What this covers

Ezra Klein talks with the historian Gary Gerstle about his book on the rise and fall of the neoliberal order, using the idea of a political order as the organizing lens. Gerstle defines it as a 30-40 year consensus in which one party sets the policy agenda and the other eventually acquiesces. The conversation first covers the New Deal order. Gerstle argues it might have been a passing Progressive moment without the Cold War. The Soviet threat pushed business toward the Treaty of Detroit, kept Eisenhower from rolling back the 91% top tax rate, and justified projects like the Interstate Highway System. He also stresses its internal contradiction: Southern Democratic support depended on leaving Jim Crow alone. The order then broke down through Vietnam, stagflation, and the New Left's mix of anti-corporate critique and demands for personal freedom.

The middle stretch is the rise of neoliberalism. Gerstle presents it as a moral ethic of individualism and cosmopolitanism as well as an economic program. He casts Bill Clinton as the "Democratic Eisenhower" who accepted Reaganite deregulation despite his bitter feud with Gingrich. Ralph Nader's consumer politics, Gerstle contends, shifted attention from employers and employees to cheap goods and changed antitrust thinking. The Soviet collapse, Iraq, and the uneven recovery from 2008 mark the order's unraveling.

The last section turns to the present. Gerstle describes bipartisan convergence on China, reshoring, and industrial policy, and notes that "protectionist" was a bad word before 2016. Joe Biden is shown continuing and extending Donald Trump's China approach. More contested is the claim that both parties now distrust unconstrained markets, with Republicans citing family and community decay and Democrats citing climate, and that a moral-renewal strand is tying virtue talk to political economy.

Sharpest takeaway

Gell argues that American politics is transitioning between political orders—from the neoliberal order (1970s–2008) to an emerging post-neoliberal order characterized by renewed emphasis on government intervention, community welfare, and national economic strategy, with both parties converging on issues like China, industrial policy, and moral renewal despite superficial polarization.

  • The neoliberal order collapsed after 2008 because market deregulation failed to lift all boats and produced visible inequality, delegitimizing the core neoliberal promise.
  • Both parties now agree on the necessity of government-directed industrial policy, tariffs, and reshoring—a fundamental break from neoliberal free-market orthodoxy.
  • A nascent moral and communitarian concern is emerging across both parties, questioning individualism and seeking to rebuild the economic and social foundations of community life.

The claims · ranked38 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

Political orders are structures of political consensus that last 30–40 years, during which one party arranges a dominant constellation of policy, constituencies, and candidates that the opposition party eventually feels compelled to acquiesce to in order to remain electorally viable.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Gary Gell

“a political order is something that lasts Beyond particular elections that refers to the ability of one political party to arrange a constellation of policy constituencies think tanks candidates individuals who come to dominate politics for extended periods of time and their dominance becomes so strong that the opposition party feels compelled if they still want to remain real players in American politics it compels them to acques and to come aboard the other political parties platform”

0.80

The Interstate Highway System was labeled 'the national system of Interstate and defense highways' and supporters argued that building 41,000 miles of new roads would facilitate both rapid transfer of military units to threatened areas and rapid evacuation of populations from areas threatened by atomic bombs, demonstrating how Cold War National Security rhetoric justified major government infrastructure spending.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Ezra Klein

“the interstate highway system was labeled uh in the bill quote the national system of Interstate and defense highways...supporters of it argued that building 41,000 mies of New Roads would facilitate both a quick transfer of military units to parts of the United States under attack and Rapid evacuation of people from areas threatened by atomic bombs”

0.79

Eisenhower maintained the 91% marginal tax rate from WWII and preserved New Deal social programs (Social Security, Wagner Act, labor organizing rights) because he understood the Cold War had to be won on an ideological front—proving American capitalism could deliver a better life to ordinary citizens than Soviet communism—which required narrowing inequality and supporting a strong labor movement to demonstrate capitalism's superiority.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gell

