
A History of Philosophy | 02 The Moral Universe in the Pre-Socractics
What this covers
This lecture, from a Wheaton College history of philosophy series, is delivered by a philosophy instructor, with a professor of philosophy contributing some remarks. It starts from the literary background of early Greek thought and then moves through the presocratic thinkers. Greek poetry was the basis of Greek education, so the lecture treats the epics and tragedies as the natural context for the philosophers, rather than the natural environment or contact with foreign cultures, a point flagged as contested. The lecture traces a shift from the capricious gods and impersonal fate of Homer's Iliad, where heroic honor matters more than justice, to the Odyssey's interest in justice, then to Zeus and his daughter Dike in Hesiod, the Oresteia's move from blood feud to law, and Antigone's appeal to an unwritten law above the king's edicts.
The philosophers are then read against that background. Anaximander describes generation and destruction as things paying penalty to one another for injustice, "according to the assessment of time." Pythagoras finds mathematical balance of opposites in nature and founds a community built on the same harmony. Heraclitus contrasts the shared, lawful world of the waking with the private worlds of sleepers, and he criticizes Homer and Hesiod. Xenophanes attacks the gods' human vices and proposes a single rational, immaterial god. Anaxagoras has everything containing a portion of everything, ordered by nous, which comes close to a transcendent principle. The lecture also glosses logos as measure, harmony, and rational order, and it stresses that these thinkers imagined an immanent principle of order rather than a Judeo-Christian creator. It describes a parallel among macrocosm, city-state, and microcosm of individual life, each understood as law-governed.
The contested turns are the rejection of Aristotle's picture of the presocratics as pre-scientific speculators about nature, and the portrayal of Democritus as the counterpoint. His cosmos is a chance vortex of atoms with no purpose, and his ethics is hedonistic, though tempered by moderation because excess brings pain. The lecture closes by arguing that these thinkers staked out later alternatives: empiricism against rationalism, materialism against its opponents, and hedonism against an ethics of moral law.
The presocratic philosophers should be understood not as pre-scientific thinkers speculating about nature, but as ethical thinkers developing the concept of cosmic justice—the idea that the universe is fundamentally ordered by moral law, which manifests in nature, society, and individual life.
- The presocratic concept of cosmic justice emerges from and extends Greek literary predecessors like Homer, Hesiod, and the tragic poets who portrayed moral order as inherent to the universe
- Key presocratic thinkers (Anaximander, Pythagoras, Heraclitus, Anaxagoras) apply moral language and concepts to natural processes, revealing they saw an isomorphic relationship between cosmic order, political order, and individual moral life
- Democritus represents the alternative worldview—a purely mechanistic, materialistic cosmos with no inherent order or purpose—making the cosmic justice thesis the defining philosophical divide of the presocratic period
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Greek literary predecessors of the presocratics—specifically Homer, Hesiod, and the Greek tragic poets—established the notion of cosmic justice, a moral universe in which justice will prevail, which the presocratic philosophers then extended and developed further.
“in their own Greek predecessors you see uh in Greek uh literature and um this is what I want to pursue this afternoon...in the predecessors of the pre socratics uh the literary predecessors of the presocratic that's a notion that you get and I'm I'm suggesting you see that um the presocratic stand in continuity with these predecessors in pushing further the emerging idea of cosmic Justice”
Anaximander claims that coming-to-be and passing-away (generation and destruction) of existing things happen according to necessity, and things pay penalty and retribution to each other for their injustice according to the assessment of time, applying moral language to natural processes.
“the source of coming to be of existing things is that into which destruction too happens all right the processes of nature coming to be and passing out of existence okay generation instruction those processes happen and the quote according to necessity for they pay penalty and retribution to each other for their Injustice according to the assessment of time the assessment of time Cronus son you see the assessment of time Cronus Cronos son the assessment of time in the course of time things get balanced out you see now of course that's a passage in which it's talking about natural processes not about moral Deeds but notice that the metaphor in the language is taken from morality and applied back to the processes of nature”
Pythagoras held that nature exhibits a mathematical order that balances opposing forces, and he founded an idealistic community organized around the principle that there should be harmony of opposing interests and a well-ordered, rationally governed life characterized by justice.
