What this covers

This conversation pairs Shane Parrish with Shreyas Doshi, an early product manager at Stripe who also led products at Twitter, Google, and Yahoo. It begins with the Three Levels of Product Work: the execution level (what can be done soon with the resources at hand), the impact level (market resonance, go-to-market, long-term outcomes), and optics (how credit and visibility are distributed). Doshi uses the framework to explain team conflict. People often talk past each other because they are speaking from different levels, not because they disagree about facts. He also argues that people tend to look down on optics-minded colleagues, which gets in the way of understanding why they care about it.

From there the talk covers measurement and decision-making. Doshi separates evaluating progress from measuring it, and warns that "if you can't measure it, you can't improve it" can do harm when the metric replaces the goal or the cost of measuring discourages the work itself. He argues that playbooks become commodities, so only judgment separates competitors, and that the gap between good and great teams is the leader's judgment about which rules to bend. Related threads include agency and the Agency-Talent Matrix, the Ikea effect as a reason teams won't backtrack, and opportunity cost as a complement to ROI).

The later sections are more personal. Doshi discusses the pros and cons of a writing culture, saying clarity comes from restructuring around a core insight and leading with what matters most. He lays out systematic competence growth, which breaks a skill like product sense into parts such as cognitive empathy, domain knowledge, and creativity. He also describes the Antithesis Principle, which asks what the opposite of an obvious truth would imply, using first impressions and dependence on great managers as examples. The episode closes with his definition of success as optionality over his time.

Sharpest takeaway

Shreyas Doshi argues that exceptional product leadership and organizational effectiveness depend on understanding the three levels of product work (execution, impact, optics), embracing judgment over rules, building high-agency teams, and cultivating competence through systematic decomposition rather than intuition alone.

  • Misalignment on which level teams operate (execution vs. impact vs. optics) is the root cause of most organizational conflict, not disagreement about facts
  • Great teams distinguish themselves through leadership judgment about when to bend rules, not by following processes perfectly
  • Competence grows systematically through decomposing complex skills into component parts (e.g., product sense into cognitive empathy, domain knowledge, and creativity) rather than hoping projects teach you

The claims · ranked60 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

Opportunity cost is the value of the optimal choice minus the value of the choice you actually made; in high-leverage roles, the goal should not just be to maximize ROI but also to minimize opportunity cost by picking the best option rather than just a positive option.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“actually um you know a better way when you're in a very high leverage role a better way to think about these decisions is through the lens of opportunity cost right where opportunity cost is you know roughly it is uh you know the the value uh you get out of uh you know the optimal option right like uh and and the value you got out of the option you chose right so so the Delta between those two right”

0.74

Many teams and individuals avoid bactracking when an initiative is not working because of the Ikea effect (sunk cost bias) and because code and systems become path-dependent; they rationalize continuing a suboptimal initiative rather than changing course, leading to long-term mediocrity.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“it's kind of like the the Ikea effect takes hold right where we we put in a bunch of work behind this and so now we think it's more valuable than it really is right and now we are going to just like uh you know stick to it uh despite uh the world telling us or giving us evidence to the contrary”

0.74

Writing, thinking, and clarity are deeply intertwined; the act of writing forces clarity of thinking and enables perspective-taking when others read the writing, which is why writing cultures facilitate both personal and collective intelligence.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“the act of writing it is very helpful for the person writing it but the act of consuming somebody else's writing is also very helpful for what we talked about when we first started which was perspective taking right so you're showing me what the world looks like from your Vantage Point what variables matter why this matters to you and how you arrived at this conclusion”

0.74

Since everyone could follow playbooks and industry standards become commodities over time, the only way to outperform competitors is through judgment—the ability to make better decisions than rivals when outcomes are uncertain.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“the reason they're they're getting paid the big bucks is and the reason they at the way they'll create Alpha for their team or for their company is uh through that judgment right because if if everybody could just follow playbooks yeah um then uh you know and they might be wonderful playbooks but over time even wonderful playbooks become the industry standard so now if you want to outperform you need something else and that something else is always judgment”

0.74

When attempting to improve something by measuring it, there is a danger of improving the measurement itself rather than the underlying thing being measured—the metric can become the goal while the actual outcome deteriorates.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“if you try to measure a thing you might think you might improve the measurement right uh but you might not actually be improving the underlying thing so that's the other danger as well”