“in order to win the ideological struggle of the Cold War which was not simply an American Soviet struggle but it was a global struggle to convince all the peoples of what was then called the third world to come with the capitalist way to come with the American way in order for that to happen America had to demonstrate that it could give its ordinary citizens a good life and that meant taking money from the rich and redistributing it narrowing the inequality between rich and poor it meant supporting powerful labor movement and not trying to roll back the Wagner Act”

0.76

In the 1990s beneath apparent bitter polarization and cultural battle between Clinton and Newt Gingrich lay deep bipartisan agreement on deregulation: both signed the Telecommunications Act (1996), repealed Glass-Steagall (1999), and abandoned the Fairness Doctrine, advancing the neoliberal project further than Reagan himself, as evidenced by the fact that both men, despite hating each other publicly and privately, recognized they were on a similar political economy mission.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Gary Gell

“one of the surprises to me in working on this book because I remember those days very well was the degree to which they worked together on telecommunication on reform of Wall Street on welfare now Clinton would claim and his Defenders would claim that he was triangulating he was trying to make the best of a bad deal that popular opinion was running with free markets was running with the Republicans and to some extent that was true but I was surprised the degree to which these two men who who loathed each other in public and in private recognized that on political economy they were on a similar Mission”

0.75

The fear of communism prompted the American business class to compromise with organized labor at a scale and degree it had never done before, symbolized by the 'Treaty of Detroit' between the three largest automobile manufacturers and the United Auto Workers, which granted unions high wages, good conditions, pensions, and health care; absent this fear, Gell argues this compromise would either not have been reached or would have been scuttled much sooner.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gell

“the business class felt that it was in its interests to compromise with organized labor in a way that it had never done before that was the Grand compromised it was symbolized in a treaty in Detroit between the three automobile makers then among the biggest corporations in America and United Auto Workers the Treaty of Detroit purchasing labor Peace by granting unions good wages good conditions good pensions Good Health Care absent the threat of communism I think that grand compromise either would not have been arrived at or it would have been scuttled much sooner than it was”

0.75

The New Left of the 1960s–1970s erupted on university campuses critiquing 'the system'—large American corporations and a corrupted federal state that was supposed to manage capitalism in the public interest but had become an instrument of corporate power—and combined this with a powerful cry for personal freedom, autonomy, and individual expressiveness, explicitly rejecting being 'folded, spindled, or mutilated' like IBM punch cards.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gell

“the new Left erupts on University campuses in the 1960s and the two primary issues in the beginning are race and Vietnam but they also quite quickly develop a critique of the established order there's a time when the operation of the machine becomes so odious makes you so sick at heart that you can't take part...and what was the system the system was large American corporations who were no longer under control and one reason why they were no longer under control is because they were being aided and eded by a large federal state that was supposed to manage them in the public interest”

0.75

Americans and Europeans previously believed that if market freedom and capitalist practices took root in China, Chinese citizens would eventually demand political freedom, democracy would flourish, and the Communist Party would be forced to reform or face ouster; this belief shaped decades of policy giving China economic access, but no one in Democratic or Republican parties believes this anymore, and recognition that democracy and markets are not linked has intensified fear of China.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gell

“for the longest period of time Americans and Europeans were willing to give China a blank check on their democracy or on their violations of democracy because of the belief that if Market freedom and capitalist practices set down deep enough roots in China that people with economic freedom would want to add to that political freedom and that democracy would begin to flourish and that the Communist party that rules China would either have to profoundly reform itself or see itself pressured from the political stage it's hard to convince people now of How Deeply rooted that belief was no one in the Democratic or Republican parties believes that anymore and that has intensified the fear along with this oh my God sense that China is not simply producing ordinary Goods it's producing very sophisticated Goods”

0.75

Before 2016, protectionism was a bad word in American politics; identifying as protectionist meant marginalization as dangerously heterodox; the sentiment has not disappeared but the term has, replaced by positive language like 'fair trade,' and this represents a profound change in both parties' orientation, now shaped daily by conversation about reshoring, industrial policy, and fair US-China trade relations.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gell

