What this covers

👉 On Substack? Visit - https://santiagocapital.substack.com/ 👉 Get Access to our Paid Research - https://macroalchemist.com

As the Dow & Gold each close the week at all time highs on the back of China's "Whatever it Takes" liqudity moment, the haters come out in force against those willing to buck the bullish trend.

Following up on last weeks episode, we again discuss the idea of Dollars & Gold rising together and why the haters above get so emotional regarding this concept. We also go into more detail on the Commitment of Traders report to hep explain who the different categories refer to, why they are positioned as such, whether its Bullish or Bearish, and why it mostly matters only at extremes.

Will this time be Different...?

This and more on the latest episode of MILKSHAKES MARKETS MADNESS.

FULL-LENGTH EPISODE 95 (September 29, 2024)

Source description (no synthesized summary yet).


The claims · ranked48 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.63

China has been struggling with incredible deflationary pressures due to bad loans in real estate market and their economy; when people talk about the US cutting rates, China just did much more than that

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“China just launched their whatever it takes a moment you know they have been struggling with Incredible deflationary pressures because of all the bad loans in their real estate market and their economy and you know when people talk about the US cut rates well China just did a heck of a lot more than cutting rates”

0.61

Technical indicators like RSI, DSI, and stochastics 'at their extremes' are worth considering for mean reversion trades, but in neutral or medium zones they provide little actionable insight.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“I think they're important to use now there's a subset of these non-c commercials or I'm sorry there's a subset of the Comm there's subsets of both of these but let's on the commercials the other argument that will be made of why this isn't a bearish chart of why this positioning here is not bearish is because they will say this doesn't mean anything this big pink line it's just the producers the the mines the you know the people that are producing the gold the gold miners the corporates they're hedging their production... but right now if you look at the total short the total short position here is about 340,000 contracts”

0.60

You never know what's going to happen; therefore you don't have to be all in on one thing; diversification is critical

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“you just never know what's going to happen and you know you don't have to be all in on one thing”

0.60

The Commitment of Traders report breaks down investors into 'non-commercial' (speculators, hedge funds, money managers, individual futures traders) and 'commercial' (big banks, bullion dealers, bullion banks, brokers taking opposite side of client trades)

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker - Host

“the commitment of Traders it basically breaks down the different types of investors and the two big ones and the there's a lot of people that do that you you can subscribe to different services that break down the Cod reports by different ways and they look at it uh on different things and you know they all have their own opinions how and how it works but the two areas that I focus on are the non-commercial and the commercials now the non-commercial these are the speculators these are those or the money managers these are the people that are long okay these are people that are buying it and and uh typically long and it could be hedge funds it could be um you know just pure speculators it could be individual investors that are trading futures the commercials these are the big banks these are the bullion dealers these are the bullion banks these are the Brokers that are taking the other side of their client trades”

0.56

On a relative basis, considering advantages and disadvantages, the US dollar has the most advantages and the US economy is much stronger than the Chinese economy

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“as a again on a relative basis you know who who has the most advantages and who doesn't I just think the dollar has many more advantages than the Chinese do and I think the US economy is much stronger than the Chinese economy”

0.55

The reason speculators are so long gold and gold is at all-time high is because not just the US but the whole world has moved to easing monetary policy; the Fed raised rates couple years ago but has moved toward easy policy, just cut rates with expectations of more cuts, and countries worldwide (including China) are cutting rates

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“part of the reason that the speculators by the way are so long gold and why there is and why gold is at its all-time high is because not just the us but the whole world you know they're back to easing monetary policy and the fed you know after raising rates a couple years ago they they've been moving more towards easy monetary policy they just cut rates the expectation for them to cut more is on the table and so that's why the dollar has been coming down not only that but countries other countries around the world are starting to cut rates China uh just did a big uh stimulus plan that pushed gold higher this week”

0.52

The dollar can go lower in the short term and can break through the $100 DXY technical level that has been support/resistance, but system-wide dollarization (rest of world stops using dollar) would send dollar much higher not lower; short-term dollar weakness perpetuates status quo by increasing global liquidity

