
Ray Dalio's Position On The Stock Crash of 1937 & Why It Matters In 2019 / 2020
What this covers
This is an 11-minute YouTube explainer from Hamish Hodder that walks through Ray Dalio's 1930s analogue for the late-2019 market. Hodder narrates and relays Dalio's argument. He starts with the run-up to 1929, when stocks rose 150 percent from 1922 to 1927 and then doubled again by 1929. He then covers the Federal Reserve's rate hikes, and the 13.5 percent single-day fall in the Dow Jones Industrial Index on October 28, 1929. From there the story moves to the zero-rate years of 1930-1937, the Fed's turn to quantitative easing, and the roughly 400 percent rally over five years. It ends with the 60 percent fall in 1937, when the Fed tried to lift rates from zero.
The middle of the video draws the comparison with 2008 onward. Dalio treats zero rates as the marker of the end of a long debt cycle, and the video argues that 2008 and 1929 both fit that pattern. The more contested material concerns wealth inequality: the claim that QE sends newly printed money mainly to asset holders, and that the resulting political polarization leaves people believing capitalism is rigged. The video flags this as a threat in itself, since a push to dismantle the system would do more damage.
The forecasts are the third strand. Dalio expects poor bond performance as rates rise, higher gold prices if inflation returns as it did from 1970 to 1982, and a long, slow equity decline of the kind that kept the market below its 1929 level until 1954. The practical section is Hodder's own. He suggests holding cash to buy at lower prices, and drawing up a list of strong businesses with estimated cash flows and target purchase prices. He also notes that Dalio favors a small gold position, while he himself prefers cash.
Ray Dalio argues that current market conditions (2019) exhibit striking structural parallels to the 1930s—including asset inflation following QE, wealth inequality, and inflated valuations—making a sustained market decline likely unless investors prepare with cash reserves and carefully selected undervalued businesses.
- Stock market rose ~400% in both the 1930s post-QE period and post-2008 recovery, creating valuations vulnerable to rate-hike shock
- QE-driven asset inflation concentrates wealth among asset holders, producing the same political polarization that destabilized the 1930s
- Rate normalization triggered a 60% one-year crash in 1937 and 25-year stagnation; Dalio expects similar long, slow decline rather than quick V-shaped recovery
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The Federal Reserve raised interest rates from 1.5 percent to 6 percent in the late 1920s to combat inflation, which caused cracks to appear in the stock market with many days showing high single-digit drops followed by brief recoveries.
“the Federal Reserve in the United States started to see inflation picking up and began to raise interest rates in order to combat this they raised interest rates from 1.5 percent all the way up to 6 percent and at this time the US stock market started to see some cracks there were many days that had high single-digit drops followed by brief recoveries”
Investors should hedge against market declines by holding more cash so that they can deploy it into the market at lower prices during a crash, allowing them to scoop up stocks at much cheaper valuations.
“one way is that you can hold onto more cash and that way if the market comes down you can use some of that cash and deploy it into the market and scoop up some stocks at much cheaper prices”
Following the stock market crash, the dramatic decline in asset prices made people feel less wealthy, which caused people to reduce spending, triggering the U.S. entry into a long and slow painful period of depression.
“the dramatic decline in stock prices made people feel a lot less wealthy many people had a lot of money in the stock market and in other financial assets and when all of these came crumbling down people stopped spending money and as people stopped spending money the u.s. entered into a long and slow painful period of depression”
After the Great Depression, interest rates hit zero between 1930-1937, making them no longer an effective method of stimulating the economy, forcing the Federal Reserve to resort to quantitative easing—printing money and buying financial assets—as a second stimulus lever.
“the first thing that happened was that interest rates hit zero which meant that they were no longer an effective method of stimulating the economy which meant that the Federal Reserve then resorted to their second option of stimulus which was to print money and buy financial assets”
In 1937, the Federal Reserve attempted to raise interest rates from zero to combat inflation, which was devastating to the stock market because the market had risen so much in such a short period, causing a 60% decline in a single year (12-month period).
