
Daniel Okrent on Prohibition and His Book, Last Call 06/07/2010
What this covers
Daniel Okrent, author of Last Call, discusses Prohibition's origins and repeal with EconTalk host Russ Roberts in a conversation that reframes the 18th Amendment as a product of fiscal policy rather than moral conviction. Okrent traces how the 16th Amendment—establishing the income tax in 1913—made Prohibition politically feasible by replacing the federal government's dependence on liquor excise revenue. The same economic logic reversed the policy: the Depression's collapse of income tax receipts, combined with mass unemployment in brewing and distilling, made repeal attractive as a revenue source and jobs engine. Between these economic bookends lies a history of single-issue political strategy, malapportionment favoring rural-Protestant legislatures, and the demonization of German brewers during World War I.
The conversation moves through the structural absurdities the law created. The Volstead Act's three statutory exemptions—home production, sacramental wine, and medicinal liquor—spawned massive unintended markets: grape prices spiked eightfold by 1920 and eightyfold by 1923, while fraudulent congregations exploited sacramental wine licenses. The law never criminalized drinking itself, only supply, which meant bootleggers could operate without fear that drinkers would testify against them. This arrangement produced what Okrent calls the classic "bootleggers and Baptists" alliance—moralists providing cover for profiteers who thrived under harsh but unenforced rules. The discussion includes the incoherent political coalition backing Prohibition (ranging from the KKK to the Industrial Workers of the World), the deliberate disunity of brewers and distillers, and the intimate entanglement of Prohibition with women's suffrage, wherein brewers' opposition to voting rights paradoxically ensured that enfranchised women would vote dry.
Okrent argues that Prohibition was driven less by genuine concern over alcohol abuse than by economic incentives (the income tax replacing liquor excise revenue), ethnic/religious conflict (native-born Protestants against Catholic immigrants), and structural political distortions (malapportionment), and that it was ushered out by the same economic logic during the Depression.
- The 16th Amendment (income tax) was a prerequisite for Prohibition because federal government depended on liquor excise revenue, and its collapse in the Depression made repeal attractive
- Prohibition coalesced through single-issue political strategy, malapportioned rural-Protestant legislatures, and the demonization of German brewers during WWI
- The Volstead Act's exemptions and lack of enforcement funding created an enormous illicit economy and a 'bootleggers and Baptists' alliance that sustained the law
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Repeal of Prohibition became possible primarily because the 1929 crash and ensuing Depression wiped out income tax revenue, reviving the appeal of liquor excise taxes to fund government, while mass unemployment made the jobs in the formerly fifth-largest American industry (brewing/distilling, employing six figures plus suppliers) attractive to restore.
“income tax collection is plummeting and there's barely enough money to fund the government... well where can there be some tax revenue aha remember excise tax on liquor”
The 18th Amendment and the 13th Amendment (banning slavery) are the only two provisions in the entire history of the Constitution that limit the freedom of individuals rather than the powers of government, making their equal constitutional weight a staggering anomaly.
“there are only two things in the Constitution's entire history limited the freedom of individuals... The eighteenth Amendment said you couldn't get liquor and the Thirteenth Amendment said he couldn't own slaves”
Before the 16th Amendment (income tax) in 1913, the federal government derived as much as 40% of its revenue from the excise tax on alcohol, so Prohibition was politically impossible until the income tax provided a revenue substitute—which is precisely why Wheeler and the Anti-Saloon League waited until 1913 to push for the constitutional amendment.
“until the the creation of the passage of the income tax amendment the sixteenth amendment in 1913 the federal government in the given year got as much as forty percent of its revenue from the excise tax on alcohol you couldn't have a functioning federal government... unless you had a substitute for that revenue”
Wheeler deliberately wrote the Volstead Act so that drinking itself (even in public) was never illegal, reasoning that criminalizing drinking would prevent the government from ever getting drinkers to testify against their suppliers (bootleggers or bartenders).
“it was never against the law to drink... what wheeler had reasoned was if we make it illegal to drink we will never be able to get anybody to testify against his supplier whether that supplier is a bootlegger or a bartender”
New York's Raines Law (1890s), which permitted Sunday liquor sales only in hotels serving food, produced unintended consequences: saloons served token 'Raines sandwiches' (two slices of bread with a brick between) and added beds to qualify as hotels, which were then used for prostitution—causing Brooklyn's hotel count to jump from about 10 to 2,000.
