What this covers

This Hedgeye Investing Summit interview puts Stefan Wheeler of Goldmoney and Josh Crumb of Abaxx Tech in conversation with Keith McCullough. Wheeler lays out a model of gold's price built on central bank policy, split into real interest rates and quantitative easing (QE)), longer-dated energy prices measured by five-year forward crude, and central bank net purchases, which he calls the least statistically important. He says the process is meant to organize thinking and locate cycle tops and bottoms, not to generate trading signals. He cites a call on the bottom around 2015–2016 and an inflection at the end of 2019. The group also discusses the limits of 10-year TIPS as a measure of real rates, since they rely on government inflation data.

The conversation then moves from gold into the energy transition (or decarbonization)). Crumb frames it as a multi-generational capex cycle of about $16 trillion, or $1–2 trillion a year through 2030, and argues that institutional investors' ESG mandates, more than government policy, have aligned incentives. Wheeler covers the physical constraints: electricity cannot be stored, Europe's carbon price has risen from about 5 to about 25 euros, and gaps in renewable energy (or renewables)) output are filled by LNG (Liquefied Natural Gas)). Oil majors are repositioning as utilities. An electric car needs roughly four times the copper of a conventional one, and the discussion of the supply chain for copper, lithium, and rare earths touches on how Western countries outsourced refining to China.

The more contentious turns are on monetary policy. Wheeler argues that a central bank borrowing in its own currency never has to let real rates rise, and that a typical recession's rate cuts cannot be delivered from a 2% starting point. Crumb describes a "chinaification" of macro in which central banks, fiscal policy, and markets are aligned against tightening, and he cites the 2019 repo episode. The group also argues that labor has lost bargaining power and that government CPI misses how inflation differs by income. Wheeler warns that an equity crash would likely hit gold first, on deflation fears and a stronger dollar, before it became a buying opportunity.

Sharpest takeaway

Gold's value is determined by three primary drivers—real interest rates, energy costs, and central bank purchases—making it a currency fundamentally embedded in economic structure rather than a speculative commodity, with the energy transition creating massive infrastructure capex demands that will reshape commodity markets and monetary policy for the next decade.

  • Gold price correlates reliably to real interest rates (TIPS yields) and longer-dated energy prices (oil forward curves), not emotional narratives or central bank proclamations
  • The energy transition to decarbonization requires 1-2 trillion dollars annually in capex through 2030, creating bottleneck demand for copper, lithium, rare earths, and other metals that will constrain the speed and scale of the transition
  • Central banks cannot sustain rate increases in a fiat system—they will always choose quantitative easing and currency debasement over allowing real rates to rise, making gold a hedge against monetary devaluation

The claims · ranked32 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

Europe is experiencing a massive transformation of the power sector toward renewable energy, with carbon cap-and-trade prices rising from 5 euros per ton a few years ago to around 25 euros currently, and the EU has extremely high emission reduction targets that are being met, but this creates a new problem: more electricity from renewables with declining spare capacity, forcing reliance on gas (via LNG) to fill gaps when renewables are unavailable.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Stefan Wheeler

“we see it i mean the one place where it's happening at a very rapid speed right now is in europe where you see a massive transformation of the power sector towards your renewable energy um you have a cap and trade system uh where prices went from five euros a ton of carbon a few years ago to today is around 25 euros um you have extremely high targets within the european union um of how much energy or no it's not how much energy should come from renewables but the target is basically how much carbon emissions you're going to save”

0.74

There is no technical reason why central banks (borrowing in their own currency) ever need to allow real rates to rise; they can simply print currency and destroy its value, which is the mechanism of long-term currency debasement.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Stefan Wheeler

“i don't see a technical reason why they ever would have to let rates appreciate as long as you're in in basically you're printing your own currency and you're borrowing in your own currency there's nothing that actually holds you back from doing that you're just destroying your currency and that's it”

0.70

Electricity is fundamentally different from other energy commodities because it must be consumed when produced (you cannot store it like coal or oil), making it nearly impossible and extremely expensive to store, which creates a bottleneck in the transition away from stable hydrocarbon-based power to weather-dependent renewables.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Stefan Wheeler

“it's it's the only way at the moment how you can fill the gap so we don't have the storage capacity electricity is different than any other form of energy that it has to be consumed when you produce it you you don't store it it's not like you can't just pile it on right so you have commodities that are relatively easy to store like coal and then a bit more difficult is oil and then more difficult is gas and then electricity is almost impossible and extremely expensive”

