What this covers

This 9-minute opener to the Existential Basics series is a solo talk by Mark, organized in three parts: the meaning of philosophy, the rejection of inherence, and brief conclusions. It begins with etymology, the Greek "love of wisdom," and with a complaint that philosophy is often pictured as old men arguing about things that don't matter. Mark says this is only half true. The other half, in his account, is a search for truth that uses observation and logic. He treats the scientific method (question, hypothesis, observation, confirmation absent contradiction) as what empirical philosophy looks like in practice, and he separates philosophy from science only by saying philosophy applies reason to what science observes. That claim is contested.

The second half turns to what he is against. He defines dogmatic philosophy as any pursuit of knowledge that claims objective facts about properties absolutely inherent to existence. He prefers the label inherence: the belief that things are supposed to be a certain way, and that doubting is wrong because someone else has already done the thinking. He says Nietzsche's "dogma" or objectivity and Sartre's spirit of seriousness and belief in essence all name the same unempirical habit of thought. He also uses Nietzsche's image of dogmatists as "dreamers" who closed their eyes long ago.

Mark's positions get sharper here. He borrows "innocent until proven guilty" as an epistemic rule: nothing counts as true until shown to be, and nothing is absent unless shown present. He dismisses metaphysics and ethics as commonly practiced as "wishy-washy armchair" philosophy, because their assumptions are detached from the observable world and no evidence could confirm or contradict them. He also claims that dogmatists don't pursue truth because they think they already have it, and that dogmatic systems pick and choose which evidence to accept. The argument is quick and assertive, and it is meant as an accessible foundation for the series.

Sharpest takeaway

Mark argues that genuine philosophy must be empirical and scientific—grounded in observable reality and testable evidence—and that dogmatic philosophies claiming absolute truth without empirical proof are inherently unreliable and should be rejected.

  • Philosophy originally meant the empirical pursuit of truth through observation and reason, not abstract armchair theorizing
  • Dogmatic philosophies pick and choose evidence and claim certainty about unobservable properties, making them unreliable
  • Existentialist philosophy rejects 'inheritance'—the belief that things should be a certain way without evidence—in favor of empirical verification

The claims · ranked18 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.61

What makes a philosophy dogmatic is a belief that something can be absolutely true even though it can never be observed or confirmed—this is what Nietzsche calls dogma or objectivity, Sartre calls the spirit of seriousness or the belief in essence.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“what makes a philosophy dogmatic is a belief that we can know that something is absolutely true even though we can never observe or confirm it so nietzsche calls it dogma or objectivity sart calls it the spirit of seriousness or sometimes just the belief in essence”

0.61

Empiricism can be justified through observable evidence: if I can see, touch, smell, hear, and taste the properties of something, it makes sense to assume they are real, and in the absence of evidence to the contrary, we can reasonably assume that observable reality is genuine.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“i don't know about you but i'd start by looking at the things that i can see and i'd assume that they're real i can touch them i can smell them i can hear and taste their properties sure i can't know for sure that i know anything's real but it seems like it makes perfect sense to just assume that they're real if i can see that they're real unless i've got some other reason to believe that they're not”

0.60

The principle of 'innocent until proven guilty'—requiring proof before accepting a claim as true—should apply to philosophy and epistemology: nothing can be truth until it's proven that it is, no crime unless there's proof of a crime, and nothing is absent unless proven present.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Mark

“innocent until proven guilty no crime unless there's proof of a crime absent until proven present nothing can be truth until it's proven that it is”

0.57

Philosophy was originally and is supposed to be empirical and scientific, involving the use of observation ('your eyes') and logic ('your brain') to reason through and discover what truth is and how reality actually works.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Mark

“what it's supposed to be what it was originally was always empirical and always scientific it's supposed to be where you use your eyes to look and then you use your brain to think your eyes do the science your brain does the logic and together you can use them to try and [4:10] reason your way through and see if you can figure out for yourself what truth is to learn how reality actually works”

0.55

The process Mark just demonstrated—using observation and rational thinking to understand truth—is both science and empirical philosophy; the distinction between them is that philosophy is logic and reason applied to what science observes.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“now all that what i just did there what does that look like to you was that philosophy that was just science wasn't it it was logic and simple math putting two and two together it was rational and testable and provable and it's what we call empirical philosophy philosophy that's informed by empirical methodology [3:39] in other words science”

0.55

If a theory is based on assumptions detached from the observable world, there is no rational reason to consider its truth claims reliable, because there could be no possible evidence that could confirm or contradict the belief.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“how can you form a theory based on assumptions that are detached from the observable world how can you say that you believe something is the truth if there's no way that you could have ever found information that could confirm if that belief was actually the truth”