0.74

Being customer-centric is not just a stated value but requires significant discipline, commitment, and consistency in practice; many organizations say they are customer-centric while their leaders do not actually live that value through their actions.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“we can all say you know yeah sure you need to be customer Centric and so on uh but the the actual process of doing so uh involves a lot of discipline commitment and consistency”

0.70

Systematic competence growth requires a growth mindset, a sense of ambition, and willingness to take personal responsibility for your own learning; organizations are not responsible for growing your competence—you are.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“of course the last piece here is this requires you know a mindset towards growth this requires some degree of ambition and this requires taking responsibility for one's own competence and so those are prerequisites right without those mindset changes none of what I said will actually be put in action or resonate with somebody um because if you are going to say well it's the organization's job to grow my competence then sorry it's not going to happen”

0.61

The solution to cluttered writing is not better word choice but restructuring the document around a core insight, writing with empathy for where the reader is coming from, and leading with the most important thing to convey early.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“I have to tell you like and this is not gonna sound uh like happy news but I would rewrite this whole thing right uh because uh you know here you are you're saying like well maybe you can just use a few better words but the problem is not the words right the problem is that we need to create greater Clarity and that means we have to rethink the structure we need to we need to write with empathy uh for where the reader is likely coming from”

0.56

People form strong first impressions of others within seven seconds; the antithesis principle suggests that while you should be aware of this bias in others, you should not fall prey to it yourself when meeting others—you should deliberately give people time and openness rather than judging too quickly.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“people form a strong impression of you within seven seconds of meeting you right and so so what that suggests is um uh that like you know if you want to be influential if you want to you know make an impact uh you should work towards creating a strong positive impression right in the first few moments of any interaction uh and I think many people do that right but when I started thinking about it for myself I realized that but wait if I fall prey to that same bias right I am going to unfairly judge other people”

0.56

Great managers are important for career success; however, applying this truth to oneself would suggest you should only succeed under a great manager, which is a trap—instead, you should deliberately cultivate the ability to do good work even without a great manager, which gives you much more career optionality and impact.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“when it comes to yourself you should turn yourself into a person who can do really good work even without having a great manager even if you have an okay or absentee manager you should turn yourself into a person who can do really great work now this second conclusion is the non-obvious conclusion that very few people draw right”

0.56

Success, for Shreyas, is defined as having optionality with one's time, specifically the ability to spend time on the top three items in your personal life stack rank (e.g., career, family, interests, friends, community).

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“success I Define as uh the optionality I have with my time and it took me a really long time to um to really understand this well um because I I was always very ambitious as an individual and so I wanted to be very successful but when I achieved certain goals that I thought you know work towards my success I was still left a little unsatisfied and so I kept looking for this kind of what is success for me and I finally cracked it in my very late 30s uh which is success for me is time optionality but particularly it's about am I able to spend the time I want to spend uh on the top three things in my stack rank of my life priorities”

0.55

Conflict between people and teams most often arises because they are not talking at the same level—execution level, impact level, or optics level—rather than because they disagree on facts or goals.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“oftentimes conflict between people and teams arises mainly because um we're not talking at the same level and we might have a you know similar missions and similar goals and okrs and whatnot but if we are not aligned on the level at which we are talking that can lead to a lot of confusion a lot of just stress among individuals and teams”

0.55

The execution level is concerned with what can be accomplished in a short timeframe with available resources and constraints; the impact level is concerned with market resonance, go-to-market strategy, brand effects, and long-term outcomes; the optics level is concerned with how credit and visibility for work are distributed and perceived.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“the execution level which is you know what is it uh that I can get done uh in a short amount of time with the resources and constraints I have”

0.53

High agency among individual contributors is essential for great teams, especially as teams scale; high agency means having both the desire and the ability to influence outcomes and execute creatively despite constraints like staffing or funding limitations.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“another one I'll share um that is often not discussed is just um you know High agency among the individual contributors of the team because I I think like at some point um you know a team say it's like 10 20 30 40 people 50 people more uh it becomes very important uh not just for the leaders to be ambitious and have good judgment and so on but for the individual contributors to be very high agency people where they feel that they have uh the ability uh to end the sort of desire to influence outcomes right”

