
China’s Banking System ‘Teetering’ | Housing Crisis | PMI | Decoupling | Battery Supply Chain
What this covers
This is a 12-minute solo China Update briefing from Tony, split into two parts: a roughly seven-minute run through China's October economic data, then a shorter segment on US-China technology decoupling. The economic half pairs the headline numbers with commentary from named analysts, and the decoupling half works through concrete cases of Chinese leverage over Western firms.
The data section opens with the Purchasing Managers Index (PMI)). The official manufacturing reading was 50.1, up from 49.8, and the Caixin reading was 50.3, up from 49.3. Non-manufacturing PMI reached 50.2, its first expansion since May. Wang Jian reads this as a sign that policy is starting to work, while Julian Edwards Pritchard points to domestic demand even as export orders fall. Property sales jumped 73% month-on-month after the September stimulus, and Chen Wening welcomes the recovery while saying more help is needed. Tony counters with the sector's overcapacity, developers' liquidity problems, and a contested estimate that vacant homes could house the entire population. Banking follows: margins of 1.54%, profit growth of 0.4% in the first half, Le Jiming's doubt that lower provisions reflect real profitability, and a reported capital infusion of up to 1 trillion yuan.
The decoupling segment starts with Skydio, the largest US drone maker. Beijing's counter-sanctions cut off the batteries it buys only from Chinese suppliers, and officials visited those suppliers directly. CEO Adam Ray has appealed to Kurt Campbell and the White House. Tony sets this against a Horizon Advisory report on China's control of the battery supply chain, and against China's share of lithium, nickel, cobalt and rare earths. The last item is Mark Warner's letter criticizing weak US oversight after a TSMC-made chip turned up in a Huawei product.
Tony argues that while China shows tentative signs of economic stabilization in manufacturing and property sales, underlying structural problems—massive property sector overcapacity, banking system strain, and strategic supply chain vulnerabilities—persist and threaten long-term sustainability, while Western firms face mounting exposure to Chinese economic leverage and sanctions.
- Manufacturing PMI barely crossed 50 (expansion threshold) despite massive stimulus, signaling weak underlying demand recovery
- Property sales rebounded but sector remains 'very sick' with 80+ million empty homes and developer liquidity crises
- Chinese banks face unsustainable 1.54% margins and may need 1 trillion yuan capital infusion despite already exceeding minimums
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Skyio, the US's largest drone maker and a supplier to Ukraine's military, faces a supply chain crisis after Beijing imposed sanctions on the company, banning Chinese groups from providing it with critical components, specifically batteries that it sourced exclusively from Chinese suppliers.
“skyio the US's largest drone maker and a supplier to Ukraine's military faces a supply chain crisis after Beijing imposed sanctions on the the company including Banning Chinese groups from providing it with critical components skyio is rushing to find alternative suppliers after beijing's move which also blocks battery suppliers from its Sole Provider said people familiar with the situation”
Despite October's property sales rebound, China's real estate sector remains fundamentally distressed with massive overcapacity, weak demand, sliding prices, and a liquidity crisis for developers.
“the sector is still very sick with massive overc capacity which we'll look at in a moment weak demand sliding prices and a liquidity crisis for developers”
Julian Edwards Pritchard, economist at Capital Economics, argues the latest improvement in China's PMI data was driven by stronger domestic demand, as the new orders component edged up even though export orders continued to decline.
“Julian evard's Pritchard an economist at Capital economics expressed on these data quote the breakdown of the survey suggests that the latest Improvement was driven by stronger domestic demand the overall new orders component edged up even though the export orders index continued to decline end quote”
Property sales surged 73% month-on-month in October, with analysts expecting this recovery due to China's strongest stimulus package to date in the previous month, which included cutting borrowing costs on existing mortgages, relaxing buying curbs in big cities, and easing down payment requirements.
“sales surged 73% month- on month analysts were expecting this as China Unleashed its strongest package of measures to date last month including cutting borrowing costs on existing mortgages relaxing buying curbs in big cities and easing down payment requirements”
According to H Securities analyst Le Jiming, lowering provisions has boosted profits for major Chinese banks, but slow or declining revenue growth in Q3 suggests underlying profitability is weakening.
“according to H security analyist Le jiming lowering Provisions has boosted profits for the major Banks but slow or even declining Revenue growth in the third quarter suggests underlying profitability is weakening”
Wang Jian, senior economist at Caixin, argues that Caixin manufacturing PMI data show market demand stabilized and optimism improved, suggesting early signs of policy impact, but the labor market remains under pressure and price levels are still subdued.
“Wang j a senior Economist at Tyson inside group expressed on the index quote data from the Tyson manufacturing PMI survey show the market demand stabiliz ized and optimism improved suggesting early signs of policy impact however the labor market remains under pressure and price levels are still subdued end quote”
China's 61 trillion-yuan banking sector is grappling with record-low margins, falling profits, and increasing bad debts as banks are directed by government to offer low-interest loans to cash-starved government entities and reduce mortgage rates.