“Pythagoras who has the notion of a mathematical order to Nature that um balances the opp opposing forces that seem to be at work now um uh one of the things that doesn't come through in this um these selections is uh the way in which he applies this not only to Nature's processes but also to the life of society in fact Pythagoras was the founder of a little Community um I notice that our editor calls it a cult it's sometimes called a society a city state well I suppose you could think of it like one of those uh religious or ethical communities founded in America in idealistic days late 19th century perhaps which there are several strewn around the Midwest as well as in the um anabaptist menonite uh group in various parts of the country that is to say a morally idealistic community living together and ordering their lives in what we think of as countercultural ways you well Pythagoras founded a group of that sort a group in which there was to be this harmony of opposing interests a balance of opposing influences and forces at work in the community a well-ordered rationally governed life characterized by Justice”
The presocratic philosophers established and staked out the main philosophical alternatives for Western philosophy: empiricism vs. speculative rationalism, materialism vs. non-materialist views, hedonistic ethics vs. ethics of moral law.
“I said last time that the presocratic sort of pose the agenda for Western philosophy U there's a sense in which they also stake out the Alternatives you see empiricism versus speculative rationalism um a purely materialistic view versus something other than just a material view yeah very much so a hedonistic ethic versus an ethic of moral law yeah”
Heraclitus argues that those who are awake share one ordered, common universe with universal laws and justice for all, whereas those in sleep turn away to private worlds, and that the thinking faculty is common to all, so those who think rationally should reach the same conclusions.
“those awake have one ordered Universe in common but in sleep or all those in sleep each turns away to his own world okay now are you awake or are you asleep that's what he's asking the thinking faculty is in common to all he goes on so if you're awake if you're thinking you'll see there has to be one ordered universe that is common to all men we live in one and the same ordered Universe with one and the same ordered laws for all one and the same Justice for All macrocosm microcosm”
Xenophanes criticizes Homer and Hesiod for ascribing to the gods the vices of men (theft, adultery, deception), seeing this as a problem with how humans conceive of the divine, and argues for a loftier conception of god as a single, purely rational, immaterial being who moves all things by thought without toil.
“he talks about Homer and hezard who ascribe to the gods whatever is infamy and reproach among men theft adultery deceiving each other and now I take that to be more a criticism of the Gods than of Homer and hezard who reported on the gods but what he's doing is pointing out obviously that that is the kind of life left and adultery and deceiving each other which needs to be brought under some kind of just control and yet the gods are guilty of things that men are hanged for every day you see and so in contrast to that kinds of gods xenophanes turns in a loftier direction he goes on Mortals suppose that the gods are born and have clothes and voices and shapes like our own but if oxes and horses and lions had hands and could paint with their hands and fashion works as men do they'd paint horike images of gods and The Oxen would paint oxlike images of gods and each would fashion bodies like their own so the Ethiopians consider the gods flat-nosed and black the thians blue-eyed and red haad but there is only one God among Gods and Men the greatest not at all like Mortals in body or mind he sees as a whole thinks as a whole hears as a whole and without toil because there are no opposites in Conflict without toil he moves everything by just the thought of his mind he thinks and it's done”
Anaxagoras held that there are as many different elements as there are different qualities or properties that can be observed, and that everything contains a portion of everything, but that cosmic mind (nous) runs through and orders this plurality of elements.
