What this covers

This is a single-guest interview on BNN Bloomberg with Gary Shilling, who runs an economic consultancy and says he has recently gone short the S&P 500 for the first time since before 2008. Much of the conversation concerns timing and evidence. He notes that the National Bureau of Economic Research did not date the 2007–2009 recession's start until a year after it began, and he reads the index's year of going nowhere as a broad top, which he says usually means a bull market is over. He also argues that recessions are mostly an absence of growth, not a collapse: consumer spending fell in only 7 of 13 post-war recessions and never by more than 1–2%.

The range is wider than equities. On policy, he says Fed easing is arriving on schedule but cannot prevent a downturn, because quantitative easing (QE)) has already flooded the system and nobody borrows in a recession. He sees the recent repo market stress as mechanical, tied to excess reserves and quarter-end factors, not a repeat of subprime. On credit, he points to roughly half of US corporate bonds being rated BBB, one notch above junk bonds, and describes a possible downward spiral as restricted institutions are forced to sell. Private equity and private credit, swollen by yield-hungry money, are flagged as vulnerable too.

The more contested material is forward-looking. He expects a fiscal stimulus built on infrastructure spending, with deficits no longer a concern in Washington, though effects would take two to three years. He argues that aging and a shift from borrowing to saving point to slower growth, yet also forecasts 2.0–2.5% long-run real growth on stronger productivity. He puts an average recession's hit to the S&P 500 at about 15–20%. His own positioning is long 30-year Treasury bonds with a 2% yield exit target, long utilities, consumer staples and the dollar, and short the S&P 500.

Sharpest takeaway

Gary Shilling argues that despite a 50-year low unemployment rate, the U.S. economy is at or very close to recession due to leading indicators (inverted yield curve, weak capital spending, transportation stock declines, Fed/OECD recession indicators), and investors should take defensive positions because the unemployment rate lags business cycle peaks by 17 months on average, making it a misleading indicator of current economic health.

  • Historical data shows a 17-month average lag between business cycle peaks and unemployment rate lows across 11 post-war recessions
  • Multiple leading indicators (inverted yield curve, capital spending weakness, transportation vs. industrial stock ratio, Cleveland/NY Fed recession indicators, OECD 32-country indicator) are all showing negative signals
  • The S&P 500 has been essentially flat for a year despite the unemployment rate hitting 50-year lows, indicating the market has already discounted recession expectations

The claims · ranked23 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

Across the 11 post-war recessions in the US, the average lag between the peak in business activity and the low in the unemployment rate is 17 months, meaning the unemployment rate could continue to decline even while the economy is in recession because job losses are a delayed reaction to economic weakness.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Gary Shilling

“if you look at the 11 post-war recessions we've had in the US the average lag between the peak in business and the and the low in the unemployment rate is 17 months okay in other words the unemployment rate could continue to decline even though you're in a recession because it's a lag”

0.75

The Federal Reserve typically eases monetary policy at the end of a business cycle or soon after a recession begins as they see the economy weakening, and they are 'right on schedule' to do so now, but monetary easing does not prevent recessions because the damage is already done, there are lags in effectiveness, and during recessions nobody wants to borrow regardless of how much money the Fed provides.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Shilling

“bear in mind that the Fed usually is patriotically easing at the end of a business cycle or soon after recession starts they see that the economy is weakening and they switch from tightness to each so they're right on schedule what that doesn't prevent recessions because the job is already done there are lags the effectiveness in monetary policy there's also the reality that that when you get into recession nobody wants to borrow”

0.75

A precarious situation exists in credit markets: approximately 50% of US corporate bonds are rated triple-B (BBB), which is only one step away from junk status, and in a recession many of these will be forced downward in rating, creating a 'cumulative downward spiral' because financial institutions that are restricted from owning junk bonds will have to sell, forcing prices lower.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Shilling

“you've got a problem with over about 50 percent of US corporate bonds or triple B and that's only one step away from junk you got a recession a lot of them forced down then you get a cumulative downward spiral because a lot of financial institutions can't own okay not on junk bonds right so you do have a precarious situation there”

0.74

Recessions are more an absence of growth than actual collapse—consumer spending in 13 post-war recessions increased in real inflation-adjusted terms in 6 of them and declined in 7, but even when it declined it never fell by more than 1-2%, so the issue is lack of growth in consumer spending rather than shrinkage.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Gary Shilling

“recessions are more a absence of growth than they are collapse I mean consumer spending for example we've had 13 recession the post-war period in in six of those real inflation adjusted consumer spending actually increased seven Omo declined but it never declines by more than a percent or two what it see it's the absence of growth which is which is what bothers people”

