
Why Everything You Think You Know About Money Is Wrong | Merryn Talks Money
What this covers
David McWilliams, author of Money: A Story of Humanity, talks with Merryn Somerset Webb's guest-host counterpart Marin Zettler about how currency has shaped the rise and fall of civilizations. The conversation runs from the earliest accounting tools to present-day debates about central banking. McWilliams argues that money co-evolved with writing, numbers, legal systems and religion in Sumer, and he cites a 20,000-year-old notched baboon femur as evidence that the ledger is an ancient technology, not a blockchain invention. Yap's stone money comes up as an example of ledger money.
The middle of the episode is mostly history. McWilliams says the Lydians' coinage and ever-smaller denominations spread commerce through society and had a leveling effect, since a prince's coin and a pauper's coin were worth the same. He describes the credit crunch engineered by Tiberius in AD 33 as a recognizable boom-bust cycle: falling rates, a property boom, tightening, hoarding, a crash, and state asset purchases. He also notes that historians have offered 214 reasons for Rome's fall, yet debasement is not among them. Zettler adds the stakes of counterfeiting, citing Dante's placement of a counterfeiter near the bottom of hell and William Playfair's forgery of French money in 1793. The discussion also covers how merchants emerged as a counterweight to kings, and how relatively equal wealth and sound money in Florence set the stage for the Renaissance. Some of these causal links are contested.
The last stretch turns to the present, where the positions are more disputed. McWilliams calls Bitcoin a scarce asset that is not really money, and compares it to Esperanto. He contrasts it with M-Pesa, which he considers a real innovation because it solved a real problem. Zettler argues that quantitative easing (QE)) is really fiscal policy and should not have been left to central banks. McWilliams links it to asset-price inequality and to political backlash such as Brexit and Trumpism, and he argues that central banks should prize stability and transparency.
Money is humanity's most important social technology—a miraculous invention that enables complex societies, drives innovation, and shapes civilization itself; understanding money's evolution from clay tokens to digital systems reveals the deep patterns explaining historical turning points and present economic crises.
- Money emerges alongside writing, empiricism, and legal systems as co-evolved foundations of civilization
- Changes in monetary systems have catalyzed artistic, intellectual, and social revolutions (Renaissance, Enlightenment, scientific thinking)
- Debasement, hoarding, and instability in money systems directly destabilize societies and trust; conversely, sound money (like the Florin) enabled unprecedented flourishing
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Money is fundamentally a social technology and life hack that compresses all necessary information into prices, enabling human societies to cope with complexity in ways no other tool has achieved.
“money is a is a shortcut it's the ultimate life hack that money allows you to have prices inside which all the information you require to understand a lot of things is available immediately”
Dante's Inferno assigns a counterfeit moneyer (Adam) to the eighth circle of hell, just above Lucifer himself; this punishment reflects how seriously Florence's political and economic establishment took currency debasement as a threat to civilization.
“Dante reserved possibly the worst punishments for a counterfeit and I said no he said so strong was the Florentine political and economic establishment behind the hard currency that an actual fact a real counterfeit an English chap called Adam tried to debase the Floren and was punished severely in real life for his efforts and Dante placed him in the eighth circle of hell just one above Lucifer himself”
William Playfair counterfeited French money in 1793 toward the end of the French Revolution to destabilize the country further, demonstrating how money can be weaponized to destabilize societies in wartime.
“you know you can use the way that money can destabilize Society in in Wartime endlessly so another story I didn't know 1793 William Playfair counterfeiting French money uh towards the end of the French Revolution to destabilize things further”
Monetary innovation does not happen through great leaps or revolutions but through gradual, iterative, evolutionary processes; money solves real problems but Bitcoin solves no genuine problem in the global financial system, which despite its flaws still works.
“the Global Financial system warts in all like the English language it's not perfect but it is and that's the key it exists”
Money is fundamentally psychological and social—when people see a price, economists see a number but everyone else sees a feeling; these feelings drive animal spirits, which in turn drive both prosperity and panic.
“money is social it's psychological and panic and hard Behavior so as I say in the book I think e economists when they see a price they see a number when most of the rest of the world sees a price we get a feeling and that feeling is what drives the animal spirits and the animal spirits are what drives all all the good stuff and the bad stuff”
Money co-evolved with writing, numbers, empiricism, legal systems, and organized religions in ancient civilizations; these were not independent developments but reinforcing innovations enabled by monetary technology.