“anex zagoras was one of the pluralists who held that there were as many different elements as there are different qualities properties so there is a seed of this a seed of that a seed of all the other things uh that can be observed or identified okay and that uh running through this in order to give it order Harmony bring an ordered World of Nature into being there is this Cosmic noose mind intelligence reason however the word noose happens to be translated okay now look in the second column then on page 41 second column page 41 um the paragraph number 11 in in everything there is a portion of everything except mind some things contain mind also okay there's vast variety of different seeds of everything going to make up our bodies with all the multitudinous variety of properties is the various aspects of the body have seeds of everything now in um some in everything there is a portion of everything but some things contain mind also not everything contains mind”
The presocratics did not conceive of a transcendent creator God in the Judeo-Christian sense; rather, they envisioned a God or principle of order that is immanent in nature, almost like a participatory principle where the divine is another aspect of nature itself.
“notice that not only is the emerging God in this account not an exolo Creator the emerging God isn't really a Transcendent God in Pythagoras and heraclitus just another aspect of nature you see it's almost a pisticci pation um and a amander comes perhaps closer in implying that this noose is always unmixed it never is mixed up with all the elements”
The term logos in Greek can mean not merely an utterance but has its emphasis on the rationality of speech; it derives from the same root as 'logic' and can mean measure, balance, harmony, or that which gives order, value, and meaning to life.
“the term if you if you trace its meaning in um Greek language in Antiquity uh if can mean um not simply a um a speech that's heard an utterance the emphasis is rather on the um the rationality of it it's the word from which we get our word logic you see um it's um it sometimes means measure in measuring out Goods that are being sold balance Harmony and harmonizing opposing influence opposing forces you see in other words it's that which gives order value meaning to life”
Anaxagoras's conception of nous comes close to suggesting a transcendent principle (by virtue of being 'unmixed' and never combining with other elements), approaching Platonic ideas more than other presocratic systems.
“in amander comes perhaps closer in implying that this noose is always unmixed it never is mixed up with all the elements”
The traditional interpretation of the presocratics as pre-scientific speculators about nature, influenced by Aristotle's treatment in his Metaphysics, is not the only or best way to understand them; they should instead be understood as developing an ethical vision of cosmic justice.
“the presocratic philosophers uh in the fashion that they're usually represented in histories of philosophy a fashion that was probably influenced by the fact that Aristotle uh in a passage from his book one of his metaphysics...Aristotle treated them that way as pre-scientific people speculating about the basic principles that make nature the way it is...I'm not convinced that it's the only way or the best way to see the presocratic”
Democritus represents the counterforce to the cosmic justice vision: he views cosmic order as resulting from sheer chance—the chance conglomeration of inert particles (atoms) whirling in a cosmic vortex, producing particular combinations through purely mechanistic processes without intelligence, purpose, or teleology.
“the opposite is democratus yet democratus has no noose has no logos you see uh democratus views the order of the cosmos as being the result of sheer chance the chance conglomeration of inert particles atoms whirling around in a cosmic Vortex producing the particular combination of things which survived a purely mechanistic account”
In Hesiod's Theogony, Zeus is portrayed as the ruler of human affairs, and his daughter Dike (Justice) oversees the affairs of mortals, establishing the notion of a divinely ordained cosmic order of justice.
“in his Theogony uh seems to think that Zeus is really in charge of human Affairs and Zeus's daughter uh Decay which is the Greek word later for right Justice Zeus's daughter Decay actually oversees the Affairs of Mortals”
In Sophocles' Antigone, the protagonist appeals to a higher, unwritten law of heaven that supersedes the king's arbitrary edicts, representing the idea that there is a transcendent cosmic justice that overrides human positive law.
“if you're familiar with um Sophocles Antony a similar story antigon is brother has been killed in fighting to retrieve his throne thieves from the usur Christ and King cus issues an edict that the body is to be left to rot but a tigy defies the edict and obeys a higher law the king threatens her with execution and demands that she confess her wrong did she choose flagrantly to disobey the king's edict and here's her reply naturally since Zeus never promulgated such a law nor will you find that Justice publishes such laws to men below I never thought your edicts had such force that they nullified the laws of Heaven which Unwritten not proclaimed can boast a currency that everlastingly is valid An Origin beyond the birth of man and I whom no man's frown will frighten um far from risking Heavens frown by clouting these”
Democritus teaches that pleasure and the absence of pain are the criteria for what is profitable and advantageous, leading to a hedonistic ethic, though he recommends temperance in eating, drinking, and merrymaking because excess tends to cause pain rather than pleasure.
