YouTube9m· Nov 2024· cataloged

Ian Bremmer on Trump's win | Quick Take


What this covers

This is a nine-minute Quick Take recorded the morning after the 2024 US election, with Ian Bremmer as the only speaker. It begins by arguing the result should not have been a shock, since incumbents lost ground in the UK, the EU parliamentary elections, Germany, France, Austria, Portugal, Japan, India and South Africa. Bremmer expects Canada to follow, with Trudeau pushed out and Pierre Poilievre likely to succeed him. He explains Harris's uphill fight through inflation and immigration: both were easing, but from high baselines, and anyone in office gets blamed. He adds that Trump did better than ever in New York City, topping 30 percent.

The domestic part also covers turnout among women, Black and Hispanic voters, and disinformation. Bremmer notes that white women overall favored Trump, and that Trump outperformed expectations with Black and Hispanic voters. He calls foreign disinformation from Russia, China and Iran a nuisance, mentions bomb threats aimed at Georgia polling places, and says the country's problems are overwhelmingly homegrown. That claim and his view of two separate national conversations are the more contested points. He also says Harris will concede because the balloting itself is not in doubt.

The larger share of the talk looks abroad, and Bremmer is most forecast-minded here. He expects Trump to deal directly with Putin and Zelensky without the Europeans, freezing territorial lines in a way that amounts to a Ukrainian loss. He sees Europe facing a choice between aligning with Washington on China and hedging, while also facing higher tariffs. He says Netanyahu, strengthened at home, may feel emboldened to go after Iranian nuclear facilities. China, with a weak economy, is courting both tariff hawk Robert Lighthizer and Elon Musk. Bremmer closes by saying Trump may collect some wins, but the world is far more dangerous than in his first term, and failures could be worse.

Sharpest takeaway

Trump's 2024 election victory reflects a global pattern of incumbent underperformance driven by inflation and immigration, and his return will significantly reshape international relations, particularly regarding Ukraine, NATO, the Middle East, and China, creating both opportunities and heightened geopolitical risk.

  • Incumbents worldwide underperformed in 2024 elections across UK, EU, Japan, India, South Africa, and Canada due to persistent inflation and immigration concerns despite improving metrics
  • Trump will likely pursue unilateral Ukraine settlement freezing current territorial lines, higher tariffs on allies including Europe, and potential escalation in Middle East, creating uncertainty for traditional US partnerships
  • The geopolitical backdrop is significantly more dangerous than Trump's first term with two active major wars, challenging US-China relations, and fragmented international consensus

The claims · ranked24 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

Harris had a significantly uphill battle as the incumbent vice president because inflation numbers, while coming down from a high baseline, still represent high prices that voters are paying, and anyone in power is seen as responsible for inflation regardless of the actual cause.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremmer

“Why? Inflation. And yes, inflation numbers were coming down, but from a high baseline. And anyone in power is seen as responsible for that. You're vice president, you don't get to say it was somebody else... the numbers coming down are still from a high baseline. Those prices aren't coming down. You're still paying them.”

0.69

Immigration represented a significant factor in Harris's defeat because illegal immigration numbers, while declining, were declining from a high baseline, and the illegal immigrants already in the United States remained present, particularly in red states from which they moved or were moved to blue states, impacting those blue state populations.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremmer

“Immigration. And more recently, immigration numbers also, illegally, coming down, but from a high level. And the illegal immigrants in the United States are still here. And a lot of those that were in red states have also moved or were moved to blue states and that certainly had an impact.”

0.69

Incumbents around the world underperformed in 2024 elections, including in the United Kingdom, across the EU parliamentary elections in Germany, France, Austria, Portugal, Japan, India, South Africa, and soon in Canada where Trudeau will be forced out and Conservative Party leader Pierre Poilievre will likely be the next Canadian prime minister.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremmer

“Anyone looking at elections around the world this year has seen incumbents underperform. We saw that in the United Kingdom, we saw it across Europe in the EU parliamentary elections as well as in Germany, in France, in, you know, everywhere, Austria, you name it. Portugal. In Japan, in the last couple of weeks. In India, in South Africa. Soon in Canada, as Trudeau will be forced out and very likely Conservative Party leader, Pierre Poilievre, will be the next Canadian prime minister.”