“the 61 trillion US banking sector in China is still grappling with a record low margins falling profits and increasing bad debts as banks are directed to offer low interest loans to help cash track the government entities and to reduce mortgage rates broadly”
Chinese authorities visited Skyio's suppliers, including Dongan Power Amp (a subsidiary of Japan's TDK that makes drone batteries), and ordered them to sever ties with Skyio, demonstrating direct enforcement of Chinese counter-sanctions.
“Chinese authorities visited Sky&'s suppliers including dongan Power Amp a subsidiary of Japan's TDK that makes drone batteries and ordered them to civer Ties scario”
According to Horizon Advisory's special report 'The China Hazard,' China's dominance in the battery supply chain is built on a holistic, government-backed approach involving control of material extraction, processing, battery production, and recycling, enabled by non-market tools including subsidies and preferential policy support.
“us-based Horizon advisory warns clients quote China's dominance Builds on an international and holistic approach to control the battery supply chain from rare materials extraction and processing to battery production and recycling that dominance is fueled by the Chinese government's deliberate planning and support provided to companies along the entire value chain via non-market tools EG subsidies in preferential policy support”
Democratic Senator Mark Warner, chair of the Senate Intelligence Committee, wrote a letter to the Biden Administration criticizing it for apparent lack of monitoring of TSMC following revelations that a chip produced by the Taiwanese chipmaker ended up in a product made by heavily sanctioned Chinese company Huawei.
“uk-based Reuters reports that Democrat Senator Mark Warner chair of the Senate intelligence committee wrote a letter which has not been made public to the Biden Administration criticizing it on Huawei according to the outlet Senator Warner criticized the Biden Administration for quote apparent lack monitoring end quote of tsmc following Revelations a chip produced by the Taiwanese chipmaker ended up in a product made by China's heavily sanctioned Huawei”
Senator Mark Warner's letter to the Biden Administration also criticized the government for repeated leadership failures in enforcement of US export rules, specifically citing TSMC's production of chips for Huawei as having serious implications for US National Security.
“in the letter reviewed by Reuters the influential lawmaker also took the government to task for quote repeated leadership failures end quot in enforcement of us export rules after tsmc informed the US that one of its chips have been found in a Huawei AI processor a possible violation of us restrictions on the chines telecommunications equipment maker the letter reportedly Express quote tsmc's production of chips for Huawei has serious implications for US National Security I urge you to swiftly take immediate steps to assess and strengthen the effectiveness of existing controls end quote”
According to Bloomberg reports, China is considering a capital infusion of up to 1 trillion yuan into its largest state-owned banks to boost their ability to support the economy, despite these banks already exceeding minimum capital requirements.
“USB Bloomberg has reported that China is considering a capital infusion of up to 1 trillion yen into its largest State Banks to boost their ability to support the economy even though these Banks already exceed minimum Capital requirements”
Combined profits across China's commercial banks grew only 0.4% in the first half of 2024, the slowest rate since 2020, with margins at a historic low of 1.54% in June, below the 1.8% level needed for sustainable profitability.
“combined profits across China's commercial Banks grew only 0.4% in the first half of the year the slowest rate since 2020 with margins at a historic low of 1.54% in June below the 1.8% level needed for sustainable profit profitability”
China accounts for approximately 60% of global battery-grade lithium supply, 65% of nickel, 70% of cobalt, and 90% of rare earth elements such as neodymium, giving it substantial leverage over global supply chains for critical materials.
“China accounts for around 60% of the global supply of battery grade lithium 65% of nickel 70% of cobalt and 90% of rare Earth elements such as neodym”
Chen Wening, research director at China Index Holdings, acknowledged that the residential market turned more active in October as home buyers regained confidence, but warned that more efforts are needed to help the sector stem its decline.
“Chen wening a research director at China index Holdings while acknowledging that the residential market quote turned more active in October as home buyers regained some confidence end quot warned quote however more efforts are needed to help the sector stem its decline end quote”
Caixin manufacturing PMI came in at 50.3 in October compared to 49.3 in September, giving a more independent snapshot of the manufacturing sector than official PMI.
“meanwhile the tyon China General manufacturing purchasing managers index PMI which gives a more independent snapshot of the manufacturing sector came in at 50.3 compared to 49.3 in September”
China's non-manufacturing PMI climbed 0.2 percentage points in October month-on-month to 50.2, registering the first expansion since May in the construction and service sectors.
“the non-manufacturing PMI climbed 0.2% points in October month on month to 50.2 a separate index for construction and service activity also returned to expansion this month official data showed this is the first expansion since May”
Skyio announced on Wednesday that it was rationing the number of batteries supplied with drones due to Chinese sanctions and did not expect to have alternative suppliers until spring.
“scario on Wednesday told its customers that it was rationing the number of batteries supplied with drones because of the Chinese move and that it did not expect to have any new suppliers until spring”
In response to economic stimulus, China's major banks recently reduced policy rates and cut deposit rates for the second time in 2024 to address falling margins and weakening profits.