“on 47 the very bottom of the second column pleasure and the absence of pleasure are the criteria of what is profitable and what is not or the very bottom of um 48 paragraph 188 the Criterion of the advantageous and and disadvantageous is enjoyment lack of enjoyment um the very bottom of 49 paragraph 200 people are fools who live without enjoyment why because in a world of sheer chance with no intrinsic order that ensures that right will out eat drink and be married you see now L um he would um uh recommend Temperance in your eating and drinking and merryment uh because too much of it tends to cause pain rather than pleasure”
Hesiod's Works and Days, addressing ordinary mortals rather than heroes, calls for justice and honest labor among common people, and emphasizes that justice will prevail over violence in the course of time through the assessment of Cronus (time itself).
“Hesiod's work works and days it's about ordinary Mortals about the orderedness of their lives and in it Hesiod calls for justice and honest labor among the common people...Justice Prevail...in the course of time and uh this uh theme runs through Hesiod it's very noticeable um the other road is better which leads toward just dealing for justice conquers violence and triumphs in the end”
Early Greek mythology portrayed nature and the gods as arbitrary and capricious, with an impersonal fate (Moira) lurking behind events, and early gods (in Homer's Iliad) as fickle and disinterested in human affairs, focusing instead on aristocratic heroic virtues of beauty, wealth, status, and honor rather than justice or social order.
“earlier Greek mythology saw no intelligence behind natural processes producing any Harmony or natural law um nature and the forces behind it and the gods seemed all to be arbitrary and there was the notion of a very impersonal kind of Fate Moira which lurs behind the scene and then gets you uh even gods of Homer seem at least in The Iliad to be fickle Limited in what they can do not particularly interested in human Affairs um the interest in um that mythology is is much more in what's known as the heroic virtues the virtue of the aristocratic hero Beauty wealth status honor”
In Aeschylus's Oresteia, the blood feud that tears apart the House of Atreus is to be superseded by the rule of law rather than by vengeful fates, representing an evolution toward the idea that justice is achieved through rational, ordered legal systems rather than through arbitrary divine vengeance.
“in Greek uh literature and um this is what I want to pursue this afternoon in fact I'm not even sure it's fair to Aristotle to say that he interpreted these as pre-scientific because he saw himself as pre-scientific or scientific I think for Plato and Aristotle it's true that as far as they're concerned their metaphysical views theories of forms studies of nature really were part of a larger concern that they had namely to maintain that um there is something that is good by Nature you'll see so their concern for the good in nature and in Human Experience is I think a um more self-conscious theme certainly on Plato's part and to a certain extent Aristotle's part than all of the metaphysics they get into and cosmology uh we'll see that as we get to Plato but in any case the uh the theme that I'm picking up on is what I've scribbled on the board here Cosmic Justice uh because in the predecessors of the pre socratics uh the literary predecessors of the presocratic that's a notion that you get and I'm I'm suggesting you see that um the presocratic stand in continuity with these predecessors in pushing further the emerging idea of cosmic Justice this is a moral Universe you say in which Justice will out they're pushing this emerging notion further than their literary predecessors and trying to tell us what kind of a thing nature is that there should be some sort of rule of moral law in the universe did you get the overall idea you see uh that is to say these um earlier literary figures recognize that there are ordered processes of nature but there are also ordered processes of moral life that you get your due due reward or the fates get you you see so that you have the macrocosm nature as a whole is ordered law governed the microcosm your moral life is ordered law governed and in between those two you have sort of an inet the emerging idea of the city state as a law governed order of society you see and there's a parallel between these three things the orderliness of nature the orderliness of the city state the orderliness of the moral life and they see analogies between the three all the time now earlier Greek mythology saw no intelligence behind natural processes producing any Harmony or natural law um nature and the forces behind it and the gods seemed all to be arbitrary and there was the notion of a very impersonal kind of Fate Moira which lurs behind the scene and then gets you uh even gods of Homer seem at least in