
What is life? A Nobel Prize-winning scientist answers | Paul Nurse Full Interview
What this covers
This is a single-speaker interview in which Paul Nurse, a geneticist who shared the 2001 Nobel Prize for work on cell cycle control, walks through the argument of his book on what life is. He begins with the cell, the simplest entity that is unambiguously alive, and then builds outward through the gene, evolution, chemistry, and information. Much of the first half rests on his own research organism, yeast. He explains why it is a convenient eukaryote for cell biological, biochemical, and genetic experiments. He also argues that the machinery controlling cell division is the same in yeast and in human cells, which points to a mechanism roughly 1.5 billion years old.
The middle of the conversation is historical and conceptual. Nurse recounts how Gregor Mendel's work on heredity was ignored for decades, even though Charles Darwin was sent a copy of it. He also recounts how Oswald Avery's identification of DNA as the genetic material met resistance because DNA seemed too simple a molecule to carry that much information. He calls evolution by natural selection probably the most beautiful idea in biology, since it lets design emerge without a designer. It also makes every living thing a relative of every other. From that point he draws an ethical conclusion about humanity's responsibility to steward nature.
The last third turns to the claim that life is chemistry plus information. Nurse describes thousands of enzyme-catalysed reactions, with DNA sequence specifying the order of amino acids in each protein. He treats the double helix as a digital storage device, an invention he dates to about 3.5 billion years ago, long before writing or computers. He adds that cells must manage information to keep their compartments coordinated. He also addresses the second law of thermodynamics: living things are bounded and not isolated, so they can build internal order while exporting disorder.
Life is fundamentally defined by five core ideas—the cell, the gene, evolution by natural selection, chemistry, and information—which together form an integrated system of bounded physical entities that use hereditary material and information management to maintain organization and evolve.
- The cell is the simplest unambiguous unit of life and expresses all characteristics of living things: growth, division, and reproduction
- DNA serves dual roles as both a stable digital information storage device and as instructions for proteins that perform chemical work
- Life requires simultaneous management of complex chemistry through compartmentalization and continuous information processing to maintain coordination and respond to environment
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The mechanism controlling cell division in yeast is the same as the mechanism in human cells, indicating that this control process was established approximately 1.5 billion years ago when yeast and humans last shared a common ancestor, and has remained unchanged since then.
“later in life, I worked on yeast for some years, together with my colleagues discovered the molecules that controlled that whole process of cell division, and then went on to show that exactly the same processes worked in human beings as well...If the same process was controlling the reproduction of a yeast cell as controls the reproduction of a human cell, then this means this was a control that was extremely ancient, because yeast and human beings diverged at least a billion years ago and probably one and a half billion years ago.”
Life invented digital information storage approximately 3.5 billion years ago, predating human computer invention by billions of years, representing an independent discovery of this informational principle.
“We like to think that we humans invented this, but actually it was invented by life probably 3.5 billion years ago.”
Living things are bounded physical entities that separate themselves from the rest of the world, allowing them to increase internal order (through metabolic processes) while exporting disorder to the environment, which means living systems do not violate the second law of thermodynamics because they are not isolated systems.
“Living things are bounded physical entities. I mean, they are working as themselves. And that's important, because otherwise you get mixed up with computer games and so on sometimes, which have evolution built into them. These physical bounded entities separate a living thing from the rest of the world, so you can increase your order within the cell as a consequence of disorder outside the cell. And this means that you don't have any problems with the second law of thermodynamics of physics.”
Life invented digital information storage approximately 3.5 billion years ago, billions of years before humans developed written language and digital computers.
“We like to think that we humans invented this, but actually it was invented by life probably 3.5 billion years ago.”
Living things are bounded physical entities that separate themselves from the rest of the world, enabling them to increase order and complexity within themselves while increasing disorder outside themselves, thereby avoiding violation of the second law of thermodynamics.
“Living things are bounded physical entities. I mean, they are working as themselves. And that's important, because otherwise you get mixed up with computer games and so on sometimes, which have evolution built into them. These physical bounded entities separate a living thing from the rest of the world, so you can increase your order within the cell as a consequence of disorder outside the cell. And this means that you don't have any problems with the second law of thermodynamics of physics.”
The cell is the simplest entity that can unambiguously be thought of as clearly alive and is both the basic structural unit and the basic functional unit of life, being the simplest object that expresses characteristics of life such as growth, division, and reproduction.
“The cell is really critical for the way I think about life...it's simplest entity that you can unambiguously think is clearly alive...everybody will agree that the cell is the basic unit of life. It's not only the basic structural unit of life...it's also the basic functional unit of life, by which I mean it is the simplest object that expresses characteristics of life. It can grow, it can divide, it can reproduce.”
Cell reproduction (division from one cell to two) is one of the most fundamental processes to study because all living things reproduce, and it is visible in its simplest form in cellular division.
“reproduction is a characteristic of all life. It's one of the things that all living things do. And you see it in its simplest form in the division of a cell. That particularly fascinated me, because when I was seeking a research project in my 20s...I wanted to study a fundamental process. And for me, cell reproduction represented exactly that, because all living things reproduce, and we see it there in its simplest form.”
Eukaryotic cells (cells with chromosomes and DNA wrapped up in a nucleus) share fundamental cell division control mechanisms between yeast and humans because the same molecular processes controlled cell division in both organisms even though they diverged 1.5 billion years ago.
“Cells from yeast through to human cells are called eukaryotes. That's a technical term, which just means their chromosomes, their DNA is wrapped up in a nucleus...I worked on yeast for some years, together with my colleagues discovered the molecules that controlled that whole process of cell division, and then went on to show that exactly the same processes worked in human beings as well.”
The cell is the simplest entity that can be unambiguously considered alive and is both the basic structural and functional unit of life, meaning it is the simplest object that expresses all characteristics of life including growth, division, and reproduction.
“The cell is really critical for the way I think about life...It's not only the basic structural unit of life...it's also the basic functional unit of life, by which I mean it is the simplest object that expresses characteristics of life. It can grow, it can divide, it can reproduce.”
DNA's double helix structure is a digital information storage device because information is encoded in the sequence order of the four bases (A, G, C, T) along the side of the ladder, similar to how books use letters and computers use bytes to store digital information.
“The first is it conveys information. And the information is conveyed in the order of those bases that make up the side of the ladder, the order of the A, the G, the C, and the T. So this is basically a digital information storage device. Now, this is a very economical way of storing information. If you read a book, they are made up of letters, which are digital information. In the computers we use, it's all made up of bytes, which is digital information.”