0.52

Great teams distinguish themselves through leadership judgment—the ability to know which rules to bend when and to make sound decisions in the face of ambiguity—rather than through perfect execution or following processes.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“to what degree is the team willing to bend rules right I'm not talking about like breaking laws because you shouldn't do that but to what degree are you willing to bend rules right uh and it turns out that rules exist for a reason whether it's a rule for like uh you know how you launch a certain product or a rule for how you get approval for a certain thing um and so on and so forth right like over time as an organization scales a lot of rules are created right um and there are teams that like want to do the right thing that will follow all the rules right”

0.52

The statement 'if you can't measure it you cannot improve it' is often applied in the wrong context and causes damage in organizations, particularly when the effort to measure something is so large that it discourages the action itself.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“you know you hear in business meetings right that uh well if you can't measure it you cannot improve it and um in certainly in most of the highly rational company cultures that I have seen these kinds of uh you know statements are taken as truths and over time I realized that used in the wrong context they they tend to you know cause a lot of damage”

0.52

Evaluation of how something is going and measurement of how it's going are distinct approaches: evaluation is qualitative judgment that can enable improvement without explicit metrics, while measurement is precise quantification; situations differ in whether evaluation suffices or measurement is necessary.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“actually the way I know that I'm improving is because I'm evaluating right and and that's where I feel like there's a difference between the idea of evaluating how you're doing and measuring how you're doing right”

0.52

A key insight about decision-making is the antithesis principle: when you observe a truth about how the world works, you should consider not just the obvious application of that truth but also its opposite, which often provides a competitive advantage.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“sometimes we should use the antithesis of that truth or Maxim uh when it applies to us okay so I call this the antithesis principle um and um it explains a lot of bad decisions or principles that we kind of adopt as individuals”

0.52

When people are not listening to you in a conflict or disagreement, the natural response is to repeat the message louder, which does not work; the solution is to step back and recognize what level or frame the other party is operating from and engage with that rather than repeating your own frame.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“look what what we end up doing when we feel like that the other party is not listening is uh that we just keep repeating our message and we do it louder each time hoping it will stick and it doesn't and then we are frustrated that it doesn't”

0.52

Teams that blindly follow all rules can point to process compliance if an initiative fails, which reduces personal accountability but also prevents innovation; followers of rules are paid minimum wage equivalents because they provide no judgment value.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“being able to defend when things go wrong right so uh you know following rules is very comfortable because if we follow all the rules and it doesn't work out we can just point at the rules and say look we followed all the rules we followed the process we came to all the product reviews we showed you all the mock-ups and all the intermediate artifacts as the rule said yeah right and so therefore now if this product failed in the market or failed to win don't blame me right like I followed the rules right”

0.52

Most people habitually judge others who are focused on optics as lesser or less important than those focused on impact and execution, but this judgment prevents true collaboration and understanding of why someone prioritizes optics.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“it was easy for me to judge uh other individuals or other teams saying like oh these people are only focused on Optics whereas I am focused on impact and execution which are the right things to be focused on um and when you start with that sort of feeling it doesn't create or make any room for True collaboration”

0.52

Understanding someone's perspective requires exploring their concerns and rationale with genuine curiosity rather than judgment; the interviewer's example of asking 'what would have to be true for me to behave this exact same way' is an effective perspective-taking tool.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Interviewer (Shane Parrish)

“if you could see the world through other people's eyes you would make the exact same decisions that they're they're making so there's something that you're missing that enables this gap between what you would do and what they're doing and putting yourself into their their mindset or taking their perspective on a problem what would have to be true for me to behave this exact same way is often a good way to sort of see a different perspective into the situation”

0.51

Most people learn better when content is entertaining; however, applying this truth to oneself would suggest you should only learn from entertaining content, which is a trap—instead, you should deliberately cultivate the ability to learn from non-entertaining content and extract value from poorly packaged ideas, giving you an edge over people who need entertainment.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“most people learn better when the content or the teaching is entertaining right when when it's entertaining it's like it's got great stories amazing analogies people just learn better right and there are many people who proudly say right like you know and I come across such folks all the time as a teacher myself or as somebody who writes online and so on is uh and well I only learn through engaging writing right now as a smart person who wants to make a big impact on yourself and on the world right if you think really deeply about this kind of truth let's just say right which is most people learn better learn the best when the content and the teaching is entertaining is uh that if you want to help people learn something make it very engaging and entertaining okay so that's the obvious conclusion that almost any smart person will reach right but it turns out there is actually one more conclusion you should draw to be a better decision maker and to have better results for yourself which is it is actually not in your best interest to be the kind of person who only learns from entertaining content right”