“with th that form of money you also see what I would describe as the co-evolution of many other things that I suppose we would regard as pillars of human civilization so numbers empiricism writing legal systems organized religions all these things all come at around the same time”
Historians have proposed 214 reasons for Rome's fall, yet money (debasement) is not listed as one, despite strong empirical evidence that currency debasement was ubiquitous in Rome's decline—a major oversight in historical analysis.
“I looked at this survey and I think it came up with uh it's in the book I think 214 reasons were have been given over the years by historians for the fall of the Roman Empire but ironically money isn't one of them and that is amazing isn't top of the list I would thought it would be Central to understanding”
The Lydians' introduction of smaller and smaller denominations allowed commerce to 'seep into the tentacles of society' in ways larger denominations could not, enabling broader economic participation across social strata.
“the lyans came up with was they introduced smaller and smaller coins you're allowing Commerce to seep into the tentacles of society in a way in which previous civilizations didn't do”
Merchants emerged as a counterveiling power to kings and warriors in the medieval period, armed not with lances but with money, and this shift had a profound catalytic impact on the Enlightenment and subsequent intellectual movements.
“the emergence of merchants as a counterveiling power to King Kings and warriors in and around this period armed not with lances or spears but with money it has a profound catalytic impact on things like the enlightenment which come later but for me there's a reasonably direct link between them all”
The ashab bone and rai stones of Yap are examples of ledger money—money that tracks value through accounting systems rather than intrinsic worth—which more closely resembles modern money (and blockchain) than gold or Bitcoin.
“you talked about the ashab bone which is effectively a type of Ledger money right um yeah to the ex we can see it like that kind of legim money a bit like the um the thing you didn't write about in the book that I simply cannot believe you didn't put in which is the the rise stones of Yap which is one of my you know my favorite my favorite money Stories”
Central banks should prioritize steadiness, transparency, and stability in money because money is a tool that allows humans to live in the future (e.g., mortgages depend on envisioning oneself 30 years hence); destabilizing money destroys this capacity.
“you do it's not you're so much you're debasing but you are certainly taking away some of the steadiness and steadiness is a strange word it's a boring word it's a very wigg is word you know it's it's it's like the sort of thing that Edmund Burke would come up with right H but it's a very important thing to Be steady and to be uh transparent and to give people”
The conflict between public and private money is ancient—corporate scrip, siege coins, and other private monies have appeared throughout history, but states inevitably reclaim monopoly over money because it is too powerful a tool to relinquish.
“the other thing that a lot of um cryptocurrency people like to think is new is this idea of a conflict between public money and private money it's as old as hell and of course that's not new at all because you know think Siege coins corporate script I mean all the many many types of private money we've had in the past”
In AD 33, the Emperor Tiberius engineered a deliberate credit crunch by requiring the senatorial class to set aside a fixed percentage of their property as cash, which caused money to be hoarded, asset prices to collapse, and demonstrating that Roman monetary policy directly shaped asset markets.
“it's ad33 and tiberias is sitting in Capri... all is going well surprise surprise interest rates fall... you get a boom in assets... what he does is basically says I'm going to hit them in their pockets and he in effect tightens monetary policy what he says is you're going to have to set aside x amount of your property in cash and as a result of that you get a credit crunch”
The Tiberius credit crunch of AD 33 shows that Rome experienced boom-bust cycles structurally identical to modern ones: low interest rates → asset boom (second-home speculation) → political instability forcing monetary tightening → hoarding → asset crash → central authority buying assets to stabilize.
“so it's ad33 and tiberias is sitting in Capri he's had a very good Reign reasonably peaceful they've conquered um Egypt loads of flow of grain loads of flows of bullion in from Egypt all is going well surprise surprise interest rates fall as they would do in the modern world and surprise surprise you get a boom in assets and the asset of choice is the property market and in particular second homes in the provinces”
A baboon femur from 20,000 years ago (in the Brussels Natural History Museum) shows notches indicative of basic accounting and ledger-keeping, proving that the ledger is not a blockchain innovation but an ancient human technology.