“before Trump and Sanders in 2016 Bernie Sanders protectionism was a bad word in American politics if you were identified as protectionist you were out of mainstream politics you were not being listened to you were being marginalized as dangerously heterodox don't you see that the period of protectionism has gone and the the period of free trade has triumphed and that has completely transformed and the word protectionism is not being used because it's such a Negative term but the sentiments that lie behind protectionism which might be described more positively as fair trade are profoundly with us and shape conversation about us economic relations with China every day of the week”

0.75

The Biden Administration, in contrast to Clinton and Obama, took Trump's approach to China (treating it as an adversary and restricting trade) and went further, representing genuine policy continuity across administrations rather than the previous pattern of Democratic reversions to neoliberalism.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“you have to take seriously that Donald Trump changed both parties on China when we're thinking about things where the other party acquiesced to a different view a different idea that Trump coming and saying we are losing the competition to China they should be treated as an adversary much more so than an ally that has become conventional wisdom in both parties and you said that protectionism had been a dirty word but then you mentioned another term that has sort of also shifted which is industrial policy that China was effective at using the government to protect and encourage and subsidize Industries and in doing so sure sometimes things ended up being losers and not winners but they actually were able to bring a bunch of major industries to life and the same is actually true at this point among Republicans they've also come in many cases to the view that we should have much more industrial policy the sense that if you leave it to the market China might by using the government to Foster and supercharge certain kinds of Market Pursuits in China just lap us I think has become the dominant view in both parties”

0.74

The collapse of the Soviet Union between 1989 and 1991 opened the entire globe to capitalist penetration to a degree unavailable since prior to World War I, generating tremendous excitement and arrogance within the capitalist world (the US), and signaled to American Republicans and the business class that communism was vanquished, vindicating their core belief that capitalism should be freed from constraint.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Gary Gell

“The collapse of the Soviet Union between 1989 and 1991 is one of the most stunning events I think of the 20th century and arguably much longer what were its consequences first it opened up the whole globe to capitalist penetration to a degree that had not been available to capitalism since prior to World War I and this generates a tremendous amount of belief and excitement and expansion and a good deal of arrogance in uis within the capitalist Citadel which is the United States”

0.74

The 2008–2009 financial crisis revealed that market freedom had led to corrupt banking practices and nearly caused financial abyss; more importantly, the unequal recovery—where stock market holders recovered by 2011 while paycheck workers didn't reach pre-2008 levels until 2016–2018—exposed the profound inequality embedded in neoliberal governance, causing people to scrutinize neoliberal inequality with new concern.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Gary Gell

“what the 2008 2009 financial crisis exposed was first a lot of the market Freedom that neoliberalism had Unleashed had had led to corrupt Banking and Financial practices that had brought the world to the edge of financial abyss...it brought into view a sense of how profoundly unequal the access to power was under the neoliberal r regime and here it's not so much the financial crash itself but the nature of what governments did to promote recovery from the financial crash and the object in the US and also in Europe became to save the banks first the culprits of this financial crisis were the ones who were bailed out first if you were an American in 2009 2010 2011 who had assets in the stock market you had pretty much recovered your position by 2011 2012 if you were not one of those fortunate Americans and you were living we week to week on a paycheck your recovery did not occur you didn't reach pre-2008 levels to 2016 2017 2018”

0.74

The New Deal order contained an internal contradiction: its political economy required southern Democratic support, which came only on the condition that Roosevelt would not challenge Jim Crow, segregation, or lynch law, creating a racial hierarchy that eventually fractured the Democratic coalition when African-Americans migrated north and became a constituency within the party during the 1940s–1960s.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Gary Gell

“the great contradiction in the New Deal party of Franklin Roosevelt was the treatment of African-Americans in order to have a new political economy of a big state managing private capital in the public interest Roosevelt had to get the south on board and the South meant the white South The South was a one party State the Democratic party was the only party that mattered congressmen and senators from from the south would get elected again and again and again and they would rise through seniority they'd be the most powerful figures in Congress and they said we will support you Rosevelt with your broader political economy as long as you leave the racial hierarchies of the South intact”