0.68

The United States is not having a single national conversation about policy but rather two very different political conversations segregated into separate bubbles, with very few votes actually up for grabs, making the election primarily about voter turnout rather than persuasion.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremmer

“Disinformation because the country is not having a single conversation about policy, it's having two very different political conversations and you are in your bubble. So there were very, very few votes that were actually up for grabs. It was more a question of who you could get out, who you could turn out.”

0.68

It is essential for the country that everyone agrees on who actually won the election, and Harris will concede because there is no real uncertainty around the balloting process itself, as the US has a gold standard system for conducting elections.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Ian Bremmer

“That is essential. It's important for the country that everyone agrees on who actually won the election. There wasn't a lot of uncertainty around the balloting process itself... The US has a gold standard in terms of the way it conducts its elections.”

0.68

External disinformation from Russian, Chinese, and Iranian sources is a nuisance and irritation, but the problems of the US political system are overwhelmingly domestic problems that will continue to be the case going forward.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremmer

“the level of disinformation externally from Russian, from Chinese, from Iranian sources, a nuisance and irritation. But the problems of the US political system are overwhelmingly domestic problems of the US political system. And that will continue to be the case going forward.”

0.65

Women did not turn out in droves despite the abortion issue, despite the presence of a woman on the Democratic ticket, and despite Trump's historical challenges appealing to women; instead, white women overall turned out in favor of Trump.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremmer

“If there's a surprise, it's that women did not turn out in droves despite the abortion issue, despite the fact that there was a woman on the ticket. And despite the fact that Trump has lots of challenges appealing to women historically, but women overall, white women turned out in favor of Trump.”

0.65

The biggest challenge facing the Trump administration is that the backdrop is a far, far more dangerous world with two major wars going on, US-China relations in a more challenging place (though better than a year ago), and lots of seriously moving and dangerous geopolitical pieces.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremmer

“The biggest challenge here is that the backdrop for the Trump administration incoming is a far, far more dangerous world. Two major wars going on, US-China relations in a more challenging place, though better than they were a year ago. Lots and lots of seriously moving and dangerous pieces geopolitically.”

0.65

A Trump administration will look very different to other countries around the world than a Harris administration would have, particularly for the Europeans who face the biggest question mark regarding Trump's foreign policy.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremmer

“Internationally, of course, this is a really big deal because a Trump administration is going to look very different to other countries around the world than a Harris administration would have. I think the biggest question mark out there is for the Europeans.”

0.60

Trump has consistently said he will end the war between Russia and Ukraine in 24 hours and would not even need to wait until he becomes president, meaning the resolution could happen in the coming weeks before his inauguration.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ian Bremmer

“Trump has consistently said that he's going to end this war between Russia and Ukraine in 24 hours. Wouldn't even need to wait until he was president. So hey, in the next few weeks it could happen.”

0.60

Netanyahu has substantial support from Trump, and while they don't love each other, they are aligned, with Trump having said he would go harder against Israel's adversaries and having criticized Biden for not giving enough support to Israelis.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ian Bremmer

“Netanyahu has a lot of support from Trump. They don't love each other, but they are aligned with each other. And Trump has said he would go harder against Israel's adversaries. He criticized Biden for not giving enough support to the Israelis.”

0.59

There were disinformation efforts including bomb threats called in particularly in Georgia in lower income and black polling neighborhoods that would have hit Democrats, but these efforts did not have an overall impact on the election outcome.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremmer

“There was a lot more effort at disinformation, most notably all of these bomb threats that were called in, particularly in Georgia, in lower income and black polling neighborhoods that would've hit the Dems, but didn't have an impact overall on the election.”

0.55

Trump improved his performance in New York City over 30% of the vote, better than he had ever before by a large margin, though he did not win the city, reflecting New Yorkers' dissatisfaction with inflation and immigration comparable to the rest of the country.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremmer

“I saw that Trump did better in New York City, my own city, than he had ever before, by a large margin. He didn't win, but he got a lot. He was over 30%. And why is that? Well, because a lot of New Yorkers aren't happy about those things.”

0.55

Trump outperformed expectations with African American and Hispanic voters, which was apparent in earlier polling but easily could have been wrong, as evidenced by the Iowa caucus poll that was spectacularly wrong in its methodology.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremmer

“He also outperformed overall with African Americans and with Hispanics. And again, this is something that looked pretty clear in earlier polls, but the polls could easily be wrong. And the biggest poll that was wrong, of course, was that Iowa outlier, which wasn't just wrong, it was spectacularly wrong.”