Every cell cycle requires that every single base pair in the genome be replicated with extraordinary precision, and while there is occasional damage to DNA during copying, mistakes are rare because the copying process is carefully controlled—this small amount of damage is important for evolution because it provides the genetic variation upon which natural selection acts.
“every single base pair in the genome has to be replicated, has to be divided, and it has to be done with extraordinary precision. Because if it made mistakes, then genes would be damaged. And if they're damaged, then the cell can't work properly. And so it's very precise in the copying, but there's a little bit of damage that occurs, and that turns out to be important for evolution.”
Information transmission between cellular compartments is critical for maintaining coordination in the cell: if different compartments weren't coordinated through information exchange, the whole cellular system could fall apart, making information management essential for the cell's integrated function.
“That can only occur if there's an information transmission from different compartments to keep the whole thing coordinated. If you didn't keep it coordinated together, then the whole thing could fall apart. It's very important to manage information for life to work.”
Life invented digital information storage approximately 3.5 billion years ago, which predates human invention of similar systems by billions of years, demonstrating that life's information management strategies are fundamentally more ancient than human technology.
“We like to think that we humans invented this, but actually it was invented by life probably 3.5 billion years ago.”
Every human being was once a single cell (a fertilized egg) and remained so before dividing, making cellular understanding directly relevant to human self-understanding.
“all of us were once a single cell. When we were once a fertilized egg in our mother's body. It was a single cell. And really, if we were all one cells, isn't that something we should be really interested in?”
Mendel's work on heredity was completely ignored by the scientific community for decades, even though Charles Darwin received a copy of his paper and it was documented in the Encyclopedia Britannica, until three botanists independently rediscovered the same results around 1900.
“What was unfortunate was that nobody took any notice of what Mendel did. None whatsoever. So they knew it had been published. Even Charles Darwin had been sent to paper. And I noticed that it was in the Encyclopedia Britannica, 10, 15 years later, but nobody took any notice of his interpretation. And then in the early 1900s, three different botanists did the same sorts of experiments, got the same results, but they then had to admit it all had been described by the gardening monk 35 years before.”
Avery's work showing DNA as genetic material was initially controversial and largely ignored by the scientific community because many scientists believed DNA was too simple a molecule to encode the information required for heredity.
“This, once again, just like Mendel, was taken no notice of. This turned out to be controversial, too. 'Cause DNA isn't a complicated molecule. And quite a few scientists at the time thought, oh, this isn't sufficiently elaborate or sufficiently complicated to encode all the information that has to be kept in genes.”
The cell is the simplest entity that can be unambiguously considered alive and is both the basic structural and functional unit of life, being the simplest object that expresses characteristics of life including growth, division, and reproduction.
“The cell is really critical for the way I think about life...it's simplest entity that you can unambiguously think is clearly alive...everybody will agree that the cell is the basic unit of life. It's not only the basic structural unit of life...it's also the basic functional unit of life, by which I mean it is the simplest object that expresses characteristics of life. It can grow, it can divide, it can reproduce.”
Yeast is an excellent model organism for studying cell division because it is simple, allows easy experimentation with multiple biological tools (cell biological, biochemical, and genetic approaches), and cell division mechanisms discovered in yeast illuminate corresponding mechanisms in human cells.
“When I thought about how to study cell reproduction, I thought, let's take a simple system. A system which we can work on easily. A system where we can do lots of experiments, a range of experiments, cell biological, biochemical, genetical...And I decided to work on yeast...It's very good as a model for other cells in all sorts of more complicated living things like our cells.”
Yeast is an excellent model organism for studying cell division because it is simple, allows easy experimentation with multiple approaches (cell biological, biochemical, genetic), and the findings in yeast often apply to more complex organisms including human cells.
“A system which we can work on easily. A system where we can do lots of experiments, a range of experiments, cell biological, biochemical, genetical...I decided to work on yeast. Most people are not excited by yeast...but actually it's more than that. It's very good as a model for other cells in all sorts of more complicated living things like our cells.”
Although DNA replication is extremely precise, occasional copying mistakes (mutations) occur and are important for evolution because they create the genetic variation upon which natural selection acts.
“it's very precise in the copying, but there's a little bit of damage that occurs, and that turns out to be important for evolution, as I'm sure we'll talk about a little later.”
Evolution by natural selection reveals that all living things are related by descent: every living thing on the planet can trace back ancestors to a common place, making every organism on Earth related to every other organism.
“One of the consequences of evolution is that we're related by descent. Because if we all can trace back our ancestors to a common place, then every living thing on this planet is related.”
Evolution by natural selection is probably the most beautiful idea in biology because it provides a mechanism by which design can emerge without a designer, based on the concepts of hereditary material, genetic variation, and differential reproductive success.
“The idea of evolution by natural selection is, for me, probably the most beautiful idea in biology...It provided a mechanism by which animals and plants could evolve. And really, you could get design without having a designer.”
The idea that animals and plants might evolve is ancient, with speculation about evolution appearing even in Aristotle's work, and becoming more prominent in the 18th century when people studied fossils and observed evidence of change over time.
“The idea that animals and plants might evolve is actually quite old. Even Aristotle had some thoughts about it. But particularly in the 18th century, there were a number of people who speculated looking at fossils and so on, that animals and plants had evolved over time.”
A simple model of evolution by natural selection can be illustrated with a single-celled organism having a red coat on its cell surface that makes it vulnerable to predators; if a mutation creates a yellow coat, the yellow-coated cells survive better than red-coated ones and eventually take over the population—a basic example of natural selection producing evolutionary change.
“Imagine a single-celled organism which had a red coat outside the cell, or a yellow coat. Let's say that the red coat got eaten by some other living organism. Then, if there was a mutation which resulted in the red coat turning into a yellow coat, then the yellow-coated cells would survive better than the red-coated ones. And as a consequence, they would take over the population. And that's just a very simple example of evolution by natural selection.”
Yeast is an excellent model organism for studying cell reproduction because it is a simple eukaryotic system in which many experiments can be conducted using cell biological, biochemical, and genetic tools to understand fundamental cellular processes.
“I decided to work on yeast...it's very good as a model for other cells in all sorts of more complicated living things like our cells...A system which we can work on easily. A system where we can do lots of experiments, a range of experiments, cell biological, biochemical, genetical, so that we can use every tool that a biologist has to understand what's going on.”