The Iliad to be fickle Limited in what they can do not particularly interested in human Affairs um the interest in um that mythology is is much more in what's known as the heroic virtues the virtue of the aristocratic hero Beauty wealth status honor that what's that's what makes the Greek hero um but um these Heroes ignored the problems of society the desperate need of the ordinary people and even pursued their honor uh to the detriment of their own real self-interest you see so um as you read The Iliad which I assume you done in Western World L um you read the ilad and adus strives in vain to return home you see and all the while while he's struggling striving to get home there are his Earth while friends devouring his resources and trying to seduce his wife you remember the narrative is he but take a step further than the Iliad to the Odyssey which centers around uh Adia son trying to keep things straightened out at home very much concerned to get his father back home in the Odyssey the gods are becoming interested there's a great gradual Evolution going on there is less focus on the heroic virtues and the goddess Athena gets involved and helps to secure Justice bringing adius home it's an interesting development significant change now you you move on to heot and there's some illusion to this in stump the secondary source history you're reading hezard in his theogony uh seems to think that Zeus is really in charge of human Affairs and Zeus's daughter uh Decay which is the Greek word later for right Justice Zeus's daughter Decay actually oversees the Affairs of Mortals and then when you take a look at um hot's work uh work works and days it's about ordinary Mortals about the orderedness of their lives and in it hod calls for justice and honest labor among the common people now I have a hunch that none of you have read his od's works and days because I discovered there isn't a copy in the library but I discovered one elsewhere and um here um a couple of selections which uh may be of interest to you uh listen now to Justice writes heot and forget violence completely for Cronus son Kronos time a Kronos son set up this law for men fish flesh foul each other may devour for right is not in them but right he gave to men and this is best by far don't fight it out but let Justice Prevail or this again those who give to every man those from abroad and those from home straight judgments and do not transgress the just their City flourishes their people Prosper too peace the children's Guardian patrols the land and Zeus farseeing doesn't cruel Wars against them upon the men who judge with honesty upon those men famine and disaster never wait they work at their appointed tasks with mert those who Delight in violence and wicked sinful Deeds farseeing Zeus the son of cronis plans to punish get the idea of a Justice that comes out in the course of time and uh this uh theme runs through heot it's very noticeable um the other road is better which leads toward just dealing for justice conquers violence and triumphs in the end or again the eyes of Zeus all seeing and all knowing behold us even now if thus he Wills the sort of justice that this city deals in within herself will not Escape his notice it is bad to be a man of Justice if the less just is to have a greater right if things are inverted or this again get good measure from your neighbor and give good measure back okay fair measures scales return as much or better if you can so that when you are yourself in need you will find him able to supply it interesting parallels there incidentally to some of the things that you find in the Book of Proverbs you see but notice the concern for justice the insistence that in the course of time in Cronus son in the course of time Justice is going to be done it's the very nature of things Cosmic Justice well if you um go on from his OD to um escalus aresta you remember uh the house of Atrius and the blood Feud the that was tearing that family apart and yet that blood Feud is to be superseded by the rule of laws not by the vengful fates but by a rule of laws that harmonizes conflicting interests Heavenly and Earthly Justice must be one”
Heraclitus teaches that wisdom is the greatest virtue and consists in speaking the truth and acting according to nature, which he understands as paying heed to the moral order of nature.
“no there's something more um and the next um next saying right after that one it's not good for men to obtain all they wish then the next sane thinking is the greatest virtue wisdom is speaking the truth and acting according to Nature paying heed you according to the moral order of nature”
Heraclitus criticizes Homer for not understanding day and night in the cosmology, implying that Homer lacked the understanding of cosmic order that Heraclitus is attempting to articulate; Heraclitus also criticizes Hesiod for not knowing something that should have been obvious from first principles.