“I went to the Belgian last summer I went when I was just putting the finishing touches of the book I decided to go over to Belgium and go to the Natural History Museum in Brussels and like all all all museums in in in in in sort of second R cities and I don't mean that in the sense of Brussels but they they don't really look out after so basically it's a couple of weirdos and you know like me looking at things and hundreds of really bored school children right yeah tell they've got a they've on the blood School tour oh my God what are we doing here anyway point is this little baboon's femur and it's very shrunken now because it's so old little notches suggestive of basic accounting of a basic Ledger don't tell me that the blockchain is anything more than a digital of something that Africans our ancestors were messing around with 20,000 years ago”
Quantitative easing is actually a fiscal policy (redistributing wealth), not a monetary policy, and should not have been delegated to central banks because it concentrates democratic powers that should belong to elected governments.
“someone clever than me pointing out to me that Q is not really a monetary policy it's a fiscal policy because it changes the distribution of wealth and that changes everything and therefore central banks shouldn't be allowed to do it at all because it it uses the powers that a democratic government should be able to use”
Bitcoin is not money in any meaningful sense; it is a scarce, non-abundant asset that violates the fundamental requirement that money must be ubiquitous to function as a network technology. Scarce money is like Esperanto—valuable only to those already in it.
“scarcity whether it be the gold standard or Bitcoin is actually the characteristic that makes money less attractive and ubiquity like in a language I compared to a language so we're speaking the English language we were talking about going to barah uh before we came on in Scotland many people in barah continue to speak Gaelic many people in Irish speak Irish but the usefulness of the English language is because the rest of the world uses it”
Quantitative easing has profoundly changed asset prices, which in turn has changed the sociology of money (who gets what), amplified inequalities between asset holders and wage earners, and contributed to political backlash like Brexit and Trumpism.
“it has profoundly changed asset prices and asset prices have profoundly changed changed the the sociology of money who gets what H and it has led to the amplification of inequalities simply because people who depend on assets for their income as opposed to the vast majority of people who depend on wages for their income those people are being rewarded”
Money emerged in Sumerian civilization not conceptually different from modern money, with writing developing as an adjunct accounting tool to track who owed whom and when payments were due.
“writing started as an adjunct uh tool for accountancy... it was just basically writing stuff down who owed who what and when were they going to pay it back”
M-Pesa in Kenya is a genuine monetary innovation because it solved a real problem: allowing financially unsophisticated populations to skip traditional banking infrastructure and use mobile phone credit as currency and store of value.
“I was doing some work uh in Kenya and I was looking down the road and there were hundreds of people outside what was an effect mobile phone Hawking station it wasn't even a shop it was a lad selling and I said to the person who was with me I said you know what's Al this and he said oh that's aesa I said what's that he said it's it's our currency I said I don't mean it's I've got this Shilling in my pocket this this is your currency don't we use that right we use that for buying beer and things but actually the the currency we used to trade is mobile phone credit I thought Jesus”
The Florentine used the hard currency of its time similarly to how the dollar functions today as a stable store of value and medium of international exchange.
“da Vinci comes at the tail end of an economic and financial Revolution that was anchored in Florence by a currency the Floren the hardest currency of its time in a way like the dollar would have been uh over the years”
Interest rate declines (as in Roman times under Tiberius after an influx of gold from Egypt) reliably trigger asset booms, particularly in property markets, demonstrating a predictable relationship between monetary conditions and speculative behavior
“interest rates fall as they would do in the modern world and surprise surprise you get a boom in assets and the asset of choice is the property market”
Bitcoin is like a well-financed residents' committee lobbying the government; it may be politically vocal but it lacks the fundamental property of money (ubiquity) and will never replace state currency because states will not surrender monetary power.
“my point is it's not money in any sense that I understand it like by all means go and buy bit I've bought Bitcoin because for the crack because I like to see this thing jumping up and down but it ain't money very very simple so what if that's not money what is the next big leap forward in money what do you see well I think I think what we're going to see I think what the book also says that leap forwards we don't really do we do gradual iterative uh almost evolutionary process”
Wealth in early Renaissance Italy was more equally distributed than in much of the rest of the world, and this relative equality enabled people to invest and become rich, creating the conditions for Renaissance flourishing.
