
Why Liquidity Matters More Than Anything Else w/ Raoul Pal & Michael Howell
What this covers
This is a conversation between Raoul Pal and Michael Howell of CrossBorder Capital, organized in five chapters that move from definitions to central-bank behavior to the current point in the cycle. Howell starts by separating liquidity, the flow of cash and credit through wholesale banking, repo markets, shadow banking and cross-border channels, from conventional money supply. He then argues that since 2008 credit has depended on collateral rather than trust, so the system needs constant balancing-sheet support. Much of the discussion asks whether central bankers are acting deliberately or improvising.
The middle of the conversation covers the mechanics. Howell points to a deeply negative term premium on Treasuries as a sign of collateral scarcity. He argues this makes the yield curve an unreliable recession signal, since it reflects financial rather than real fragility. He also treats the redefinition of quantitative tightening (QT)) as letting debt roll off, rather than withdrawing liquidity, as a goalposts shift. The Bank of England's reversal during the UK gilt crisis and the Congressional Budget Office (CBO)) assumption of Fed purchases serve as evidence that quantitative easing (QE)) is not finished. Money parked in reverse repo is described as idle liquidity that Treasury bill issuance would need to replace once the debt ceiling is resolved.
The range also covers China, where demographics, high debt and political limits on consumer empowerment are said to lock the country into credit-led growth like Japan's. It touches on Basel III collateral hoarding, and on the view that a Western banking crisis would hand China a propaganda opening for the yuan. Several claims are openly contested. These include the near-term inflation outlook (low trend, high volatility), the idea that equities as long-duration assets rally on liquidity regardless of fundamentals, and the case for monetary hedges such as gold and crypto against currency debasement.
Central bank liquidity, not interest rates or conventional monetary policy, is now the paramount driver of financial markets and asset prices; governments monetize debt interest payments to sustain debt-dependent economies, making continuous QE inevitable regardless of inflation or rate cycles.
- With $350 trillion global debt at ~5-year maturity, $70 trillion must refinance annually; balance sheet capacity (liquidity) matters more than interest rates for rollover success
- QE expansion correlates nearly 1:1 with S&P 500 and other asset prices (0.97 correlation); liquidity cycle turnaround in October 2023 predicts ~6 months of continued market strength
- Negative term premium on US Treasuries signals collateral shortage, forcing central banks into perpetual liquidity support; yield curve control and QE rebranding as QT are evidence of deliberate monetization strategy
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Post-2008, credit markets shifted from being based on trust to requiring collateral; this structural change means the financial system cannot function without adequate collateral, forcing central banks into perpetual liquidity support.
“before 2008 uh credit markets were Allied to a large extent on trust post 2009 they demand collateral you've got to have collateral collateral is what the financial system is all about now”
With $350 trillion of global debt with an average maturity of around 5 years, approximately $70 trillion of debt must be refinanced every year, making balance sheet capacity (liquidity) the paramount factor in markets rather than interest rates.
“if you've got 70 trillion of debt to refinance every year you need balancing capacity to do that and balance sheet capacity is a measure of liquidity and so liquidity is the Paramount factor in markets”
Liquidity is defined as the flow of cash and credit through global financial markets and is fundamentally different from conventional money supply (retail deposit liabilities); it includes wholesale banking, repo markets, shadow banking, and cross-border flows.
“what we Define it as as the flow of cash and credit through Global Financial markets okay now it's not conventional money supply and money supply as defined is the retail deposit liabilities of High Street Banks”
Governments are determined to preserve the integrity of sovereign debt markets at any cost; the UK gilt crisis (September 2023) forced the Bank of England to reverse announced QT and implement QE, demonstrating prioritization of debt market stability over inflation control.
“you can see in many ways how governments are acting even in the last few months and what is of absolute importance is the Integrity of their sovereign debt markets that will do anything to preserve those sovereign debt markets and you can see that in the example of not just Japan but more uh explicitly look at what happened in the UK guilt Market the British guilt Market in September of last year uh guilt sold off that was a you know that was a huge shock to the system the bank of England changed overnight from a QT policy which they announced only days before to a full-fledged QE again”
China's rapidly aging population means Chinese consumers will not spend money; combined with cultural preference for saving, this ensures consumer-led growth is structurally impossible.