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“what I have always said is we are not going to have wholesale systemwide dollarization where the rest of the world stops using the dollar and the dollar Falls versus its peer the whole milkshake theory is that if we are going to dollarize it this again not just a little bit like fully dollarized it's going to send the dollar much higher not lower but over a short period of time the dollar can absolutely go down but the point I would make is if the Dollar's falling that's the fed and the central banks and the powers that beat that's the system that's the system continuing to survive as it has survived for the last 40 or 50 years the dollar going lower increases liquidity in the world and it perpetuates the status quo it doesn't change anything”

0.52

Portfolio betting analogy: if choosing between worst person (like Hitler but worse) on right and nicest perfect person on left, wouldn't bet all hard-earned money on left unless left has exceptional MMA skill; must remove emotions of what you want to see happen versus what you think will actually happen

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“and let's say the guy on the left is the The Golden Child and just does everything perfect and the nicest person ever do you think the guy on the left is going to beat the guy on the right would you bet your portfolio your Harden all the money that you have saved all the hours that you have toiled away at your job and you had to put it all on the line are you going to bet on the guy on the left or you going to bet on the guy on the right again perhaps the guy on the left is some mixed martial arts Jedi and he has some super clever technique and he's going to jump up and poke the guy in the neck and the guy's going to the big guy's going to fall is it possible sure it's possible but are you going to invest all of your hard- earned money on that small possibility again you have to remove your emotions”

0.52

All investments involve risk and cannot remove all risk from the table; when technical, sentiment, and positioning indicators all line up together, the risk-reward becomes favorable even if individual signals are weak

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“all Investments involve risk you cannot make an investment and remove all risk from the table and when everything is printing like this this tells me that the risk reward is pretty favorable and not only that but to be clear I didn't short gold”

0.52

Speaker's job is to analyze the world as it is and come up with what they think will happen, not to snap fingers and make things different; you don't have to like something in order to think it could win (Darth Vader vs Jawas example)

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“my job is to analyze the world as it is and come up with an answer of what I think's going to happen and this is somewhat related is that you don't have to like something in order to think that it could win like if Darth Vader is going up against the Jawas you don't have to like Darth Vader to know that he is going to slaughter the Jawas”

0.49

Critics argue that large commercial short positions in gold are 'just' producers hedging future production and therefore don't signal anything meaningful; however, producers account for only 70,000-80,000 of the ~340,000 total commercial short contracts, meaning ~250,000 (75%) are non-producer commercials (swap dealers)

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“there's a subset of the Comm there's subsets of both of these but let's on the commercials the other argument that will be made of why this isn't a bearish chart of why this positioning here is not bearish is because they will say this doesn't mean anything this big pink line it's just the producers the the mines the you know the people that are producing the gold the gold miners the corporates they're hedging their production so as they're pulling the gold out of the ground they want to lock in prices and so how do they do that well they sell the gold short through the Futures Contract and then they eventually have to deliver the gold later when they get it out of the ground or wherever it's at so and that is true the a section of the commercials is the producers who are hedging their production but right now if you look at the total short the total short position here is about 340,000 contracts The Producers let me did I put it in here no I didn't put it in here but the producers their short position is like 70 or 880,000 contracts which means 250,000 are the speculators so only about 20% of this over all commercial short position is producers hedging their future production so the idea that the only reason this is big is because the producers are hedging their production is completely wrong”

0.49

The DSI (sentiment measure) on gold closed in the high 80s a couple days before the trade and was likely in the high 80s or 90s on the morning of the trade, which is extremely overbought

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unknown Speaker - Host

“the the DSi which is a sentiment measure um it had closed in the high 80s a couple days before and my guess was that it was in the high 80s maybe even in the 90s real time that morning it just doesn't get much higher than that”

0.48

The speaker originally said dollars and gold would rise together, which required extensive explanation of the concept of 'together' meaning them rising against foreign currencies while going up at same time but not necessarily same rate; they didn't expect to have to spend so much time explaining what 'together' means

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“and when I first started talking about this at the very first interview when I said dollars and gold will rise together I knew that would be kind of you know not controversial but it certainly wasn't you know the the the main way to think about things and and and I knew I would have to explain it and so I kind of went to Great Lengths in that interview to explain dollars and gold Rising together versus foreign currencies and I knew I would have to spend a lot of time throughout you know whenever this was going on that I would have to clarify that what I did not think I would have to spend so much time doing is explaining what together means together means that they go up not at the same time at the same rate or they it means they go up at the same time but not necessarily neily at the same rate”

