish people were accused collectively as a people of deide of the crime of the murder of God in the figure of Jesus of Nazareth and that that anathema on them was not lifted until' 64 well after the uh perpetrators of the Holocaust had stood trial in secular courts and been rightly punished for their actions”

0.78

Pope John Paul II made 94 public recognitions of appalling crime, error, cruelty, and stupidity by the Church, including apologies for the African slave trade in 1995, admission that Galileo was right in 1992, legalized torture during the Counter Reformation in 1995, silence during the Holocaust in 1999, and the burning alive of Jan Hus in Prague.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“it followed no less than 94 94 count them uh public recognitions on his part of appalling crime and error and cruelty and stupidity and defenses to the free intelligence ranging from I shall be summary like Bishop Marini the African slave trade apologized for in 1995 uh the admission that Galileo was right about the relationship between the Sun and the Earth and other orbs which came in 1992 one might add no I won't say it's too easy to say better late than never here I said it to violence and torture legalized torture torture was legalized and institutionalized by the Roman pontiff during The Counter Reformation that came in 1995 um and for silence during Hitler's final solution or shower as well as in 1999”

0.74

Cardinal Bernard Law, the Archbishop of Boston who covered up and protected priests who committed crimes against children, was not prosecuted but was instead personally appointed by the Pope to an important position in Rome and was therefore eligible to vote in the 2005 papal conclave, making him a fugitive from justice voting on who the next Vicar of Christ would be.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“where is Cardinal Bernard law now where is he where is the Cardinal Archbishop of Boston whose resignation was indignantly demanded finally by 50 members of the church and by the whole Ley of Massachusetts who also demanded his prosecution for the promotion and protection and covering up and uh apology for and defense of uh people whose crimes against children are too revolting to specify and he's not in the jurisdiction of Massachusetts now as perhaps you know he's the Supreme Vicor of the Church of Santa Maria maor in Rome personally appointed by the pope to that as well as many other important syur and in 2005 this man a fugitive from Justice and from and from complicity in the filthiest crime that it's possible for a human being to imagine was one of those voting in conclave to decide who the next vicer of Christ on Earth will be”

0.74

Tiso, head of the Nazi puppet state in Slovakia, was a priest in holy orders, demonstrating direct Church involvement in fascist governance.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“the fact that father Teo head of the Nazi puppet state in Slovakia was a priest in holy orders”

0.74

The German Catholic Church asked Hitler's birthday to be celebrated from the pulpit every year until he died.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“the German church should have asked Hitler's birthday to be celebrated from the pulpit every year until he died”

0.74

Child abuse, covered up and protected by the Church, is 'the crime that cries out for punishment' and 'the one thing that if we were accused of on this side of the house we would die rather than admit and if we were guilty of it we would kill ourselves,' yet the Church has decided to excuse itself for this under the current papacy.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“and it's the crime that cries out for punishment it's the thing that if we were accused of on this side of the house we would die rather than admit and if we were guilty of it we'd kill ourselves and it's the one thing the church has decided to excuse itself for under this papacy”

0.73

The Church's teaching that AIDS is bad but condoms are immoral is responsible for the death and suffering and misery of millions of Africans, and this should be apologized for directly.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Christopher Hitchens

“staying in Africa I think it will one day be admitted with shame that it might have been in error to say that aids is bad as a disease very bad but not quite as bad as condoms are bad or not as immoral in the same way I say it I say it in the presence of his grace and I say it to his face the preachings of his church are responsible for the death and suffering and misery of millions of his brother and sister Africans and he should apologize for it”

0.71

The Fourth Crusade resulted in the sack of Constantinople and massacre of Byzantine Christianity in April 1204, and the anathema on all Eastern Orthodox Christians as unbelievers, heretics, and people dwelling outside the health of the church was not lifted until 1964.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“the papacy's also asked to be forgiven for the sack of Constantinople and the massacre of Byzantine Christianity in April 124 as part of The Fourth Crusade the anathema on all Eastern Orthodox Christians as unbelievers Heretics and people dwelling outside the health of the church was lifted only in 1964”