Cell division cycle (CDC) genes are genes necessary for the process of cell reproduction from cell birth through growth to division, which can be identified by finding mutant yeast cells that grow larger but cannot divide, revealing which genes are required for the reproduction process.
“I looked for mutant yeast cells that would simply get bigger and bigger and would never divide. And by doing that, I could define some of the genes that were necessary for the whole cell reproduction process. And that reproduction process from the birth of a cell to its division is something we call the cell cycle. And so I call these genes, cell division cycle genes, or CDC.”
DNA's structure makes it extremely easy to copy precisely because when the double helix ladder is separated, one side has complementary bases to the other side, allowing the creation of two identical copies from one original DNA molecule—this complementary pairing is the physical basis of heredity.
“the structure of it means it's extremely easy to copy precisely. Because if you tear that ladder apart, then you will have on one side, half a rung. So you will have one of the bases, like A, T, G, C, and the other side will have the complementing bases. So now you can copy those molecules, those sides of the ladder, and make a very precise copy of producing not just one double helix, but two. And that is the basis of heredity.”
Understanding life requires understanding that life is chemistry—living cells contain thousands of chemical reactions catalyzed by enzymes (proteins) made of amino acid chains, with the sequence of bases in DNA specifying the type and order of amino acids in proteins that carry out these chemical reactions.
“Life is made up of molecules and chemicals, and what we, if we study this, and that's the study of biochemistry, then you quickly learn that what happens in living cells and therefore in all living things is that a huge amount of very complicated chemistry going on all the time in a little cell. There are many thousands of chemical reactions going on all the time. And they're catalyzed by something we call enzymes...the chain of different bases in the DNA specifies the type and order of the amino acids in proteins that are encoded by those genes. And it's in fact those proteins that are fundamentally responsible for the characteristics of life.”
Cells perform different chemistries simultaneously by using compartmentation: proteins isolate one chemistry from another, and membrane-bounded cellular structures (organelles) create separate compartments where different chemical reactions can occur independently yet coordinately, allowing thousands of reactions to happen simultaneously in the same small space without interfering with each other.
“One of the ways in which cells can carry out all of this chemistry, in fact, different chemistries, in fact, it's the main way, is that the cell is made up of lots and lots and lots of little compartments. The proteins themselves isolate one chemistry from another chemistry because they keep that separate. And then we have structures in cells, which are membrane-bounded components where you have one set of chemistries different from another set of chemistries. And it's compartmentation that allows all these different chemistries to occur simultaneously in such a small space. It's miraculous that it can work like that.”
Cells regulate chemical processes using negative feedback control: as a substance produced by a gene increases, it switches off the gene; as it decreases, it turns the gene back on—this maintains the substance at a constant level and demonstrates that information management (measuring substance levels and adjusting gene activity) is critical to maintaining homeostasis and cellular stability.
“a control system where, let's say, a gene is making a substance, and it wants to keep that substance at a constant level. Then cells have a very clever mechanism whereby as that substance increases, it switches off the gene, and when it decreases, it turns the gene on. And so it maintains the substance at a certain level. Now, this is what we would call a negative feedback control, and that maintains homeostasis.”
Evolution by natural selection is one of the most beautiful ideas in biology because it explains how design and adaptation can arise without requiring a designer.
“The idea of evolution by natural selection is, for me, probably the most beautiful idea in biology...you could get design without having a designer.”
Nurse named the genes controlling cell division 'cell division cycle genes' or CDC genes, and was following work by colleague Lee Hartwell who had used the same approach on a different yeast species a few years earlier.
“So I call these genes, cell division cycle genes, or CDC. And I was actually following with this work, work done by a friend of mine, Lee Hartwell, who worked on a different yeast to me, but he'd done this a few years before I did it. And he called his gene CDC genes as well.”
Gregor Mendel, an Austro-Hungarian monk in the 19th century, discovered the fundamental principles of heredity by studying pea plants through controlled crosses and quantitatively analyzing offspring ratios, establishing the foundation for genetics.
“Gregor Mendel...worked in a town in the Austro-Hungarian Empire called Brno...he belonged to an order of monks that taught in local schools and encouraged research...Mendel was interested in looking at the genetics of plants, of peas. And what he did is he crossed different peas with different characteristics...studied how when you cross plants that were different in these different characteristics, what were the progeny like.”
Natural selection works through a multi-step mechanism: (1) all living things have hereditary material with variation, (2) some variants result in organisms that grow faster or produce more offspring, (3) advantageous variants become more common in subsequent generations, (4) populations gradually shift from one type to another through this accumulating change.
“what he speculated was that all living things have hereditary material...If this hereditary material had some differences that resulted in the living thing...being different, then it is possible that what was produced was perhaps a plant or an animal that could grow faster or produce more offspring. And that would mean that in the next generation, there would be more of that particular variant. And if it was advantageous in the environment in which it found itself, then it would eventually take over the whole population. So you get a change from one type of organism into one that was a bit different.”
Two distinct ideas must be understood about evolution: first, whether animals and plants actually evolve (a factual question), and second, what mechanism enables that evolution (a mechanistic question).
“There's two things we have to think about here. One is evolution itself. Do animals and plants evolve? And the second is, what is the mechanism by which it takes place?”
Evolution involves two separable concepts: whether animals and plants actually evolve over time, and the mechanism by which evolution occurs (natural selection).
“There's two things we have to think about here. One is evolution itself. Do animals and plants evolve? And the second is, what is the mechanism by which it takes place?”
Robert Hooke first observed cells in the 1660s using a simple microscope, examining a thin slice of plant tissue and publishing the findings in 'Micrographia' in 1665, which showed structures identical to those observed centuries later.
“Robert Hooke, who, in 1660s, working in Oxford where I live, used a very simple microscope, took a thin slice of a plant and looked under the microscope, and there he saw the cells. He published them in a very famous book called 'Micrographia' in 1665. And it looked just like what I was looking at under the microscope centuries later.”
Cell division control mechanisms are extremely ancient, having been established at least 1.5 billion years ago when yeast and human ancestors diverged, and are still functionally identical today despite this vast evolutionary timespan.
“if the same process was controlling the reproduction of a yeast cell as controls the reproduction of a human cell, then this means this was a control that was extremely ancient, because yeast and human beings diverged at least a billion years ago and probably one and a half billion years ago. So it meant that this control process was put in place one and a half billion years ago, 1,500 million years, just to hear how long it was.”
Nurse's research strategy involved identifying mutant yeast cells that could grow but could not divide, accumulating larger and larger without reproducing, allowing definition of genes necessary for cell division.