0.72

Multiple factors point to slower GDP growth in the years ahead: aging populations (people don't spend as much), a major consumer spending boom since the early 1980s (when consumers borrowed heavily) that is now reversing as people shift to saving, and when saving (rather than spending), income growth is slower than spending growth.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Gary Shilling

“there's a lot of lot of things that suggest that global slowing growth in in years they had one is aging population yeah people don't spend as much money another one is that you have really since the early 80s had a big rush into consumer spending people have been borrow heavily spending now they're saving and when you're spending your your your your income is growing slower than spending when you're saving is the reverse”

0.69

If Shilling is correct that the US is in or near a global recession, there will likely be a fiscal policy response featuring infrastructure spending, which both Republicans and Democrats now agree on, though such fiscal stimulus takes 2-3 years to have full effects as states navigate zoning, contracts, and staffing.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Gary Shilling

“if I'm right that we are in recession and a global one US Canada Europe Japan that there will be a fiscal policy response and that will probably be infrastructure spending that was what happened in 2009 they had big tax cuts and rebates and infrastructure spending”

0.69

Private equity and private credit markets attracted large flows from pension funds, family offices, and money managers due to extended low interest rates pushing investors to search for yield, but these are now vulnerable to multiple headwinds: interest rate pressure, fee compression, and the structural corporate bond situation.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Gary Shilling

“these lower interest rates were so long because so many pension funds family offices money managers to move into that area and still are specifically almost even more so in or in the later side of this the private credit market are you concerned”

0.68

Despite structural headwinds pointing to slower long-term growth, productivity growth in the US has picked up (though not in Canada) and will continue to be stronger, so real GNP growth of 2.0-2.5% in the longer run is achievable and is higher than most people expect.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Shilling

“I happen to think productivity growth which has picked up in the US and not in Canada but I think it has picked up and it will continue to be stronger in the years ahead so I think we're going to have real GNP growth of two to two-and-a-half percent that's that's higher than most than most people expect”

0.66

The National Bureau of Economic Research, the private organization officially designated to call recessions in the US, did not declare that the 2007-2009 recession had started until December 2008, a full year after it actually began in December 2007, because recession calls come after the fact when it is obvious and data is revised.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Gary Shilling

“the guys who officially call recessions called the National Bureau of Economic Research private organization no president in the United States would ever want to call a recession no no but this group studying them since the 1930s they didn't until December of 2008 say that the recession has started in December of 2007 that was the Great Recession a lot of times they don't get around to making a call that you have to hit the top until the recession is over”

0.66

The Federal Reserve has been flooding the world with money since quantitative easing followed the big decline in interest rates after the Great Recession, so it is not as if monetary easing is a new or instant solution to economic problems.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Gary Shilling

“the Fed has been flooding the world with money ever since quantitative easing followed the big decline in interest rates after the Great Recession so it isn't it isn't this instant now”

0.64

Shilling believes there is probably further upside in long-term Treasury bonds with declining yields due to the US being a safe haven and lack of credit demand in the expected global recession creating 'zeal for safety.'

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Gary Shilling

“I do think there's probably still some further rally in long Treasuries decline in yields and and because because the US is a safe haven and if I'm right that we're in or close to a global recession I the lack of credit demand and the zeal for safety I think we'll see some further rally”

0.57

A critical error in market analysis is paying attention only to what the Fed does (easing) and missing the context of why the Fed does it (because they're worried about the economy); what matters is the economy's effect on earnings and general spending conditions, not the Fed's actions themselves.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Shilling

“it's not what the Fed does it's why the Fed does it Fed is if Fed is easing because they're worried about the economy then you've got to worry then you've got to think about the economy and what it does to earnings and and and general spending and economic conditions and the Fed does not really matter for a number of quarters”

0.52

The bull market narrative of 'consolidation is healthy' in the S&P 500 after a year of no gains fails to account for what comes next—the stimulus effects that worked for the past decade have 'played out' and the Fed cannot 'pull this one out of the ground.'

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Shilling

“what do you do for an encore now the Fed is they've you know they've been dumping money out of helicopters there's not much you can do...I don't think the Fed is going to I don't think the Fed can really pull this one out of the ground”

0.52

Low interest rates are causing a painful 'agonizing reappraisal' among financial institutions due to margin compression and fee pressure, making it a very different and less attractive world for financial sector careers and investments than it was a decade ago.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Shilling

“low interest rates are our causing shall we say an agonizing reappraisal among financial institutions so when you look at that plus the pressure on fees there's no question that the financial sector I would if I were doing over I would not go into her today and I was lucky to be involved in it and benefited like almost everybody else in it but it's a very different world today and you have low low fees you have pressure on on markets”

0.49

Nobody in the US government cares about deficit spending anymore (deficits of a trillion dollars are treated as 'big deal'), which means fiscal stimulus will be deployed despite the deficit, as both political parties now agree on infrastructure spending and have become 'callous to the idea of deficits.'