0.48

People who claim they don't care if their favorite investment goes down in the short term often get upset when told it may go down in the short term, and even more upset if told someone is placing trades to profit from that downside

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“so many people tell me that own gold for the long term they don't really care whether it goes up or down in you know in the short term but it sure is funny people who say they don't care if their favorite investment goes down in the short term sure do get upset when you tell them it may go down in the short term and they get even more upset if you say you placed a trade that may profit from it going down in the short term”

0.48

The speaker realized they had missed something when the dollar rose 15% (~2014), prompting investigation that revealed focusing only on the US misses that the whole world is in trouble, the US has many advantages despite problems, and all currencies trade relative to each other

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“he had seen something that I had missed and I wanted to understand what he was seeing so that kind of started me on my journey of what had I missed and that's when I realized that everybody who focuses on the dollar falling typically does that when they focus just on the United States but when you start looking at the world as a whole you realize the whole world is in trouble and you realize that the US despite all its problems has many advantages and all currencies trade relative to each other”

0.48

Speaker's point on gold: absolutely own it (may be tiebreaker for survival in chaos) but it's not the only thing to own, and if you own it you must work to remain non-emotional, especially important when everyone else is getting emotional

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“I think it may in fact be the the the tiebreaker whether or not you ultimately survive any chaos to come but I don't think it's holy I don't think it is the only thing you should own and I think if you do own it you have to work to remain non-emotional about it and I think it's especially important to do that when everybody else is getting very emotional about it”

0.48

When the speaker came to the Milkshake thesis idea, they knew they were onto something because they hated the answer; they are extremely conflicted about the answer, don't like a large part of it, have looked for ways they could be wrong, but haven't been able to convince themselves they're wrong

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“part of the reason I knew I was on to something was because I hated the answer and I am still extremely conflicted about the answer truth be told I don't like large part of it but no matter how I try to dig through and figure out how I could possibly be wrong I haven't been able to convince myself I'm wrong but I've looked and I if I could snap my fingers and make it different I probably would do so but it's not my job to snap my fingers and make it different”

0.48

When speculators are bidding up the price and acting with euphoria, that is typically when things reverse; the 'naturality' of commercials being short when price rises does not prevent reversals

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Host

“when the speculators are long the commercials are going to be short again that that that goes back to explaining that previous chart It's Not Unusual as price Rises and speculators want to speculate on price Rising that the commercial which are taking the other side of the trade are going to be short my point is that typically when it gets to extremes and all the speculators are bidding it up typically that's when thing when Euphoria hits that's when things typically will reverse”

0.48

The reason the speaker publicly explained the Twitter interactions and tactical trades was to educate people about the reasoning and methodology, not to convince skeptics, but to help others understand analytical thinking.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“I want people to understand the thinking and when you read something on Twitter and they say the commercials don't matter you got to ask yourself why are they saying the commercials don't matter and do they really know what they're talking about and if they say the speculators don't matter or if they're saying DSi doesn't matter or relative strength doesn't matter all on their own they probably don't matter but when you're trying to build a case and everything starts to line up the odds start to go into your favor”

0.47

Just because some countries like Russia have largerly dollarized and 'are doing okay' does not mean every country in the world can easily dollarize; widespread dollarization would be an ugly deleveraging not a beautiful deleveraging, analogous to a bank run where first people to withdraw are fine but everyone at once cannot all get their money

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“it's a little bit like a bank run one or two people can go to the bank and the first or or if if there's a if everybody goes to the bank to get their money the first one or two three people that get there they can get their money out but if everybody on the same day goes to get their money they cannot all get their money and so yeah well maybe Russia is doing okay in the short term because they have natural resources and their nuclear power just because they are so far doing okay does not mean every country in the world can just easily dollarize um and in fact D dollarriz would be a an ugly deleveraging not a beautiful deleveraging”

0.46

The speaker has always said everyone should own gold; they talk about the dollar because gold alone cannot solve all problems for countries or companies or individuals—it helps and can potentially save in crisis, but is not a universal solution

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“the reason is is it's very important on gold gold can help in many many ways but gold is not going to solve all problems it's not going to solve every country's problem it's not going to solve every company's problem and it's not going to solve every person's every problem”