0.69

Hitchens notes that responses claiming child abuse would not have happened if homosexuals hadn't been allowed in the Church are 'hideously false' and that homosexuality in the Church is an 'old story' that is worse than pornography and worse than bad language on TV.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Christopher Hitchens

“the rape and torture of children is not something to be relativized it's not something to be excused as a few bad priests it's certainly not to be excused by the hideously false claim made by some Catholic conservatives that this wouldn't have happened if queers hadn't been allowed into the church sorry to say that quom in the church is an old story too um and it's worse it's much worse than pornography and it's much worse than bad language on TV”

0.69

In the Jubilee Millennium year of 2000, the Vatican spokesman Bishop Piero Marini said explaining a sermon of apology given by the Pope that was supposed to cover the entire history of the church, that given the number of sins committed in the course of 20 centuries, reference to them must necessarily be rather summary.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Christopher Hitchens

“the Vatican spokesman Bishop P Marini said explaining a whole sermon of apology given by his Holiness the Pope that was supposed to cover the entire history of the church in its Jubilee year that I'll quote uh Bishop Marini directly said given the number of sins we've committed in the course of 20th centuries reference to two them must necessarily be rather summary”

0.66

The Church's complicity with fascist regimes extended to Croatia's Ustashe state and General Franco's regime and Salazar's regime, all operating under full clerical protection and disguise.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“the Croatian fascist puppet state the ustaria state of anti pavich was also operating Under full clerical protection and disguise as was the regime of General Franco and the dictator Antonio Salazar”

0.66

The Church has covered up rape and torture of orphans and other children in church-run schools in almost every country on Earth, from Ireland to Australia.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“there are smaller but significant um equally significant avowals of a very bad conscience these have included uh regret for the rape and the torture of Orphans and other children in church run schools in almost every country on Earth from Ireland to Australia”

0.66

The only hope for the human species lies in the unfettered intelligence, the method of free inquiry in philosophy and science, and the refusal to admit that any one person can tell you not to do that, and the Church has always stood and still stands against this essential principle.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“behind all these crimes and miseries is the denial of what we on this side of the house affirm which is the only little candle of hope that our species does possess our our poor bare forked primate mamalian species of whom you have two such Splendid examples on this side of the house and not bad on the other tonight um is the is the unfettered in intelligence the method of free inquiry in philosophy and in science and the the refusal to admit that any one person can tell you not to do that it's the one thing I might say I think is if not sacran or sacred is shall we say essential and the church has always stood and still stands against it”

0.66

The Vatican made a concordat with Adolf Hitler—his first treaty ever signed—giving the Church a monopoly over education in Germany in exchange for dissolution of the Catholic Center party, allowing the Nazi party a clear run.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“I would like them to take back the concordat made with Adolf Hitler the first treaty he ever signed giving the church a monopoly over education in Germany in exchange for the dis dissolution of the Catholic Center party to give the Nazi party a clear run”

0.61

Roger Williamson, readmitted as a bishop by Pope Joseph Ratzinger after being excommunicated, is a member of the Society of St Pius X, denies the Holocaust occurred, and believes 'the Jews did Kill Christ,' and Pope Ratzinger prioritized Church unity over these positions.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Christopher Hitchens

“the readmission as a bishop of Roger Williamson a member of Marcel Le's F fanatical hysterical Breakaway sect so-called Society of St pus I 10th Roger Williamson found hiding in a reactionary quasi fascistic establishment in Argentina has long been a believer that I'll put this shortly that the Holocaust did not occur but the Jews did Kill Christ in otherwise in other words genocide no decide yes he was quite rightly excommunicated some years ago along with several other members of his rat bag organization but Joseph ratzingers invited him back in to the communion because to him having this man this liar this fraud This Racist in the church is more important because it's Church Unity than the things that he said and done”

0.61

Stephen Fry is condemned by the Church not for his actions but for his nature—his homosexuality—and the Church uses the casuistry that it 'hates the sin and loves the sinner' while actually rejecting people based on their essential nature rather than their conduct.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Christopher Hitchens