“what I did was to look for mutant yeast cells that couldn't undergo that process. They could still grow, actually, but they couldn't reproduce...the cells would just get bigger and bigger...'Cause although nothing was affecting their growth, they were unable to divide themselves. So what I did...I looked for mutant yeast cells that would simply get bigger and bigger and would never divide. And by doing that, I could define some of the genes that were necessary for the whole cell reproduction process.”
Mendel proposed that inheritance operates through discrete 'unitary particles' (genes) rather than blended contributions, and these particles could be passed between generations and control traits like plant height.
“he realized, being a physicist, that these were sort of very simple combinations. And he had this idea that maybe what was responsible for inheritance of a tall plant or a short plant could be described in terms of a gene that influenced that process, a sort of unitary particle, which could be passed down from one plant to another.”
DNA replication and the precise copying of hereditary information is the physical basis of heredity itself, representing the beautiful integration of information storage, transmission, and replication mechanisms.
“And that is the basis of heredity. It's very, very seldom that a particular experiment, the beautiful X-ray structure discovered in London, the interpretation of it discovered in Cambridge, which explains the nature of heredity, how information is encoded, and how that information is then precisely copied.”
Although DNA copying is extraordinarily precise, small amounts of damage do occur, and this damage is important for evolution because it creates genetic variation that natural selection can act upon.
“But it's in a process we call S phase for DNA synthesis...But there's a little bit of damage that occurs, and that turns out to be important for evolution, as I'm sure we'll talk about a little later.”
All living things on Earth are related by common descent because all ancestors can be traced back to a common origin, making every organism on the planet a relative of every other.
“One of the consequences of evolution is that we're related by descent. Because if we all can trace back our ancestors to a common place, then every living thing on this planet is related.”
Living things are bounded physical entities that separate themselves from their environment, creating internal order from external disorder while obeying the second law of thermodynamics.
“Living things are bounded physical entities. I mean, they are working as themselves...These physical bounded entities separate a living thing from the rest of the world, so you can increase your order within the cell as a consequence of disorder outside the cell. And this means that you don't have any problems with the second law of thermodynamics of physics.”
Information transmission between cellular compartments is essential to coordinating the diverse chemical reactions occurring in different parts of the cell; without such coordination, the cell would fall apart.
“That can only occur if there's an information transmission from different compartments to keep the whole thing coordinated. If you didn't keep it coordinated together, then the whole thing could fall apart. It's very important to manage information for life to work.”
Cells regulate gene expression through negative feedback control: when a gene produces a substance, the substance itself shuts off the gene; when the substance decreases, the gene turns back on, maintaining the substance at a constant level and preserving homeostasis.
“a gene is making a substance, and it wants to keep that substance at a constant level. Then cells have a very clever mechanism whereby as that substance increases, it switches off the gene, and when it decreases, it turns the gene on. And so it maintains the substance at a certain level. Now, this is what we would call a negative feedback control, and that maintains homeostasis.”
DNA replication and its perfect copying mechanism form the molecular basis of heredity, explaining how genetic information is precisely transmitted from one generation to the next.
“And that is the basis of heredity. It's very, very seldom that a particular experiment, the beautiful X-ray structure discovered in London, the interpretation of it discovered in Cambridge, which explains the nature of heredity, how information is encoded, and how that information is then precisely copied.”
Understanding life requires two complementary approaches: understanding life as chemistry (the molecules and chemical reactions that enable cellular function) and understanding the role of genes in encoding the properties of cells.
“understanding that the basic unit is a cell, understanding that hereditary central and that involves the gene, and then evolution by natural selection, can give you diversity of life. It doesn't actually tell you quite how life works. And for that, there's two ideas that I think are important. And the first of those is life as chemistry.”
DNA is a digital information storage device whose structure is stable and can preserve information for very long time periods, but to perform work, the information in DNA must be copied into protein structures through RNA, transferring information from the stable DNA to the more chemically active proteins.
“DNA is a digital information storage device. And the structure of DNA is such that it's very stable and it has the, it can store that information for a very long time. But it has to do work. And to do work, that DNA is copied into protein structures, as I've explained. And that has a much more elaborate chemistry that can do work, but it is transferring information from the DNA to the protein so the protein could work.”
Evolution by natural selection is probably the most beautiful idea in biology because it explains how design can emerge without a designer—organisms with favorable hereditary variations produce more offspring, causing beneficial variants to increase in frequency over generations, gradually changing one organism type into another.
“The idea of evolution by natural selection is, for me, probably the most beautiful idea in biology...It provided a mechanism by which animals and plants could evolve. And really, you could get design without having a designer.”
A consequence of evolution is that all living things are related by descent because if we trace back our ancestors, we find a common place of origin, meaning every living thing on the planet is related to every other living thing through deep evolutionary history.
“One of the consequences of evolution is that we're related by descent. Because if we all can trace back our ancestors to a common place, then every living thing on this planet is related.”
Watson and Crick's interpretation of Rosalind Franklin and Maurice Wilkins' X-ray crystallography images of DNA revealed that DNA has a double helix structure: a ladder twisted into a helix where bases form rungs, with complementary base pairing (A with T, G with C).
“some beautiful X-ray pictures were taken of DNA by Rosalind Franklin, and Wilkins...was also involved in this. And that revealed a very interesting plot, a diffraction image...And that's what Crick and Watson did. They interpreted those spots and revealed that they could be explained if the structure of DNA was a double helix...it's like a ladder with rungs going across. And each rung consists of two bases...A...is always linked to a base beginning with the word T, and another pair is G and C.”
Every cell division requires copying every single base pair in the genome with extraordinary precision in a process called S phase (DNA synthesis), and mistakes in copying would damage genes and prevent proper cell function.
“Because every time a cell reproduces itself, it has to copy that DNA, and it has to be segregated into the two newly divided cells...every single base pair in the genome has to be replicated, has to be divided, and it has to be done with extraordinary precision. Because if it made mistakes, then genes would be damaged. And if they're damaged, then the cell can't work properly.”
Humans diverged from gorillas approximately 5-10 million years ago, making gorillas evolutionary relatives that share a common ancestor with modern humans.
“Here I was almost talking to a sort of relative diverged five million years ago, 10 million years ago.”
Understanding life requires understanding that it is made up of molecules and chemicals, and studying biochemistry reveals that living cells perform thousands of chemical reactions simultaneously, catalyzed by proteins called enzymes.