“after that the Federal Reserve then had to attempt to raise interest rates inflation was picking up and they needed to raise interest rates in order to get interest rates of that very low bottom of zero but as soon as they attempted to do this it was devastating for the stock market because the stock market had risen so much in such a short period of time any increase in interest rates was dramatic to the stock market and the result was that the stock market went down in 1937 by 60% in a single year in a 12-month period which is devastating”
The 2008 global financial crisis was in many ways very similar to the 1929 Great Depression because in both cases interest rates hit zero, indicating the end of the long debt cycle.
“the first similarity is that the 2008 global financial crisis was in many ways very similar to the 1929 Great Depression one of those major similarities is that in both cases interest rates hit zero indicating the end of the long debt cycle”
The stock market rose 150 percent from 1922 to 1927 and then from 1927 to 1929 stock prices doubled again, creating an unsustainable bubble prior to the Great Depression crash.
“the stock market rose 150 percent from 1922 to 1927 and then from 27 to 29 stock prices doubled again”
During the mid-1930s, the U.S. Federal Reserve conducted quantitative easing by buying financial assets with newly printed money, and over a five-year period the stock market rose approximately 400 percent.
“essentially during the mid 1930s the US Federal Reserve began quantitative easing they were buying financial assets with money that they were printing and the result was that over a five year period the stock market went up almost 400 percent that's 400 percent in just a five year period”
Rising wealth inequality is bad for any civilized society regardless of political ideology because it causes large populations at the bottom of the system to believe that capitalism is rigged against them, leading them to advocate for dismantling capitalism entirely, which would be far more devastating.
“rising wealth inequality is something that is bad for any civilized society no matter what your position is on capitalism and the reason why wealth inequality is so bad for any civilized society is because it causes a large amount of people to be stacked up at the bottom of the system who believe that it is rigged in favor of the uber wealthy that it is rigged against them and that the only way that they can move forward is to completely dismantle capitalism which would ultimately be way more devastating”
The stock market is predicted to decline over the next few years based on Dalio's analysis, so investors should prepare by developing a list of great businesses with competitive advantages and excellent management, estimating future cash flows from these businesses, and determining acceptable purchase prices before prices fall.
“so how can you prepare for such a crash what can you do to prepare yourself and the first thing that I would say as a stock market investor is that you first need to have a list of really great businesses that you understand businesses that you understand businesses that have a competitive advantage within them and that are run by a great management team and then you need to estimate how much cash you're going to get out of these businesses over the next few years and therefore you can work out what price you're willing to pay so that when prices come down you're ready to start investing”
Ray Dalio identifies three major similarities between the 1930s and 2019: (1) both periods followed asset crashes that forced central banks to conduct QE, (2) both saw stock markets rise approximately 400% in the recovery period, and (3) both experienced increasing wealth inequality as a result of QE.
“Ray Dalio believes that there are many similar things that are happening today that were also happening then and he actually brings up three major similarities that he can compare between back then and today the first similarity is that the 2008 global financial crisis was in many ways very similar to the 1929 Great Depression one of those major similarities is that in both cases interest rates hit zero indicating the end of the long debt cycle and essentially the Federal Reserve in both circumstances decided to do quantitative easing they decided to print money and buy financial assets and in both circumstances the stock market went up massively in the 30s it went up by about 400 percent over a five year period and over the past ten years the stock market has also gone up about four hundred percent”
Gold prices rise at approximately the rate of inflation, and Dalio expects much more inflation in the future, making gold prices likely to rise similar to the 1970-1982 period when gold prices exploded as inflation surged in the United States and globally.
“the reason why he thinks this is is because gold really goes up at the rate of inflation and he sees they're going to be much more inflation in the future and as a result a similar thing will happen as to what happened between 1970 and 1982 which was that the price of gold exploded as the price as inflation began to massively increase in the United States and across globally”
Quantitative easing causes a disproportionate amount of newly printed money to flow toward wealthy asset holders while ordinary people hoarded relatively small amounts, creating and amplifying wealth inequality.
“because the Federal Reserve printed money and purchased financial assets anyone who held financial assets massively benefited from the global financial crisis in 2008 as well as the global crash depression that occurred in 1929 and this causes a disproportionate amount of that money going towards the wealthy and an increasing amount of money hoarded by a small number of people while the rest have a relatively small amount of money”
Since the 1929 Depression, the stock market did not recover to the same level until 1954, representing a 25-year period where the stock market essentially went nowhere.