0.74

Vietnam, an enormously unpopular war inaugurated and presided over by Democratic presidents, split the Democratic Party and was perceived by Democratic constituents as being misrepresented by leadership; it also created trade-offs between war funding and Johnson's Great Society programs, causing inflation, and thus constituted the second major factor in the collapse of the New Deal order.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Gary Gell

“Vietnam a vastly unpopular War inaugurated and presided over by democratic presidents who were perceived by their own constituents to not be telling the truth about this awful Quagmire it swallowed up a President Who otherwise would be regarded as a great president in American history Lyndon Johnson and had deeply split the Democratic party it also inaugurated trade-offs between funding a war and funding Johnson's beloved Great Society inflation began to take off”

0.74

In the 1970s, international political economy shifted decisively against American Supremacy: Western European and Japanese economies recovered and began competing seriously with the US (symbolized by Japanese car manufacturers' rise); OPEC nations asserted control over their oil resources and quadrupled prices; these factors combined with inflation from Vietnam spending to plunge the US into stagflation (simultaneous inflation and unemployment), which conventional economic textbooks said should not occur and for which existing policy tools no longer worked, constituting the third major factor in the collapse of the New Deal order.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Gary Gell

“one of the the reasons why America was able to enter its Grand compromise between capital and labor and pay labor very high wages was that America had no serious industrial competition in the world from the 40s to the 60s most of the industrialized world have been destroyed the US is actively helping the recovery of Western European economies Japan promoting development in Southeast Asia and in the 1970s these economies begin to challenge American Supremacy economically the symbol of that is the rise of Japanese car manufacturers who suddenly begin competing very seriously with the US...most of them controlled by us and British oil companies and Saudi Arabia and other oil producing nations in the 1970s say no these are our resources we will deter DET how much is drawn out of the ground and the prices that they will be charged and the quadrupling of oil prices leads to a profound economic crisis”

0.74

The 1950 Nixon-Khrushchev Kitchen Debate in Moscow—where the US demonstrated superior household appliances and dishwashers—was a moment where the US publicly admitted the Soviet Union was a serious economic rival, not merely a military one, and America had to prove that capitalism could deliver better consumer goods and living standards to ordinary citizens.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Gary Gerstle

“the Soviet Union was still doing quite well in the 1950s there was an extraordinary debate that occurred in Moscow in 1959 Vice President Nixon debated kusf about who could deliver better kitchens to their consumers and the Americans imported all the most recent household appliances from the United States reassembled them on a stage in Moscow and Nixon and Cruz Chief went at it including a dishwasher for the first time when it wasn't a common feature of American homes what was this about this was the United States admitting that the Soviet Union was a serious rival not simply militarily but economically as well”

0.74

The Iraq War, which Gell considers the worst foreign policy mistake in US history requiring 50 years for the world to recover from, was imbued with neoliberal hubris—the belief that the world was waiting for the wonders of a market economy to be unleashed and that spreading market freedom would solve problems.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Gary Gell

“I think that's right I mean there are many places where I think there's continuity between Barack Obama and Joe Biden but China is really not one of them I think you have to take seriously that Donald Trump changed both parties on China when we're thinking about things where the other party acquiesced to a different view a different idea that Trump coming and saying we are losing the competition to China they should be treated as an adversary much more so than an ally that has become conventional wisdom in both parties and you said that protectionism had been a dirty word but then you mentioned another term that has sort of also shifted which is industrial policy that China was effective at using the government to protect and encourage and subsidize Industries and in doing so sure sometimes things ended up being losers and not winners but they actually were able to bring a bunch of major industries to life and the same is actually true at this point among Republicans they've also come in many cases to the view that we should have much more industrial policy the sense that if you leave it to the market China might by using the government to foster and supercharge certain kinds of Market Pursuits in China just lap us I think has become the dominant view in both parties”