0.51

The core difference between a good team and a great team is the judgment of the leader of that team, not the execution quality or individual talent level.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“the core difference between a good team and a great team is the Judgment of the leader of that team”

0.51

To grow competence systematically, decompose the desired skill into component parts and develop each component intentionally; this approach is far more tractable than hoping that projects will somehow teach you the whole skill.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“if I want to increase my confidence grow my competence systematically right uh it becomes much clearer how I do that which is okay in order to grow my product sense I need to grow my cognitive empathy I need to grow my domain knowledge and I need to grow my creativity um now there are details of how you might do that but the point is now you have um you know much more clarity on kind of this systematically growing your competence”

0.51

The antithesis principle requires embracing inconsistency: observing how the world works is consistent with not embodying that pattern yourself; the very fact that a pattern exists in the world indicates you must recognize it but not necessarily live by it.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“the reason and it is the antithesis principle is not extremely intuitive and certainly it wasn't for me early on in my life is because it requires us to embrace inconsistency right like we we just like habitually look for consistency so the thing we observe in the world we want ourselves to act consistently with the thing we observe in the world but the antithesis principle says that the very fact that you made an observation about this thing in the world the way the world works and in all of its imperfect ways um it indicates that yeah sure by all means to have an impact and to be effective you need to recognize um the way the world works but that doesn't automatically mean that you also embody that in yourself right”

0.50

A business document is an experience for the reader, similar to a movie, book, or podcast; writing should be intentional about what experience and emotional response is being created in the reader.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“all of these things are experiences right like a movie is an experience uh a book is an experience that somebody is creating a podcast is an experience and so similarly a document that you're writing is an experience you're creating for your target audience so it it helps to be very intentional about what do you want them to experience”

0.50

Writers should work backwards from the emotional response they want to evoke in readers—excitement, concern, fear about a competitor—and let that intention shape word choice, structure, and emphasis throughout the document.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“I go you know I even go to the extent of kind of really brainstorming in these situations like you know what is the core emotion we want to evoke right in the reader and I'm not talking about fiction writing right I'm talking about like just like business non-fiction writing about a certain product or a certain whatever but it's really important to work backwards from you know do I want them to be excited do I want them to be slightly concerned uh do I do I want to kind of clarify that like we should be afraid about a certain you know competitor or whatever the case may be”

0.50

The Agency-Talent Matrix categorizes people along two axes: agency (high or low) and talent (high or low), creating four archetypes: cogs (low agency, low talent), frustrated geniuses (high talent, low agency), go-getters (high agency, low talent), and game changers (high agency, high talent).

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“you know I I sort of as I was thinking back a few years ago about like the the people I've seen that have outsized outcomes consistently uh both for themselves and for the teams and the companies they're part of um I'd realized that there were some patterns um between those uh individuals and um that's when I came across this term High agency which I believe Eric Weinstein coined the term uh and you know essentially it's a high agency is about uh it's basically about you know doing certain things doing taking on hard things uh without waiting for condition to be conditions to be perfect or otherwise blaming your circumstances right”

0.49

The compounding effect of consistent deliberate learning over time is so powerful that even 5-10 hours per week of outside-work learning, if sustained, will make you substantially more effective at your project work and ultimately take less time overall.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“what what happens is that kind of even if it's five percent right say five percent or 50 hours right so the in a week so that's two and a half hours a week where I'm explicitly not learning just from you know doing projects at work and what that does is that compounds like crazy over time right”

0.48

Teams don't need all members to be high-agency; a few high-agency individuals who can navigate obstacles creatively and influence others can dramatically improve team outcomes and culture.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“you don't need the entire team to be extremely high agency but the ability of at least a few individuals on the team to have and embody this High agency approach such that oh actually yes we do have this obstacle but here's how we're going to creatively execute around that obstacle in order to make impact”

0.48

Stripe's founders (Patrick and John) lived the company's values by regularly talking to customers, including non-executives like customer support teams, and sharing observations widely, which signaled to employees that customer closeness was genuinely valued, not just rhetoric.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“the founders kind of lived these values as well right so you know Patrick and John until a very very long time as the company was scaling and to a point where you wouldn't expect the founder to do so uh they were talking to customers they were talking to users and and not only that in many cases they would kind of you know have a meeting with the customer and send out notes right”

