
Buying Stocks vs Real Estate Investing -- Which is Better?
What this covers
This nine-minute Motley Fool video is narrated by Deidre Woollard and compares stocks and real estate as long-term investments. It starts with the raw appreciation numbers. An S&P 500 index fund has historically returned 9–10% in total, while median U.S. home values have risen 5.5% a year since 1940. That figure shrinks to 4.6% once it is adjusted for the growth in average home size (1,246 square feet in 1940, 2,430 in 2010), and to about 1.5% after inflation. Stocks, at roughly 7% real, come out more than four times ahead on appreciation alone, which is the usual reason given for saying a home isn't an investment.
The rest of the video explains why that gap may be misleading. Leverage is the central example: a 3% gain on a $500,000 property bought with a $100,000 down payment works out to a 15% return on the cash invested. Woollard also notes that origination fees, closing costs, and monthly payments reduce that gain. She treats rental income, including renting out part of a home ("house hacking"), and depreciation deductions as further advantages that stock investors lack. The Great Recession serves as a cautionary case, when investors bet on price appreciation instead of cash flow and lenders gave mortgages to borrowers who weren't creditworthy.
Because individual property returns can't be compared one to one, she uses REITs as a proxy. The Vanguard Real Estate mutual fund beat the S&P 500 over 20 years, though REITs lagged badly over a three-year stretch when the Federal Reserve raised rates eight times. The video also covers how REITs are taxed and how they can be held in retirement accounts. It lists real estate's costs as well: it takes more effort than buying a stock, it is illiquid, and every market differs. It ends by recommending a diversified portfolio of stocks, bonds, and real estate over choosing one.
Real estate and stocks have comparable long-term return potential, but real estate offers unique advantages through leverage, rental income, and tax benefits that can amplify returns, making a diversified portfolio holding both asset classes optimal.
- After inflation adjustment, stocks return ~7% annually versus real estate's ~1.5% appreciation, but leverage and rental income can amplify real estate returns to competitive or superior levels
- REITs have matched or exceeded S&P 500 returns over 20-year periods despite short-term interest rate sensitivity
- Real estate's tax advantages (depreciation, REIT dividend treatment) and income generation complement stock portfolio returns
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
If you use debt responsibly in real estate investing by maintaining focus on cash flow, it is a healthy and necessary part of a real estate investing strategy.
“If you use debt responsibly, it's a healthy part of a real estate investing strategy. Just don't forget about the core metric of any property: its ability to generate cash flow, when you're thinking about real estate investments.”
There is no reliable way to gauge individual investment property returns on a wide scale because every property investment in each market is different, making one-to-one comparison impossible.
“This is a tough question to answer partly because there's no reliable way to gauge individual investment property returns on a wide scale. Every property investment in each market is different, so there's no real way to make a comparison on a one-to-one basis.”
During the Great Recession, real estate investors got into trouble with debt for two specific reasons: they stopped focusing on cash flow and instead bet on price appreciation, and lenders offered creative mortgage products to borrowers who were clearly not creditworthy.
“If you look at the most dire periods of the real estate market -- AKA the Great Recession -- the simple truth is that investors got into trouble with debt during the financial crisis for two reasons. One, they stopped caring about their properties' cash flow and focused on price appreciation. People were essentially betting that home prices would go up because they go up, without focusing on fundamentals. Two, there were tons of creative mortgage products given to borrowers who were clearly not creditworthy.”
Individual property returns are too difficult to track and compare on a one-to-one basis due to too many variables, so examining Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) is a good proxy for visualizing the power of real estate investments.
“It's difficult to find reliable historical data on total returns from individual investment properties. There are too many variables, and there's no reliable way to track total returns achieved by individual investors. However, one good way to visualize the power of real estate investments is to examine how real estate investment trusts have performed over time.”
Real estate investments have stronger return potential than pure price appreciation because of leverage, where you can use significant amounts of financing for real estate investments without adding a ton of risk, whereas borrowing to invest in stocks is irresponsible.