0.73

The New Deal order (1930s–1970s) would likely have been only a temporary Progressive moment—a 'blip'—rather than a dominant political order lasting 40 years, absent the existential threat posed by the Soviet Union and the Cold War, which gave Republicans incentive to maintain New Deal policies and thus legitimized them as bipartisan consensus.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Gell

“absent the Cold War the New Deal which we now regard as such a juggernaut would be seen as a momentary blip like so many other Progressive moments in American politics and we would see it as a blip and not for what it became which was a political order that dominated politics for 30 years”

0.73

Concerns about moral fiber, virtue, and morality in American life are not new to Republicans (going back to Jerry Falwell and 1990s figures), but what is new is recognizing that moral renewal requires connecting those concerns to a serious program of political economy that rebuilds the economic and social foundations underlying community and family welfare, not merely calling people to virtue through churches.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Gell

“the concern about the moral fiber of the American people is not new in the Republican party that goes back to Jerry fwell to some of the min who became popular in the 1990s...the new element is a sense that one has to connect that concern for this kind of morality to a serious program of political economy that it's not enough simply to call on people to be virtuous it's not enough simply to pack churches on a Sunday morning and have them listen to sermons that serious Christians that serious conservatives have to find a way to rebuild the economic Foundation that lies at the root of so much immorality and so much despair in American life”

0.73

Neoliberalism is not only an economic theory but also a moral ethic emphasizing cosmopolitanism, individualism, and liberation from constraints, making it appealing to leftist constituencies who value personal freedom, diversity, immigration, and global travel—Reagan appealed to this freedom ethic while emphasizing free enterprise, while Clinton connected neoliberal economics to support for feminism, sexual liberation, civil rights, and cosmopolitan values.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Gell

“Reagan was an enormously successful president and and by success I mean he was able to excite the imagination of majorities of American voters and his core message was freedom and half the time he meant freedom in terms of a free enterprise economy but the other half of the time he meant freedom in terms of giving individuals the autonomy to go their own way now he was not a fan of himself of the liberation movements of the 60s but when Clinton becomes president in the 1990s he has a profound connection to those Liberation movements of the 1960s to feminism to sexual Liberation to civil rights and he detects in a world in which everyone can travel to wherever they want to go he valorizes immigrants he valorizes diversity these are all values that are profoundly compatible with the neoliberal vision”

0.73

Both parties increasingly believe that markets left to their own devices will trample over core values and goals—community, family, environmental sustainability—that should instead be served by markets; Republicans frame this in terms of broken communities and eroded male economic provision affecting family formation, while Democrats emphasize climate change, illustrating a shared rejection of neoliberal faith that markets will produce desired social outcomes.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“I think both parties have come to a view they didn't hold us strongly before if they did hold it at all which is that markets left to their own devices are going to trample over values goals visions that they should instead be serving so the sort of ideological strain in the Republican party that JD Vance is part of this sort of more populist dimension of it what they see markets and particularly free trade and trade with China and immigration as having violated is the strength of communities and families they look around and they see broken communities hauled out communities they see families where the male Breadwinners have lost their jobs and lost their earning power and so they're not getting married and their divorces and there are too many single parent families and on the Democratic side I think there's some of the same views there's a lot of broken communities and I also think a huge participant in this ideologically is climate change sense that markets would happily make people Rich by cooking the planet”

0.71

Bill Clinton functioned as the 'Democratic Eisenhower': when punished in the 1994 midterm elections, he read this as a mandate to abandon the older Democratic Party of the New Deal and acquiesce to core Reaganite deregulation beliefs rather than attempting to roll back the Reagan revolution, just as Eisenhower acquiesced to the New Deal rather than rolling it back.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gell