0.48

At Stripe, every function was treated as equal in status and importance, with no implicit functional hierarchy (such as engineering being most important), which enabled authentic conversation about what is right rather than debates being settled by pulling rank or title.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“at stripe uh you know certainly you know during the time I was there that hierarchy was absent right like really you treated every function uh equally right and now they might perform different roles right but but it wasn't like one function was better than the other so one function was higher than the others right”

0.48

When a product manager or engineer leads a presentation to executives with execution-level details while the executives are asking impact-level questions, the audience becomes confused and disengaged, even if the details are accurate and relevant.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“if you lead with that you are going to lose uh the audience uh and so and this is merely just one example of where like you know executives are probably thinking at the impact level product managers or Engineers are thinking at the execution level”

0.48

When two teams cannot work together effectively, the root cause is often that their leaders are fixated on different levels (execution, impact, optics) rather than genuinely disagreeing on what is best for the joint initiative.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“I've also encountered uh Team issues inter team issues you know famously there are many organizations where two teams can't work together uh and they complain uh and each team complains that we can't work well with this other team even in those situations I've often found that it's actually the leaders of the team that are fixating uh on different things”

0.48

Once you understand the three levels of product work and recognize which level a conflicting party is operating at, you can take a step back, explore their perspective with empathy, and identify a solution that achieves both parties' objectives.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“when I saw these situations where perhaps somebody else some other team leader that I'm trying to collaborate with is really focused on Optics uh I wanted to take a step back then and really explore their perspective a little more and perhaps you know the reason they were focused on Optics is because they've been burned before”

0.48

In highly measurement-oriented organizational cultures, individuals and teams can demonstrate impact through a combination of leading indicators—both quantitative measurements and qualitative signals such as customer testimonials and adoption by high-value customers—rather than waiting for full revenue impact to materialize.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“ultimately the measurement is not the goal right the impact is the goal we hope that the measurement is uh just a proxy for the impact we made right and sometimes we we forget the the we can't differentiate between the proxy and the goals right and so we make the proxy the goal”

0.48

Professional managers tend to gravitate toward quantitative indicators while founders tend to gravitate toward qualitative signals; however, this pattern reverses as companies scale, with founders often learning that they must manage by numbers because they lose direct customer empathy at scale.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“if we were talking about General patterns um that matches my understanding and my observations too”

0.48

Founders who scale successfully and build great products long-term strike a balance between managing by numbers (necessary for scaling) and maintaining qualitative signals from the market, customers, and competition; founders who lose this balance mistake the map (numbers) for the territory (reality) and can drive themselves off a cliff.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“the founders that have been able to scale really well and their companies have been able to build incredible products over the long term I have found uh they kind of strike this balance really well they do stay very close to their customers they do stay very close to some anecdotes and don't just kind of manage by spreadsheet”

0.48

At Stripe, product thinking—concern with what the right product is, why you're building it, and how it will resonate with users—was everybody's job across engineering, design, sales, and other functions, not siloed to product managers, which enabled the creation of magic products.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“when product and thinking about the product and thinking about the customer experience is everybody's job which it certainly was uh and and has been at strike for a while um you know kind of thinking about the product and fixating on what kind of product we're building and why we're building it and how it's going to resonate with our users when it is everybody's job uh you know engineers and designers and even sales and marketing and other functions uh then you can you have at least the ingredients for creating Magic”

0.48

Many successful and modern tech companies inadvertently undermine magic product creation by relegating product and customer thinking to one or two functions while expecting other functions to stay in their lane; this siloing results in uninspiring products.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“too often what happens uh and I've seen this at many many companies in the valley some of the most successful and modern companies uh in in the technology space is uh that at some point uh this idea of like okay are we building the right product are we building a product uh that our customers will really love and are we building a product uh that uh that will win in the market that's those concerns get relegated to one function uh or or a couple of functions while the other functions get more focused or somehow are asked to get more focused on just like stay in your lane do your thing you know ship your code right”

0.48

A writing culture in organizations enables a permissionless environment where anyone can document insights and proposals asynchronously without waiting for meetings or permission, which increases transparency and innovation.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“a true writing culture kind of removes a lot of those constraints right so if you spot something um that you think needs to be improved in a writing culture in a in a true writing culture you can write about it and share the document and uh see what people have to say see if it resonates”