“with a very rapidly aging population old people do not spend money so how do you have a retail boom with a bunch of old people yeah and particularly Chinese consumers they tend not to be Big Spenders anyway um you know compared with with Western consumers in general they tend to save my money and the older Generations are much more wedded to that anyway”
The yield curve is hugely biased by negative term premium and signals potential financial fragility rather than real economic fragility; therefore, it cannot be trusted as a recession predictor.
“the yield curve is hugely biased by these negative term Premier now the term Premier are nothing to do with economic expectations or rate expectations it's to do with a shortage of collateral so what they're really telling us is more about potential Financial fragility than real economic fragility”
Money trapped in the reverse repo market represents zero-velocity liquidity that is withdrawn from the system; this needs to be replaced via Treasury bill issuance to maintain money market fund demand once the debt ceiling is resolved.
“the reverse Reaper the reverse repo uh in the words of some fed governor is the signal there is lots of excess liquidity in the financial system in all honesty that's completely rubbish it's a signal of the generosity of the Federal Reserve in paying high interest rates that's all it is but that money is locked up it's on the FED balance sheet is not circulating so the money funds who are putting money into the into the reverse repo are basically that the the velocity of that money to put another way is basically falling it's it's zero velocity so the Federal Reserve is taking it out of the system that needs to be put back in in some way the easiest way to do that once the debt ceiling issue is is resolved is to start issuing a lot more treasury bills”
Central bank balance sheet expansion is a form of currency debasement (lowering the value of the denominator/dollar), not mere inflation hedging; investors should use monetary hedges like gold and crypto to protect against this debasement.
“one of the ideas that I've got that people still dismiss is that this is actually debasement of currency so you're actively what you're doing is lowering the value of the denominator um the the dollar is still King in all of this”
China cannot grow without continued monetary stimulus due to bad demographics and high debt; this structural constraint means China is locked into the same credit-expansion path as Japan, guaranteeing continued infrastructure spending and shadow banking lending.
“it also seems very difficult for China with Scott a really bad demographic and a lot of debt not to rely on on monetary stimulus you know the boj have kind of taught us the lesson here there's no other way around it”
China has three growth engines: consumer spending, capital/infrastructure spending, and exports; China relies on the latter two because enfranchising consumers would lead to demands for democracy, which the government will not permit.
“there are three engines of growth in the for any economy consumer spending um Capital spending infrastructure or export growth now China has relying to a great extent on the latter two um infrastructure spending people say well that's spent but actually if you look at what they're doing currently is they're releasing more funds to local authorities uh in China which means there's going to be more infrastructure spending they're basically you know treading the same path again”
The risk of cutting rates too much is incentivizing private sector debt growth, which increases financial fragility; the real issue is that the system is inherently fragile and cannot function without central bank liquidity support.
“the problem with that particular scenario is that if you go down to very low interest rates you're incentivizing people to take on more debt and that's the problem ultimately we're we're taking on too much debt now it's okay in a way famous last words if the government sector takes on the debt okay uh but if the private sector is settled on that debt you get a lot more financial fragility and the the problem is that you know that's as I say the world we're in uh the financial system is not um as robust as many people would think hence the central banks have got to keep coming in they've got to keep supporting with liquidity”
The Congressional Budget Office projects a widening fiscal deficit over the next decade (through 2033) and factors in an increasing share of Treasury debt to be purchased by the Federal Reserve, acknowledging that QE is not dead.
“one of the things that you know viewers ought to be looking at is to go on to the Congressional budget office website and look at the projections of the the U.S fiscal balance over the course of the next decade they publish estimates out to 2033 and what you see there is a widening deficit but more particularly if you start to drill into the numbers you'll see there that the CBO actually factor in a rising share for the Federal Reserve taking up treasury debt okay so in other words there is uh acknowledgment that the Federal Reserve has to play a bigger and bigger role QE has not gone away it is not dead it is there”
The debasement of fiat currency through QE drives up the price of real assets over time, creating inflation in asset prices while goods prices may remain stable.