“Life is made up of molecules and chemicals, and what we, if we study this, and that's the study of biochemistry, then you quickly learn that what happens in living cells and therefore in all living things is that a huge amount of very complicated chemistry going on all the time in a little cell. There are many thousands of chemical reactions going on all the time. And they're catalyzed by something we call enzymes.”
Enzymes are long protein molecules made up of chains of amino acids, analogous to how DNA is a chain of bases, and the sequence of bases in DNA specifies the type and order of amino acids in proteins.
“And these are long molecules called protein. And they're chains of amino acids, just like the DNA is a chain of bases. Proteins are chains of amino acids. And in all cells, the chain of different bases in the DNA specifies the type and order of the amino acids in proteins that are encoded by those genes.”
Oswald Avery conducted experiments at Rockefeller University showing that DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid) is the chemical responsible for heredity, using bacterial pneumococcus that could form smooth or rough colonies and demonstrating that DNA extracted from smooth colonies could transform rough colonies into smooth ones.
“a very famous experiment was carried out in Rockefeller University in New York...this was an experiment that showed that genes were made of DNA, deoxyribonucleic acid. And this was done by a scientist called Avery. And what he did is he found that he worked on a bacteria, pneumococcus, and the bacteria could make smooth colonies or rough colonies. And if he took, extracted the chemicals that make up the bacterial cells from, say, a smooth colony and then added it to the rough colony, sometimes they were turned into smooth colonies.”
The argument that evolutionary relatedness to all life creates human responsibility for stewardship is the strongest abstract argument Nurse has seen for why humans should care for every living thing on the planet.
“And it's the best argument I've seen in an abstract sort of way that we should take care of every living thing that we can on this planet because we're related to every living thing on the planet.”
Understanding life requires combining chemistry and information perspectives: describing DNA's structure at the molecular level reveals atomic relationships but doesn't make biological sense unless DNA is understood as a digital information storage device.
“When we study the chemistry of life, what we do is describe the molecules and how they interact with each other and how the atoms are spaced one with another. But if we have to understand what that means in terms of biology, then nearly always it has to involve information. If we take DNA, we could understand the structure of DNA and describe it in terms of how one base is related to another base, but it only makes biological sense when it is seen to be a digital information storage device.”
The five core ideas of biology (cell, gene, evolution by natural selection, chemistry, information) bound together through their interconnections provide a framework emphasizing core principles of life rather than a neat dictionary-style definition.
“Putting all these five ideas together...And so we can evolve living things from one type into another. And for me, that bounds everything together, not in a neat dictionary way, like a dictionary definition, but in a way that emphasizes the core principles underlying life.”
Because humans are related to every living thing on the planet through evolution, humans have a special responsibility to be stewards for all animals, plants, and fungi.
“doesn't it mean, if we're related to every living thing on the planet, do we not have a special responsibility for every living thing on this planet? They are really all our relatives. Do we not really have a responsibility to be a steward for all animals, plants, fungi? We have a responsibility for them.”
Mendel was quantitative and counted data unlike most biologists of his time, likely because he was trained as a physicist and amateur astronomer, demonstrating that his mathematical background led him to quantify inheritance patterns rather than merely describe them qualitatively.
“He was trained as a physicist, actually. He was an amateur astronomer...Physicists tend to measure things and therefore count. And he counted the different types of offspring that were produced from these pea plants.”
Life must constantly manage and process information in addition to conducting chemistry, and information management is essential for life to function—this is a principle perhaps less universally accepted than the others but equally important.
“Life is chemistry, but life is also built on information. And this is perhaps the idea that is less well-accepted. It's one that I think is very important, because life has to constantly manage information.”
Life is fundamentally built on information in addition to chemistry: life must constantly manage information by sensing and processing environmental signals to change behavior, a requirement exemplified by a butterfly that senses its environment, converts sensory input into knowledge, and changes its behavior to avoid predators or find food.
“life is also built on information. And this is perhaps the idea that is less well-accepted. It's one that I think is very important, because life has to constantly manage information...that butterfly was sensing its environment around it, taking in that information, turning that information into knowledge of what was happening, and then changing what it did maybe to avoid being eaten by a bird or a shadow, or to find a flower to eat some nectar. And you can understand how the butterfly is operating in terms of information, capturing information and managing it and then changing what you actually do. And that is central to life.”
Information management in computers (silico) uses hardware driven by software, whereas in living things (wetware), information is managed through communication via molecules diffusing through water, allowing for rewiring of connections not just through software-like changes but through physical rewiring of molecular signaling pathways.
“When we do it in a computer, in silico, you have hardware in the computer and we have software that drives it. In life, living things, it's a little different. I sometimes use the word, I didn't invent it, but in living things then, it's not hardware, it's wetware. Because actually what's happening is that the way information is managed is by communication and using molecules from one part of a cell to another. And that's diffusing through liquid, through water. And that allows you to rewire the connections.”
Every human being was once a single cell—a fertilized egg in the mother's body—which should generate profound interest in understanding cells because understanding cells leads to understanding ourselves and every other living thing on the planet.
“all of us were once a single cell. When, we were once a fertilized egg in our mother's body. It was a single cell. And really, if we were all one cells, isn't that something we should be really interested in? Is it something that we haven't fully appreciated? Well, for me, I think it is...If we understand cells, we'll understand ourselves and every other living thing on this planet a bit better.”
The framework presented—emphasizing core principles rather than neat dictionary definition—is more effective at understanding life because it emphasizes the mechanisms and interconnections underlying living systems rather than trying to provide a reductive, checklist-style definition.
“for me, that bounds everything together, not in a neat dictionary way, like a dictionary definition, but in a way that emphasizes the core principles underlying life.”
Nurse had a profound personal experience observing a gorilla family in a Uganda rainforest that brought home the relatedness of humans to other primates; a large male gorilla made direct eye contact with him and performed a display of strength, creating an almost conversational connection that emphasized their kinship.
“this was brought home to me in a very special way, almost spiritual, when I was trekking through a Uganda rainforest looking for gorillas. And we came across a whole family of them, 20, 25 of them...this very large male gorilla sat down in front of me and looked at me, deep brown eyes. He put out his arm, he bent down a sapling tree, two, three, four inches in diameter...sitting there, just looking at him, seeing the similarities, his deep brown eyes, and they were really staring at me, it just looked like we were having a conversation somehow.”