“for condemning my friend stepen Stephen Fry for his nature for saying for saying you couldn't be a member of our church you're born in sin there's a revolting piece of casuistry that's sometimes offered on this point yeah we hate the sin only we love the sinner Steven is I'm sorry to say not quite like other girls it's his nature actually he is like other girls in that in that he's when I last checked absolutely boy mad um he's not being condemned for what he does he's being condemned for what he is you're a child made in the image of God oh no you're not you're a [ __ ] and you can't join your church and you can't go to heaven”

0.61

The Church should apologize for its role in Rwanda, the most Catholic country in Africa, where priests and nuns and bishops are on trial for inciting from their pulpits and on the church's radio stations and newspapers the massacre of their brothers and sisters, and the papacy was silent on this appalling occasion.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Christopher Hitchens

“I think that there will be an apology for what happened in Rwanda the most Catholic country in Africa one of the most Catholic countries in the world um where priests and nuns and Bishops are on trial for inciting from their pulpits and on the church's radio stations and newspapers the massacre of their brothers and sisters uh and the papacy was silent on this appalling occasion and everyone in Rwanda knows it and there hasn't yet been a properly written apology for that disgrace”

0.60

50 members of the Church and the whole state legislature of Massachusetts demanded Cardinal Law's resignation and prosecution for his covering up of crimes against children.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“whose resignation was indignantly demanded finally by 50 members of the church and by the whole Ley of Massachusetts”

0.60

The Vatican made the Lateran Pact with Mussolini, which was the first treaty ever signed by that fascist dictator.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“I'd apolog for The latan Pact with musolini myself also the first treaty ever signed by that fascist dictator”

0.59

The fundamental problem underlying all of the Church's crimes is that it believes it possesses a truth that others do not and has a God-given right and Mandate of Heaven to tell people what to do in both their public and private lives, and until this belief is changed, the crimes and miseries will continue to be repeated, partially denied, and covered up.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“how is an apology possible how is any understanding or undertaking or firm purpose of amendment to be allowed when the original sin so to say the radics malorum the fs at orgo the problem in the first place is the belief on the part of this church that it does possess a truth that we don't have and it does have a god-given right a warrant a Mandate of Heaven to tell other people what to do not just in their public but in their private lives and until that is changed till that fantastic and Sinister and nonfounders will go on repeating themselves being partially denied partially admitted when it's too late to do anything else and covered up”

0.59

The stimulus to crime and the impetus to crime lies in the belief that a Divine warrant entitles you to do whatever you like, and this belief in certainty and divine authorization is the sin that must be cancelled, annealed, and apologized for.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“the stimulus to Crime the impetus to crime the belief in certainty the the belief that a Divine warrant entitles you to do whatever you like is the sin that must be that must be cancelled that must be annealed that must somehow be uh apologized for”

0.56

The human species' dignity and intelligence demands that we reach a state of affairs where no one on Earth claims to be infallible, which Hitchens describes as something that should become permanent rather than temporary.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“if the human species is to rise to the full height that's demanded by its dignity and by its intelligence we must all of us move to a state of affairs where that condition is permanent and I think we should get on with it”

0.54

The Church's doctrine of limbo—St. Augustine's solution to what he saw as the fate of unbaptized children—is a 'cruel and stupid' doctrine that caused torture 'sometimes worse than the physical' by teaching Catholic parents that unbaptized children go to limbo.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Christopher Hitchens

“I'm pleased to see that due reconsideration ation is now being given and May in fact have been given to the hellish I choose the word carefully doctrine of limbo St Augustine's uh cruel and stupid disposal problem solution to a non-existent problem that is to say the destination of the souls of unbaptized children up until now Catholic parents have been taught that's where their unbaptized children went a form of torture that's sometimes worse than the physical”

0.52

The Catholic Church's apologies use the evasive euphemism 'some Christians' when discussing the Crusades, Inquisitions, and anti-Semitic pogroms, as if these were individual moral failures rather than official Church doctrine and policy, which allows the Church to deny responsibility for systematic wrongdoing.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Christopher Hitchens