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Gary Shilling

“and now none of them care about the deficit it's a trillion dollars and big deal you haven't had a collapsing in the economy you haven't had sky-high interest rates they've gotten callous to the idea of deficits”

0.48

Multiple leading economic indicators are currently signaling recession risk: the inverted yield curve, weakness in capital spending, a decline in transportation stocks relative to industrials, negative recession indicators from the Cleveland and New York Federal Reserve banks, and a negative OECD leading indicator across 32 countries (US, Canada, Europe).

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Gary Shilling

“when you look at all the indicators the inverted yield curve the weakness in capital spending you look at a transportation stocks which have declined versus industrials that's normally a sign of a peak there are a lot of other indications there the Cleveland and New York Federal Reserve banks there was their recession indicators are are in negative territory is the OECD indicator of you know 32 leading countries US Canada to Europe etc that's in negative territory”

0.45

Shilling has recently taken a short position on the S&P 500, a position he has not held since before the 2008 financial crisis, based on his conviction that multiple economic indicators point to recession and market action (the S&P 500 being essentially flat for a year) suggests a broad top formation that typically signals the end of a bull market.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Gary Shilling

“we are we are short the S&P 500 we've only done that in the last couple of weeks”

0.45

The global economy is in or near recession, particularly Europe (Germany) and other major economies (Canada, Japan), so stimulus outside the US will not help and the US will face headwinds from global weakness.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Gary Shilling

“you've got the rest of the world which is pretty much in recession particularly in Europe Germany and and and also the the you know the the effects of stimulus at this point it's it's pretty much you've you've played out you played out the game”

0.45

An average recession lasts about 3-4 quarters, and if a typical/average recession pattern holds, the S&P 500 would decline roughly 15-20% from current levels (which would bring it to approximately the level of its December 24th low), compared to the 22% average post-war recession trough decline, similar to the subprime mortgage recession but less severe than that event.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Gary Shilling

“if it's an average recession it lasts about three or four quarters you get you can get big ones whether special factors like the subprime mortgage collapse that gave you this very deep recession in 2007 2009 but ordinarily it and and in by the way if you had the normal reaction of stocks it would say that that the SP would drop probably maybe a couple hundred points below the low it reached on in December 24th Christmas Eve in other words it wouldn't be a dramatic collapse but it still would be declined from here”

0.45

The repo market stress that has occurred is more a matter of mechanics (excess reserves created by QE, bank caution about holding money, quarter-end tax payments, special factors) rather than something deep-seated like the subprime mortgage crisis, and the Fed has been relatively slow but is now waking up to address it.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Gary Shilling

“it's a very arcane area catherine i tend to think that it is is more a manage of the mechanics as opposed to anything deep-seated there are a lot of you know there's a lot of excess reserves there they were created with quantitative easing and they and the banks have been very cautious on that they've been told to hang on to their money and time and so forth and so i think you had and you had quarter in tax payments and constant special factors and and you know the Fed is they were a little slow on the slow on the trigger but i think they have woken up to that”

0.42

The S&P 500 has been essentially flat (where it was a year ago) despite a big sell-off in Q4 and some revival since then, and when you get a broad top formation like this it usually indicates that 'the game is over' and the bull market is ending.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Gary Shilling

“if you look at if you look at the u.s. S&P it really has been going it's really topped out year early last year as a matter of fact it's it's nowhere it's essentially where it was a year ago at a big sell-off in the fourth quarter some revival but it's going nowhere in the last in the last year and when you get that broad top like that it usually tells you that that the game is over”

0.40

Shilling's portfolio has maintained long positions in 30-year US Treasury bonds (with a target yield of 2%, and current yield around 2.03%), defensive stock sectors (utilities and consumer staples), and the US dollar as a safe haven, while maintaining short S&P 500 and avoiding commodities.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Gary Shilling

“we're still holding him my tire was 2% and I'm very aware from past experience of overseeing a winning position...we have not we have not liquidated our positions are helping long Treasuries”

0.17

Shilling is aware from past experience of the risk of oversizing a winning position in Treasuries and has set a 2% yield target as his exit point, showing discipline in position management.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Gary Shilling

“I'm very aware from past experience of overseeing a winning position I mean that had been there done that well”