0.55

Nietzsche calls dogmatists 'dreamers'—those who closed their eyes long ago and now live in their own fantasy world completely detached from reality.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Mark

“this is what nietzsche says that dogmatists are the ones he calls dreamers the ones who close their eyes a long time ago and now live in their own fantasy world completely detached from reality”

0.51

Metaphysics and ethics, as commonly practiced, are 'wishy-washy armchair' philosophies built on assumptions detached from the observable world, making them unable to rationally justify their truth claims.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Mark

“talk about that other half then they have that a whole lot of people especially me i think it's just wishy-washy armchair they call them metaphysics and ethics and what they are is abstract theories that are based on assumptions that are essentially detached from the observable world”

0.48

Existentialists reject the idea of inherence in all its many forms because they are empiricists who reject dogma and any form of dogmatic philosophy—any pursuit of knowledge or truth that claims to know anything that cannot first be proven empirically.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“there's our first lesson in existential philosophy we as existentialists and therefore as empiricists reject the idea of inheritance in all its many forms we reject dogma and any form of dogmatic philosophy any pursuit of knowledge or truth that claims to know anything that can't first be proven empirically”

0.44

Mark prefers to call dogmatic philosophy 'inherence'—a philosophy of inherence means a belief that things are supposed to be some way without any evidence, and that it is wrong to doubt or think because someone else already did the thinking and all one needs to do is follow and believe.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Mark

“me though i like to call it inheritance a philosophy of inherence after all means exactly what it says it's a belief that things are supposed to be some way without any evidence and that it's wrong to think that they might not be that way to doubt is evil to think is evil because somebody else already did all the thinking for you all you need to do is follow and believe”

0.43

Dogmatists don't care about reaching truth because they usually believe they already know the truth, making the pursuit of further knowledge unnecessary.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“they don't care about reaching the truth because usually they believe that they already know the truth why would you go out and look for something if you think you already have it”

0.43

The practical meaning of philosophy can be defined as the search for truth—taking what you can see and what you think you know and using your brain to figure out how reality actually works.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“philosophy is the search for truth to take what you can see and what you think you know and to use your brain to put it all together [4:42] talk about that other half then”

0.43

Dogmatic philosophies do not give us rational reasons to trust their truth claims because they are not empirical or scientific—they are philosophies that pick and choose what kinds of evidence they will accept.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“the problem with this other half with these unempirical philosophies is well it's just that the problem is that they're not empirical they're not scientific so they [5:44] never give us any rational reason to think that their truths are reliable these are what we call dogmatic philosophies the ones that pick and choose what kinds of evidence they'll take”

0.43

A dogmatic philosophy is defined as any pursuit of knowledge that believes there are properties of existence which are absolutely inherent to it and that these inherent properties can be known as objective facts of reality.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“a dogmatic philosophy is any pursuit of knowledge that believes that there are properties of existence which are absolutely inherent to it and that we can know these inherent properties as objective facts of reality”

0.43

All the various philosophical terms for dogmatism—whether Nietzsche's 'dogma or objectivity', Sartre's 'spirit of seriousness' or 'belief in essence', or others—mean the same thing: any unempirical or unscientific way of thinking.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark

“it doesn't really matter what we call it they all mean the same thing just any unempirical or unscientific way of thinking”

0.41

The scientific method involves formulating a question, forming a hypothesis based on observable phenomena, collecting data through observation of the world, and confirming the theory in the absence of contradictory evidence—this process is what empirical philosophy looks like.

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Mark

“here's draw that first i asked a question what is truth how can we know that what we think is true is actually the truth then i formed a hypothesis there's a sense in which i can know truth because i can go out into the world and confirm whether or not the things which [2:37] i see match up with the things i believe next i took data i observed the world and found evidence that it was actually the case that i can go out into the world and confirm whether or not the things which i believe match up to what i can see and finally i confirmed my theory in the absence of evidence to the contrary”

0.34

The word 'philosophy' comes from Greek: 'filo' meaning to love and 'sofia' meaning wisdom, which together mean the love of wisdom or the pursuit of knowledge.

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Mark

“here's the greek where the word comes from and what it's actually supposed to mean that's filo that means to love [1:06] and sofia which means wisdom put them together what you get is the love of wisdom or something like the pursuit of knowledge”

0.17

Many people misconceive philosophy as merely a couple of old white guys sitting around arguing back and forth about things that don't matter, which is partially true but misses the other half that actually pursues truth.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Mark

“i've met more than my fair share of people that are pretty convinced that they know exactly what philosophy is it's a couple old white guys sitting around arguing back and forth about a bunch of that doesn't matter and honestly they're right about half the time what we're interested in though is that other half”