“real estate as an investment has much stronger return potential. Real estate values tend to barely outpace inflation; however, there are a few reasons why real estate investments tend to do better. First is leverage, also known as investing with someone else's money. Unlike stocks, where it's irresponsible to invest with borrowed money, you can use significant amounts of financing for real estate investments without adding a ton of risk.”
Leverage in real estate is not a perfect strategy because mortgage origination fees, closing costs, and monthly mortgage payments all eat into returns, but leverage can still dramatically amplify return on investment, which is why most investors choose to use it rather than paying cash for properties.
“This isn't a perfect example. When it comes to real estate, you'll typically have to pay an origination fee to a lender, as well as various closing costs when you buy property. These costs eat into your return. Plus, if you borrow money to buy a property, you'll need to make mortgage payments each month while you own it. That said, leverage can still dramatically amplify your return on investment, which is why most investors choose to use it rather than paying cash for properties.”
The average home in 1940 was 1,246 square feet — roughly half of the 2,430 average of 2010, meaning on a per-square-foot basis, the annualized increase in home values drops to 4.6%.
“The average home in 1940 was 1,246 square feet -- roughly half of the 2,430 average of 2010. So, if you just for home size, the annualized increase on a per-square-foot basis drops to 4.6%.”
After accounting for inflation, the average home value has risen by just 1.5% per year since 1940.
“And, after accounting for inflation, the average home value has risen by just 1.5% per year.”
Small 3% returns on a real estate asset can be dramatically amplified through leverage: a 3% appreciation on a $500,000 property with only $100,000 down payment results in a 15% return on invested capital, compared to 3% return when investing $100,000 in cash.
“Here's an example. Let's say that you buy an asset for $100,000 in cash, and its value increases by 3%. You earned a $3,000, 3%, return on your investment. On the other hand, let's say that you buy a $500,000 asset by investing $100,000 of your own money, and borrowing the other $400,000. If the value of this asset increases by 3%, you'll have a return of $15,000, or 15%, of your initial $100,000 investment.”
Investment properties generate rental income, allowing investors to use real estate as a cash-flowing asset in addition to appreciating property, unlike stocks which primarily generate returns through price appreciation and dividends.
“The second reason why investment real estate can produce strong returns is that investment properties can be rented out to generate income. You can also rent out part of a house and live in the rest -- a move called house hacking.”
Real estate is an illiquid investment where it can take months to sell a property unless you accept a deeply discounted price, whereas stocks can be sold with a couple of clicks in a short time.
“Also, real estate is an illiquid investment. You can sell stocks with a couple of clicks in no time at all. Conversely, it can take months to sell an investment property unless you want to accept a highly discounted price.”
Real estate investing requires significantly more time and effort than stock investing because you must search for, evaluate, and buy properties, in contrast to buying stocks with a couple of clicks.
“Now, there are some downsides to real estate investing. Actually buying real estate is a time-consuming investment. Hiring a property manager helps, but searching for, evaluating, and buying properties consumes far more time than simply buying stocks.”
Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) avoid corporate taxes by paying out most of their income as dividends, and they can be held in tax-advantaged retirement accounts where investors can avoid dividend and capital gains taxes in the short term.
“Real estate investment trusts, or REITs, get an extra tax benefit in that they avoid corporate taxes by paying out most of their income as dividends. REITs are easy for investors to buy in an IRA or other tax-advantaged retirement account, meaning they can avoid dividend and capital gains taxes altogether in the short term.”
Real estate investors can write off the purchase price of an investment property over a certain number of years as depreciation, a tax deduction that stock investors cannot access, giving real estate a tax advantage.
“Real estate investors enjoy tax advantages that stock investors don't. For example, when you buy an investment property, you get to write off the purchase price over a certain number of years -- a tax deduction known as depreciation. It would be awesome if you could write off your stock investments in a similar manner. That isn't the case.”
Stocks have generated roughly 7% per year over the long run after accounting for inflation, meaning the stock market has generated returns at more than 4X the rate of real estate appreciation.
“Stocks have generated roughly 7% per year over the long run after accounting for inflation. In other words, the stock market has generated returns at more than 4X the rate of real estate appreciation.”
Real estate experiences less volatile price swings than the stock market, making it a lower-volatility investment vehicle despite using leverage.