0.45

None of the individual technical indicators (RSI in 80s, DSi in 90s, stochastics at 99) individually indicate gold will crash; they only indicate pullback or pause is more likely than not, and speaker is positioning to profit from that pause

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“it can and it doesn't listen none of these things indicate that it is going to crash all it indicates is that it's more likely than not that we going to get a pullback or a pause and I am happy to try and profit from that pause or that pullback will it work we will have to wait and see but again this is not a gold crash prediction”

0.45

The Relative Strength Index (RSI) on gold was at its highest level in five years, in the 80s, at the time the speaker made the tactical trade

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unknown Speaker - Host

“the RSI is as high as it's been any time in the last five years”

0.45

The most important factor in portfolio management is removing emotions about what you want to see happen versus what you actually think will happen; speaker likely mentions this in every episode

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“and you've heard me talk about this a lot and I'm probably going to say it in every episode epis if I remember to say it because I think this is probably the most uh important factor that that I that that I think goes into portfolio management you have to kind of be a mercenary about what you're investing your money in”

0.45

Commitment of Traders shows speculators have their biggest ever speculative long position and commercials have their biggest ever (or near-biggest) short position in gold futures, which when lined up with other indicators suggests favorable risk-reward for tactical pullback trade

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“we have the biggest position on the cut the commitment of Traders the speculators have their biggest ever speculative position and the commercials have their biggest ever or almost their biggest ever short position so now again any of these on their own it's probably not a tradable signal but when they are all lined up together that tells me the risk reward is pretty favorable”

0.45

Historically, every time the commercial shorts in gold have reached this level (340,000+ contracts), it has ended badly for speculators who are long

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker - Host

“every time previously that the commercial shorts have gotten to this level it has ended badly for the speculators who are long”

0.44

Speaker doesn't necessarily love the dollar, doesn't think the US is bright shining city on hill, thinks US made incredible mistakes and continues making them, but US is a big power you cannot ignore just because you don't like it

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“I don't necessarily love the dollar I don't think the US is necessarily the bright shining City on the hill I think the US has made incredible um mistakes and continues to make them but they are a big big Power and you cannot ignore it just because you do not like it okay”

0.43

Many people in the gold world are emotionally unable to handle the idea of the dollar doing better than other fiat currencies; many have large portions of portfolio concentrated in gold/gold miners/silver (almost exclusively in one industry) rather than diversified

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“I think a lot of the people that I interact with they just emotionally cannot handle the idea of the dollar doing better than other Fiat currencies and I think in many ways people my experience with people in the Gold World a lot of people in the Gold World and listen I have a lot of friends in the Gold World um and I respect the hell out of them um I know that they're trying to help people but it's my experience that many people in the Gold World have a huge portion of their portfolio in gold or gold miners or silver whatever it is in other words almost almost almost exclusively con concentrated in that one industry”

0.43

When Commitment of Traders positioning is in neutral to medium zones it doesn't matter much, but when at extremes it becomes important to use as analytical tool

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“my point is that typically when it gets to extremes and all the speculators are bidding it up typically that's when thing when Euphoria hits that's when things typically will reverse and again when these are when when these when these charts are kind of in neutral to even medium Zone not big but when they're at their extremes I think they're important to use”

0.39

Zimbabwe's decision to use gold reserves to strengthen its currency and the 44% devaluation of its currency against the dollar despite these efforts demonstrates that gold alone does not solve structural currency problems when the dollar remains the dominant fiat currency.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“over the last year they instituted a policy where they were going to use some of their gold reserves to bolster their own currency and uh you know the number of emails Twitter DMS and messages that PE people you know will post things on Twitter and tag me in at saying you know this is this is Zimbabwe using to get out from underneath the dollar well this week Zimbabwe again had to devalue their currency 44% against the dollar despite trying to use gold to strengthen their currency the bottom line is that it the dollar is just still the dominant fiat currency and just because you have gold doesn't mean it solves all your problem”

0.39

Speaker manages portfolios with 10-20% allocations to gold; once you have gold position you don't need to do much—it just sits there, no earnings/management concerns, just sits until needed; less to talk about on show than with other assets