0.69

In a typical recession, the Fed cuts rates by approximately 5.5%; if starting from 2%, this would require rates to reach -3.5%, which is impossible, so the Fed must pursue quantitative easing or other extreme forms of monetary expansion (like UBI) to achieve equivalent effects.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Stefan Wheeler

“in a normal recession they usually cut rates by about five and a half percent and if you start at two percent then you would end up with three minus three and a half percent now obviously you can't have minus three and a half percent rates so you're gonna get it in some other form that has the same effect and and it's some form of qe but they probably have some do some more extreme form of qe”

0.64

Oil companies cannot sustainably survive at $40–45/barrel, so there is a structural floor in long-dated energy prices below which supply will constrain, supporting a medium-to-long-term floor for energy-driven gold prices.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Stefan Wheeler

“the oil companies and and and uh hydrocarbon producing companies they can't produ they can't survive at these levels forever um in one of the main producers still is the u.s despite the the declining production right now in the back of low prices and and there you have uh an even lower price right so the back end and ti is around 45 and that's not prices where these companies uh can survive for very long”

0.56

Major oil companies are announcing plans to transition from hydrocarbon producers to utilities, reflecting uncertainty about how they will exist in a decentralized (renewables-based) power system where the traditional centralized utility model may no longer make sense.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Stefan Wheeler

“you see actually it's it's very interesting over the past year or so you have seen pretty much every major oil company announcing that they are planning to become a utility and at the same time the activity is actually trying to find out how they are going to exist in this future because if you decentralize the power then the question is what are the utilities going to do”

0.55

Inflation differs significantly by income bracket—low-income households experience inflation primarily through shelter, food, medical, and energy costs, while higher-income households experience different inflation baskets including discretionary goods and services, making a single government inflation measure inadequate for describing real purchasing power erosion across the economy.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Stefan Wheeler / Keith

“inflation is different for for everybody rich people have very different level of inflation that poor people have and and pretty much everybody has experienced a different level of inflation so by focusing on one level of inflation you're obviously missing this so you would have the market's level of inflation i think actually gold does a much better job to measure what real rates are than what we the real rates we read out of tips”

0.55

The global energy transition to decarbonization and electrification is a once-in-a-multi-generational transformation that will require massive capex infrastructure investment estimated at 16 trillion dollars total, or 1-2 trillion dollars annually through 2030, which is larger in scale than the cloud/mobile tech transition or the BRICS/Chinese urbanization transitions that dominated prior decades.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Josh Crumb

“uh you know you're essentially changing you know where where the flows and the source of hydrocarbons are and the economies that build around that you're changing that to electrification and and the capex you know go our our former colleagues at goldman uh have put out some some really great reports this year uh talking about this energy transition in carbonomics um and and what they've pegged the capex at is about 16 trillion dollars about one to two trillion dollars a year needed to meet the the paris goals of 2030”

0.55

The central bank incentive structure is now aligned with fiscal spending and monetary stimulus (what Josh calls 'the chinaification of macro markets'), meaning central banks will not meaningfully reduce monetary stimulus or allow real rates to rise because doing so would cause systemic stress, as evidenced by the 2019 repo market reversal when the Fed briefly tried to reduce its balance sheet and quickly pivoted to massive QE.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Josh Crumb

“the difference is the incentives of the system are all now aligned so uh interestingly enough the green new deal as much as it gets headlines from aoc and and this sort of thing uh at the end of the day it's it's it's really not it's not even joe biden that's driving this uh and in fact if you look at his policies i would say they're conservative uh the ones that are actually driving this from my view are you know larry fink and you know and and goldman sachs uh you know john hassius now and now has the same economic policies as you know stephanie kelton or or or jerome powell uh right or or joe biden or donald trump you know that this this sort of centrally planned uh what what i call the sort of china vacation of of of our macro markets um i i think has has only accelerated uh with with coven”

0.52

Gold's price is determined by three main drivers over long time periods: central bank policy (split into real interest rates and quantitative easing), longer-dated energy prices (measured by five-year forward crude contracts), and central bank net purchases (the least statistically important due to data quality and lags).