“that debases fiat currency over time which drives up the price of assets again a lot of people don't yet understand it but I really urge you to start understanding how liquidity matters more than anything else”
Until investors understand that central bank liquidity is the dominant macro force, they will continue using broken models (P/E ratios, etc.) and make poor investment decisions.
“until you understand that if you don't understand that you don't understand anything anymore because your models won't work your price earnings ratios won't work how you value things don't work until you understand how liquidity drives everything”
Term premium on US Treasury markets is deeply negative and at its lowest level since records began in 1961, indicating an excess demand for collateral in the system and explaining why the financial system is fragile.
“look at the term Premier on the U.S treasury market it's published every day by the New York fed okay that number is not just negative but if you take out the inflation Trend in that data it's the most negative it's ever been now textbooks will tell you that term Premier should be positive not negative but they're hugely negative they're the lowest they've been since records began in 1961 right now what is that telling you it's telling you there is an excess demand for collateral in the system”
Basel III regulations forced massive hoarding of collateral by banks, creating an endless collateral shortage that drives up demand for the dollar (as dollar-denominated collateral) and forces perpetual central bank papering of cracks.
“Basel III was another big part of that yeah you know the forcing of that massive hoarding of collateral means there's a endless collateral shortage which endlessly makes the dollar go up because it's a game of musical chairs because the whole world is a dollar funding mechanism”
Equities are high-duration assets; in a liquidity-driven world, more liquidity means investors want to take more duration risk, driving equity rallies independent of economic fundamentals.
“if the only outcome is more liquidity then equities essentially become and crypto and everything else essentially becomes a probability weighting of more liquidity because liquidity is what's driving it's a duration play that's all you need basically what's happening the equities are a high duration uh asset class if you put more liquidity in the system you want to take more duration risk and that's basically what's going on”
Central banks will not allow a major banking crisis because a banking crisis in the West would provide China a propaganda opportunity to promote the Yuan as an alternative currency, threatening US reserve currency status.
“the reason being is that it's absolutely in no one's interest to have a banking crisis now because you're presenting a gift to China okay if we if China sees a banking crisis in the west they'll say look told you so don't rely on these guys you've got to come with us and try and help the Yuan be a new currency alternative so don't give China or anything like that”
The trend direction of inflation is downward or low, but there is high volatility in inflation rates due to periodic liquidity spills from central banks; therefore, the outlook is disinflationary long-term but with inflationary volatility in the near term.
“I think the the first thing is that I'm fundamentally a deflationist because I think that what the world is going through is a is a japanification I think Japan has shown the world what happens and I think demographics are a huge huge Factor here so I believe that that's where the trend is on the other hand if you look at what's happening in terms of Central Bank liquidity injections in other words it's monetization you've got to say that there there is a case as we've seen in the last uh two years of that liquidity spilling over from time to time into the price level so my view is that the trend in inflation is probably downwards or it's low but we've got a lot of volatility uh in that inflation rate”
With trend GDP growth at ~1.75% and government debt at 100% of GDP plus private sector debt of ~120% of GDP, there is insufficient nominal GDP to service interest payments without central bank monetization (QE).
“if Trend rate of GDP is like 1.75 percent um and interest rates long-term interest rates are somewhere around the same it's there's still a hundred percent of GDP that goes in paying the government debt and then the private sector is another 120 of GDP excluding the finance sector so there's not enough GDP to pay the interest”
Negative term premium can only go up (become less negative) if liquidity expands (QE) or debt issuance increases; either way, this will put upward pressure on long-end interest rates despite short-end rate cuts.
“my only concern about the treasury market is that what you're sitting on is a very negative term Premier and those term Premiere can only likely go up from here and they will go up if liquidity in other words QE expands again which I think inevitably will and you've got a big increase in debt issuance which is surely coming so that's going to put upward pressure on term premium so the outlook for the long end of the market may not be as wonderful as people would argue”
Liquidity is the biggest and most dominant macro factor in markets today; most investors still don't understand it and continue using old analytical frameworks that are broken.