Nurse had a profound experience in a Uganda rainforest where he encountered a family of gorillas and sat facing a large male gorilla who looked deeply into his eyes, bent down saplings to demonstrate strength, and then urinated on him—an interaction that conveyed to Nurse the deep connection and similarity between humans and our evolutionary relatives who diverged 5-10 million years ago.
“I was trekking through a Uganda rainforest looking for gorillas. And we came across a whole family of them, 20, 25 of them. I sat down behind a tree...And then this very large male gorilla sat down in front of me and looked at me, deep brown eyes. He put out his arm, he bent down a sapling tree, two, three, four inches in diameter. I'm sure he was telling me, you know, 'I can do this. I'm not sure you can do this.' But sitting there, just looking at him, seeing the similarities, his deep brown eyes...just looked like we were having a conversation somehow...then he climbed up the tree, and then he peed all over me.”
Life is fundamentally built on information: cells must constantly manage information about their environment and internal state, sense information, convert it to knowledge, and change behavior in response to maintain functionality.
“life is also built on information. And this is perhaps the idea that is less well-accepted...life has to constantly manage information...the butterfly was sensing its environment around it, taking in that information, turning that information into knowledge of what was happening, and then changing what it did maybe to avoid being eaten by a bird or a shadow, or to find a flower to eat some nectar. And you can understand how the butterfly is operating in terms of information, capturing information and managing it and then changing what you actually do. And that is central to life. Life is, and can only operate through information.”
Computer and biological information management differ fundamentally: computers use hardware and software (in silico), while living things use 'wetware' where information is managed through molecular communication and diffusion through liquid, allowing rewiring of connections through molecular changes.
“When we do it in a computer, in silico, you have hardware in the computer and we have software that drives it. In life, living things, it's a little different. I sometimes use the word, I didn't invent it, but in living things then, it's not hardware, it's wetware. Because actually what's happening is that the way information is managed is by communication and using molecules from one part of a cell to another. And that's diffusing through liquid, through water. And that allows you to rewire the connections.”
The information management in living cells ('wetware') differs fundamentally from computer information management ('hardware' and 'software') because in cells, information is managed through molecular diffusion in aqueous solution, allowing rewiring of cellular connections at the molecular level.
“When we do it in a computer, in silico, you have hardware in the computer and we have software that drives it. In life, living things, it's a little different...in living things then, it's not hardware, it's wetware. Because actually what's happening is that the way information is managed is by communication and using molecules from one part of a cell to another. And that's diffusing through liquid, through water. And that allows you to rewire the connections.”
A direct encounter with a mountain gorilla family in a Uganda rainforest revealed the profound relatedness between humans and other primates through observable similarities: the gorilla's deep brown eyes and apparent intentional communication conveyed connection across an evolutionary divergence of approximately 5-10 million years.
“This was brought home to me in a very special way, almost spiritual, when I was trekking through a Uganda rainforest looking for gorillas. And we came across a whole family of them, 20, 25 of them...this very large male gorilla sat down in front of me and looked at me, deep brown eyes. He put out his arm, he bent down a sapling tree, two, three, four inches in diameter...it just looked like we were having a conversation somehow...Here I was almost talking to a sort of relative diverged five million years ago, 10 million years ago.”
Nurse illustrates information management through the example of a yellow brimstone butterfly: the butterfly continuously senses its environment, converts sensory information into knowledge about what is happening, and then changes its behavior accordingly (e.g., avoiding predators, finding flowers for nectar), demonstrating that life operates through constant information capture and processing.
“a yellow butterfly, a brimstone yellow that I saw when I was a child and started me thinking about life, coming in, flying into the garden, settling, taking off, going, and leaving the garden. And all the time, that butterfly was sensing its environment around it, taking in that information, turning that information into knowledge of what was happening, and then changing what it did maybe to avoid being eaten by a bird or a shadow, or to find a flower to eat some nectar.”
While digital computer metaphors are useful for thinking about biological information, they should be treated as metaphors rather than direct analogies, given the fundamental differences in physical substrate and implementation.
“I see the digital world that we think about with computers as more as a metaphor rather than a direct analogy.”
The five great ideas of biology (cell, gene, evolution, chemistry, information) together provide a framework that bounds understanding of life in terms of core principles rather than neat dictionary definitions.
“And for me, that bounds everything together, not in a neat dictionary way, like a dictionary definition, but in a way that emphasizes the core principles underlying life.”
A bounded physical entity is best described as a chemical and informational machine that emerges from the five ideas (cell, gene, evolution, chemistry, information) and has a hereditary system with variability, enabling the whole system to evolve by natural selection.
“The bounded entity is described as a chemical and informational machine, and that emerges from the ideas that we've talked about. And then critically, that informational chemical machine in a bounded entity has a hereditary system that determines how it works, which has variability.”
A cell can perform thousands of simultaneous chemical reactions in a tiny space requiring precise coordination, whereas human chemical plants can only perform 20-30 reactions and require extreme conditions (high heat, high acidity, or high alkalinity) to work, making cellular chemistry nearly miraculous in its efficiency.
“I want you to imagine in a tiny, tiny cell that you need a microscope to see, there's thousands of chemical reactions, all very different, going on all the time, very, very close to each other. Now, when we make us human beings a chemical plant to do something similar, we only perhaps do 20, 30 chemical reactions. We have to put a lot of heat in or make it very acid or make it alkali.”
The relationship between evolutionary relatedness and ethical responsibility to protect other living things is the best abstract argument Nurse has encountered for taking care of every living thing on the planet.
“And it's the best argument I've seen in an abstract sort of way that we should take care of every living thing that we can on this planet because we're related to every living thing on the planet.”
Robert Hooke first observed cells in the 1660s using a simple microscope, examining thin slices of plant material, and published his observations in the famous book 'Micrographia' in 1665.
“Robert Hooke, who, in 1660s, working in Oxford where I live, used a very simple microscope, took a thin slice of a plant and looked under the microscope, and there he saw the cells. He published them in a very famous book called 'Micrographia' in 1665.”
Every human being was once a single cell—a fertilized egg—and therefore understanding cells is essential to understanding ourselves.
“all of us were once a single cell. When, we were once a fertilized egg in our mother's body. It was a single cell. And really, if we were all one cells, isn't that something we should be really interested in?”
Nurse's research strategy was to identify yeast mutants that could grow but could not divide, allowing the cells to enlarge indefinitely, thereby identifying genes necessary for the cell division process.
“I looked for mutant yeast cells that would simply get bigger and bigger and would never divide...By doing that, I could define some of the genes that were necessary for the whole cell reproduction process.”