“I think Clinton in the beginning is a little uncertain about what he is going to do and he has some ambitious proposals in his first two years most notably a vast program of national health insurance which crashes spectacularly and then he gets punished for that Venture severely in the 1994 Congressional elections which bring new new inrich and a very right-wing group of Republicans to power the first time that Republicans control both houses of Congress since 1952 it's a huge achievement for the Republicans Clinton reads that moment as signifying that the older Democratic Party of the New Deal of Franklin Roosevelt and Lynden Johnson really had to be reworked and revamped and the only way for him to win re-election and the only way for the Democrats to hold on to National Power and to regain it in Congress in 1996 is for him to acques to some core reaganite beliefs”

0.70

Ralph Nader, a man of the left but fitting neither the old nor new left, championed the 'consumer left' and made the consumer the key figure in American society, thereby deflecting attention from the core capitalist relationship—between employers and employees—and enabling a profound shift in antitrust policy, such that corporate power became permissible as long as it served consumers with cheap goods.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Gary Gell

“he executed a profound shift in ideology and I'm not even sure how aware he was of the consequences of what he was generating because in the process of making the consumer Sovereign he deflected attention I would say from what was and what Remains The Core relationship in a capitalist economy and that is in the realm of production and the relations between employers and employees”

0.69

China was initially viewed as a cheap labor economy undercutting US wages, but by the Obama Administration was recognized as an advanced competitor building infrastructure, moving into advanced manufacturing, dominating renewable energy and EV supply chains, and pulling ahead in semiconductors—a recognition creating bipartisan agreement that America cannot make things and China can, representing huge conceptual agreement between parties.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“over a long period of time now going back into the Obama Administration before Donald Trump China has been exerting an enormous pressure on American politics initially the view is that China is taking lowcost low wage manufacturing by undercutting us on how much workers are paid theyve all these people they pay poverty wages that you couldn't get away with in in America and it's just a cost cutting measure but by the time of the Obama Administration begin to have this sense that they're doing things we're not doing anymore building trains building whole new cities at at very rapid Paces they're beginning to move into advanced manufacturing by the time you get to Donald Trump and and then to Joe Biden they're dominating in certain areas like pulling ahead of us in in some ways on the ability to build lowcost electric vehicles they're dominating the renewable energy supply chain”

0.68

The Soviet Union's collapse was important to Republican and conservative identity because it eliminated the external enemy that had justified Republican opposition to big government and commitment to maintaining some government functions; with communism gone, Republicans cast about for new enemies (global jihadism after 9/11) which proved inadequate, leaving the party without a unifying external threat and opening space for Trump.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“I've always thought that one of the identity crises in the Republican Party one reason the Republican part is not held together better is it the Soviet Union was fundamental to what made its various factions stay in place and it was also I think fundamental to what kept the Republican party which at its core has a real anti-government streak committed in any way to real government and then I think there's a sort of casting about for another enemy I think you end up finding it after 911 or think they have in what they try to turn into Global jihadism and that falls apart both as the ant and as a project”

0.65

Neoliberalism is defined by the belief that the best economic program is one that frees capitalism from government shackles and allows people to truck, barter, and exchange goods freely, with government's only role being to ensure markets function freely and robustly—the opposite of New Deal logic, which held that capitalism left to its own devices would destroy itself.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Gary Gell

“neoliberals believe that the best economic program is one that frees capitalism from its shackles that allows people to truck barter and exchange goods that gets the government out of economic life and the only role for government is to ensure that markets can function freely and robustly so it runs opposite to the new deal if the core principle of the new deal was capitalism left to its own devices would destroy itself the core principle of neoliberalism remove the shackles from capitalism that will bring us the most productive and freest world we can imagine”

0.63

The 2016 election was a decisive inflection point marking the end of the neoliberal order; neoliberalism did not disappear, and advocates for free markets remained, but the order as a governing consensus ended, opened by Trump's challenge to Republican orthodoxy.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Gary Gell

“I would agree with that and that speaks to the decisive nature of the election of 2016 which we will see the longer we get from it as a decisive inflection point as really marking the end of the neoliberal order and marking the end of the neoliberal order doesn't mean that neoliberalism disappears it doesn't mean that suddenly there are no more Advocates of strong free markets”