“what was called a reigns sandwich after the law was two slices of bread with a brick in between... the more nefarious the consequence of the range law is that saloons that wanted to stay open on Sunday put in a few beds and what were those beds used for prostitution inevitably”
In a Massachusetts vote to repeal the state's prohibition enforcement law, coastal fishing-county residents (overwhelmingly white Anglo-Saxon Protestant) voted to keep enforcement in place because they had entered the lucrative rum-running business, while inland residents voted to repeal it to obtain liquor more easily—a clean illustration of economic self-interest overriding ethnic/religious voting patterns.
“the only people who wanted to keep it in place were in the coastal counties where nearly everyone who was involved in the fishing industry suddenly found themselves involved in the rum-running industry as well”
The dry political leadership tolerated massive non-enforcement of Prohibition because the symbolic existence of the law was paramount to them—they feared modification more than they feared failure to enforce, since the law symbolized control over the country and the native-born-versus-immigrant cultural conflict.
“what they feared more than anything else was a modification of the law the symbolic nature of the law was absolutely critical to them and they would tolerate all sorts of slippage particularly in the failure to to appropriate enough money for enforcement because they want to keep that law in place”
Wayne B. Wheeler pioneered single-issue balance-of-power politics by dedicating the Anti-Saloon League to backing or opposing candidates solely on their prohibition stance, delivering 5-20% of votes in close races, thereby controlling outcomes without ever commanding a majority—a playbook later used by figures like Lee Atwater, Karl Rove, and James Carville.
“he dedicated his organization the anti-saloon League to one issue and one issue only... he could deliver in any given constituency anywhere from 5% to 20% of the votes based on are you for or against prohibition so without ever having a majority he could tell the balance between any two candidates in a reasonably close race”
The collapse of income tax revenue in the early 1930s made the repeal of Prohibition more attractive, mirroring how a tax-law change ushered it in—so the same revenue logic both greased the skids for Prohibition's adoption and its abolition.
“you cite my colleague Don boudreaux's been a guest on this program many times his work with Adam Pritchard that when in the early 1930s when the income tax revenue was falling dramatically it made the repeal of prohibition that much more attractive”
The 'bootleggers and Baptists' theory (Bruce Yandell) explains Prohibition: legislation is typically supported by high-minded moralists (Baptists) who provide moral cover and self-interested profiteers (bootleggers) who benefit from the rules; once Prohibition passed, bootleggers had a strong stake in keeping it because harsh-but-unenforced laws maximized their tax-free profits.
“the bootleggers and Baptists idea is that there are two usually two interest groups that that are in favor of legislation... one of the high-minded folks who have the moral authority... then you have the bootleggers the people who profit from the illegalities”
Bootleggers had a clear stake in supporting dry legislators and harsh-but-unenforced laws, as exemplified by corrupt wet politicians like Chicago Mayor Bill Thompson backing dry legislation, because nothing was better for bootleggers than strict laws that weren't enforced.
“you do have many instances of wet administered politicians in executive positions like Mayor Bill Thompson of Chicago... supporting dry legislators because there was nothing better for the bootleggers... than to have harsh laws that weren't enforced”
The Jewish sacramental wine exemption was exploited because, unlike the hierarchical Catholic Church, any rabbi could obtain a license to distribute ten gallons of wine per congregant per year, leading to explosive fake-congregation fraud (e.g., a Boyle Heights congregation jumping from 180 to 1,000 families, with members' names taken from telephone directories) and 'rabbis' named McLaughlin and O'Hara, until crackdowns reduced the limit to five gallons around 1926.
“any rabbi could get a license to distribute wine to the adult members of his congregation ten gallons per member of the congregation per year”
Brewers in Texas (1903-1905) cynically mobilized the still-existing pre-Jim-Crow black vote against statewide prohibition by sending agents on Election Day equipped with poll-tax money, powers of attorney to vote on others' behalf, and posters of Abraham Lincoln.
“they equipped those people these agents with three things the money to pay the poll tax... a power of attorney that enabled them to vote the person's vote and third a poster of Abraham Lincoln to indicate whose side they were on it was diabolical and it was very very effective”
Jack London supported California women's suffrage in 1911 because he reasoned women would vote to close saloons, which would finally enable him to stop drinking.