0.48

A key challenge of writing culture is that not everyone is a good writer and some people hold limiting beliefs about their writing ability, which makes it harder for such people to influence others in writing-dependent organizations.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“another aspect um is that when you kind of write things down one of the challenges that arises um is that not you know the the problem is that not everybody is a good writer right and that kind of some people have also told themselves stories about oh I'm not a good writer right and and so one of the challenges is that such a culture makes it hard for people who kind of think they're not a good writer to be able to influence right”

0.48

When people write documents that receive no executive attention despite the executives asking for them, they often interpret this as lack of caring and become discouraged, but the real issue is that the documents are poorly structured and fail to make the core insight easy to find.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“I observed that in that the documents had all the right ideas but it was hard to find those ideas and it was hard like here's 20 pages but there's like three good ideas in here go find them”

0.48

A common error in professional writing is attempting to communicate everything one knows about a topic rather than identifying the one core insight and building the document around that, which results in readers becoming lost in the detail.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“the reason that some folks do this when they are writing is because they want to communicate everything they know about this topic yeah they have this deep desire to like you know I know all of these things about this thing so I'm going to communicate everything and I'm going to communicate every single angle and every single detail and anecdote and statistic about this thing”

0.48

A writing culture enables asynchronous, distributed decision-making and feedback without formal permission structures, creating a permissionless environment where ideas spread based on merit.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“when you have a writing culture you it becomes more of a permissionless environment because you know in our you know you know say non-writing culture where perhaps the way big decisions are made or proposals are shared it's usually in some meeting where perhaps uh you know we have a discussion uh or I walk you through a slide deck well the observation is that uh all of a sudden if that's the way that big proposals need to be made or even small proposals need to be made now you need permission right you need permission to join the meeting you need permission to present at the meeting”

0.48

Cogs (low agency, low talent) perform essential but undifferentiated work that does not substantially change team or personal outcomes; go-getters (high agency, low talent) are ambitious and creative despite lacking experience; frustrated geniuses (high talent, low agency) have tremendous potential but are blocked by something and spend energy complaining about constraints rather than working around them.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“if you have low talent and low agency right uh then you are going to be a cog in the wheel you're going to perform some undifferentiated work”

0.47

Product sense consists of three decomposed components: cognitive empathy (understanding how users and customers think and what resonates for them), domain knowledge (understanding the technology, market, competition, and regulatory constraints), and creativity (converting empathy and knowledge into compelling products, UX, and go-to-market approaches).

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“well it turns out product sense has three components uh the first is cognitive empathy which is do I understand how you think as a user how customers think how they approach situations what will resonate for them or not right that is cognitive empathy second is domain knowledge right do I understand enough about this domain about the technology about the market about the competition etc etc uh such that I can make a decision that will differentiate us such that uh you know I do understand regulation and the limitations of what we can get done Etc right so that's kind of domain knowledge and then the third piece is creativity”

0.46

Return on investment (ROI) is calculated as (value minus cost) divided by cost; when optimizing for ROI, teams can increase the numerator or decrease the denominator, and the second approach leads to chasing low-hanging fruit and quick wins rather than ambitious, high-impact initiatives.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“the formula for Roi is like yeah you know the value you got minus uh the you know the effort or the time or you know expense you put in to get the value divided buy the effort time expense right whatever the case might be um so so it's a ratio right now whenever you have a ratio and you want to increase that ratio so in this case Roi uh you can increase the numerator or you can play a trick and decrease the denominator right”

0.46

Game changers (high agency, high talent) are rare and change the trajectory of teams and companies; if you identify a game changer early in their career, you must invest heavily in providing opportunities and support to realize their potential.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“the last quadrant in this Matrix is you know the high agency and high Talent quadrant and these folks I just call them game changers right like they they change the game for the company for the team for themselves um uh and but the reality is that there are very few of them right so if you come across a game changer early in their career uh you better hold on to them right and you better provide them with the opportunities and the support uh that is necessary for them to achieve their potential”

0.46

Many professionals assume their only learning vehicle is projects at work, but allocating 5-20% of career time to deliberate learning outside work projects compounds dramatically and makes you far more effective at your project work.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Shreyas Doshi

“some people think that um the at some point in their career they reach a stage where they start making the assumption that the only way that they'll grow their competence is through projects they do at work which is hey I'm clearly doing all this work and I'm learning all these new things right and that's growing my confidence and absolutely it is no doubt whatsoever uh but the challenge is that some what I ask people to do instead of just being focused on learning from projects at work is you know look you have 168 hours in a week like you know take some number of hours and call it your career time and I don't care if it's 30 hours 40 hours 50 hours 60 hours 70 80 90. whatever you do you do you you pick some number of hours in a week which is your career time and your career time certainly involves all the time you spend on your work on your projects at work right but let it not be 100 percent right I want you to carve out five percent ten percent twenty percent of your career time uh and I want you to allocate that time on learning outside of your work projects right”