0.63

Tim Alberta's book 'The Kingdom, the Power and the Glory' documents how sincere Christians could support Trump despite his perceived paganism and moral failings, suggesting the Christian right's adoption of Trump was driven by factors beyond theology.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstle

“part of what I've been trying to understand is how sincere Christians have been able to give such incredible support to the man who I regard as the most Pagan man ever to inhabit the White House and he may well inhabited again and a book that helped me a great deal is Tim Alberta's book The Kingdom the power and the glory American evangelicals in an age of extremism he took me into a world that I otherwise didn't have accessibility to and he helped me to understand a great deal that I did not so I thank him for that”

0.61

Abortion and reproductive rights represents a moral issue running too deeply between Republicans and Democrats for common ground, limiting the potential for moral-based bipartisan conversation if JD Vance and associates maintain their stance on the issue.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Gary Gellman

“there are some issues that run so deeply on questions of morality between Republicans and Democrats it's hard to see how they can find common ground and probably the most important of these is on the question of abortion and Reproductive Rights and to the extent to which J D Vance and his associates take their stand on this issue the possibilities for developing a conversation about morality with liberals and Democrats are going to be very very slim indeed”

0.60

We are currently in an interregnum between political orders: the neoliberal order has ended but no new political order has established itself with assurance, leaving multiple possible outcomes still possible and explaining current political upheaval and internal party divisions as both parties attempt to remake themselves and respond to the emerging order.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Gary Gell

“their are multiple outcomes uh that are still possible and that's a sign that uh we're living in an interregnum between political orders and no new political order has established itself to the point where we can say with Assurance yes this will Triumph”

0.54

There is zero confidence that if Donald Trump wins a second term, we will see a cohesive ideological agenda in the direction of industrial policy or serious political economy; Trump's ideological commitments do not run deep enough to sustain coherent policy across an administration.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ezra Klein

“to be clear I have zero confidence that if Donald Trump wins we're going to see a cohesive ideological agenda in any of these directions I do want to bring up another piece of it that I think Trump represents though which gets to that other dimension that more moral Dimension”

0.53

Among young right-wingers, classical virtue (via figures like the Claremont Review and Stoic philosophy) is displacing Christian moralism as the philosophical container for conservative moral renewal, suggesting the Christian right may be too weak and insufficiently appealing to be the vehicle for contemporary conservative moral pushback against individualism.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Ezra Klein

“I am very struck on the right at the moment if you look at the kinds of people that young right-wingers read hilariously the bronze agage pervert but the Claremont review people the things that I think would have once been framed in terms of Christianity are now framed in terms of classical virtue there's a sort of rediscovery of the stoics not the early Christians and so there's something here where obviously efforts to remoral America are not new but this idea that we have gone wrong in modernity by becoming so individualistic seems to be gathering a fair amount of force my read of it is that the Christian right is just too weak and not sufficiently appealing to be the vehicle for it and so these other aesthetic and ancient contain ERS are being searched for”

0.52

Gell describes the neoliberal vision through four freedoms: freedom of movement (people); freedom of goods to move across national boundaries; free flow of information; and free flow of capital across all boundaries, such that in a perfect neoliberal world all four move freely without constraint.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gell

“it's what I sometimes call The Four Freedoms of neoliberalism freedom of movement people freedom of goods to move across National boundaries the free flow of information and the free flow of capital across all boundaries in a perfect neoliberal world people Goods information and capital are moving freely without constraint”

0.49

The Republican Party is more deeply split on industrial policy than the Democratic Party is: Democrats arranged a grand compromise between left (Bernie Sanders) and center (Biden) symbolized by Build Back Better's $5 trillion industrial policy commitment, while Republicans have committed figures (Rubio, Cotton, Vance, Holly) but also remain influenced by Silicon Valley tech figures (via Peter Thiel) with a different vision, and it's unclear where Trump stands.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Gary Gell