“he tells us wife that he voted for women's suffrage... he said that he realized that when the woman gets to vote she will vote to close the saloon and if a saloons close I will finally be able to stop drinking he supported it for the sake of his own sobriety”
The Volstead Act's three statutory exemptions (farmer fruit-juice/home production up to 200 gallons, sacramental wine, and medicinal liquor) created enormous unintended markets: grape prices rose roughly eightfold by 1920 and up to eightyfold by 1923 as growers shipped grapes east to immigrant cities where families legally made wine, with up to 70,000 freight cars a year going east.
“in 1920 the first prohibition the harvest suddenly the price of grapes has gone up Eightfold... by 1923 is up something like 80 fold because suddenly the the grape growers realized they can just ship huge quantities of grapes ease to the big cities”
The sacramental wine exemption, intended to win Catholic and Jewish support, instead created a large fraudulent business: figures like Georges de Latour sold communion wine in ten grape varietals, and a 1929 court ruling that sacramental status depended on use rather than the liquid itself legalized sacramental brandy and crème de menthe.
“by 1921 was sending out brochures across the country advertising his communion wine which he by then only one year into prohibition came in ten different grape varietals”
Prohibition degraded wine quality through a market response: growers tore out fine varietals (Cabernet, Zinfandel, Chardonnay) and planted the Alicante Bouschet, a thick-skinned grape that shipped well and produced lots of color, valued only because it could survive cross-country transit and yield something resembling wine—leaving few who knew how to make decent wine at repeal.
“the grape growers tore out their Cabernet grapes their Zinfandel grapes their Chardonnay grapes and planted this grape called a Laconte bush a Alicante Bechet had two great qualities it shipped extremely well... and secondarily... it produced a lot of color and you could get something that looked like wine even if it didn't taste much like wine”
The political alliance for Prohibition was ideologically incoherent by modern standards, stretching from the Ku Klux Klan (anti-immigrant) through the Progressive Party to the far-left Industrial Workers of the World (who believed liquor was a capitalist tool to keep workers down), reflecting the birth of the 'nanny state' before today's left-right categories existed.
“the political Alliance for prohibition stretched from the Ku Klux Klan at one end... to the far left the Industrial Workers of the world the Wobblies they supported prohibition because they believed that liquor was a tool used by the capitalists to keep the working man down”
The prohibition and women's suffrage movements were inextricably linked from 1850 onward: the Anti-Saloon League allied with suffragists, and brewers passed a 1871 resolution to oppose women's suffrage everywhere because they feared women would vote dry—which paradoxically guaranteed women would vote for prohibition once enfranchised.
“the Brewers... they vowed in the resolution passed in 1871 by the US Brewers Association to oppose women's suffrage everywhere and anywhere because they saw the vote for women would be their downfall of course the more that they oppose women's suffrage the more than that guaranteed that when women did get the vote they would vote for prohibition”
The only two states that refused to ratify the 18th Amendment were Rhode Island and Connecticut—the two most Catholic states—because at least one house of their legislatures was honestly apportioned and heavily Catholic, and Catholics almost universally opposed prohibition for political and ethnic reasons.
“The only two that didn't were Rhode Island and Connecticut the two most Catholic states in the country... the representation at least in one house of the legislature in each of those states was was honest fair and heavily Catholic and Catholics almost universally opposed prohibition”
Utah being the 36th and decisive state to ratify repeal demonstrates how deeply Prohibition was despised and how desperately people wanted liquor back, since even a heavily Mormon, traditionally dry state voted to bring it back.
“the 36th state to ratify the amendment... the repeal amendment is Utah and when you toss the one that says bring back liquor you know how much people wanted it back”
By 1830, the peak of American drinking, the average American consumed somewhat over seven gallons of pure alcohol a year, equivalent to about ninety fifths of 80-proof liquor or nearly two bottles a week, and since many people abstained, actual drinkers consumed far more.
“the average American consumes somewhat over seven gallons of pure alcohol a year that's the equivalent of ninety fifths of 80 proof liquor nearly two bottles a week”
World War I was decisive in putting Prohibition over the top because the German surnames of the major brewers (Anheuser-Busch, Pabst, Schmidt) allowed Wheeler to demonize them as a treasonous fifth column sapping the war effort and consuming grain needed to feed starving Belgians, totally discrediting the anti-prohibition forces.