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“so you know as someone who manages other people's portfolios Diversified portfolios if I've got a 10% allocation to gold or a 15% allocation to gold and some people I have we have a 20% allocation to Gold that's probably enough I probably don't need to sell absolutely everything else and put it all in gold and so once you here's the thing once you have your gold position there's not much else to do it just sits there there's no earnings you have to worry about you don't have to worry about the management team you don't have to worry about you know what what something is said in the Press about you know the the the the new strategy for the company it's just you buy it and you have it and it's there”

0.38

The speaker has always said the dollar was going to rise versus other currencies, never said the dollar was going to rise and everything else crash; since first mentioning Milkshake theory (early 2018), the DXY has never been lower than when they first said it

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“I always said the dollar was going to rise versus other currencies I never said the dollar was going to go up and everything else was going to crash um and since that time the dxy has never been lower than when I first said that now can it go lower than that sure it can but I'm just saying so far it hasn't happened”

0.37

Critics say unless speaker claims dollar is worst thing in history and anyone talking about dollar is horrible person and anyone associated with dollar is Satan's love child, then speaker is not good enough; speaker recommends such people remove speaker from their feed for their own emotional and portfolio well-being

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“if I don't also say that the dollar is the worst thing in history and anybody who talks about the dollar is a horrible person person and anybody any in any way associated with the dollar is basically you know Satan's love child then then apparently that's not good enough and listen it all I can say is is if you if you are of that mindset I take me out of it just for your own emotional well-being and your portfolio well-being you got to get out of that mindset”

0.36

A short squeeze scenario where banks are forced to cover large short gold positions at rising prices could theoretically send gold to 3000-3500, representing an extremely low probability but non-impossible outcome.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“if the banks have to cover at these prices you're going to sh a short squeeze and you're going to see gold go to 3,000 or 3500 that is absolutely a possibility in my opinion it's an extremely low probability but it is not impossible and every time previously that the commercial shorts have gotten to this level it has ended badly for the speculators who are long now can it be different this time it can absolutely be different this time I don't think it will be”

0.35

In the first 2-3 years of the Milkshake thesis, the dollar outperformed gold on a percentage basis toward their target prices; over the last couple years, gold has outperformed the dollar, but this variation was always anticipated within the thesis framework

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“I didn't think I would have to spend so much time meaning that you know I thought there would be periods of time where gold went up a little bit more than the dollar there'd be periods of time where the dollar went up a little bit more than gold but in general those two would rise against all the other currencies and you know that that has largely happened over the first two or three years the dollar outperformed gold um on on a percentage of of how they're going to their Target price you know again we explained that last week and then over the last couple years the gold outperform the dollars”

0.19

Critics believe because speaker says dollar will go higher, speaker must love the dollar, wants it to happen, approves of dynamics that would cause it, and is a secret agent for government/State Department/Fed working to promote dollar and extend US Empire

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“because I have said I think the dollar is going to go higher I think they automatically think I love the dollar that I want this to happen that I approve of the Dynamics which will send it higher that and that I am somehow a secret agent who is working on behalf of the government and putting out propaganda that is going to extend the the US Empire for another 10 20 30 40 50 years”

0.15

The speaker bought put options on gold (GLD, SLV, GDX) 1-5% out of the money with expirations between late October and end of year as a short-term tactical hedge while maintaining strategic long-term gold position

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“when gold hit its all-time high on it was either Wednesday or Thursday I can't I can't remember which one it was I think it was Thursday morning and you know I have a process when things get really oversold or when things get really overbought I am happy to do some short-term tactical trades and so as part of the short-term tactical trades we bought some puts on gold on Thursday morning gold was around 2680 at the right time 2678 2680 something like that and then listen we bought Golds on puts on we had bought we had actually bought some the day before on GLD and SLV and then we bought more on Thursday morning on GLD SLV and um uh GDX and we bought them anywhere from one to I think one to three or four percent maybe 5 percent out of the money depending on which instrument and the expirations are any time between uh late October in the end of the year”

0.14

The Fed cut rates at a recent meeting and indicated likely additional cuts before year-end depending on data

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“we had the FED meeting was it last week or two weeks ago I think it was last week uh and you know they they cut rates and indicated that they you know likely to do so again before the end of the year are depending on the data”