“I would agree with that although I think the Republican party is probably more deeply split on this than the Democratic party is the Democratic party arranged another kind of grand compromise between the left represented by Bernie Sanders and the center represented by Joe Biden which led to a profound commitment symbolized by build back better at $5 trillion project that was going to insert industrial policy into the part of government economic relations in a way that marked the Biden Administration as profoundly different from his Democratic predecessors both Obama and Clinton I think the Republican party does not have agreement on that to the same degree”

0.49

Both parties are beginning to converge on concerns about the moral fiber of American life—particularly around technology and youth, with growing skepticism about whether individualism and permissiveness have failed, and with both left and right articulating that government should take paternalistic responsibility for protecting young people from technology harms.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ezra Klein

“is a world where kids are on their smartphones all the time and families are having this much trouble and did we get something more fundamental almost spiritual wrong I think that's right I think the concern about the moral fiber of the American people is not new in the Republican party that goes back to Jerry fwell to some of the min who became popular in the 1990s and calling America back to moral virtue”

0.47

Jimmy Carter, influenced by Ralph Nader, was uncertain about and torn between the older Democratic party of unions, federal policy, and vast programs and a newer orientation toward smaller government and deregulation, as evidenced by contradictory speeches—one month preaching that 'government can't solve people's problems,' the next sounding like an old Democrat—making him a transitional figure unable to master the moment but only to glimpse it.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gell

“he's very uncertain about this path for the Democratic party and he's very torn and so one day as in this speech that we just listened to he's supporting smaller government deregulation preaching a philosophy that government can't solve people's problems but that older Democratic party of unions federal policy vast programs a welfare state is still there and still present and he'll give another speech a month later where he sounds much more like an old Democrat and I think as I evaluate the Carter presidency I see a man really caught in the throws of a moment of transition able to Glimpse what is coming but unable to master what is coming and so what defines his presidency for me is uncertainty vacillation and thus failure he's a classical transitional figure more controlled than in charge of the moment”

0.47

The personal computer movement, which valorized individual autonomy and freedom from IBM mainframe control, emerged as part of the New Left in the 1960s and was later channeled by Steve Jobs and Stewart Brand into a vision of personal liberation through technology that inadvertently created the infrastructure for individualistic neoliberalism.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstle

“the battlecry of the Free Speech movement in Berkeley in 1964 arguably the first mass moment of protest uh on the part of the new left was I will not be folded spindled or mutilated where does that phrase come from that was a phrase printed on every IBM card IBM was the dominant computer maker of the time the computers were these enormous machines mainframes and they were seen as stultifying to human creativity and the personal computer movement was borne on as part of the new Left um Steve Jobs steuart brand imagined a personal computer that would be free of the IBM Mainframe free of big corporations big corporate power that it would be the authentic voice of only every individual who would be using that machine it was a profound expression of a desire for personal autonomy individuality expressiveness unconstrained by larger structures”

0.43

The effort to regulate morality and content via government policy predates the 2020s: Congress attempted an anti-pornography measure in the 1996 Telecommunications Act, and trans-related policy conflicts in the 2020s resemble those in the 1990s, suggesting continuity rather than novelty in moral regulation efforts.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Gary Gell

“I think this does go back to the 1990s and in one respect one of the few pieces of Regulation that Congress imposed on the IT industry in the 1996 telecommunication Act was kind of an anti-pornography measure that then gets thrown out by the court so it comes irrelevant but it was part of the Congressional package it was one of the few elements of an attempt to regulate morality for the general welfare and on the other side some of the flash points of conflicts that we had in the 1990s over trans issues and the like today remind me very much of flash points in the 1990s”

0.14

Abraham Lincoln's America had no standing army, no large federal state, and no strong executive power until the Civil War consolidated the state; Eisenhower inherited this tradition of executive constraint but used it to defend the New Deal order rather than roll it back.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Unidentified Speaker — Are We on the Cusp of a New Political Order? [bGmzHXnRP9o]

“N/A”