“I've always been very taken by research that suggested that uh wealth in that sort of early period in Italy was a result of a a more equal spread of wealth a concentration of wealth that was less intense and in much of the rest of the world and that was one of the things that led to the ability of people to invest and the ability of people to get rich etc etc”
Coinage (introduced by Lydians) was inherently democratic because a prince's coin and a pauper's coin were worth the same, creating a leveling effect on social hierarchies within rigid, stratified societies.
“coinage is very interesting because coinage is essentially a very Democratic notion that if for example think about it you're in a very hierarchal structure in terms of the way in which societies are organized but with this bizarre thingal coin a Prince's Fiverr and a popers Fiverr are worth the same so this is a very weird weird idea that suddenly you get almost a leveling out of social hierarchies with this bizarre technology”
Economists are failing to tell the story of money well, not out of unwillingness but out of inability; they have shied away from treating money as a miraculous, wondrous technology emerging from human imagination.
“in the business of economics and again I I I speak as a former you know Central Banker which is the kind of Holy Holy Grail of monetary economics should be at least anyway I kind of got the impression that economists don't tell the story well enough not because they're unwilling but maybe because they're unable and that is a big charge was I I mean I teach monetary economics at Trinity I teach economics to to to postgraduates and over the years I've thought L there's more to this you know”
Boom-bust cycles are endemic and repetitive patterns across history; every generation believes 'this time it's different' and attempts to get rich first before exiting, demonstrating a fundamental and recurring stupidity in human economic behavior
“like like like you and I have been writing about money for many years and I think you're always fascinated at our endemic H repetitive stupidity when it comes to booms and bust and this time it's going to be different and I'm going to make money I'm going to get out first”
Leonardo of Pisa (Fibonacci) made mathematical advances that directly enabled Leonardo da Vinci's later genius; da Vinci's education was fundamentally an economic and accounting education rooted in the quantitative methods Fibonacci introduced.
“there's a character in the book called Leonardo of Pisa who is better known but for mathematical students as Fibonacci uh but I make the claim or at least again it's suggestions these are these are these are polite nudges rather than sort of boisterous claims that you know without Leonardo of Pisa there's no Leonardo da Vinci”
Ancient Greeks became the first heavily financialized society and experienced an intellectual revolution (shift from myth to logic between Homer and Xenophon within 200 years) that was impossible without a monetized society because money forces empirical, precise thinking.
“the Greeks are the first really heavily financialized uh society that we that we we we we come across and also I don't know about you but years ago I was you know you're doing this stuff in history in schooling why why were these Greek fellows what made them sort of smash the sort of intellectual glass ceiling when it came to philosophy and art and democracy and republicanism and all these incredibly sophisticated Notions and and and it strikes me it's inconceivable these things would have happened without a monitorized society and the reason is because money makes you count it makes you think empirically it makes you think precisely”
Fibonacci learned mathematics from Arabs in Sicily, who borrowed it from Persians, who borrowed it from Indians; medieval Christians regarded zero and algebra as 'Saracen magic' because they lacked the mathematical sophistication of Islamic merchants.
“da Vinci went there so I thought this is fascinating that da Vinci's education was actually an economic education and accounting education based on the numbers of sequencing of Fibonacci who learned his mathematics from the Arabs in Sicily who borrowed their mathematics from the Persians who borrowed it from the Indians”
The continuous debasement of Roman currency eventually destroyed the empire because currency debasement does more than cause price inflation—it fundamentally messes with people's cognitive ability to understand the world through prices.
“the general idea that that the Roman Empire fell in the end because of not treating its money with proper respect yes the continual debasement of the currency in the end is what destroyed the Empire”
The state owns money and will never relinquish that power to private actors, regardless of lobbying efforts; this is a fundamental fact demonstrated across thousands of years of monetary history
“one huge fact and I call it a fact that comes out from research in thousands of years of the history of money is that the state owns money whether we like it or not and they're not about to give that power away to a couple of tech Bros right okay no matter how much they Lobby the SEC”
Debasement and the loss of trust in money through repeated policy interventions that 'bribe' asset holders during crashes erodes this technology's ability to serve as a bridge to the future.