“we remember that in a bid to support the struggling economy China recently introduced its largest relief package to date reducing policy rates and cutting mortgage borrowing costs on 5.3 trillion Us in outstanding loans major Banks followed by lowering deposit rates for the second time this year to address falling margins and weakening profits”
Skyio's CEO Adam Ray met with US Deputy Secretary of State Kurt Campbell and senior White House officials seeking help from the Biden Administration to address the battery supply crisis caused by Chinese sanctions.
“skyio the Joe maker has sought help from the Biden Administration chief executive Adam Ray last week met us deputy secretary of state Kurt Campbell and held discussions with senior officials at the White House one person familiar with the situation said”
China's official manufacturing PMI came in at 50.1 in October 2024, up from 49.8 in September, marking the first expansion after months of contraction, driven by faster growth in basic raw materials, equipment manufacturing, high-tech manufacturing, and consumer goods sectors.
“the official purchasing managers index PMI the China's manufacturing sector came in at 50.1 in October up from 49.8 in September data showing manufacturing activity that month registered faster growth with key sectors such as basic raw materials equipment manufacturing high-tech manufacturing and consumer goods showing a positive performance”
A former deputy head of China's government statistics bureau estimated last year that the entire population of China could fit into the country's vacant homes, though some experts argue the true number is smaller.
“a former deputy head of the government statistics Bureau last year said that the entire population of China could fit into the country's vacant homes some experts still argue that the true number is smaller”
China's residential property sales in October saw their first year-on-year increase of 2024, with new home sales from the 100 biggest real estate companies rising 0.1% year-on-year to $61.2 billion, reversing from a 37.7% slump in September.
“China's residential property sales in October saw their first year on-year increase of 2024 the value of new home sales from the 100 biggest real estate companies Rose 0.1% from a year earlier to $ 61.2 billion reversing from a 37.7% slump in September”
China's major state-owned banks reported modest profit increases in Q3 2024 despite a slowing economy and shrinking margins: Industrial and Commercial Bank of China saw a 3.8% profit rise, while Agricultural Bank of China, Bank of Communications, Bank of China, and China Construction Bank reported gains between 1% and 6%.
“China's major state-owned Banks managed modest profit increases in the third quarter despite a slowing economy and shrinking margins Industrial and Commercial Bank of China limited saw a 3.8% rise in profits while other Banks like agricultural Bank of China limited Bank of communications Cod Bank of China limited and China construction Bank Corp reported gains of just over 1% to nearly 6%”
According to Bloomberg reports, cash-trapped developers are counting on a sales revival to persuade debt holders to accept restructured terms, illustrated by China Vanke's third quarter loss and 35% decline in contract sales in the first nine months of the year compared to the same period last year.
“USB Bloomberg reports today that cash trapped developers are counting on a sales Revival to persuade debt holders China vaner Co suffered another Hefty loss in the third quarter with its contract sales down 35% in the first at 9 months from the same period last year”
Bill Bishop, veteran China analyst, argues that the Skyio case is a cautionary reminder that Western firms engaging in anything the PRC could construe as endangering Chinese interests need to end reliance on China for critical components, expressing surprise that a company could sell arms to Taiwan while sourcing key components from mainland China.
“veteran China analyst Bill Bishop observed on this development today quote this was a good reminder for any firm not just selling arms to Taiwan but also engaging in anything the PLC could now or in the future construe as endangering the PC's growing interests that they need to end Reliance on China for critical components it is a bit surprising that a company could think it could sell drones in an arms package to Taiwan while sourcing key components from the PRC end quote”
Local analysts estimate that in July 2024 there were 32 million unsold homes in China, with idle properties or those bought by investors but not lived in adding another 49 million, putting conservative estimates of total empty houses at over 80 million.
“local analysts estimate that in July there were 32 million unsold homes idle Properties or ones that have been bought by investors but are not lived in could add another 49 million so conservative estimates put the number of empty houses at over 80 million”
According to Horizon Advisory, China's global footprint and dynamic approach to guaranteeing market access allows Chinese players to manipulate international trade regimes and co-opt global raw material resources beyond Beijing's borders.
“and is paired with a robust Global footprint China's Dynamic approach to guaranteeing Market access allows Chinese players to manipulate international trade regimes and co-opt Global B material resources Beyond beijing's borders”
China is currently implementing a strategy for long-term total domination of the battery supply chain and is monitoring and maneuvering to respond to the US's efforts to build a domestic supply chain in order to maintain market control.
“China is currently implementing their strategy for long-term success Total Domination of the battery supply chain they are also watching as the US begins to build a domestic supply chain and they are maneuvering in response to maintain their Market control”
Horizon Advisory argues that the US must combine industry incentives matched with robust protections against China's market maneuvers to build a formidable domestic battery supply chain, and must seize this opportunity quickly as the foundation has been laid.
“therefore as the US Works to build a formidable battery supply chain at home industry incentives matched with robust protections against China's Market Maneuvers must must be firmly in place the foundation has been laid now the US must decide to seize the opportunity at hand and fast end quote”
It is unclear whether China's October property sales rebound is sustainable or merely a burst in response to government stimulus measures.
“it is unclear whether this is sustainable or just a burst in response to the measures we will have to see”