“all of them were German and it was very easy for wheeler and the anti-saloon League to demonize the Brewers that they were destroying our country and our country's war effort... they were the tools of the Kaiser who were working unpatriotic ly diabolically as a fifth column inside the United States”
Brewers and distillers were economic rivals who never united against Prohibition because every glass of beer was a shot of whiskey not bought; brewers attacked distillers as purveyors of poison while distillers attacked brewers as the vile managers of corrupting saloons, and this disunity meant there was no effective organized opposition to Prohibition.
“they were economic rivals every glass of beer you bought was a shot of whiskey didn't buy and vice versa they did not see their interest as being in common”
Both the wealthy conservative eastern plutocrats and southern white racists opposed Prohibition on states'-rights and anti-government grounds—the plutocrats as part of a package with opposing income tax, suffrage, and child labor laws; the racists because acknowledging federal power to ban liquor would validate the 15th Amendment they were resisting.
“the wealthy extremely conservative Republicans... opposed the income tax amendment they opposed the woman suffrage amendment they opposed child labor laws they opposed prohibition they saw all of those things as a package”
Prohibition created the first national criminal syndicate because it generated the need to move large quantities of physical goods across regions, requiring confederates at multiple points—culminating in the 1929 Atlantic City meeting where mobsters set territories, fixed prices, and rules, building a national crime organization that persisted for decades.
“the creation of the first national criminal syndicate direct product of prohibition... once prohibition comes there's suddenly the need to move large quantities of physical goods from one place to another and you need Confederates”
By 1775 alcohol was so established in American life that George Washington decreed every member of the Continental Army would receive a daily ration of four ounces of whiskey, and government fiscal dependence on whiskey began with Hamilton's 1790s excise tax precisely because it was consumed nationwide.
“George Washington decreed that every member of the Continental Army would get a daily ration of four ounces of whiskey... Alexander Hamilton Institute's the excise tax on whiskey which he put there because he knew it was the one thing that was being consumed throughout the the the young nation”
It is politically easier to play offense than defense: people fight harder to change something than to keep what they already have, which is why the organized drys defeated the disorganized drinkers who were 'too busy drinking' to mobilize.
“you never get people to fight as hard to keep something than to do they do when they want to change something it's politically it's easier to play offense than defense”
When a law is passed, the regulated industry's ingenuity is inspired by the possibility of profit, leading lawyers and firms to immediately search for legal ways around it—a recurring human impulse that Roberts ties to the contemporary (2010) financial regulation legislation.
“what's going on inside the headquarters and the law firms representing the financial industry they're looking at the law as it appears to we'll be figuring out how do we legally get around this ingenuity is inspired by the possibility of profit”
Modern call brands of liquor (asking for 'a Dewar's' rather than 'a scotch') established themselves during Prohibition because, when product provenance and quality became uncertain in the black market, branded names served as quality signals—though counterfeiting branded bottles with rotgut became a huge business that, lacking legal recourse, had to be policed through violence.
“once you don't know the quality of the liquor you're being offered you don't know its provenance... suddenly there's comfort and say it... give me a Dewar's and the call brands that we know today established themselves... during Prohibition”
Congress unconstitutionally refused to reapportion the House of Representatives for nearly the entire 1920s after the 1920 census (the first showing more urban than rural residents and reflecting decades of immigration), because reapportionment would have shifted voting power toward wet urban districts—only the 1930 election produced a reapportioned Congress that made repeal possible.
“the drys decided not to reapportioned a simply ignored the constitutional stipulation that they were supposed to reapportion and there were reapportionment measures introduced in Congress beginning in 1921 forward until 1929 and not one of them passed”
Severe malapportionment of state legislatures (rotten boroughs)—where rural Protestant districts vastly overrepresented their populations relative to urban immigrant districts—was a structural prerequisite that enabled Prohibition's ratification across the states.
“you had these rotten borough districting that enabled the rural districts which is to say the Protestant districts which is to say the pro prohibition districts to dominate state legislatures across the country”
The 'free lunch' was a staple of the urban tied-house saloon (1890-Prohibition): brewers provided saloons everything from glassware to signage in exchange for selling only their brand, and offered free salty food (saltines, sardines, sausage) designed to make patrons thirsty and buy more beer.