“everything else you're probably going to lose money from because this is the biggest most dominant macro factor that exists today and a lot of people still don't see it they're still using old ways of looking at things but liquidity has gone from being an important component to being literally everything right now”
Central banks learned how to manage crises in 2008, had a dry run in 2020, and can now prevent/solve crises by taking any asset as collateral and printing money against it.
“to 2008 they learned how to do it in 2008 they had a dry run in 2020 and they don't they can do it again now like listen fascinating conversation you know you've been amazing with this work that you're doing on liquidity and I think it's really important so it just it was great to chat with you and learn a bit more about it good bro enjoyed it enormously thank you so I thought that was a really fascinating conversation”
Authorities have redefined QT (Quantitative Tightening) to mean letting debt roll off the balance sheet, not withdrawing liquidity; this is a goalpost shift that allows continued QE under a different name.
“interestingly the authorities not just in the US have changed the goal posts what they're now saying is that QT is not withdrawing liquidity it is basically letting debt government debt roll off central bank balance sheets that was never how I understood it it certainly wasn't how they originally painted it but they've changed that and that gives them a way out”
Most financial crises historically (2020, 2019, 2008, 1997) are refinancing crises rather than other types of crises, demonstrating the centrality of debt rollover capacity to systemic stability.
“if you don't get that role if you can't refinance you have a refinancing crisis most of the crises that you look at historically whether it's be 2020 2019 the current situation 2008 uh 1997 not all refinancing crises”
There is evidence of 'daisy chain of support' among central banks supporting treasury markets, suggesting coordinated policy across the Fed, ECB, BOE, and BOJ.
“there is a uh on Twitter which uh uh I know you you played and I played as well uh if you look at Twitter there is a comment by uh a former Central Bank uh mem or official and she's said that what's going on right now is she terms it a daisy chain of support among central banks supporting the treasury markets now I'm not sure about the size of that there may be some debate but in principle I think it makes huge sense”
China's credit cycle currently leads the global cycle; Chinese government has been goosing the economy with major liquidity injections post-COVID, driving a pickup in Chinese financial system liquidity that will lift global commodity prices.
“what the Jack would say what the Chinese have been doing um since the end of covid or since the lockdowns ended is they've been goosing their economy with big liquidity injections and what you're seeing is very significant pickup in the amount of liquidity that's going through the Chinese Financial system uh and that's why you've seen this bottom in the Chinese markets”
Rate cuts are inevitable because the Fed will need to finesse extremely difficult financial conditions; rates will have to come below the trend GDP growth rate (~1.75%) to avoid being 'too tight' in a debt-saturated world.
“they've got that mess they've got a face and the real issue is that you've got this debt ceiling debate which is going on now that's clearly a frustration it's not helpful it is likely to run on until probably mid-year I would imagine uh and it really thwarts the ability or the flexibility of the Federal Reserve or the US authorities what they really need to do is to get the debt issue resolved to start issuing treasury bills significantly to draw down that reverse repo that may help but ultimately they have to get rates down”
Yield curve control is likely coming to the US and global markets; this is the inevitable next step after failing to manage bond markets through traditional QE.
“the the main focus of uh of governments or treasuries and monetary authorities in certainly recent months uh in both the US and Japan and the UK has been attempts to oh and in the Eurozone that attempts to try and control the yield curve that's what they've got to do they've the yield curve control is you know it's coming to a High Street near you soon uh if it's not already there”
The British gilt crisis and subsequent policy reversal in October 2023 marked the turning point for the liquidity cycle and bifurcation of policy (interest rates for inflation, balance sheet for stability).
“I mean if the Turning Point genuinely was October and the British guilt crisis which I think that's what marked it for me um I saw a change in Attitude going on and actually what's more at the time I made the point that what seems to be happening is a bifurcation of policy where they're using interest rates to control inflation and they're using the balance sheet for financial stability reasons now that was a conjecture but actually that same opinion has now appeared many times in the media since so it looks as if it's beginning to be fed out by the central banks this is what they want people to understand”
Economists' track record at predicting the stock market is woeful; the stock market predicts the economy, not the other way around.