Nurse named the genes controlling cell division 'cell division cycle genes' or 'CDC genes', following the convention established earlier by his colleague Lee Hartwell who worked on a different yeast species.
“I call these genes, cell division cycle genes, or CDC. And I was actually following with this work, work done by a friend of mine, Lee Hartwell, who worked on a different yeast to me, but he'd done this a few years before I did it. And he called his gene CDC genes as well.”
Mendel's groundbreaking heredity work was completely ignored by the scientific community during his lifetime; his results were not recognized until the early 1900s when three different botanists independently rediscovered the same patterns, forcing them to acknowledge Mendel's prior work from 35 years earlier.
“what was unfortunate was that nobody took any notice of what Mendel did. None whatsoever...Even Charles Darwin had been sent to paper...but nobody took any notice of his interpretation. And then in the early 1900s, three different botanists did the same sorts of experiments, got the same results, but they then had to admit it all had been described by the gardening monk 35 years before.”
Watson and Crick working in Cambridge, along with Wilkins and Franklin in London, determined the double helix structure of DNA through analysis of Rosalind Franklin's X-ray crystallography images, revealing DNA as two complementary antiparallel strands twisted into a helix.
“Watson and Crick working in Cambridge, Wilkins and Franklin working in London. And some beautiful X-ray pictures were taken of DNA by Rosalind Franklin, and Wilkins, a little before her, was also involved in this...That revealed a very interesting plot, a diffraction image, which if you could interpret it properly, would indicate the structure of the molecule. And that's what Crick and Watson did. They interpreted those spots and revealed that they could be explained if the structure of DNA was a double helix.”
A simple model demonstrates evolution by natural selection: a single-celled organism with a red coat is eaten by predators, but if a mutation produces a yellow coat, yellow-coated cells survive better and eventually take over the population, illustrating how selection on a single trait can drive evolutionary change.
“Imagine a single-celled organism which had a red coat outside the cell, or a yellow coat. Let's say that the red coat got eaten by some other living organism. Then, if there was a mutation which resulted in the red coat turning into a yellow coat, then the yellow-coated cells would survive better than the red-coated ones. And as a consequence, they would take over the population.”
Watson and Crick in Cambridge and Wilkins and Franklin in London conducted beautiful experiments revealing DNA's structure as a double helix by interpreting X-ray diffraction images taken by Rosalind Franklin, showing that DNA consists of a ladder twisted into a helix with four types of bases (A, T, G, C) where A always pairs with T and G always pairs with C.
“Watson and Crick working in Cambridge, Wilkins and Franklin working in London. And some beautiful X-ray pictures were taken of DNA by Rosalind Franklin...And that revealed a very interesting plot, a diffraction image, which if you could interpret it properly, would indicate the structure of the molecule. And that's what Crick and Watson did. They interpreted those spots and revealed that they could be explained if the structure of DNA was a double helix...a ladder with rungs going across. And each rung consists of two bases...a base, which begins with the word A, is always linked to a base beginning with the word T, and another pair is G and C.”
Charles Darwin developed the mechanism of evolution by natural selection in the 1840s based on observations from a five-year voyage on the HMS Beagle collecting animals, plants, birds, and studying geology, but did not publish his theory until 1865.
“It took Charles Darwin in the middle of the 19th century to come up with a mechanism, evolution by natural selection. And he came to this position because of a five-year voyage he took in a small royal naval boat called the Beagle that went round the world, and he collected animals and plants and birds and studied the geology...And this eventually led in the 1840s to his idea. He didn't publish it till 1865.”
Robert Hooke discovered cells in the 1660s in Oxford by using a simple microscope to examine a thin slice of plant tissue, publishing his findings in the famous book 'Micrographia' in 1665, which revealed box-like structures (cells) for the first time.
“Robert Hooke, who, in 1660s, working in Oxford where I live, used a very simple microscope, took a thin slice of a plant and looked under the microscope, and there he saw the cells. He published them in a very famous book called 'Micrographia' in 1665.”
In the early 20th century, Avery discovered that DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid) is the chemical substance responsible for heredity by showing that DNA extracted from smooth bacterial colonies could transform rough colonies into smooth colonies, proving DNA is the material that makes up genes and carries hereditary information.
“a very famous experiment was carried out in Rockefeller University in New York...this was an experiment that showed that genes were made of DNA, deoxyribonucleic acid. And this was done by a scientist called Avery...If he took, extracted the chemicals that make up the bacterial cells from, say, a smooth colony and then added it to the rough colony, sometimes they were turned into smooth colonies...he looked to see what chemicals were responsible for that, and he found that DNA was the chemical that caused it.”
Gregor Mendel was a monk trained as a physicist who studied plant genetics in the 19th century by crossing pea plants with different characteristics (tall/short, different flower colors, different seed shapes) and observing that inheritance followed clear mathematical ratios (3:1, 9:3:3:1), suggesting inheritance was controlled by particulate units now called genes.
“Mendel was interested in looking at the genetics of plants, of peas...he crossed different peas with different characteristics, like tall pea plants and short pea plants, which had flowers of different colors or seeds of different shapes...And he counted the different types of offspring that were produced from these pea plants. And he began to notice, there were very clear ratios, famous ratios, like three to one, and nine to three, to three to one.”
Gregor Mendel's work on pea plant inheritance was ignored at the time and received no credit for his discovery, though his findings were independently rediscovered in the early 1900s by three different botanists who then had to acknowledge Mendel's earlier work, eventually leading to the discipline of genetics being named 'Mendelism' in his honor.
“What was unfortunate was that nobody took any notice of what Mendel did. None whatsoever...And then in the early 1900s, three different botanists did the same sorts of experiments, got the same results, but they then had to admit it all had been described by the gardening monk 35 years before. So he got no credit for his discovery, but now of course a central part of genetics is called Mendelism in his honor.”
During the cell cycle, every single base pair in the genome must be replicated with extraordinary precision in the S (DNA synthesis) phase, and any mistakes result in damaged genes that prevent the cell from functioning properly.
“it occurs every cell cycle, it's in a process we call S phase for DNA synthesis, every single base pair in the genome has to be replicated, has to be divided, and it has to be done with extraordinary precision. Because if it made mistakes, then genes would be damaged. And if they're damaged, then the cell can't work properly.”
Dinosaurs went extinct only 65 million years ago, which is far shorter than the 1.5 billion year evolutionary period over which cell division mechanisms have remained conserved.
“And just to put that in perspective, dinosaurs just went extinct only 65 million years ago, and this is far, far longer.”
DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid) was identified as the chemical material responsible for heredity and gene function through experiments by Oswald Avery at Rockefeller University, who demonstrated that DNA extracted from smooth bacterial colonies could transform rough colonies into smooth colonies.
“a very famous experiment was carried out in Rockefeller University in New York...this was an experiment that showed that genes were made of DNA, deoxyribonucleic acid...a scientist called Avery...worked on a bacteria, pneumococcus...the bacteria could make smooth colonies or rough colonies. And if he took, extracted the chemicals that make up the bacterial cells from, say, a smooth colony and then added it to the rough colony, sometimes they were turned into smooth colonies...he looked to see what chemicals were responsible for that, and he found that DNA was the chemical that caused it.”
Initial skepticism about DNA as the genetic material stemmed from the belief that DNA was too simple to encode the complexity required for genetic information, but this skepticism was unfounded.
“This, once again, just like Mendel, was taken no notice of. This turned out to be controversial, too. 'Cause DNA isn't a complicated molecule. And quite a few scientists at the time thought, oh, this isn't sufficiently elaborate or sufficiently complicated to encode all the information that has to be kept in genes. But in fact, he was absolutely right.”
All living things are either single cells or made up of groups of cells acting together, and therefore understanding cells is critical to understanding all life.
“all living things, myself, a plant, an insect, everything that we see around us that is alive is either a single cell or made up of groups of cells acting together.”
Charles Darwin, during his five-year voyage on the Beagle collecting animals and plants and studying geology, developed the idea of evolution by natural selection in the 1840s, though he did not publish it until 1865.
“Charles Darwin in the middle of the 19th century came up with a mechanism, evolution by natural selection...because of a five-year voyage he took in a small royal naval boat called the Beagle that went round the world, and he collected animals and plants and birds and studied the geology...And this eventually led in the 1840s to his idea. He didn't publish it till 1865.”
Living cells perform thousands of simultaneous chemical reactions catalyzed by proteins (enzymes), which are long chains of amino acids specified by the DNA sequence of genes.
“a huge amount of very complicated chemistry going on all the time in a little cell. There are many thousands of chemical reactions going on all the time. And they're catalyzed by something we call enzymes. And these are long molecules called protein...in all cells, the chain of different bases in the DNA specifies the type and order of the amino acids in proteins that are encoded by those genes.”
Cells employ negative feedback control systems to maintain homeostasis: when a substance reaches excessive levels, the gene producing it is switched off; when levels drop, the gene is turned back on, thereby maintaining constant substance concentration.
“a control system where, let's say, a gene is making a substance, and it wants to keep that substance at a constant level. Then cells have a very clever mechanism whereby as that substance increases, it switches off the gene, and when it decreases, it turns the gene on. And so it maintains the substance at a certain level. Now, this is what we would call a negative feedback control, and that maintains homeostasis.”
Evolutionary thinking is ancient, with even Aristotle speculating about evolution, and in the 18th century multiple people speculated about animal and plant evolution based on fossil evidence, but it was Charles Darwin in the mid-19th century who provided the mechanism of natural selection.
“The idea that animals and plants might evolve is actually quite old. Even Aristotle had some thoughts about it. But particularly in the 18th century, there were a number of people who speculated looking at fossils and so on, that animals and plants had evolved over time. But it took Charles Darwin in the middle of the 19th century to come up with a mechanism, evolution by natural selection.”
Despite getting no credit during his lifetime, Mendel's discovery is now honored by naming a central part of genetics 'Mendelism' in his honor.
“but now of course a central part of genetics is called Mendelism in his honor.”
Eukaryotic cells (cells from yeast through humans) are defined by having their chromosomes and DNA wrapped up in a nucleus, distinguishing them from prokaryotic cells.
“Cells from yeast through to human cells are called eukaryotes. That's a technical term, which just means their chromosomes, their DNA is wrapped up in a nucleus. And such cells are called eukaryotes.”
Gregor Mendel, a 19th-century monk trained as a physicist, discovered the basic laws of heredity through quantitative analysis of pea plant crosses, identifying consistent ratios (3:1, 9:3:3:1) that suggested the existence of particulate units of inheritance he called 'genes'.
“Gregor Mendel...worked in a town in the Austro-Hungarian Empire called Brno...He was trained as a physicist, actually...he was quite quantitative. He counted things...he counted the different types of offspring that were produced from these pea plants. And he began to notice, there were very clear ratios, famous ratios, like three to one, and nine to three, to three to one...he realized...that maybe what was responsible for inheritance of a tall plant or a short plant could be described in terms of a gene that influenced that process, a sort of unitary particle”
DNA's structure consists of a double helix with two complementary strands where each strand acts as a ladder with rungs, where each rung consists of two bases (A paired with T, G paired with C), and the sequence of these base pairs encodes genetic information.
“the way I like to explain it is it's like a ladder with rungs going across. And each rung consists of two bases. And these bases, one comes from one side of the ladder, and the other from the other side of the ladder...a base, which begins with the word A, is always linked to a base beginning with the word T, and another pair is G and C...the side of the ladder was string of letters, A, G, C, T, and the complement was on the other side of the ladder. And this ladder was then twisted into a helix and is in fact what DNA is made up of.”
Proteins are fundamentally responsible for the characteristics of life because they are the molecular agents that perform the chemical work enabling growth, reproduction, energy capture, and other vital processes.
“it's in fact those proteins that are fundamentally responsible for the characteristics of life.”
Darwin delayed publishing his evolutionary theory for decades after developing it, not publishing until 1865 (roughly two decades after formulating the idea in the 1840s).
“this eventually led in the 1840s to his idea. He didn't publish it till 1865.”
Mendel's work became foundational enough that a central part of genetics is now called 'Mendelism' in his honor, despite him receiving no credit during his lifetime.
“So he got no credit for his discovery, but now of course a central part of genetics is called Mendelism in his honor.”
In the early 20th century, genes were studied as abstract entities with unknown physical basis; it was not known what genes were materially composed of.
“genes were studied for quite a long time in the 20th century. They were rather abstract. Nobody knew what they were.”
The gorilla's display of strength (bending a sapling tree several inches in diameter) appeared to be a statement of dominance or superiority, though the interpretation remains ambiguous.
“I'm sure he was telling me, you know, 'I can do this. I'm not sure you can do this.' But sitting there, just looking at him...He sat and looked at me for a while, then he climbed up the tree, and then he peed all over me. So I don't really know whether he was trying to put me in my place”