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Stefan Wheeler

“basically what we looked at is um what we found is that there is simply three main drivers for gold prices over very long time periods um and one we call central bank policy which is actually two drivers it's real interest rates and it's quantitative easing and and then what this second driver is longer dated energy prices and we use as a proxy we use like a five year forward rent price there and then the rest the last one and that's actually the least important one um is central bank uh net purchases”

0.52

Real interest rates are measured by 10-year TIPS yields, which represent the opportunity cost of holding non-yielding gold versus interest-bearing US dollar assets; however, TIPS yields may not perfectly measure true real rates because they use government inflation data rather than market-measured inflation, which can cause the model to overpredict or underpredict gold prices depending on the divergence.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Stefan Wheeler

“for the us dollar so if you look at you the gold price the newest dollar um what you compare your real interest rate on gold to is the real interest rate on on the us dollar and and we look at 10-year tips there it's not a perfect matter and we actually that's we just i just updated the model quickly and i wanted to see how it performed in this crazy time since the beginning of the year and he has done admiral b but also it actually underpredicts the price at the moment by around 100 and and so if you look at real interest rates i think conceptually that's the right way to look at it the problem is always how do we measure real interest rates”

0.52

Transportation sector (which accounts for ~70% of current oil demand) is at the beginning of a shift to electric and hydrogen vehicles, with cities beginning to ban internal combustion engines and all major automakers committing to the transition, which will force producers and consumers to shift to new technologies and create enormous demand for battery metals.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Stefan Wheeler

“you will see um first in in you will have smaller regions probably cities that will outright ban the sale of um cars with internal combustion engines so you will only be allowed to drive in cities with electric car and hydrogen car and that will force the producers and the consumers actually to shift and that's about 70 of where your oil goes at the moment so on one hand this will impact the demand for the hydrocarbons in the future but also it will create enormous demand for the materials you need to build that new that new transportation infrastructure”

0.52

The incentive alignment for the energy transition has fundamentally shifted in the past ~5–10 years, driven primarily by major institutional investors (BlackRock, others) implementing ESG and carbon mandates, not by government policy or ideological commitments; this creates alignment across previously opposed actors (government, finance, business).

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Josh Crumb

“the difference is the incentives of the system are all now aligned so uh interestingly enough the green new deal as much as it gets headlines from aoc and and this sort of thing uh at the end of the day it's it's it's really not it's not even joe biden that's driving this uh and in fact if you look at his policies i would say they're conservative uh the ones that are actually driving this from my view are you know larry fink and you know and and goldman sachs uh you know john hassius now and now has the same economic policies as you know stephanie kelton or or or jerome powell uh right or or joe biden or donald trump”

0.52

If equity markets crash, gold will likely experience a sharp correction because the market will price in deflation expectations (rather than inflation) and the US dollar will rally, as happened in 2008–2009 and March 2020, and this would represent the best buying opportunity into gold.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Stefan Wheeler

“i think my my biggest concern here is is if if equity eventually crash um you you could have a similar we we had this twice we saw this in 2008 2009 uh at the at the beginning of the crisis you see a rapidly appreciating us dollar and you see actually nominal rates rising yeah and you see inflation expectations are actually declining because when when when equities crash like people start to price pricing and rather deflation than inflation and we saw this actually in march as well and we had a quite a strong pullback in gold”

0.52

Commodities (gold, energy, metals) represent the best alpha opportunity in the current environment because they are structurally underowned relative to the scale of capital reallocation being driven by the energy transition ($16 trillion capex), making commodity price appreciation likely across multiple cycles.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Keith McCullough

“like a lot of different there are a lot of different commodities out there that are under owned and and certainly um underappreciated in this in in this framework am i correct in thinking it through broadly that way fully loaded like i'm long rare earth for example as well”

0.52

Labor has lost bargaining power in the current MMT-aligned system where central banks print and distribute money via UBI rather than allowing wage growth, so labor inflation is unlikely to materialize in the near term (next 6-12 months) despite tight labor markets, because the system allows money printing to suppress wage growth.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Josh Crumb / Stefan Wheeler

“labor just doesn't have the bargaining power at all in this in this mmt world right so so for us to you know fix the balance sheets this year uh we basically printed uh 110 million labor uh labor years um that's the equivalent of the trillions of dollars that were printed 110 million labor years how does labor compete against that right so so my view is we don't have labor inflation anytime soon if we can just dump buckets of money down from the top of the system”

0.51

There is significant rare earth mineral availability in North America (e.g., Mountain Pass in California), but there are very few operational rare earth mining and refining facilities, unlike China's strategically developed rare earth industry, which means North America cannot quickly replace China's supply chain dominance.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Keith