“the track record of of Economics predicting the stock market is that is woeful the stock market predicts the economy not the other way around”
Stock markets tend to discount economic conditions about six months ahead; the January 2023 equity rally therefore implies markets are pricing in a bottom in the US economy around mid-year.
“if that's correct uh stock markets in my experience tend to Discount what about six months ahead so the rally we've been seeing since the beginning of the year seems pretty much on track as far as I can see”
The Federal Reserve's quantitative easing exactly matches government interest payments over prior 3.5-year periods, suggesting the Fed balance sheet is deliberately monetizing interest payments to prevent crowding out of the private sector.
“when I backed out the quantitative easing I found out that it exactly matched the interest payments that were for the prior three and a half years and so it seems that the FED balance sheet is being used to monetize those interest payments so it doesn't crowd out the private sector”
Despite ongoing QT, the Federal Reserve injected approximately $500 billion into US money markets following SVB's failure, proving that liquidity has increased even while treasuries nominally rolled off.
“what you've seen in the last few weeks in the U.S is that treasuries have continued to fall off the balance sheet but the Federal Reserve is disinjected half a trillion dollars into the U.S money markets following svb's failure so the liquidity has gone up”
Multiple markets have bottomed since the October 2023 liquidity turning point: crypto has exploded upward, gold has risen, equities have bottomed and rallied, and technology has led.
“since that October low Point liquidity has picked up as I said from by eight to ten percent in absolute terms and many many markets have bottomed okay so what have you seen you've seen the crypto space explode upwards you've seen the gold market go up you've seen equities bottom and pick up technology has been a leader okay yeah what more evidence do you want”
For every one dollar of new financing for capital spending, seven dollars are transacting in financial markets for debt refinancing, a 7:1 ratio that explains why liquidity is critical and why refinancing crises (not capital spending cycles) drive financial instability.
“if you do the math and you look at it in terms of uh let's quantify this for every one dollar of new financing in terms of capital spending you've got seven dollars that are transacting in financial markets today for debt refinancing so a seven to one ratio that's why liquidity is so important”
GDP growth is driven by three components: productivity, demographics, and debt growth; productivity is poor due to demographics, and debt growth has reached 100% of government GDP, meaning nominal GDP growth is insufficient to service debt without monetization.
“if I look at GDP growth we can use the formula of productivity times you know um it's it's productivity demographics and probably debt growth of the three components of GDP and demographics are bad so it slows GDP productivity has been terrible because of the demographics and that's been slowing GDP so we've we've had debt growth and that seems to have got to a point where we got to that hundred percent of GDP in debt by the government sector”
Bond market volatility (MOVE index), not VIX, is the critical risk metric in modern markets; equity investors need to watch MOVE because falling bond volatility signals increasing collateral values and ability to deploy leverage.
“Equity investors for example need to look beyond the VIX Index which is their traditional measure of risk start looking at the move index Bond volatility that's what's critical because it Bond volatility Falls you're likely to see a collateral uh the ability to use collateral increase significantly collateral values uh will go up in that environment of lower bond market volatility and so central banks have got to get bond market volatility down”
The same QE-to-interest payment correlation the host found for the US also holds for Japan, the UK, and Europe, suggesting central banks have coordinated this monetization strategy across countries.
“the other thing by the way I looked at as I went through and checked my numbers about this interest payments in QE and it worked for Japan it works for the UK and it works for Europe they're all the same”
Liquidity and S&P 500 correlation is 0.975 (as measured by G5 central bank balance sheets), demonstrating that liquidity is the dominant driver of equity prices.
“if we use just the even just the G5 central bank balance sheets there's a simple proxy for liquidity not sophisticated in some of yours the s p correlation is 97.5”
Gold is a monetary hedge against currency debasement, not an inflation hedge; combined market cap of gold plus crypto moves almost 1-to-1 with liquidity cycles, making these the primary beneficiaries of future QE.
“it's always been a monetary inflation hedge it so happens that monetary inflation can feed into High Street inflation but that's not the that's not the starting point is monetary inflation and the other is crap now you know if you look if you combine and I'd probably uh shown you charts before and I think in a pack I send her I've got that that evidence but if you look at what I call monetary Hedges look at the market cap of gold plus the market cap of all crypto that moves with liquidity almost one for one”
When normalized for QE (dividing assets by Fed balance sheet), S&P 500, gold, and real estate show no real gains since 2008; only crypto and technology showed gains, as they benefited from secular trends independent of debasement.