0.14

PCE (Personal Consumption Expenditures) inflation data came in slightly below expectations this week, and GDP came in flat, neither of which caused the market to reverse its expectation of Fed rate cuts.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“pce uh was a big one that came in this week it came in a little bit doish uh GDP basically came in flat but the market uh the market didn't hate these and they weren't they certainly weren't hawkish and so it certainly didn't dissuade anybody from thinking that wow the FED is no longer going to cut”

0.14

Silver was essentially flat for the week, closing just above $31, continuing its underperformance relative to gold.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“silver had another good week it was basically flat I think up slightly closed above 31 again”

0.14

Oil pulled back during the week and closed in the high 60s, below the $70 level it had been near.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“oil pulled back again it's back down below 70 um in the high 60s now”

0.14

Gold closed at an all-time high of $2,658, pulled back from approximately $2,680-2,685

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“gold had another good week it closed up I think another 25 bucks 30 bucks uh closed alltime High 2658 it pulled back a little bit from it it was around 2680 85 maybe at one point”

0.14

China opened floodgates on stimulus, injecting money into the system to combat deflationary pressures, which was the biggest news of the week and pushed gold higher

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“and then finally the the really big news of the week probably the biggest news of the week was China um finally could no longer withstand the deflationary pressures within their economy and they basically opened the floodgates on stimulus injecting money into the system”

0.13

The VIX Index was relatively flat most of the week but rallied Friday afternoon, with speaker's bias that VIX will climb and markets won't remain as sanguine as recent weeks

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“and the VIX Index was relatively flat most of the week but it rallied Friday afternoon and so you know we're going to see what that brings next week uh again equity's had a pretty good week the Dow I think ended at an all-time high the S&P in the NASDAQ didn't Faire quite as well and everything pulled back Friday afternoon um as the vixs started to rise now what the exact Catalyst was what was for that I'm not sure and whether that will continue into next week I don't know for sure my my bias is that the vix is going to climb and that we're not going to have such a sang wi markets as we've had for the last couple weeks”

0.13

The speaker bought gold positions years ago at much lower prices and does not personally need to buy gold at current all-time highs, which is a separate consideration from the recommendation that others should own gold.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“hopefully you bought it years ago and you're not having to buy it right now at alltime Highs but listen if just to be absolutely clear if you don't own any gold right now you should absolutely go buy some I mean I I've said for as long as I can remember everybody should own gold in their portfolio I don't particularly like buying things at their all-time highs”

0.10

The speaker first mentioned 'Milkshake thesis' in early 2018 (January or February) in a brief 10-15 minute presentation to clients (one slide); later in May or June 2018 did first detailed presentation on Real Vision about the Milkshake theory

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“the second blue circle here the one that's at the very beginning of 2018 that I highlighted that because that this from January to June of 2018 is when I really started first talking about this whole milkshake thesis I think it was either January or February when I first time I ever said the word milkshake in relation to the US dollar and it was just it was in a I think like a 10 or 15 minute presentation I sent out to clients in early 2018 but it was just one slide and I said that it's going to be like a milkshake and and then it was later in that year I think it was May or June where I did the first ever presentation slin I did it on real vision and when I talked about the milkshake theory in detail”

0.10

The speaker had numerous Twitter, phone, email, and DM interactions this week about the gold puts trade, making it a significant part of their week and raising questions about contradiction/argument

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“I had a lot of interactions uh with this over this week both on the phone in email form in DM on Twitter and on Twitter itself so uh you know this this was this turned out to be a rather big part of my week um and this is this is probably one of the biggest uh drivers of this uh of the contradiction or or the uh you know the the the argument what however you want to Define this”

0.10

The speaker became bullish on the dollar because the evidence was right there in front of them, even though they didn't like it; approximately 10 years ago (around 2014, summer), a friend named Raul put out a report saying the dollar would strengthen when the speaker thought it was trash, and the dollar subsequently rose ~15% (first blue circle on chart)

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Unidentified Speaker — GOLD: Love & Hate [_xPxPagkRjc]

“part of the the reason I took that time frame um is because in 2014 some almost exactly 10 years ago maybe a little bit more than 10 years ago I think it was the summer uh my friend Raul put out a report saying and he he he likes gold and he said he thought gold he thought the dollar was going to get stronger and I remember thinking god what the heck is he talking about Dollar's trash and then over the next six months go or the dollar went up about 15% and that's that that first blue circle on the left side of the chart there”