“Although real estate does experience price swings over time, they tend to be far less dramatic than stock market swings.”
The combination of rental income, leverage, and tax benefits can together produce attractive long-term gains in real estate investing that exceed stock returns.
“Together, the combination of rental income, leverage, and tax benefits can combine to produce attractive long-term gains.”
Over a 20-year period, the Vanguard Real Estate mutual fund (a benchmark index of equity REITs) has outperformed the S&P 500 stock index, demonstrating superior long-term real estate returns compared to stocks.
“Let's compare the total returns of the S&P 500 stock index and the Vanguard Real Estate mutual fund, a good benchmark index of equity REITs. The difference isn't too significant over the first few years, but by 20 years out, the vanguard ETF crushed the S&P 500.”
Over longer time periods, the effects of interest rate fluctuations tend to balance out, allowing a clearer comparison of real estate and stock performance where real estate shows comparable or superior performance.
“However, over longer periods of time, the effect of interest rate fluctuations tend to balance out, and we can get a better look at how the performance of these two asset classes stack up side by side. If you look at the longest time period, you'll notice that the performance is comparable, but with a significant edge to real estate.”
REITs offer the same liquidity and flexibility as stocks while preserving the benefits of real estate investment, though to fully realize REIT benefits it generally makes sense to hold these investments for the long term.
“Of course, if you invest in real estate investment trusts, you have the same flexibility that you would with stocks; however, to really see the benefits of REIT investing, it generally makes sense to hold these investments for the long term.”
Real estate investments have just as much, if not more, return potential as stock investments when you combine the effects of leverage, price appreciation, income potential, and tax benefits.
“It's tough to make an apples to apples comparison of the two, but it's fair to say that real estate investments have just as much, if not more, return potential as stock investments. When you combine the safe use of leverage, price appreciation, income potential, and the inherent tax benefits of real estate investing, there's potential for impressive long-term returns.”
Rather than choosing between stocks and real estate, investors should maintain a diversified portfolio including stocks, bonds, and real estate to weather market volatility while capturing relative advantages of each asset class.
“In the end, you don't really have to choose. Since stocks and real estate investments are vastly different and each offers their own advantages, why choose? A diversified portfolio with stocks, bonds, and real estate will put you in a position to better weather market hiccups, while also seizing the relative advantages each asset has to offer.”
Real estate stocks (REITs) are correlated with interest rate fluctuations over short periods, which caused significant underperformance versus the S&P 500 over a three-year period when the Federal Reserve raised interest rates eight times.
“Real estate stocks tend to be correlated with interest rate fluctuations over short periods of time, which is the main reason for the big underperformance over the three-year period. Rising interest rates are bad for REITs, and the Federal Reserve raised interest rates eight times over the past three years.”
S&P 500 index funds have historically produced total returns in the 9% to 10% range over long periods of time.
“Over long periods of time, an S&P 500 index fund has historically produced total returns in the 9% to 10% range.”
Stocks tend to increase in value quicker than real estate, which is a central finding when comparing nominal appreciation rates of the two asset classes.
“First, it's important to note that stocks tend to increase in value quicker than real estate.”
Since 1940, the median home price value in the United States has increased at an annualized rate of 5.5%.
“Since 1940, the median home price value in the United States has increased at an annualized rate of 5.5%.”
Lenders typically finance investment properties with down payments of 20% to 25% of the sales price, while primary home purchases can require significantly lower down payments.
“Lenders typically finance investment properties with down payments of just 20% to 25% of the sales price. When buying a primary home, the down payment requirements can be significantly lower.”
Primary home buyers may be able to put down as little as 3% to 5% with mortgage insurance, and some programs like VA loans offer no down payment requirement.
“You may have to pay mortgage insurance with less than 20% down, but you may be able to put down as little as 3% to 5% -- or, in some cases, such as VA loans, no down payment at all.”
Although some creative mortgage products that contributed to the Great Recession are no longer available, responsible use of debt remains an important strategy in real estate investing.
“It's unfortunate that those people got roped into complicated products. Fortunately, many of them aren't available anymore.”