0.54

Netanyahu has fired his defense minister and is riding high in terms of internal popularity and war success, with major gains in killing Hamas leadership both political and military as well as gains with Hezbollah.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Ian Bremmer

“Netanyahu just got rid of his defense minister, fired him. He is riding high right now, riding high in terms of internal popularity compared to months ago, in terms of how his war efforts are going in killing the leadership of Hamas, both political and military, as well as major gains with Hezbollah.”

0.54

Everything geopolitical will be much more uncertain and volatile in the coming months, making close focus on geopolitical developments essential.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Ian Bremmer

“there's a lot to talk about. Certainly everything geopolitical is going to be much more uncertain and volatile in the coming months, and I expect to be focused on it closely and chatting with you about it as we go through.”

0.52

The central question is whether Europeans will align with the United States as they have in the last couple of years, support the US on China, or hedge, especially given that economically underperforming Europeans will also face higher tariffs from a Trump administration.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremmer

“But how the Europeans will play that, both with Ukraine themselves as well as inside NATO, inside the European Union. A very big question, a very big problem, especially as the Europeans who are economically not performing well will also be facing higher tariffs from a Trump administration. Will they align with the United States as they have in the last couple of years? Will they support the United States on China or will they hedge?”

0.48

When Trump says he wants to end the war, he means the Ukrainians don't get to keep fighting and the Russians don't get to keep fighting, which means the territorial lines freeze where they currently are and Ukraine loses the war.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremmer

“But when Trump says he wants to end the war, what he means of course is that the Ukrainians don't get to keep fighting. The Russians don't get to keep fighting. It means that where the territory lines are right now, that's where they're going to get frozen.”

0.45

Trump will get some wins as president of the most powerful country in the world because countries will listen to him more than others when they disagree, but if things go wrong, they will go much more badly wrong than they would have in his first administration.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremmer

“Trump is going to get some wins because he will be the president of the most powerful country in the world, and therefore what he says, countries will listen to more than they would other people when they disagree, but the potential for things to go wrong, if that happens, they'll go much more badly wrong than they did or would have in his first administration.”

0.45

China has an economy that is really underperforming and will feel very defensive facing a Trump administration, reaching out to both Robert Lighthizer who is pushing hard for more tariffs on all Chinese exports to the US and to Elon Musk who has business in China and is close to Trump.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ian Bremmer

“And then of course China, which it has an economy that is really underperforming. They're going to feel very defensive right now, reaching out to both people like Robert Lighthizer, who has been pushing hard for more tariffs on all Chinese exports to the US as well as through third countries. And also reaching out to Elon Musk, who's travelled to China, who has a lot of business in China, who's clearly very close to Trump and who the Chinese will hope is someone they can facilitate an easier, softer relationship with.”

0.45

The question of whether Trump will support a softer China relationship facilitated by Elon Musk is uncertain given the likely GOP wave across Senate and House, representing a competing pressure on Trump from hardline Republicans.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ian Bremmer

“Will Trump support that? What will that mean for the GOP in Congress given that you're likely to see a GOP wave across both Senate, clear they've taken, as well as likely the House at this point.”

0.42

The Trump administration will unilaterally reach out to Zelensky and Putin to dictate peace terms without coordinating with the Europeans, which might well succeed and will place Zelensky under massively greater pressure.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ian Bremmer

“the Trump administration is not going to coordinate with the Europeans, they're going to unilaterally reach out to Zelensky and Putin and try to dictate those terms. Might well succeed. It is possible. Zelensky will be under massively greater pressure.”

0.42

Zelensky immediately congratulated Trump and referenced a great recent bilateral meeting because it is political reality and what he needs to do, not because of genuine alignment.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ian Bremmer

“Zelensky, Ukrainian president, immediately putting out a congratulations to Trump. What a great meeting bilaterally they just had when Zelensky was in the United States. All of that. He has no choice. It's political reality, it's what he needs to do.”

0.42

A very interesting question is whether Trump's support for Israel will embolden Netanyahu to attempt to take on Iranian nuclear facilities, and this should be watched carefully in the coming weeks.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ian Bremmer

“Will that embolden Netanyahu to try to take on Iranian nuclear facilities? That's a very interesting question. We should watch carefully over the coming weeks.”