“the free lunch was an absolute staple of the urban saloon from 1890 or so until prohibition the saloons were almost all by then dominated by what's called the the tide house business”
Soft-drink and entertainment magnates supported Prohibition out of pecuniary self-interest: Asa Candler of Coca-Cola backed it (and it boosted his product), and the Shubert Brothers (controlling many theaters) reasoned that closed bars would drive people to theaters instead.
“the groups who were supporting prohibition out of their pecuniary self-interest were organizations like the soft drink founders ASIC Ambler of coca-cola... another example would be the Schubert Brothers... they reasoned that if the bars were closed people who go to theaters instead”
The primary reason alcohol consumption was so widespread early on was the bad quality of water, since one could be safe with a distilled beverage, though seven half-gallons of pure alcohol a year far exceeds what thirst alone would require.
“the primary reason really for there being so much for its being so widespread was the bad quality of water right one could be safe with a distilled beverage”
The saloon transformed drinking from merely available into a structural feature of working men's lives because it served as a hiring hall, men's club, bathhouse, and brothel, providing escape from harsh industrial and frontier labor, which fueled both excessive drinking and the anti-drinking movement on behalf of women left behind.
“the saloon was everything from a hiring hall to a men's club to a place we're going to get a bat in the shower it's a place we're going to get a prostitute where one can escape from the toils and travails of daily life and once in the saloon the drinking didn't stop”
Prohibition was substantially a nativist Protestant movement aimed at Catholic immigrants (Irish and Italian), because middle-American native-born Protestants believed they were losing their country to immigrant hordes and blamed liquor, which was central to immigrant life and to the saloon-based political machines.
“it was a Protestant movement aimed in many cases against Catholics the immigrants who are coming into the cities these were Irish and Italian”
Prohibition was deliberately under-enforced: only about 2,000 federal prohibition agents covered the entire country, because the same Midwestern-dominated, penny-pinching Republican Congresses that passed Prohibition refused to appropriate money to enforce it during a low-spending era.
“there were 2,000 federal prohibition agents to cover the entire country which is a ridiculous number... this was a time when no one wanted the government the federal government to spend money so the idea of voting two dollars to enforce prohibition was a nassima to penny-pinching republican congressmen”
A Philadelphia police captain on a salary of about $1,800 a year had accumulated a bank account of $150,000, which he claimed to have acquired by raising and selling pet birds—exemplifying the scale of police corruption fueled by Prohibition's illicit cash flows.
“this one police captain who on a salary of something like $1,800 a year had a bank account of a hundred and fifty thousand dollars and he said that he had been able to acquire that by by raising pet birds and selling them”
Brewers funded a covert campaign of bogus journalism, supplying fabricated pro-beer articles to country newspaper editors who accepted bribes, as part of their underhanded efforts to discredit the prohibition movement.
“they supported a huge campaign of bogus journalism that they gave to country editors all over the country articles that purported to be selling the true story about people making certain accomplishments because of the beer they were drinking and it was all fabricated it was all bribery”
The class paternalism in the drinking debate paralleled pro-slavery paternalism: upper classes (both conservative and progressive reformers like Jane Addams) believed they could hold their liquor but the working man had to be protected from himself, an idea Okrent and Roberts connect to writers like Dickens and Tennyson who argued black people couldn't make their own decisions.
“the upper classes saw themselves capable of holding their liquor but the working man of course had to be protected protected or kept down depending on the perspective”
St. Louis was historically a 'tied town' dominated by Anheuser-Busch, as illustrated by a bar in the early 1990s offering only Budweiser-family products (Bud, Bud Light, Michelob, Busch) when asked what beer was available.
“they had the entire array of Budweiser anheuser-busch products so st. Louis it then was it's probably still is somewhat of a tied town”
George Ehret's advertising brochure in Detroit showed a three or four year old child drinking beer as a healthful beverage, illustrating how brewers marketed beer as wholesome 'liquid bread.'
“there's a photograph in the book... of an advertising brochure from George G's a grower of German extraction in Detroit which shows a three or four year old child drinking beer because it's a healthful beverage”