“if the if the dod in the u.s decides that we're not taking any molybdenum or any any rare earths from the chinese you know there are very few places you can get that in north america it's not like we're just like loaded up to the gills with a bunch of rare earth mining operations”

0.49

The recent Fed balance sheet expansion (since early 2020) doesn't even have a formal name, unlike QE1–4, which suggests the Fed has stopped communicating about monetization and is now executing expansions automatically without public announcement or formal labeling.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Stefan Wheeler

“i looked this up before this interview because i wanted what what what which qe is this we're looking at right now and that actually tells you the incentive about the whole thing this doesn't even have a name they printed actually trillions of dollars and it's not qe123 it doesn't have a name qe4 started at some point in 2019 in september and the the recent the recent increase in the fed's balance sheet doesn't even have a name so they don't even care anymore”

0.48

They called the bottom in the gold market at the end of 2015/early 2016 based on their model showing all major drivers (energy, real rates) were at cycle lows, which was a good call, and then they identified a major inflection point at the end of 2019 when everything changed and a new bull market began.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Stefan Wheeler

“we called the bottom in the gold market at around the end of 15 early 16 and i think this has been a pretty good call but um i think what we also saw again model based is that everything changed probably by the end of end of 19 that's when we really think uh the the new bull market started”

0.48

Their process is not designed to produce trading signals or hype anything, but rather to organize thoughts and identify the main drivers of gold so they can understand where price should be going and where cycle bottoms/tops are forming.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Stefan Wheeler

“we just basically our framework is not something we we developed in in order just to hype something or to give us like it's not a magic machines that gives us trading signals it really what we try to do is we try to organize our thoughts we try to find out okay what are the main drivers of gold”

0.48

A fully electric car requires approximately four times as much copper as a conventional internal combustion car; a hybrid car requires approximately twice as much copper, demonstrating the massive material requirements of vehicle electrification.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Stefan Wheeler

“if you look at just a hydra sorry a hybrid car um that already consumes about twice as much copper as a regular card right if you go to a fully electric car that's about four times as much copper”

0.48

The rate of change of TIPS expectations and TIPS prices is a very good leading indicator for the rate of change of real rates, so you don't need perfect inflation measurement agreement—tracking the momentum of TIPS is sufficient to understand real rate direction.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Keith

“but it's it's it's all about the rate of change so it's the bloody calculus of it all so if whatever they call it it's still you know generally speaking and again there's there's some standard error there but the rate of change of tips expectations and you know the actual price of tips is a very good leading indicator on the rate of change of real rates”

0.47

Beyond resource scarcity, the supply chain for heavy metals like copper, lithium, and rare earths comes with significant environmental externalities, and Western countries have outsourced most of this production to China specifically to avoid having smelters and refining facilities in their backyards.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Josh Crumb

“there is a whole supply chain and a lot of these heavy metals in particular uh come with all with their own versions of environmental externalities and and these heavy metals you know we we stopped liking having things like lead smelters in our backyard uh for for all of these reasons um you know but but you know i think what's what's you know beyond just looking at the geological scarcity and do we have the political will to do this um i think again to stefan's point the long lead infrastructure that matters so uh you know we're not gonna you know and i had this conversation a lot back you know 10 years ago when when you know at goldman we would you know every once in a while speak to say energy ministers or or sort of you know planners at the government level uh and and really the only country that was on top of this 10 15 years ago was china um you know there was there was there was very few others and maybe japan um and and one one of the interesting things that china was always doing is they were controlling the supply chain of those pieces that we didn't want in in in the west right so so uh so if you look at you know again zinc and lead smelters um you know those are almost all built in in china these days”

0.47

Gold has a very high energy component in its production because it is extremely scarce, requiring crushing tons of rock to extract a single gram; therefore, gold will always be correlated to the energy inflation basket that low-income households experience, making it a more representative measure of inflation for the broader economy than government CPI.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Josh Crumb

“we see that it's got a very very high energy component uh because it's so scarce uh which which makes sense right uh uh crushing you know tons of rocks to get a gram of gold um now every other uh real good in the economy has a similar energy component so there's going to be reasons why gold is always going to be correlated to that inflation basket that everybody else that everybody has but depending on where you are on the comma on the income spectrum your goods basket may be closer to that raw commodity and that raw energy cost”