“Homer deserves to be thrown out of the contests and whipped yeah for the virtues that he espoused those heroic virtues the Greek jcks you'll see um I trust that a weat and JS are not like Greek ones in those regards with the wrong values you see the most popular teacher is hiad of him people think he knew most who um didn't even know day night that there one he hadn't pressed into the cosmology of the thing you see”
From Homer's Iliad to the Odyssey, there is a significant evolution in Greek thought: the Odyssey shows less focus on heroic virtues and greater interest in justice, with goddess Athena actively helping to restore order and bring Odysseus home, representing a shift toward viewing the divine as concerned with justice.
“but take a step further than the Iliad to the Odyssey which centers around uh Adia son trying to keep things straightened out at home very much concerned to get his father back home in the Odyssey the gods are becoming interested there's a great gradual Evolution going on there is less focus on the heroic virtues and the goddess Athena gets involved and helps to secure Justice bringing adius home it's an interesting development significant change”
Greek poetry and literature formed the primary education of ancient Greeks and was deeply embedded in their culture; therefore, it would be odd if the philosophical themes found in this literature did not appear in early Greek philosophy.
“consider how um how large a place the poetry and literature of the earlier Greeks played in their education later this is the stuff they were raised on schooled on that they celebrated you so that it would be at least odd if something of this didn't appear in um early Greek um philosophy”
The proper context for understanding the presocratics is Greek literature and poetry—the myths, epics, and tragedies that formed their intellectual predecessors and shaped their concerns, not natural environment or encounter with foreign cultures.
“I think the first place to look is in their own Greek predecessors you see uh in Greek uh literature and um this is what I want to pursue this afternoon”
In the triadic structure of order that Greek thought developed, the macrocosm (nature as a whole), the mesocosm (the city-state as a law-governed society), and the microcosm (individual moral life) are all understood as law-governed and morally ordered, with explicit analogies drawn between these three levels.
“that is to say these um earlier literary figures recognize that there are ordered processes of nature but there are also ordered processes of moral life that you get your due due reward or the fates get you you see so that you have the macrocosm nature as a whole is ordered law governed the microcosm your moral life is ordered law governed and in between those two you have sort of an inet the emerging idea of the city state as a law governed order of society you see and there's a parallel between these three things the orderliness of nature the orderliness of the city state the orderliness of the moral life”
The dichotomy between cosmic justice thinkers and Democritus surfaces before Plato and Socrates, establishing the conflict of worldviews that shapes Socrates' philosophical project and his confrontation with the sophists.
“at least some of the sophists seem to be CL closer to democratus and without the least bit of Interest or belief in a law governed Cosmos you'll see and so the dichotomy between these two views if you like these two World Views these two World Views uh before we uh we even get to Playdoh surfaces you and it's into that conflict between World Views that play those steps that Socrates emerges”
Democritus argues that aesthetic qualities (sweet, bitter, color) exist only by convention, not in nature itself, implying that values and qualities are subjective or arbitrary rather than grounded in cosmic order.
“notice this about aesthetic qualities sweet exists by convention bitter by convention color by convention”
Plato and Aristotle's metaphysical and cosmological theories were subordinate to a larger concern: demonstrating that there exists something good by nature—that the universe embodies goodness in its very structure.
“their metaphysical views theories of forms studies of nature really were part of a larger concern that they had namely to maintain that um there is something that is good by Nature”
Heraclitus criticizes hedonism by arguing that if pleasure were the highest good, oxen would be happy when eating vegetables—a reductio ad absurdum showing that pleasure cannot be the measure of human happiness.
“if happiness lay in bodily Pleasures oh yeah there were the hedonists of that day too if happiness lay in bodily Pleasures we would call oxen happy when they find veg to eat okay”
Heraclitus states that to God (or the logos), all things are beautiful, good, and just, but humans have falsely divided things into just and unjust categories—suggesting either that everything is ultimately just from the divine perspective, or that humans are more discerning than the gods in recognizing moral distinctions.