“moreover since the 1929 Depression the stock market did not recover to the same level until 1954 which is a 25 year period where the stock market essentially went nowhere”
On Monday, October 28, 1929, the Dow Jones plummeted 13.5 percent in a single day, after which the Dow Jones Industrial Index was down 50 percent from its September peak.
“then on Monday the 28th of October 1929 the Dow Jones plummeted 13.5 percent in a single day after the smoke cleared the Dow Jones Industrial Index was down 50 percent from its September peak”
Wealth inequality and resulting political polarization will lead many nations to experience massive political changes, with two groups becoming tribal in their beliefs, locked into parties, and increasingly polarized in their party views.
“Ray Dalio believes that this is going to happen again and he also believes that there are going to be many nations that are going to see massive political changes because of this wealth inequality there becomes this this term called political itical polarity where you have two groups of people who are tribal in their beliefs and really locked into their parties and the parties become the views of the parties become more polarized”
Investors can hedge against both the stock market decline and inflation by holding a small amount of gold, which Dalio believes will appreciate if inflation accelerates significantly.
“another way that you can head yourself against the stock market and against inflation is to hold a little bit of gold if you were to hold a little bit of gold and inflation was to pick up massively then Ray Dalio believes that the price of gold would also go up although that is something that I do not personally do”
Ray Dalio predicts three major outcomes over the next few decades: (1) bond market poor performance due to rising interest rates eroding older bond values, (2) gold prices rising due to future inflation, and (3) a long and painful stock market crash similar to the 1930s-1940s period rather than a quick V-shaped recovery.
“essentially Dahlia thinks that there are three major outcomes that will happen over the next few decades the first is that there will be a decrease in poor performance in the bond market and the reason why is because he believes that interest rates are going to go up from here...the second effect that he believes will happen is that gold prices will rise the price of gold will go up and the reason why he thinks this is is because gold really goes up at the rate of inflation...and the final event that Ray Dalio sees happening is that the stock market will crash and will have a long and painful crash rather than a really quick one with a quick recovery”
Ray Dalio expects the stock market to experience a long and slow decline over the next few years rather than a quick V-shaped recovery, similar to the 1930s-1940s pattern where the market fell 60% in 1937 but then continued declining for many years without recovering to 1929 levels until 1954.
“he believes that it's going to be similar to what happened in the 1930s and 40s where the market went down slowly after that 60% decline which was in no way slow but after that decline the market continued to go down for many many years and as I said didn't recover to the 1929 levels for 25 years and Ray Dalio believes that this is going to happen again”
Higher interest rates will cause older bonds (10, 20, and 30-year bonds) to decrease in value relative to newer bonds because newer bonds offer better returns.
“and essentially what that means is that with higher interest rates it means that those newer bonds are going to offer a better return than the older bonds which means that the older bonds the 10 20 30 year bonds are going to decrease in value”
Quantitative easing is defined as the Federal Reserve's second lever of monetary stimulus, involving printing money and buying financial assets to kick-start the economy when interest rates are at zero.
“You may have heard of the term quantitative easing that is exactly what we're talking about it's the second lever of stimulation that the Federal Reserve can use in order to kick-start the economy”
Interest rates will rise from current rock-bottom levels over the long term, which is not a novel prediction but a straightforward extrapolation from the current state.
“the reason why is because he believes that interest rates are going to go up from here and considering interest rates are at rock-bottom it's not a great prediction it's a it's a pretty obvious prediction to suggest that over the long term interest rates are likely going to be higher than they are now”
Ray Dalio is one of the most successful investors of all time and has recently been sending warning signals to investors about the current state of the market.
“Ray Dalio is one of the most successful investors of all time and recently has been sending warning signals to investors about the current state of the market”
The speaker personally prefers to hedge against the stock market by holding more cash rather than gold, despite Dalio's recommendation for gold.
“personally I just like to hedge myself against the stock market by holding on to more cash”
Understanding the relationship between what is happening now (2019) and what happened almost 90 years ago (1930s) is necessary for investors in the stock market.
“if you are investing in the stock market in 2019 then you need to understand the relationship between what is happening now and what was happening almost 90 years ago”