0.45

Creativity in the product context means converting cognitive empathy and domain knowledge into concrete proposals, compelling user experiences, and effective go-to-market and marketing approaches; without creativity, you can have empathy and knowledge but fail to create products that resonate.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“creativity and creativity is about taking these two inputs which is cognitive empathy and domain knowledge and turning it into a concrete proposal for what we are going to build so you can have the first two but if you don't have the creativity on your team uh then you can take all those inputs but you won't be able to convert those inputs into a compelling product proposal in a compelling ux and a compelling go to market approach and a marketing approach and so on that will actually then resonate”

0.45

Product teams that optimize solely for ROI tend to work on incremental improvements and table stakes, avoiding ambitious projects that might have large impact but require working through ambiguity, leading to uninspiring products that meet but do not exceed market expectations.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“we get kind of really seduced by this kind of you know tendency to want to reduce the denominator uh and and what does that do what that leads to is a lot of me too products it leads to us kind of just meeting table Stakes it leads to kind of uh picking the safe things because the safe things are uh you know easy to quantify and they're safe because they're easy to quantify”

0.45

Go-getters (high agency, low talent) are often better hires than frustrated geniuses for roles that require navigating ambiguity, such as product management, because go-getters will work to resolve ambiguity whereas frustrated geniuses complain about it.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“given a choice between hiring a frustrated genius and hiring a go-getter um if it is a role that has a high degree of ambiguity I would rather hire the go-getter than the frustrated genius because I know the go-getter will work hard to resolve the ambiguity versus uh you know complain about the ambiguity and in many ways product management uh you know the role I have done for many many years is a role whose primary responsibility is to resolve ambiguities and act in the presence of ambiguities so for PMs it becomes really important to kind of have this High agency”

0.45

Go-getters can develop into game changers over time through accumulated experience, which is why experience gaps are less important than high agency when hiring for roles that require navigating ambiguity.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“sometimes go-getters over time become game changers um because you know with enough experience now you can increase your competence so you can go from the low perhaps on the low Talent side to the high Talent side just by virtue of having that much more experience um and and so again you know in many cases you know for certain roles I would rather prefer a go-getter who's perhaps a little bit lacking on certain of the certain experience factors uh because I've found that those experience factors can be rapidly made up for”

0.43

Product sense is the ability to consistently make correct product decisions even in the face of high ambiguity; it is not an innate trait but a skill that can be developed systematically.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“the ability to usually make the correct decision about a product or a product feature um whether it's macro or micro uh even in the face of very high ambiguity right”

0.43

In a writing culture, documents spread through asynchronous comments and discussions across Slack channels and other channels without formal approval, enabling a form of viral transparency and collective intelligence that is not possible in meeting-based cultures.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“at stripe as a writing culture I saw it often where uh there were people you know regardless of their role um and their function within the organization uh kind of wrote down something super insightful and as they shared it it kind of spread through various slack channels saying like oh this person wrote this doc you know you should check it out”

0.43

Shreyas did not feel truly successful in his 20s and mid-30s because he was unable to spend time on his top three life priorities, but now, in his late 30s and beyond, he achieves his definition of success by having that optionality.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“I wasn't really successful in my 20s or mid 30s uh because I was not able to spend all the time I wanted to spend on the top three things in my stack rank uh but uh luckily now I am uh so I feel like I'm kind of successful”

0.43

Stripe was adding product management relatively late, after achieving significant success without it, which made it an interesting test case for whether product management can create unique value at already-successful companies.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“you know usually you'll have product management added at you know several dozen to 100 or so people uh so stripe was adding product management a little late um and uh had done just fine without product managers”

0.43

The core insight of a document should be clearly stated early, with supporting ideas and details that follow, not buried within or at the end; this structure respects the reader's attention and decision-making constraints.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shreyas Doshi

“which is what is the most important thing I want to convey right and start with that message in any kind of document and proposal in the work setting um and you know share that message very early on in the document whatever that might be you know our core Insight is X and based on this core inside x uh our proposal is that we do a b and c right”