“just divided various assets by just the FED balance sheet or the G5 either way and what you found is is the s p went nowhere since 2008 right gold actually didn't go anywhere so I had offset the debasement but didn't actually gain anything real estate same the only ones that did were Krypton technology because they were secular Trends”
Equities should be valued against inflation, not against bonds; if inflation comes down, equities should do well because the discount rate applied to earnings rises less than earnings fall.
“one of the things that I've always maintained is that if you're valuing let's say equities you don't value equities against bonds you value equities against inflation that's what works best in my experience if inflation's coming down Equity should do pretty well”
The interest bill cannot be allowed to rise because the debt environment is unworkable; the only solutions are yield curve control (fixing the long end) or monetary hedges (gold, crypto, tech).
“you know the interest Bill if the interest build starts to go up it compounds on this debt environment starts to get absolutely unworkable and that's why I think you know we're in this world where if you start extrapolating into the future the only way is to look for monetary Hedges as Alternatives in the way that we've discussed whether it be gold whether it be uh crypto in some form uh or whether it be Act nicely uh technology”
In a debasement-driven world, there are only two assets worth owning: gold (as a debasement hedge that doesn't profit) or technology (which offers real productivity gains in addition to debasement protection); traditional equities and real estate offer no real gain.
“if this is the world we're in then there are only really two assets yes you can own gold and it will work but if you actually want to make money in addition to the debasement you've only got a couple of assets you can really own right makes sense over a full time”
A bull market in liquidity began in October 2023 and will likely last until 2026, following normal cyclical patterns; this does not mean a straight-line rally but will include difficulties like the SVB and Credit Suisse failures.
“we've gone on record as saying a Bull marketing liquidity started in October of last year okay uh and we're in the early months of that that cycle will last through until about 2026 that's what the normal cyclical pattern says so we're in the early stages of that uh it's not going to be a straight line upwards that'll be difficulties but you know hey we're we're beginning that Journey around trough of the cycle you always get banking problems svb Credit Suisse is not a great surprise”
Historical correlation between liquidity (measured as G5 central bank balance sheets) and S&P 500 was 0.5-0.6 from 1980-2010, but has risen to 0.8-0.9 in the last decade, a phenomenal increase in co-movement.
“if you look at the correlation between liquidity and say the s p uh had a correlation coefficient uh looking out from maybe the start of the 80s through until uh 2010 of about 0.5.6 but as you rightly say for the last decade it's p nearer sort of 0.8.9 uh I mean it is a phenomenal difference uh liquidity is all important right now”
Fixed income markets (not economics textbooks) tell the truth about financial conditions; they signal a bottom in the US economy around mid-year 2023 and a shallow recession rather than deep downturn.
“what the fixed income markets in my estimation are telling us is there is a bottom in the U.S economy around about the mid-year okay I'm not saying the economy avoids a recession but it's probably going to be quite shallow in my view”
The yield curve steepens about 6 months after the first inflection in the liquidity cycle; this pattern (observed and traded at Salomon Brothers) is repeating again, validating the October turning point.
“yield curve is beginning to steepen okay the yield curve always steepens about six months after uh the first inflection in the liquidity cycle that's how it's Salon Brothers we used to trade the yield curve those were you know fundamental points liquidity leads the yield curve it's doing it again”
Liquidity measures have spurted 8-10% higher since October 2023 low point, driven by both pickup in collateral values and increases in central bank balance sheets from the Fed, PBOC, and BOJ.
“since the low point in liquidity in October is something like an eight to ten percent increase in liquidity from that point so it's been meaningful now what about the future where do we go”
People are frustrated that equity markets are not crashing; they 'want their crisis' but central bank monetization prevents major crises now.
“people they kind of want their crisis but I think you can't have it not with the use of liquidity anymore just it doesn't exist as you said you can stop a banking crisis immediately by printing money and putting anything on the balance sheet”