“to God all things are beautiful and good and just but men have supposed some things to be unjust and some just now that passage has been taken two ways one espousing the view of God singular perhaps logos that everything in the end works out right justly the other taking the view that this is critical of the Greek gods who let anything go and said oh that's all right and some men have been more Discerning than that calling some things just and some unjust now which way has it meant I don't know okay”
Plato is critical of Anaxagoras (in several dialogues) because Anaxagoras sees order in nature but fails to recognize purpose and end-oriented design; Plato insists that natural processes are ordered not merely for mechanical consistency but to achieve ends and goals.
“Plato isn't satisfied with anexas anex zagoras knows in a number of places in his dialogues he's critical of the man because he sees order but he fails to see that there is purpose as well in the way things are made oh yes I said that an ex amender I said last time an ex amander seems to have a teleological view an ordered Universe yes but not by virtue of intelligent conscious purpose”
Pythagoras's dietary restrictions and other injunctions (abstain from beans, abstain from living things, follow the gods, restrain your tongue) are not arbitrary rules but examples of using reason to identify limits and boundaries that prevent harm, embodying the principle that rational understanding should govern life.
“well why do you think the um handle on the tongs you use on the barbecue has wood on it rather than just picking up iron to take things off the barbecue you get the idea you see uh reason tells you that there is going to be some sort of clash some sort of pain if you stir the fire with iron raisin Stakes out the limits does those sorts of things and uh you you can see all sorts of dietary restrictions as you go down the uh the column 37 and 8 abstain from Beans abstain from living things for whatever uh reasons they have dietary proposals ruling their lives by reason you see”
Heraclitus and Pythagoras can be understood as double-aspect monists—thinkers who recognize two opposing yet unified aspects of nature: the ordered and the disordered, the permanent and the changing.
“you remember I had linked heraclitus and Pythagoras suggesting that they double aspect monists two sides to Nature the ordered and the disordered the change and the permanent ordered Unity of things well you find that in heraclitus”
Anaxagoras's account of Mind (nous) shaping primordial chaos into an ordered cosmos may have influenced later theological accounts (such as the King James Version's account of creation), representing the Presocratic precursor to Judeo-Christian cosmogony.
“well it almost sounds as if the King James translators may have read um an exageras in the beginning the Earth was without form and V and God said and it was so now I say almost perhaps they did after all um King James version was translated after the Renaissance of learning which brought Greek thought back into the Consciousness”
Cicero, in his work On the Nature of the Gods, states that Anaxagoras was the first human thinker to hold that the orderly disposition of the universe is designed and perfected by the rational power of an infinite mind.
“the Roman Cicero in his book on the nature of the Gods I alluded to it earlier in his book on the nature of the Gods Cicero says the first human thinker to hold that the orderly disposition of the universe is designed and perfected by the rational power of an infinite mind was an exageras”
Some of the sophists (to be discussed in the next lecture) will be closer to Democritus's worldview than to the cosmic justice tradition, showing no interest or belief in a law-governed cosmos.
“next time we'll be looking at the sophists and Socrates and notice how at least some of the sophists seem to be CL closer to democratus and without the least bit of Interest or belief in a law governed Cosmos”
It is possible to teach the history of Western philosophy by beginning with the presocratics and systematically developing their fundamental insights and alternatives, an approach superior to abstract discussions of 'issues and worldviews' because it grounds philosophy in concrete historical thinkers and texts.
“I have a friend who um this sounds like a horrible thing to do but uh as I understand it he used to introduce people to philosophy he was teaching in a seminary but he used to introduce people to philosophy who had never had any Philosophy by taking them through the presocratic now compare that with the wonderful intro to philosopy course you had here under the label issues and World Views and you see a difference but on the other hand you can see that it's possible you see it's possible obviously you'd have to supply an awful lot in addition but um yeah it sets the agenda and for that matter it poses the main Alternatives right”