“the same euphemism comes in the term some Christians that is used in all the apologies about the the Crusades the inquisitions uh the anti-semitic prgrams and all the rest of it it say some Christians fell into error some Christians allowed themselves to be to be uh uh deceived in this way and to act against the gospel well anti-Semitism was preached as an official doctrine of the church until 1964”

0.48

The Catholic Church is restoring the Latin Mass to gratify fascistic followers of Archbishop Lefebvre and is reviving the sale of indulgences, offering remission of sin and purgatory to youth festival attendees, which is the same temptation offered during the Fourth Crusade that led to massacre of Jews.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Christopher Hitchens

“finally under this Pope as if it wasn't bad enough to try and restore for the Latin Mass to gratify the mad fascistic followers of Archbishop lefel uh but to begin again to offer remission of sin as Cardinal as Bishop ratzinger the pope I'll call him the pope for's sake uh wants to do if you come to a Catholic Youth Festival in syy Australia where I just was you'll get a certain remission from purgatory or hell it may be temporary if you come a lot and you give a lot you'll get possibly permanent remission from the Eternal punishment that they don't know any more about than you and I do this is the sale of indulgences blatantly openly of it's the same Temptation that was offered to those who set off on that Fourth Crusade that's just been apologized for and killed all the Jews of Europe on their way”

0.48

In response to institutional rape and torture of children in Catholic institutions, Pope Ratzinger said 'it's a very severe crisis which involves us' but only recommended applying 'the most loving pastoral care' to the victims, which Hitchens argues is not accepting responsibility in any adult sense.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Christopher Hitchens

“one of the few he's made on the institutionalization of rape and torture and maltreatment of children in Catholic institutions he said it's a very severe crisis which which involves us he said in the following in the need for applying to these victims the most loving pastoral care well I'm sorry they've already had that and to say that this is the responsibility laid upon you by the the horrific admission that you've already had to make is not accepting responsibility in any adult sense”

0.43

Pope Joseph Ratzinger defended Indians massacred during forced conversion in Brazil by saying 'nonetheless it must be remembered that before we came to convert them they were silently awaiting the arrival of the church,' which Hitchens characterizes as a non-genuine apology.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Christopher Hitchens

“Joseph ratzinger the current pope considered by some by Catholics to be the Vicor of Christ on Earth says of Indians of the Indians who were massacred in the course of conversion in Brazil after the apology had been made to them he said nonetheless it must be remembered that before we came to convert them they were silently awaiting the arrival of the church I don't think that's a very genuine kind of apology”

0.26

Archbishop Lefebvre's Society of Saint Pius X is described as a 'fanatical hysterical Breakaway sect' that represents a 'reactionary quasi-fascistic establishment.'

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Christopher Hitchens

“the readmission as a bishop of Roger Williamson a member of Marcel Le's F fanatical hysterical Breakaway sect so-called Society of St pus I 10th...found hiding in a reactionary quasi fascistic establishment in Argentina”

0.26

Pope John Paul II was 'a very impressive and serious human being,' according to Hitchens, despite the Church's historical crimes.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Christopher Hitchens

“that followed a whole series of preceding apologies or apologies I would say of a Kind made by the late Pope John Paul who it troubles me not at all to say was a very impressive and serious human being”

0.26

Hitchens lives in a country where the Pope's reign and authority don't run and the Church cannot burn, silence, or censor him, and therefore he does not wish ill upon the Pope out of fear for his safety.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Christopher Hitchens

“I can forgive even that CU I live in a country where their reign doesn't run their RIT doesn't apply and they can't burn me and silence me and sensor me any more than they can tell my wife that she can't use contraception or any more than they can really tell Steven that he's a beast um so I'm not I don't at all look forward to the death of uh of Joseph ratzinger”

0.21

During papal vacancies, there is a 'delicious Lucid interlude' where there is no one on Earth claiming to be infallible, which Hitchens finds satisfying.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Christopher Hitchens

“except for one tiny reason which I ought to confess and share with you when he dies there's quite a long interval till the conclave can meet maybe Cardinal law will still be on it to pick another Pope sometimes it goes on for months till they get the white smoke and for that whole time that whole interval it's a delicious Lucid interlude there isn't anyone on Earth who claims to be infallible isn't that nice”