0.46

Keith's process for analyzing markets and gold specifically relies on three components: history (past behavior and cycles), mathematics (quantitative relationships), and behavioral/psychological factors (sentiment, narratives), which are all equally important.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Keith McCullough

“the three big things that i like to think about when i think about process and markets are the history the math and the behavioral components”

0.45

The future storage problem for renewable energy could be solved by building gigantic battery storage systems to store electricity and feed it back into the grid when needed, but currently no such technology exists at meaningful scale—only hydro storage exists, and there's limited room to build more hydro capacity.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Stefan Wheeler

“you have to bring it for example from the summer to the winter so you have to find completely new solutions to the problem we think about what could happen is that you build gigantic batteries uh where you literally store the the electricity and feed it back into the into the network when you need it something we don't have right now the only way we can store any electricity at the moment is with uh is with hydro and and there's really not much around and there's not much built there”

0.45

Josh invested in building a new commodity exchange to trade LNG and gas approximately 2.5 years ago because he believes LNG and gas will be the global balancing point for the energy transition and will experience sustained demand for many years.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Josh Crumb

“as you know keith you know about two and a half years ago i started investing in this energy transition by building uh a new commodity exchange to trade lng and gas because we think that's going to be the global balancing point for this this entire uh you know this tighter energy transition is an lng um”

0.45

Within their current framework and assuming no major regime change in currency or monetary policy, the upside for gold is constrained to approximately $2,100/oz; gold will move to around $4,000 only if real interest rates turn significantly negative (real rates of -2.5% to -4%) or if the regime shifts to a new currency system altogether.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Josh Crumb

“and maybe i'll let stefan take the energy one but but in general the reason i had that 2100 bound within this within this framework before we get to something totally different in a new currency world um you know where i think the next level is probably something like four thousand um but but i don't think we enter that new that new regime uh yet um so so within the sort of current uh the current you know general state of that we're in um you know if you if you look at where we think uh uh that you know the forward curve of oil which represents a lot of energy costs in our model um where that tops out again we don't see it going to a hundred two hundred dollars a barrel anytime soon so that kind of puts a top end of the range and on the real interest rate side um again the way the way that that inflation is is measured the way the institutions invest in inflation we don't see a potential in the very near term for something like you know negative two and a half three four percent real interest rates”

0.45

Labor's bargaining power has been grossly suppressed for years on the North American side, but there is currently a seminal moment in cyclical time where labor is reasserting itself and wages are beginning to rise, as evidenced by labor cost inflation in fast food (Wendy's, McDonald's franchise costs).

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Keith

“we're at a a seminal moment in cyclical time i guess is what you would call it where labor's been grossly underpaid you know particularly on the north american side and that's why you're seeing you know what you just gave that basic example of what's happening at wendy's well my brothers got a mcdonald's franchise in winnipeg manitoba and you'd think that he invented the light bulb if he puts a big max on sale for two bucks uh for for four hours like because if there's a complete change that's happened in terms of cost of living cost of labor expected cost of labor and that's that”

0.40

The host (Keith McCullough) has a bearish long-term US dollar view, which is linked to MMT-style monetary expansion, and expects commodities to benefit as the dollar weakens and central banks prioritize growth over currency stability.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Keith McCullough

“if i have a bearish dollar view that's linked to what you just said josh on mmt like starting next year or starting at some point late this year it's like almost the layup of layups commodities”

0.23

Josh Crumb and Stefan Wheeler developed their gold price model by the end of 2015 and have collaborated on commodities analysis for over a decade, having first worked together at Goldman Sachs where Josh led metals research and Stefan led oil research under the fixed income macro commodities team.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Josh Crumb / Stefan Wheeler

“so stefan and i have worked together uh probably for over a decade now um we first met at goldman sachs where i was uh leading metals research and and stefan uh was was leading oil research uh out of the uh out of the fixed income macro and commodities team”

0.13

Stefan is now the head of research for one of Europe's largest energy and power traders, giving him direct exposure to European energy market dynamics and the renewable transition.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Keith

“i mean to really look at something practically you know from a fractal perspective you you have to look at everything all at the same time and be able to remain sober or unaffected emotionally we've seen people affected emotionally on the topic of gold which you guys may have thoughts on but you guys really aren't emotional at all when it comes when it comes to your framework correct stefan yeah i mean we just basically our framework is not something we we developed in in order just to hype something”