“if you go down the road of every time there is a an asset crash which you and I know happen with extraordinary regularity the way in which you will actually plug that particular Gap is by a bribe in effect to asset holders uh and you debase you debase this This brilliant technology and as you say you debase out your peril”
The Greeks improved upon Lydia's coinage and became the first heavily financialized society in recorded history, using sophisticated financial instruments and commercial practices that preceded modern finance by over 2,000 years
“the Greeks then take that baton and do what the Greeks did all across the across the board they make it better and so the Greeks are the first really heavily financialized uh society that we that we we we we come across”
Christianity was an entirely urban phenomenon that coincided with the emergence of commerce and marketplaces in the ancient world, suggesting a direct causal link between commercialization and religious emergence.
“Christianity was an entirely Urban phenomenon as who was Commerce as to was the marketplace”
Christianity emerged as a radical ideological counterweight to the meritocratic economic system created by monetization in ancient Rome; it appealed primarily to losers in the monetary economy by offering compensation via the afterlife.
“could it have been a response to the commercialization of the ancient world and is it any doubt or is it any coincidence that you know Christianity was an entirely Urban phenomenon as who was Commerce as to was the marketplace”
Money has a paradoxical core: it must be debased (degradable) for it to function, but it also cannot be scarce because it is a network technology where ubiquity makes it more powerful, creating a fundamental tension.
“what fascinates me about money is its ubiquity this very cintu of idea that although you can debase it in order for the technology to work it can't be scarce either it has to be bountiful and plentiful because it is a network technology and the more of us who use it the more of Us come into the network and the more powerful money is so it's got this slightly paradoxical element at its core which is that scarcity whether it be the gold standard or Bitcoin is actually the characteristic that makes money less attractive and ubiquity”
It is possibly too early to fully understand what quantitative easing has done to the global financial system and global inequalities, and the subsequent political backlash is evidence that the effects are still unfolding.
“I think it's it's possibly too early to to really understand what it has done to the Global Financial system uh and also to Global inequalities and the subsequent and an evident political backlash”
The Roman Empire fell partly because of continual debasement of its currency, which eventually made coins so thin that they contained almost no precious metal and could only display the emperor's head on one side.
“the general idea that that the Roman Empire fell in the end because of not treating its money with proper respect yes the continual debasement of the currency in the end is what destroyed the Empire yeah and so much so that towards the end they could only print the emperor's head on one side of the coin they was so thin and it was uh there was no proper hard Metals in it are very very very little”
Every major change in the nature, understanding, or usage of money has historically led to new levels of prosperity and innovation in human societies.
“every big change in the nature of money or the understanding of money or the way that money is used can and often has led us to a new level of prosperity or a new level of innovation”
The global financial system, despite its flaws, currently exists and functions, and this fact makes it the baseline against which proposed alternatives should be judged—problems do not have to be 'big enough' to justify replacing what already works.
“our problem with crypto is there ain't a problem big enough to be solved the Global Financial system warts in all like the English language it's not perfect but it is and that's the key it is it exists”
The drachma (Greek currency) was called the drachma until 18 years ago when the EU introduced the euro, destroying the oldest continuously-used currency name in the world.
“the drma which ironically or not ironically I just think fascinatingly was called the drma then and was the dragma up until about 18 years ago um which which means a handful in ancient Greek yeah look at that another thing the EU destroyed the oldest current in the world”
Over a 10-year investment horizon, physical property (real estate) is more reliable than Bitcoin or gold because societies have made property investment extremely cheap through tax subsidies.
“10 years one asset gold or Bitcoin gold any other asset said you would definitely hold over a 10-year period I think unfortunately things like very boring things like everybody holds property bricks and water basically it it moves along our societies have made it so cheap ironically to put money into property with o tax scams you might call them that that is again a construct of society”
Bitcoin enthusiasts have an emotional relationship to Bitcoin (similar to Esperanto speakers) where Bitcoin is 'incredibly important to them' but they 'can't talk it to anybody else' because it lacks the network effects necessary for universal adoption
“if you meet anybody who speaks espiranto it's incredibly important to them they can't stop talking about it but they can't talk it to anybody else cuz none of the rest everybody exactly you know and the same carry on with with Bitcoin”